4 ms·
I'm seeing a lot of criticism here in the comments, but what's the alternative for free accounts? If you're not using it, how long is Google (a for-profit compa
by crazygringo 4y ago
I'm seeing a lot of criticism here in the comments, but what's the alternative for free accounts? If you're not using it, how long is Google (a for-profit company) supposed to hold onto your data for free? 100 years? 50 years? 15 years?
2 years seems pretty reasonable to me for something provided by a for-profit corporation. And as other reporting has noted, they're not deleting YouTube videos (makes sense, since while nobody else views your e-mails, public videos are public).
People here are saying, what about if you go to jail for more than 2 years, or you're in poor health for multi-year stretches? Then pay for a cheap Google One subscription, export your data with Takeout, or have a trusted friend log in once a year. These are lots of options.
If this were a government-provided service then it would be one thing. But it's not, it's a for-profit company that gives you free products in exchange for ads. There are lots of options for keeping an account active. I see no reason why we should expect a company to keep providing storage for dormant accounts beyond 2 years though.
- cj 4y agoPhotobucket (remember them!) kept hundreds and hundreds of photos in my account with them despite complete inactivity for over a decade. I simply forgot the account existed, and remembered one day to find a ton of amazing decade old photos. There’s something to be said for doing things that earn your company respect from consumers. Had photobucket deleted my decade old photos because I didn’t log in frequently enough, I’d be pissed and wouldn’t use them in the future. If a small photo storage company can afford to keep customer photos for decade+ with no login, I hope Google can store some text emails for at least 5 years. Re: the jail/health issue, making sure Google doesn’t delete my account would (literally) be the last thing on my todo list if I were on my way to prison or a coma.
- dingusdew 4y agoSee, I read this situation as entirely differently. Google is not being unreasonable in understanding that they can't afford to store all data from everyone indefinitely. They are not being unreasonable that it is a potential security risk. Where they are being unreasonable is that they have basically gotten everyone addicted to their "free" product, and then, a decade after promoting the idea that no one should run their own services, they should just use free offers in the cloud: they are now admitting the downsides to this arrangement. That Google account that your dead friend had that you keep on your buddy list because it gives you memories? Gone. That Facebook account with your dead family members photos and timeline? Gone. The Twitter account with all the tweets from you child who died too soon? Gone. The lesson should be that if you're hoping for someone else to be the steward of all your digital histories, you're in for a bad time. If you're on someone else's servers, you're bound by their rules, because much like going to their building, you are on their private property. The thing is, they spent over a decade making sure that people trusted that their data would always be there, and that storing it in someone else's private property indefinitely, somehow, wasn't a problem. It was always a problem. If you want to keep your data indefinitely, you have to know how to store it yourself on your own storage mediums that you keep in your own home and on your own computers/servers. So, Google is currently doing nothing wrong, based on the realities of security and cost of data storage. The wrong they did was convincing users for over a decade that this wouldn't happen, knowing full well that eventually it would.
- tivert 4y ago> That Google account that your dead friend had that you keep on your buddy list because it gives you memories? Gone. That Facebook account with your dead family members photos and timeline? Gone. The Twitter account with all the tweets from you child who died too soon? Gone. And unless you're the account owner, good luck archiving any of that. I believe Facebook is extremely hostile to scraping, and I don't think Twitter is very easy, either.
- ajross 4y ago> Photobucket (remember them!) kept hundreds and hundreds of photos in my account Photobucket doesn't even offer free service anymore. Isn't this proving the opposite of your point? They couldn't afford to do what you're asking, so they stopped.
- pizza 4y agoIt’s hard to say from outside the org whether they did it because the costs were too high rather than because someone just wanted to so it to make even more money per new user
- doodlebugging 4y ago>I see no reason why we should expect a company to keep providing storage for dormant accounts beyond 2 years though. Remember when Google said they would hold on to everything that their users did on their site forever? People were concerned about the privacy implications, etc. and how a part of their lives that maybe they didn't want anyone to know about would be out there, probably for sale, forever. Well as far as I'm concerned Google made their bed and now they get to lie in it. Don't piss down my neck and tell me it's raining. They promised (or threatened, or noted) that they would hold onto it forever and that storage costs were manageable, etc. They need to be held to it. In my case that means they get to archive all my junk mail (a few hundred emails with account info for places I might never visit again) since that is the sole purpose of my gmail account and I haven't intentionally used google search in years since DuckDuckGo showed up as an option. This is actually funny to me. Life caught up with them and forever ended up being a much more normal, physically quantifiable time period that fit nicely in less than a human lifetime. But still, they should be forced to live up to their promises, or threats, etc.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rippercushions 4y ago> Remember when Google said they would hold on to everything that their users did on their site forever? Err, no, as a matter of fact I don't. Would you have a cite for this?
- jfoutz 4y agoit's probably a wishful interpretation from the initial coverage, https://slashdot.org/story/04/04/01/0038200/googles-gmail-to-offer-1gb-e-mail-storage https://slashdot.org/story/04/04/01/0038200/googles-gmail-to... "hey want to offer their searching capabilities so that users can search through their entire set of e-mail, I guess forever. " https://googlepress.blogspot.com/2004/04/google-gets-message-launches-gmail.html https://googlepress.blogspot.com/2004/04/google-gets-message... "Storage: Google believes people should be able to hold onto their mail forever. That’s why Gmail comes with 1,000 megabytes (1 gigabyte) of free storage – more than 100 times what most other free webmail services offer." (at the time, I thought it meant forever, silly me)
- panic 4y agoThe issue is with the expectation they’ve set. “Store your important data with us, and we'll keep it safe” was the message many people got, even if they never actually promised to do that.
- benatkin 4y agoYes, and their "plenty of time" is six months from the announcement.
- Aeolun 4y ago> it's a for-profit company that gives you free products in exchange for ads Exactly. If I stop using their free services, do I stop seeing their ads though? Because that’s kind of required to make this argument work. Or it’s just Google gets to delete my data because they have all the power in this relationship? I get to keep being fed ads, make Google money, lose my data, and cost Google less at the same time. There’s only one side of the relationship that benefits off any of this.
- nhinck2 4y ago> Exactly. If I stop using their free services, do I stop seeing their ads though? How would you be seeing their ads if you aren't using their services?
- Aeolun 4y agoHave you gone to any site on the internet in say, the last 20 years?
- chrismcb 4y agoYeah, I think if you stop using their free service you do seeing their ads. I'm pretty sure you are talking about using a Google service... Which you wouldn't use unless it benefits you. So no there isn't only one side that benefits
- lamontcg 4y ago> If this were a government-provided service then it would be one thing. But it's not, it's a for-profit company that gives you free products in exchange for ads. It is so big it is nearly a monopoly and it is part of our lives which is almost impossible to avoid. It should be regulated a lot more like a government and not treated like some kind of startup business.
- CapstanRoller 4y ago[dead]
- tedunangst 4y agoThe storage costs to google are also asymptotically approaching zero, too, no? Last year I was using $1 of storage, this year it's 0.50, ...
- sjfidsfkds 4y agoCost per GB of hard disk has not dropped much in the past few years, the money has to come from somewhere.
- brigandish 4y agoThey make more than 50 cents per year of off people’s info, even from inactive accounts I’d reckon.
- chii 4y ago> 50 cents per year of off people’s info info which they already got, since the account is inactive, it is no longer contributing any new info. So why would they be paying for nothing?
- brigandish 4y agoI didn't say they should, I simply pointed out that the "money [which] has to come from somewhere" is coming from somewhere, they place we all thought it came from - our data.
- sjfidsfkds 4y agoThe money faucet is search ads. If you aren’t an active user you aren’t clicking on search ads.
- autoexec 4y ago> the money has to come from somewhere. I mean, they do have billions in profits so...
- 8note 4y agoI think the obvious alternative is nationalization? Why should email be run by Google?
- qotgalaxy 4y ago[dead]
- aimor 4y agoI found out yesterday that my Google Voice number was no longer mine. No inactivity warning email like I had received in the past, no notice at all, I just tried to Zelle some money to myself (testing the service with $1, thankfully) and was surprised to find out the number wasn't mine anymore. I wanted to contact Google to ask if there was any hope of getting it back, but I couldn't find a way to reach them. The Voice app lists a developer email, apps-help@google.com , which returns this message: "You have emailed an address that is no longer being monitored." I understand it's a free service, that I'm not a paying customer, that I was wasting a resource by not actively using the service. It's distressing to be given something by someone with power, to use the thing and in small ways rely on it and enjoy it, then suddenly it's taken away. I hope every inactive person gets their notices before they lose their data. I didn't for my Voice number and now I'm trying to sort out all the services I have tied to it. Again, I understand Google has all the power. I had no leverage and shouldn't have had any expectations for how I'd be treated. However the amount of goodwill I have towards Google is rapidly approaching zero. I've read a thousand messages here saying variations of, "don't rely on Google, you will get hosed eventually". This (deleting inactive accounts with no option to opt out) is the kind of treatment that annoys people, eventually hurts them, and turns them off of a service.
- nashashmi 4y agoI remember the email that asked me if I wanted to keep my number. New accounts were paid for. And mine was free. I said yes to keep.
- kyrra 4y agoYou should get inactive email alerts. I got them regularly from March 2019 until Oct 2022 (I got rid of the number finally). The email has the subject of: > Your Google Voice number (xxx) xxx-xxxx will expire in 30 days Sent by "voice-noreply@google.com".
- zdimension 4y ago> And as other reporting has noted, they're not deleting YouTube videos I haven't seen anything mentioning that, do you have a source for it? Old YouTube videos disappearing are my main concern from this policy change
- branon 4y agoYeah this seems wrong, from the link it appears they definitely WILL delete YouTube videos: > Starting later this year, if a Google Account has not been used or signed into for at least 2 years, we may delete the account and its contents – including content within Google Workspace (Gmail, Docs, Drive, Meet, Calendar), YouTube and Google Photos. This needs to be frontpage of HN for MUCH longer, this is honestly catastrophic. So much knowledge will be lost, imagine if public libraries started throwing books away if authors didn't publish any new books for 2 years. This is insane from my perspective (though I see how it makes sense from Google's) This needs to be talked about MUCH more, though even as I'm writing these words I doubt the utility of even discussing it - nobody except Google has the ability to even store all of this. Data hoarders are backing up Imgur prior to their purge... but Google is about to rip YouTube a new one. This looks insurmountable.
- tinus_hn 4y agoIt’s not only keeping the old emails, if your email address becomes available for registration an attacker can also register it and receive password reset emails etcetera.
- noobermin 4y agoThis is probably a real hot take, but some services should indeed be public utilities and be run by a non-profit. That way we can avoid the constant debates about deplatforming and all that.
- Vvector 4y agoMaybe the USPS? No way I'd trust them
- ksec 4y ago> If you're not using it, how long is Google (a for-profit company) I vaguely remember Google promise not to delete your account in the era when they said they do no evil. That was before smartphone era and probably before their IPO.
- to11mtm 4y ago> what about if you go to jail for more than 2 years, or you're in poor health for multi-year stretches? Then pay for a cheap Google One subscription, export your data with Takeout, or have a trusted friend log in once a year. At least for the first case, that assumes a lot of leeway in the justice system of a given country. Not everyone gets the SBF/Elizabeth Holmes treatment. To say nothing of other risks, and the layering of other provider's kafka-esque policies. As an example, I have a few service accounts tied to a barely used gmail address. -Primarily- because those services [0] don't have a good/any way to move accounts between e-mails or merge accounts between two separate emails. [0] - One of which is Sony, not exactly a bit player