19 ms·
Dell goes back on WFH pledge, forces employees to come back to the office
- theshrike79 4y ago> Unlike some other companies’ approaches, Dell seems to be asking workers who live within an hour’s commute to work from the office for three days per week, rather than specific job roles. Hour during rush hour or hour as measured by Google Maps without traffic data? So they're basically asking people to spend 40 hours a month, unpaid, in their car going to and from work with no compensation?
- karolist 4y agoYou are free to live closer if you want to work there, not saying it's right or wrong, just not the 40 hour constant you bring up.
- verall 4y agoThe 40 hours is interesting because it seems like you could also live further from work and it would go down to 0 hours.
- mschuster91 4y ago> You are free to live closer if you want to work there How? Most people can barely make rent as it is, the problem is that almost everywhere the large employers are in the city centers and people can't reasonably move close to there.
- theshrike79 4y agoI know multiple people first hand who moved away from their expensive homes to cheaper and bigger ones during the pandemic when WFH became a standard. There are exactly zero ways you can force those people from their homes back to city apartments. Their kids go to school in the new city, their SOs might have in-person jobs there, they have a huge yard and better quality of living. Some of them theoretically work under an hour away from their current job. If companies force WFH, they will just quit and find a new remote-only job.
- pif 4y ago[flagged]
- Gigachad 4y ago>If companies force WFH, they will just quit and find a new remote-only job. Cool, and I'll apply for the now open position as I have great train access to the city.
- jen20 4y agoDell is in Round Rock which has precisely zero train options besides the model railway exhibition each December, so unless you’re one of the Borrowers, you’re talking crap.
- TexanFeller 4y agoRound Rock is near where a lot of those large and cheap houses are in the first place. The people in small and expensive apartments downtown moved near Round Rock or Cedar Park during the pandemic.
- jen20 4y agoIt’s where they _were_ before the pandemic. All the way out to Leander costs princely sums for cookie cutter suburbs these days. I doubt Dell have adjusted their pay to accommodate that.
- verall 4y agoOur model railway runs hourly but it doesn't go to round rock :P
- Gigachad 4y agoI was talking generally about most companies, but if Dell does have an office in the middle of nowhere, then I guess they will have problems.
- andy_ppp 4y agoI didn’t see them lowering salaries when WFH was implemented in the first place so I don’t think that they should raise salaries when removing it. A few people I know had WFH written into their contracts so I guess they would be able to renegotiate or keep home working. In the end this has always been about manager/owner power, not about getting work done or doing the right thing by your employees.
- jjeaff 4y agoI remember at least proposals from companies like Facebook talking about lowering salaries for people moving to lower cost of living areas. Not sure how broadly it was implemented.
- WheatMillington 4y agoYou're not forced to live at the outside edge of the given commute.
- hnlmorg 4y agoYou say this like it’s a new and offensive idea when in fact this has been the norm for as long as paid workforce has been concept. With regards to hybrid jobs: you can get a job closer to home, but there is a reason why house prices are more expensive in tech hubs and why wages are lower where housing is cheaper. So you can either have cheaper housing but lower income, higher income but higher house prices, or have both but pay the penalty with you time (ie longer commutes). This is how it’s always been and why fully remote jobs have been a great life hack. But you can’t really complain about having to spend you own time commuting should you have a hybrid role.
- georgemcbay 4y ago> this has been the norm for as long as paid workforce has been concept. Just because something has been done for a long time doesn't mean it's fair or right. The standard work week was once 12-14 hours a day, 6 days a week. Things change. > But you can’t really complain about having to spend you own time commuting should you have a hybrid role. Of course you can. You can complain about anything, and sometimes with very good reasons. Ultimately employers are free to demand that employees RTO with no travel time compensation if they want, but it's silly to say this is something the employees can't complain about.
- shjake 4y agoSo one person buys/rents an expensive house just to be closer to the office and not have to commute. Somebody else makes the decision to live 1.5 hours away to save money. How would travel time compensation work in this situation? Why would companies not discriminate implicitly or explicitly against employees who live further away?
- georgemcbay 4y agoI am not advocating for travel time compensation; I am advocating for the right to complain in general. I work from home the vast majority of the time currently with very occasional visits to the office. The office for me is 15 minutes away. I would never accept a job that required a greater than 20-minute single direction commute, so travel time compensation is not on my radar of things to worry about.
- thepostman0 4y agoThe real bind is fitting travel around family life that changed since 2020, kids going to different schools and spouse changing jobs means work life balance is shared differently for most people. I can see the issue going beyond pay, people can't be into places at once, but you can put the hours in when remote spread over the day.
- u801e 4y agoMaybe employees should take that into account. If work hours are from 9 am through 5 pm, then the commute starts at 9 am and again at 4 pm.
- flakeoil 4y agoIf you don't want to work, you don't have to. Why don't you just resign instead and stay in bed 9-5?
- whateveracct 4y agoI do work and quitting time is 1pm every day :) not a bad way to make a lot of money
- mkl95 4y agoA major perk of going to the office is that you will be able to replace your Dell's battery pretty quickly when it swells like a balloon.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dry_soup 4y agoIt's quite clear to me that tech companies know that reneging on WFH will cause some employees to leave. I think that this is actually the entire point. You can do a soft layoff, without ever having to say the word layoff, and without ever getting "Tech company XYZ announces layoffs" headlines.
- throwaway5371 4y agowhere are they gonna go when few allow wfh?
- nlnn 4y agoEven if none allow WFH, they might go somewhere with less of a commute, or to a more trustworthy employer that doesn't backtrack on promises.
- scarface74 4y agoPeople are still acting like the current job environment doesn’t suck. Where are these trustworthy companies currently that aren’t also announcing layoffs or that you can count on not to have layoffs?
- nlnn 4y agoI don't think you can count of any company not to have layoffs, that's quite dependant on the economy, company performance, sector, etc. If a company promised no layoffs ever, I wouldn't believe them. But if they promised to continue WFH, I'd believe them, since that's directly under their control.
- scarface74 4y agoNo you can’t. But the odds are better for not having layoffs if they are actually profitable.
- komali2 4y ago
- 49erfangoniners 4y agoDude you're getting a different job
- jen20 4y agoThinking about it, perhaps Dell should shut it all down and return the money to the shareholders.
- hbogert 4y agoWhy would people suddenly need to take up childcare? Did those employees conflate WFH with skimping on childcare? I know the answer to that.. I had those colleagues. It's a shitty move on their part, their output was definitely less and reflects poorly on people who actually did their hours WFH and outputted more!
- olliej 4y ago[flagged]
- WheatMillington 4y agoChildcare is a job, especially with younger kids under, say, 6. The idea that you can execute childcare and your full time job effectively, simultaneously, is just a joke.
- olliej 4y agoNo. Again with the projection. Just because you are unable to get your job done while having children around doesn't mean that's true of others. It tells me that your only measure of getting a job done is "are you 'doing your job' from 9 to 5 with no break" rather than "are you getting the work your job requires done". Which is the standard trope of all these "we must be in the office, because without being in the office we lack the emotional maturity and competence to do our job" asshats. I am done listening to all this "you must be in the office to do a job that has no functional requirement to be in an office" BS from people who are apparently not capable of doing their own jobs without being hand held. Just because you can't do your own job without being in an office doesn't mean other people can't, so stop projecting your own issues on others and accept that maybe other people have different weakness. I can recognize that "Getting my job done without an office" discipline isn't universal, why are you folk incapable of recognizing that your own weaknesses are not also universal?
- viraptor 4y ago> Just because you are unable to get your job done while having children around doesn't mean that's true of others. No, it really is. There's probably some age threshold where you can say "I don't care what you're doing, don't bother me for the next X hours" (that's not taking care of your child though). Below that threshold... what do you expect to happen when your kid wants to play and has a meltdown next to you? Some days they demand ~100% of your time and there's no way around it - you would not be able to do your job while trying to look after the kid.
- thepostman0 4y agoIf you're remote and move, then work requires you to change office location, in UK employment law I think they have to cover moving expenses. That could mean you get a moving allowance that you put into bricks. I'm not sure how it works but I'd hope that the building and land at kept at the same size.
- deofoo 4y agoI guess we need to start enforcing WFH policy in our contracts. I have zero trust in companies to respect WFM without it. Something like, if they break the policy, an amount of X months will be paid for the employee.
- ternaryoperator 4y agoWhat contracts? Is there any major US tech company that has employment contracts? Certainly none that I've worked at.
- jorlow 4y agoThey for sure all have contracts. If nothing else with non disclosure clauses.
- zarzavat 4y agoWait what, how does that work? How can you employ someone without a contract?
- Havoc 4y agoPink promise driven employment?
- fuzzy2 4y agoAn employment contract will absolutely exist for employees. Just because at-will means it can be terminated at any time doesn’t mean there is no contract.
- jve 4y agoActually they go to hybrid and offers case-by-case options to people that need fully remote.
- noobdev9000 4y agoProbably have enough data to judge WFH experiment as failed.
- throwbadubadu 4y agoOr probably just some politics based on beliefs and sensitivities took hold, as often, not specific to this company and topic? ;) (Otherwise, why not bring up this data to justify something that you know will frustrate some employees?)
- DoctorDabadedoo 4y agoProbably enough data to support that WFH is against the status quo, takes effort to make it work and upper management isn't comfortable with it. It's not for everyone, but nothing is.
- SonOfKyuss 4y agoHow so? There are still many more people doing fine working from home now than before the pandemic. I would say we probably have enough data to judge that WFH works for some jobs/businesses and not others. I don’t think many people expected every business to switch to 100% permanent WFH. The fact that some companies are pulling back doesn’t mean the experiment has failed.
- hooby 4y ago> Microsoft announced a report indicating that workers were indeed productive at home (and sometimes more so), just that managers were failing to have confidence in workers. Maybe it's down to management style. It's long known that (at least in somewhat creative and self-directed jobs) workers who are motivated and happy with their jobs are more productive than those who are not. Managers then have to work hard, to keep motivation up and people happy. Let's call this the "supportive" management style. It's also known that frustrated, unhappy workers are more likely to skip as much work as they can get away with, and do only as much as they are forced/required to do. Managers than have to work hard to control and monitor everyone, to keep the slack to a minimum. Let's call this the "adversarial" management style. In one of those styles, WFH employees can be more productive, more happy, and more efficient. In the other, WFH employees can't be monitored closely enough to keep them from slacking. Some managers prefer one style over the other, and not many are able to switch styles.
- kubb 4y agoIt's more about lower management becoming less needed. If a dude managing a team of 5 and not contributing anything can't have f2f meetings all day he suddenly feels obsolete and fears for his future at the company. Of course he will sacrifice his 5 reports to feel more important so he communicates up the chain that it's absolutely vital that they return to the office. 5 guys will commute for a combined 50 hours per week so that 1 guy who doesn't do anything can keep his job. "Efficiency".
- lozenge 4y agoI feel this, as I get to make decisions on my own at home. In the office I need to discuss and explain all the options, only to have my manager make the same decision I would come to.
- globalise83 4y agoDecision-making processes shouldn't really be affected - if someone's manager has a psychological need to rubber-stamp their decisions, then that is just as necessary with them working from home as in the office, and failure to do so will ultimately lead to conflict and probably looking for a new job in the end.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jorlow 4y agoMuch of the discussion is philosophical about commutes and keeping an eye on kids while wfh. But those issues aren't new. What's egregious to me is companies committing to something which has major life and financial implications to the people that work there and then pulling the rug out.
- ciropantera 4y agoYeah that's the most interesting thing for me as well. I'm also curious about how wfh was granted and then removed: was there a contract change to guarantee it? Or did they simply "promise" to do so? If there was a contractual change to guarantee wfh, can they make another change and remove it just like that? I've learned the hard way to never organize my life around benefits that are "promised" but not in my contract. This here is exactly what happens every single time: the person who made you the promise leaves the company and the promise goes along with them.
- revicon 4y agoWhat are these "contracts" you're referring to? I've worked full time in tech for 25 years and I've never had a contract of any sort that I'm aware of.
- mk89 4y agoyou can have it written in your contract that you work from home. in some countries it's necessary to pay taxes differently, for example.
- larkost 4y agoI think the disconnect is that in Europe employment contracts spell out a lot. In the U.S. they are really don't cover a lot about how you work. The common phrase in the U.S. is "additional tasks and duties as required", which could mean anything.
- 4y ago
- lnsru 4y ago3 days in the office is fine for me. Though I work sometimes with hardware. Big corp I work for asked to be in the office 4 days and the managers asked in private to be whole week here and they might spare us from next wave of layoffs. Logical solution is job search. I feel very bad for my new subordinate. One year ago I promised him nice salary, good home office rules (he’s doing remote master degree) and rather boring tasks. Salary was reduced half year ago and now full back to the office. Poor guy…
- DoctorMckay101 4y agoI think my sentiments are best expressed in a greentext manner: > be me > wfh as a soft dev for a big tech company > company tells me to come back to the office > they claim it is to promote coworking and socialize > have to wake up an hour earlier > 1h commute, no real public transport options > get stuck in traffic, +20 minutes > arrive late at office > no matter, no one checks office logs and I turned on my laptop in the car > half of the workers are wfh > no one from my team is there > remember they are not even from the same city lol > put on my headphones > zoom meeting, have to book a room > finish meeting > put some spotify on > don't talk to nobody for 6h > make a greentext in ycombinator > leave an hour earlier because no one checks office logs > 1h commute back
- noncoml 4y agoIn my latest 1-on-1 my manager was asking me to go back to office. In the same meeting a bit later when I said I’m underutilized and asked for more work, he said there isn’t much work to be done at the time other the sustaining I’ve been already doing. He just wants me to be in office just for the shake of being in office..
- DoctorMckay101 4y agoPretty much, yeah. In my case I would not care about going to the office if it were anywhere near downtown. That way I could go down to my local pub or game store after work. However, my company is located in the periphery of the city. If I want to go anywhere that means getting in my car once more.
- xiphias2 4y agoIf you look at a financial point of view lot of companies need to show that offices are still critical for working, because office valuations (that the company may own or long term lease) are plummeting.
- izacus 4y agoThis conspiracy theory is repeatedly being dragged out but can you give any kind of proof that offices are actually something that moves a needle on any companies financial statement in a way that INCREASES profits?
- gorgoiler 4y agoThe actual journalism, linked to from TechRadar, is here: https://www.theregister.com/2023/05/10/dell_remote_work_revision/ https://www.theregister.com/2023/05/10/dell_remote_work_revi... Neither article gives Dell reasons for telling people to come in more often. The only quotes are from the past, and allude to productivity in new hires being low — the same reason Zuckerberg is bringing Meta back into the office.
- namdnay 4y agoWith a stock image of people using... macbooks :)
- commitpizza 4y agoIf my company would mandate this, I would look for another job.
- ngrilly 4y agoI'd be really curious to read the memos — if there is any... — explaining the rationale leading to those decisions. What concrete problems have they seen with the WFH setup? But also what advantages? How does it compare to the pros and cons of working at the office?
- euroderf 4y ago3 days a week is enough to ensure that their employees don't have two full-time jobs, if other employers institute the same requirement. Sort of like, a gal is by definition your main squeeze if you're with her 4 or more nights out of every 7.
- bowsamic 4y agoThese companies made a bad bet on the long-term impact of the pandemic. At the time, it seemed like remote work was the inevitable future, but now we are out of the pandemic and it seems totally possible to return to before, so why not?
- hashtag-til 4y agoTried reading, but there are so many pop-ups and alerts and "type your e-mail for our newsletter", which makes this site very annoying.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoIt could be just another downsizing/layoffs, but instead of directly firing people, they just take away the perks, until enough people quit.
- cauliflower99 4y agoAll the people here saying WFH employees are happier than those who aren't are completely incorrect in the long term. This claim does not account for a very large group of employees: The junior engineer. A junior learns at a fraction of the pace of a senior and relies on direct 1-1 help, together with learning by observing others. This is quite difficult online and requires a lot of hand-holding which most mid-level / seniors are not willing to do. So saying that WFH policies should be the norm is no longer an acceptable statement. It sacrifices the longevity of the team and the company if juniors cannot be onboarded quickly.
- scarface74 4y agoEasy, in todays market, there are plenty of experienced developers who are being laid off so you don’t have to hire juniors. There is no statistic longevity in tech. It’s well known that the quickest method to make more money especially when starting out is to change jobs after two or three years. Salary compression and inversion is real. Yes I know it’s a prisoner’s dilemma. If no one is willing to hire juniors, then how do you get a pool of seniors. It’s a local maximization problem
- jen20 4y agoIt’s not like sitting in one place makes someone a more “senior” dev in anything but tenure. Juniors who stay at one company tend not to be developers with 10 years of experience at the end, but instead developers with 1 year of experience 10 times.
- scarface74 4y agoAnd that’s good enough for that company. It’s a problem when they get ready to get a new job.
- jen20 4y agoExactly: all this bullshit about job hopping benefits only low grade employers who want fungible employees. Screw them all: hop away!
- stephc_int13 4y agoThis is not surprising, given the recent waves, that corporate goons will try to reverse the steam on this subject.
- newsclues 4y agoI'd love to see a number of businesses split into companies that are Office or WFH, and see the competition that occurs. My guess is that ultimately high performers will migrate to one or the either and it may depend on what industry. I think many of the conversations happen in silos (software devs) and the reality is messier than anyone thinks.
- throwawaaarrgh 4y agoWorking from the office is a management strategy. It goes like this: If you work remote, you have to actually write down things, like 1. who your workers are, 2. what the teams are, 3. where they are, 4. how to contact them, 5. what they're working on, 6. who else they depend on or who depends on them, etc. There are a lot of new tools to learn, you have to learn how to ask for someones time and schedule time. That's a lot of work that managers don't want to do. If you work from the office, you mostly have to: 1. walk around the office and ask someone. Interrupt whatever they're doing to ask anything you want anytime. Of course, there may be many offices, but then you call the other offices and ask the secretary to go around and ask people. It's also very easy when wfh to accidentally leave a paper trail or records of conversations you'd rather stay hidden. In an office you can just talk in person with no record. Wfh is a right that white collar workers are gonna have to fight for, the way all unions have had to fight for the rights workers deserve. Don't threaten to quit, threaten to unionize.
- TexanFeller 4y ago> If you work from the office, you mostly have to: 1. walk around the office and ask someone. Interrupt whatever they're doing to ask anything you want anytime. In the office one person at a time can DOS attack my attention and everyone else can see I'm busy helping them. Slack is far worse, multiple coworkers are DDOS attacking me and 10 more unread messages pop up before I finish helping the first guy.
- joshstrange 4y agoThis same thing happens in an office if it's not small/one big shared workspace. Literally no difference. Also if you have other offices/remote works this can happen even with WFO. People message me while I'm on zoom, I tell them I'm busy but I'll get to them in the order they reached out. It works just fine. I have a note on my computer I add their name to and once I get off zoom I check if I still need to reach out to anyone.
- gedy 4y ago> walk around the office and ... Interrupt whatever they're doing to ask anything you want anytime. Without sarcasm, I think a lot of people think this is what "important hallway conversations" and "collaboration and innovation" are. I also find it hugely disruptive, and it caters to people can mostly only communicate verbally.
- carl_sandland 4y agoI mean I'm kind of shocked we're still getting away with WFH at all; it was just a blip in time and will be gone within 5-10 years entirely. There are very few pure software roles that don't require high-bandwidth, interactive, in-person communications. Simply from a political view, those who are in the office more, by definition, are winning (politics is people).
- manuelabeledo 4y ago> There are very few pure software roles that don't require high-bandwidth, interactive, in-person communications. I would counter that new tools will surface, and they will be remote oriented, making it even easier for people to work from home. At some point, only the "old guard" would want to go back to the office, and will eventually diminish dramatically, like paper did after computers took over. > Simply from a political view, those who are in the office more, by definition, are winning. While this may be true, what about upper management who are fully remote?
- daviddever23box 4y agoStrictly my opinion: upper management who are not servant leaders and individual contributors of their own account are, in fact, doomed. No amount of Kafka-esque office theater will save them from cuts. As for support businesses (food / clothing / commercial real estate / parking / technical services), nearly all of that is also doomed. Urban planners had best figure out how to address the issues of keeping more valuable services (commercial kitchens, entertainment, boutique retail) from fleeing to places closer to home.
- sneed_chucker 4y agoRemote work existed before the pandemic
- soared 4y agoThis is flame bait?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoHas Dell had any layoffs yet? I wonder if this an attrition-boosting cover so they they don't have to call it a layoff.
- josephcsible 4y agoIf a company makes a promise like this, and you either accepted the job because of it, or you already had the job but did something like moving across the country because of it, and they then break their promise, would that count as constructive discharge for purposes of unemployment?
- TrackerFF 4y agoImagine commuting 1 hour each way, that's 520 hours a year. Or almost 22 days of just commuting! If someone asked you to give up 22 days of your life, every year, they'd need a really compelling reason.
- arrowsmith 4y ago> they'd need a really compelling reason. Money?
- ryankrage77 4y agoCommute time isn't usually paid for.
- addisonl 4y agoYou chose where you live and you chose where you work which is why arguments centered around commutes don’t really hold much water.
- TrackerFF 4y agoOh absolutely, and hopefully talented workers will say: "No thanks, I'll rather go and work for someone that offers unlimited WFH."
- Emmy_Toy 4y ago[flagged]
- btbuildem 4y agoI think those that choose to stay at Dell, should now add their commute time to their working hours. Over the past three years we've clearly demonstrated that WFH is effective and productive - shift the cost of travel to the office onto the employers if they want butts in seats so badly.
- judge2020 4y agoThe company can very well fire you if you do this, since DOL does not consider commute time from home to the designated/required work site to be working hours: https://www.dol.gov/general/topic/workhours/traveltime https://www.dol.gov/general/topic/workhours/traveltime
- btbuildem 4y agoThanks for the reference! It's a shame that's the way it is -- but it places the onus on the employer. They would have to fire you, and bear the cost of replacing you.
- brickteacup 4y agoDoesn't really matter if you're salaried though, does it?
- judge2020 4y agoYeah, if you're salaried exempt (there are some salaried non-exempt jobs that can get OT) you can't even put in overtime and aren't entitled to it. https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fact-sheets/17a-overtime https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fact-sheets/17a-overtime
- thedougd 4y agoI recall when Yahoo and then IBM did this. It's all part of the downward spiral.
- puma_ambit 4y agoI might not work for them, but this does affect my perception about them and potentially purchasing products from them if they treat their people like this.
- no_wizard 4y agoMy take on RTO: If its not left up to 100% employee choice and nothing else (and therefore, the policies, processes and procedures don't equally accommodate remote workers) then I think its a power play, as there is no discernible benefit to the business, as others have stated, the Microsoft study that came out, as have other studies, shown that WFH has been a net increase in worker productivity. I do think it should be an employee choice though, there are some folks, even if its less than majority, that work better in an office, for whatever reason, and they should be supported too
- drakenot 4y agoOne thing that I worry about is that the “choice” is actually not real. Those individuals that work better in an office setting, do they work better when everyone else is in the office and they get to interact with them in person? If the person shows up to an office that is pretty sparsely populated and then has to sit in Teams calls — does that even meet their desire? I’m saying this as someone who is strongly pro WFH, have seen my own productivity rise, etc.
- no_wizard 4y agoThe idea is that indeed, yes, choice is real. Being in an office should have tangible benefits beyond seeing people (its nice to just not be home to work). Having to be on calls isn't supposed to be negated by being in an office, since you need to accommodate remote workers too right? If the only reason you're going into the office is to socialize with other people, then I think there's bigger questions to ask
- karaterobot 4y ago> The news comes from COO Jeff Clarke, who sees the move as one that begins to more clearly define what hybrid working means for the company. Hybrid is the worst of both worlds. It's not a solution, it's a new problem. Generally, when management creates a new problem, consultants pop up to sell them a solution. Do we he have an industry of "hybrid work consultants" yet?
- rybosworld 4y agoHybrid is likely just a bridge to full RTO.
- indymike 4y agoThere are really three drivers for work from the office: 1. Investment in real estate. Unoccupied large campuses are very expensive to maintain. 2. Management style. 3. Collaboration (this is really limited as most office workers don't spend more than 1-2h per day "productively" collaborating)
- dehrmann 4y ago> Unoccupied large campuses are very expensive to maintain. It's cheaper than maintaining occupied campuses.
- dzonga 4y ago> managers were failing to have confidence in workers. the most unproductive set of employees i.e managers wanting to see productivity. say it ain't so.
- rybosworld 4y agoI don't think the return to office trend will abate until the economy returns to growth mode. We are in a tightening economy where stock prices are jumping double digit percentages from layoff announcements. Everyone seems to recognize that forcing employees to return to office will result in attrition (aka soft-layoff). Perhaps when growth becomes the focus again, companies will switch back to work from home. The public line of reasoning will be something dumb like "eliminating office costs" or "reducing emissions associated with commute".
- rybosworld 4y agoUnfortunately we live in a world where business leadership at most companies can be boiled down to "monkey see, monkey do". Leaders at mediocre companies can mimic what great companies are doing, and usually get some percentage of the results that the great companies obtained. And, merely appearing to increase productivity is often just as valuable as actually increasing productivity, at least from the perspective of an individual manager. Forced return to office has the benefit of "everyone else is doing it" and at the same time, management can pretend like it has measurable benefits to the business, even if that runs contrary to the available evidence.
- bobobob420 4y agoThe entitlement is bizrre. Sorry but you need to go to office and collaborate with your team members and be part of the office culture. Not sure how working in your pajamas is good for anyone. Obviously there are edge cases but the babying is out of control. Get up and go to work. The entire country runs people working important jobs in medicine, utilities, plumbing, etc who don't get to write code in their pajamas. We need to do a salary swap with actual essential workers..people have lost the sauce.
- TrackerFF 4y agoWhy do we need to do that? If you can do the same task at home, at work, or on the south pole for that mater, why do we NEED to keep the office culture alive? This reeks of "Because that's how we've always done it" Hell, there are plenty of doctors doing consulting over video these days.
- bobobob420 4y agoI wouldnt categorize my job as just doing tasks. It's more of working with others to reach common goals. Just because the task can be done at home doesn't mean its optimal. At the end of the day get up and go to work. Adults are turning into children now.
- MrPatan 4y agoHere is the problem, and it's not a technical problem, you guessed it, it's a people problem, and it doesn't have a solution, because people suck: - It's probably more difficult to do great work WFH than F2F. But I mean "great", properly great stuff, novel, hard, high stakes, high pressure, high coordination, moonshot level. - It's probably not difficult at all to do mid level boring stuff WFH, and everybody saves time and money on top. - 99% of orgs do the later kind of work - 99% of orgs don't like to admit they do the later kind of work This is why we can't have nice things
- chasd00 4y agoIt's hard to teach old dogs new tricks. Management doesn't like wfh because they've probably been "managing" for a long time and would have to change the way they work. Ask a Sr. dev to stop doing what they think they're good at and now start doing something else in a different language with different metrics for success and you'll get the same reaction.
- brailsafe 4y agoI just got laid off in April after months of downtown and getting on bad terms with my manager. Out of the blue he started micromanaging me, and what was once a truely remote frontend job in a completely different timezone (good) became a game where he'd call me in the middle of my day (late evening for him) and then send me passive aggressive slack messages when I wasn't immediately available. There's this managerial idea that people need to be butt in seat ready to go on a video call whenever they feel like initiating it, and that's just one more thing that stripped autonomy away and removed any sense of agency I had in how I got my work done. I was already in a zoom call at 6am most days, so I'd work for a bit, rest or go outside to enjoy the limited daylight, then come back and finish or go to a cafe. He was definitely promoted beyond his capability though, and as a "director of engineering" couldn't keep his hands out of the minutiae of day to day code discussion.
- dahwolf 4y agoCompanies think that a hybrid model is some kind of fair compromise, or perhaps the best of both worlds. Hybrid means you'll commute to work to arrive in an half-empty office. In this office are people sitting in calls all day. You cannot have good old fashioned face-to-face meetings in a hybrid model. Because part of the crew will be remote on any given day. Likewise, you cannot catch up on a project at the coffee corner, because the remote folks won't see that. You need to put all of that in writing, just like you do when everyone is remote. The work-related stuff does not change back to the old ways when you go hybrid, it will remain in remote mode. What hybrid does offer is in-person socialization. Breaks, lunch walks, etc.
- thoughtstheseus 4y agoWork from home does not work well if labor productivity is changing rapidly...