18 ms·
Apple dives into display-making to cut reliance on Samsung
- jiggawatts 4y agoAre these FALD backlights for LCDs, or full-resolution LED arrays?
- barbariangrunge 4y agoPutting this facility in Taiwan seems risky, considering the political situation. I heard Warren buffet just pulled his tsmc stocks out of caution over it
- mjhay 4y agoAlmost their whole supply chain is in China. If a Taiwan strait war breaks out, Apple is completely screwed anyway.
- treeman79 4y agoMight help matter. If China blows up part of Apple, they are going lose all of Apple Business. That’s a big cash cow China would lose.
- Flatcircle 4y agoI still don't understand why China would possibly want to try and invade Taiwan? The chip foundry's would immediately be scuttled, and whatever would be left would be a nice, but simple island. In exchange for taking that land mass, their entire international trade business which mainland china is extremely reliant on, would be in jeopardy. It would almost be political suicide to invade as far as I see it. But I'm no expert.
- IlliOnato 4y agoI still don't understand how Russia (the country where I was born) would possibly want and invade Ukraine... But it did.
- SXX 4y agoNo idea why you being downvoted. I as owner of Russian passport even been to Kiev in December 2021 and talked with a lot of friends and just normal people there on gamedev conference. There been a lot of tension for 8 years since 2014 and even more during 2021. Yet no matter political views no one in either Russia or Ukraine seriously considered full scale war possible. Conclusion: there no way to know what is inside a head of aging autocrat.
- londons_explore 4y ago> no matter political views no one in either Russia or Ukraine seriously considered full scale war possible. Plenty of experts have been calling it for a decade now... EU/US influence has been slowly creeping east for 30 years. Russia had no other options really - as soon as a pro-west leader was elected to Ukraine, war was inevitable. And the same will happen in Belarus when the leadership changes there too.
- murkt 4y agoWhat is this “no other options” bullshit? They could just not attack Ukraine and that’s it. Nobody would attack Russia.
- sampullman 4y agoI don't think the political situation has changed that much since 1949, except for minor updates in 1971 and 1992. Besides, as the sibling commenter mentions, Apple (and every other consumer electronics manufacturer in the world) is in deep trouble if war breaks out. If they de-risk by doing this in the US or India, what are they going to use the screens for?
- melling 4y agoChina has the second largest economy with the second largest military budget. The world is definitely a lot different than it was 50 years ago. Taking an island 100 miles offshore is definitely doable
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sampullman 4y agoSure, I was being a bit flippant. The world is different in many ways, including more interdependence between Chinese and Taiwanese economies. Without getting too deep into it, the issue mostly comes down to whether the US decides to intervene. Everybody suffers massively if there's hot war in the strait. The main point is that unless supply chains are unwound from both countries, it doesn't matter that much where you put a new screen factory.
- melling 4y agoOf course it matters… It’s completely absurd to think it doesn’t matter …or are you being flippant again. I don’t have time to burn so say what you mean. If you really don’t understand, I can explain the obvious advantages to not placing a factory in a potential war zone. Then there’s the other danger… https://finance.yahoo.com/news/us-destroy-taiwans-semiconductor-factories-172312987.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/us-destroy-taiwans-semiconduc... The US could not intervene other than destroying all the semiconductor factories.
- 4y ago
- bioemerl 4y agoIt's a pretty far out risk and far better than putting it in China like most companies do.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- alberth 4y agoHas Apple in its history ever manufactured components themselves? I know they have created machinery for their suppliers to use, but actual manufacturing before?
- vkdelta 4y agoThey have designed their own SoCs, own BLE radio and now working on their own cellular and Wifi radios. I understand displays is another beast but apple is doing complete vertical integration like no one else. Anytime they notice a dependency on specific vendor, they try to move out.
- alberth 4y agoBut design is not manufacture. Have they ever manufactured components before?
- AlotOfReading 4y agoThe sapphire glass used on some devices was reportedly made in an apple owned factory, according to Apple terms, using equipment Apple paid for. The actual production was handled by a third party using that space that went bankrupt, but I'd say it counts. This would be the most significant component they've manufactured in-house though.
- sangnoir 4y agoThat doesn't count because the other company had designed the process, but didn't have capacity to produce at Apple-level volumes. Apple paid for the expansion,and then ditched the company's product (which led to the bankruptcy)
- andruby 4y agoDesigned, yes. But not manufactured afaik
- babl-yc 4y ago
- baybal2 4y agoApple for long time tried to buy JBD Display, they sent their due-diligencers, which inspected everything millimetre by millimetre, and then poached their process head. JBD then armed itself with lawyers, and for long tried to frustrate Apple from reproducing the technology.
- valine 4y agoIs MicroLED the be all end all for display technologies? Perfect blacks, high brightness, no burn in, no bezels, thin. It's hard to imagine another display tech displacing MicroLED once it takes hold. Does it have any theoretical downsides other than cost?
- londons_explore 4y agoMicroled will prove very cheap when somebody figures out a good production process. None of the materials are expensive. The risk is that they patent that process and we have 20 years to wait till we get cheap screens.
- cubefox 4y agoMore "if" rather than "when". It's far from obvious whether they will be successful. They just have a higher maximum brightness, and a large cost cut is not guaranteed.
- manaskarekar 4y agoSomeone correct me if I’m wrong, but micro-LED, by design is going to suffer from PWM flicker. That is a deal breaker for many.
- valine 4y agoWhy can’t they reduce voltage to each pixel to reduce brightness? I don’t see this as a fundamental limitation of the display technology, PWM is just easy and cheap to implement.
- londons_explore 4y agoBecause the display can only have one row of pixels on at once. If you have a display 1000 pixels tall, then the brightest LED's are on for 1/1000th of the time.
- 4y ago
- brightball 4y agoWho’s stock will this negatively impact?
- lostmsu 4y agoSamsung?
- buran77 4y ago> "Apple's ultimate plan is to introduce the technologies on its iPhone, which is its key revenue source and has much bigger volume, to justify the investments over the years," said one of the sources who has seen samples of the company's microLED screen. One thing I really appreciate when it comes to Apple is that despite all their shortcomings they don't "sleep on the job". Over the years they never hesitated to cannibalize their own product lines (iPod), or go through several tough technological transitions (68K/PPC/x86/ARM) if it meant building a better product. And bigger profits of course. For example I'm sure Google would just rather stuff your phone to the gills with ads in order to drive revenue than actually bother with a coherent investment in a long term strategy to make a better product. And bigger profits of course.
- dehrmann 4y ago> cannibalize their own product lines (iPod) I disagree on this. The iPhone was a potential iPod replacement when it launched, but the choice was selling $200 iPods or $500 iPhones. The iPhone felt like a leap of several generations, but the hardware and business model were still similar. Where Apple actually cannibalized something was Apple Music and the iTunes store, but they drug their feet on it.
- buran77 4y ago> but the choice was selling $200 iPods or $500 iPhones I don't think we are in disagreement. But the fact is very few companies do this regardless. When it comes to the product that's their bread and butter they tend to put it on a pedestal never to be touched until it falls into irrelevance. Apple didn't launch an improved iPod and retire the old. They didn't try to sell a phone and a music player by artificially differentiating them, or by sabotaging one of them. They didn't try to make $250 off the iPod and another $250 from a phone that "shouldn't compete too well". They launched 2 product lines made by different parts of the company, knowing that the iPhone may undermine the iPod userbase and then still fail, possibly souring those customers. They wouldn't necessarily do this today. iDevices now are clearly (and artificially) differentiated from the Macs: different OS, no options to use them in a way they truly compete despite having such similar hardware theoretical capabilities. Again to give the Google example, when they tried to have competing lines (Google/Nest) they managed to fail at both and lose the customers completely.
- dang 4y agoUrl changed from https://www.macrumors.com/2023/05/18/apple-mass-produce-microled-iphone/ https://www.macrumors.com/2023/05/18/apple-mass-produce-micr..., which points to this. Submitters: "Please submit the original source. If a post reports on something found on another site, submit the latter." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- shmerl 4y agoTypical Apple NIH mentality. What will be next, memory chips may be?
- worrycue 4y agoI think they are just warily of being reliant on a single supplier - they have been burned before; https://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=MacBasic.txt https://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=MacBasic.txt
- MBCook 4y agoSome companies they’ve been beholden to that made their lives worse: Microsoft, Adobe, Motorola, IBM, Intel, nVidia, Qualcomm, Samsung, Metroworks, Oracle, and ATI/AMD. They’ve done everything they can to either kick those to the curb or minimize the risk. Sony is the one big exception I can think of. Sony makes the camera sensors and I don’t remember hearing of Sony causing issues. Wouldn’t surprise me if Sony was next on the list after displays though.
- neximo64 4y agoThis is funny, they only did this because they don't like dealing with Samsung on the display side.
- MBCook 4y agoThey don’t like being beholden to anyone. It’s why they their own chips. Their own chipsets. Their own storage controllers. They’re working on their own radios. Their own fingerprint sensors. Their own facial recognition. Their LIDAR. Their image processing chips attached to the camera. They often contract out actual manufacturing. But they design and control everything they can, being very hands on with manufacturing. On the iPhone the screen and the camera sensors are the two big things they don’t control. The Samsung angle absolutely doesn’t help. But if they were using LG I think they would still do this. It’s the direction they’ve been heading in for years.
- fwlr 4y agoOne exciting thing about microLEDs is they can achieve much higher pixels per inch. Before Apple’s big Retina push, PPI was around 80-120. It went to around 200-300 with Retina. Researchers making microLEDs in the lab have gone as high as 6000 PPI, and something in the low thousands seems quite plausible for commercial technology. Apple could conceivably bring in “Double Retina” at 800 PPI, or they could go straight to “Double Double Retina” at 1600 PPI. It’s often claimed the human eye can’t see above 300 PPI; this is even more misleading than the claim that the human eye can’t see above 30fps (we all know there’s a distinct visual difference between 30fps and 60fps, and most people are able to detect the difference between 60fps and 144fps as well). The PPI limit of the eye depends on how brightly lit the subject is and how far away one is viewing it; for a real upper limit you might use something like the maximums of https://lobsangstudio.com/ls_pixel.cfm https://lobsangstudio.com/ls_pixel.cfm which says at 6 inches viewing distance under 10,000 lux (bright sunny day), the eye could go as high as 1200PPI. The fact that microLEDs offer the potential to go beyond even the maximum of generous estimates in best conditions is very exciting, it’s like Formal Proof version of Retina rather than the current Good Enough.
- ericpauley 4y agoThe point of Retina is that the pixels aren't visible at normal viewing distances. You really shouldn't be using any (non-VR) screen 6 inches away. At 18 inches the effective PPI would be 400, so not much more than retina even at insane brightness. I could see it being a big deal for VR, though.
- thr-nrg 4y agohttps://clarkvision.com/articles/eye-resolution.html https://clarkvision.com/articles/eye-resolution.html >The 10600 pixels over 20 inches corresponds to 530 pixels per inch, which would indeed appear very sharp. Note in a recent printer test I showed a 600 ppi print had more detail than a 300 ppi print on an HP1220C printer (1200x2400 print dots). I've conducted some blind tests where a viewer had to sort 4 photos (150, 300, 600 and 600 ppi prints). The two 600 ppi were printed at 1200x1200 and 1200x2400 dpi. So far all have gotten the correct order of highest to lowest ppi (includes people up to age 50). See: http://www.clarkvision.com/articles/printer-ppi http://www.clarkvision.com/articles/printer-ppi I have no idea why everyone forgot how shit 300dpi printers were and how much crisper 1200dpi looked.
- heliophobicdude 4y agoCouple of questions. Is Apple intending to use microOLED from Samsung after buying Sony's microOLED for this upcoming AR HMD? Also are they intending to use Samsung's new purchase of eMagine optics for the higher quality microOLED micro displays with no color filter? If so, are they then just trying to cut reliance on specific types of displays? Also microLED != microOLED.
- nologic01 4y agoThe headline that would bring tears to my eyes is "Users dive into Linux to cut reliance on big tech" The endless cola versus pepsi discussion is not really going to move the needle and the users pay with inferior experience. Apple has been playing its cards well and in a sense its good that it exists. It shows that different business models are possible but thats a far cry from it being a functioning market that delivers for users. Ultimately you want multiple manufacturers, low switching costs between platforms that wont lock-in users, 100% stop with the abominable surveillance adtech, extensive recyclability and reparability. These are not absurd demands that cant be delivered, these are very basic aspects of a sane personal computing landscape. But we will not get them if all the ink is spent on which of the two options is the least bad one.
- jvm___ 4y agolow switching costs between platforms that wont lock-in users, 100% stop with the abominable surveillance adtech, extensive recyclability and reparability. Who pays for that? What you want is less "pollution". A polluted market where you can't switch from apple to Samsung. A polluted privacy environment online. A polluted world with a phone that's just full of glue. Companies, and humanity in general, just pollutes as much as their local environment allows. What your saying is possible to do, but doing those things means less money for the owners of the companies and less features going out the door (as money and time are spent on non-profit expenses). No one will pay $$ to switch between apple and google. Why would either company make it easy to lose monthly app subscriptions? They'd be paying money to shoot themselves in the foot. What needs to happen is more regulation (just like physical world pollution) but the USA culture is very anti-government so nothing will happen.
- nologic01 4y ago> Who pays for that? Users will pay. One way or another users pay for everything. But you cannot pay for something that doesnt exist. Reduced competition is the best way to ensure real choice doesnt exist. Its the simplest of truths yet we are past the stage of even grasping simple truths.
- xyzabc098123 4y agoThis is history repeating itself; like the "frowned-upon", complex structures of conglomerate in Japan and South Korea. Samsung is an example most are familiar with. At least gen Z and millennials get to see how one is borned. Too much money, why not DIY?