4 ms·
US may default on debt as soon as June 1, Yellen reaffirms
- tivert 4y agoI like the new spirit of bipartisanship, where each side would rather blow up the economy than negotiate or compromise. They've even spent months talking about how bad it will be, but it it will actually be that bad, why won't they budge?
- kylehotchkiss 4y agoThe solution to this thing always seems to be "social security is going to stop payments during the default so all recipients will clog their representatives phones threatening to vote for the other party"
- ttymck 4y agoThis should tell you more about the ineffectiveness of our "democracy" than it does about the integrity of the individuals in office
- dist-epoch 4y agoThey won't. Both republicans and democrats are heavily invested in the stock market which will crash and burn if US defaults. It's all a show.
- blibble 4y agoin games of chicken there's one possible outcome where both sides lose
- dist-epoch 4y agoIn fast reaction time ones. This is a slow burner.
- kccoder 4y agoCouldn't some reps just bet against the market, and invest in other currencies, and ...?
- bryanlarsen 4y agoI don't think both-sidesism is appropriate here. The Democrats did not pull this stunt on the Republicans even though the $1T Trump tax cuts could have been used as a motivation.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoYeah, funny how the GOP only pulls this stuff when there's a Dem president (and the Dems have never pulled this on a R president).
- tivert 4y ago> Yeah, funny how the GOP only pulls this stuff when there's a Dem president (and the Dems have never pulled this on a R president). That's a selective reading. The parties aren't perfectly symmetrical. The Dems like spending, so they're not going to challenge the debt. They have their own stuff they want to "pull," like trying to abolish the filibuster or pack the Supreme court because it's not currently controlled by liberals.
- UncleOxidant 4y ago> like trying to abolish the filibuster or pack the Supreme court Note that they haven't been able to do either. If enough Democrats were on board with those items (the filibuster would have to be abolished before the packing court packing could begin) it would've happened by now. But many Democrats in the Executive and Legislative branches are very hesitant to do those things. GOP congress folks have not been hesitant to play chicken with the debt ceiling.
- tivert 4y ago> Note that they haven't been able to do either. They were very, very close. IMHO, it's only a matter of time, and when it happens, there will be no delay.
- yamtaddle 4y ago> The Dems like spending, so they're not going to challenge the debt. A lot of our current deficit is due to tax cuts in the current century (Bush, Trump) and I suppose you'd agree that Dems dislike tax cuts, so why haven't they tried to push increases/cut-reversals in debt ceiling negotiations?
- emodendroket 4y agoAgreeing to negotiate or compromise itself legitimates the strategy of refusing to pass the debt ceiling.
- tivert 4y ago> Agreeing to negotiate or compromise itself legitimates the strategy of refusing to pass the debt ceiling. And defaulting is somehow better than that?
- emodendroket 4y agoOnce you agree to make concessions because your counterparty threatens to cause economic disaster if you do not, you have encouraged them to do that over and over again to get their way.
- tivert 4y ago> Once you agree to make concessions because your counterparty threatens to cause economic disaster if you do not, you have encouraged them to do that over and over again to get their way. That's just a rationalization for being unwilling to cooperate and compromise. They're both in a car heading towards a cliff. One party has its foot on the gas, the other has its hands on the wheel, and neither will move. Complaining about how unreasonable the other side is doesn't change that fact doesn't make your side reasonable except to your partisans. If the Republicans were responsible, they wouldn't be refusing to pass a debt limit increase. If the Democrats were responsible, they'd compromise now and wait for the next opportunity to repeal the debt limit (not fantasizing about untried gimmicks like platinum coins and a constitutional challenge). Neither party is being responsible.
- yamtaddle 4y agoOnly one party's making demands and threatening to drive off the cliff if those demands are not met, though.
- zaptheimpaler 4y agoIt's not purely a question of cooperation. The debt is real. How many times are they going to raise the debt ceiling and how high will inflation go if they keep doing that?
- bullfightonmars 4y ago...until taxes are raised to an appropriate level to cover expenditures?
- GrinningFool 4y agoWhen my bills come due, I can't refuse to pay while I figure out how to reduce my spending/increase my income in the future. No matter how much I need to change that future spending, I still owe money today. How is this different?
- sacrosancty 4y ago[dead]
- yamtaddle 4y agoThe "debt ceiling" and having to raise it separately from committing to spend money is basically a dumb accident that we can't get rid of because one side finds it politically useful to do this dance every time the other party's got the presidency, and the other side's terrified of the attack ads that would play if they proposed getting rid of it.
- Dylan16807 4y agoI haven't seen much correlation between the debt ceiling and inflation, so I would guess "not very high".
- mc32 4y agoEnough of the print moar money. It's time we defaulted, so the fed, treasury sec and the GOV finally take budgets and their deficits seriously and not act like the GOV is living like a trust fund kid where mommy and daddy (taxpayers and foreign investors) ensure the funds keep flowing. If Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton could swing it during hard times then Gov has no excuse not to be able to do it now.
- lghh 4y agoAh yes, hold the economy hostage to teach a few people in government offices a lesson. Certainly, the outcomes of that will only affect those people in office.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoWhat is the Fed supposed to do when Congress creates the budget and allocates money to be spent? This is Congress attempting to not pay for what it already pledged to pay for, all because they think they can strongarm a far-right agenda through in legislation.
- yamtaddle 4y agoThe 90s "irrational exuberance" (to quote Greenspan) years being budgetary hard times is... not a take I've seen before. (the crash wasn't until '01/'02)
- HDThoreaun 4y agoBipartisanship is dead. Both sides see the other as terrorists who only negotiate in bad faith. They also believe anyone calling for it is doing so in bad faith which is why you are being downvoted.
- jaybrendansmith 4y agoI call Bothsidesism. There's only one side that are political terrorists. Only one side has consistently blown up the economy and budget. 25% of the current debt is from Trump's tax cuts for the 1%. Only one side tried to overthrow the government, and won't back away from the big lie. It's exhausting. It would be one thing if anything they wanted was based on facts, or logic, or something. But no, it's all nonsense, just more weaponized propaganda from the billionaires. So yes, I think that side is deserving of a $1T platinum coin, and the 14th amendment, and oh so much more.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoWell you certainly see the other side as terrorists. Pretty sure the other side sees you the same way.
- jaybrendansmith 4y agoStupid is as stupid does.
- no_wizard 4y agoPart of me wants the democrats to keep playing chicken with the Republicans. I generally back the liberal policies outlined in the democrats version of the bill (it’s focused on closing tax loopholes to pay for things). More importantly Republicans have shown time and again they are willing to consistently hold their positions without any expectation they'll have to compromise and berate other legislators and bully around to get what they want, I don’t want to see democrats give in to that again and again and again EDIT: Couldn't Biden do an end run around the Republicans by strategically calling an emergency session after hours via Article II, Section 3 of the constitution? It has no requirements that the majority leader be there to start quorum, only that the session has been declared. Then attending democrats could just vote this thing through and call absence on the rest
- yamtaddle 4y agoBest case IMO is that the deadline passes, Biden picks one method or another to pay for the already-budgeted-by-Congress spending anyway, that's affirmed as OK by the courts, and I get to never hear the words "debt ceiling" ever again.
- emodendroket 4y agoThis seems like an optimistic view of the courts.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoSure, there's a chance the "original intent" contingent says it's limited only to gov pensions and military. In that case go with the $1T platinum coin. There's also some option for the Fed to buy treasuries maturing during that period.
- emodendroket 4y agoI think that they rule based on their political preferences and come up with post hoc rationalizations afterward. Therefore, it doesn’t really matter which method is chosen.
- givemeethekeys 4y agoWhat happens if the treasury runs out of money? Does government shut down? Do they pick and choose which agencies cease to operate until more tax $ show up? Do they prioritize interest payment over other expenses?
- HDThoreaun 4y agoFirst they try a myriad of loopholes that have never been tried. These include the fabled "trillion dollar coin" as well as an executive order based of a clause in the fourteenth amendment. After that I think it's up to Biden to focus on bond repayment versus shutting down services. We've had government shutdowns before, surely the same thing that happened then would happen again. National parks shut down and non essential federal services have employees furloughed. The real answer though I think is that we don't really know and it's up to the courts.
- eclipticplane 4y agoWe've never faced shutdown due to the debt limit. We've only ever faced shutdowns due to budgets not being passed. Both are awful. But the former is _far_ worse.
- MuffinFlavored 4y agoWhat was the process in which the U.S. passed legislation to inject capital into the system through the Federal Reserve + Treasury during COVID relief? Why can't/won't that happen here?
- UncleOxidant 4y agoThe problem is that "pass legislation" part.
- MuffinFlavored 4y agoWhy were the same legislators willing to print money for COVID relief but not US debt ceiling? Isn't it a basic law of economics that the debt ceiling needs to be readjusted basically annually due to inflation since it's denominated in dollars, which are inflating slowly every month?
- tikkun 4y agoMarket implies a 3.9% probability of default (US 1 year credit default swap, which is basically a product for buying insurance against the risk of a US default risk). https://www.msci.com/www/blog-posts/the-cds-market-s-view-on-us/03820087801 https://www.msci.com/www/blog-posts/the-cds-market-s-view-on... It feels like we've gotten here (to the point of massive national debt, and an economy where rate hikes wipe out banks) for a few reasons: 1) The US economy is like a big forest. Good forest management involves doing controlled burns or allowing small fires. The US has prevented small fires. So now we have a very overgrown, very flammable forest. 2) The US abusing its position as a world monopoly, basically to make money. Issuing more currency as one key way of doing that. There are good monopolies and bad monopolies. I'd argue Amazon is a good monopoly - they continually reinvest in making their product better for customers, keeping the potential gap between what a benevolent monopoly could do, and what they're actually doing, small. Then there are other monopolies like certain large enterprise software companies, that take advantage of their moat to extract value and don't reinvest much. The US govt has done the latter. Burning the forest down would be chaotic for the world. The world doesn't want that. The question is - how do you fix it without burning the forest down?
- 88913527 4y agoThe implied 3.9% probability is lacking context, since reaching the debt ceiling is a fairly regular occurrence. Is this probability any different from previous times is what should we should be asking.
- mateo411 4y agoWhy is the US economy like a big forest?
- curiousgal 4y agoThat probability of default is based on the credit triangle which is a back of envelope type of estimation, I would take the number for face value at all.
- patrickmay 4y agoDisallow spending more than was received in the past fiscal year. Force Congress to do the hard job of balancing the budget instead of relying on ever increasing debt.
- WarOnPrivacy 4y agoLike every American my age, I've been here so often I should have my own room.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kgwxd 4y agoNobody cares. Why is CNN parroting republican talking points now? This is a non-event designed to rile up an idiotic base.
- yamtaddle 4y ago1) Fake scares gets eyeballs, which is what advertisers pay them for. 2) Many things the media (including Hollywood) do, if you assume the "liberal media" smear is more true than not, don't make much sense—it's as if that smear is kinda bullshit and they all just love money and lots of the owners of the media companies aren't actually left-leaning at all, and, go figure, that does seem to fit reality more than the smear does, while also explaining their confusing-if-they-were-actually-commited-to-the-liberal-cause behavior. 3) CNN has made some moves lately that make it seem like they're trying to pick up some of Fox's audience after the Tucker Carlson firing. This may not be part of that (actually, I doubt it is—see point #1, "the sky is falling!" gets viewers, which sells ads, and that's enough to explain this) but then again, it might be.
- mikewarot 4y agoBiden should have a million, $1,000,000 Platinum Coins minted, and make them fully legal tender. What Billionaire wouldn't want that kind of bling?