6 ms·
All the exciting media outlets are dying – what comes next?
- 2devnull 4y agoTwitter.
- 908B64B197 4y agoPublications like The Walrus face a double threat. The first is a shift in add spend that favors content aggregators like Facebook and Google. There's simply little interest in long form low quality content, therefore it attracts less eyeballs and companies would rather spend their advertising budget elsewhere. The second is unfair competition by state media. While independent companies like The Walrus have to attract readers, the state medias like CBC and the BBC can simply get a check from the government no matter who's watching.
- houseatrielah 4y ago[dead]
- Gud 4y agoSelf-publishing.
- friend_and_foe 4y agoI think it's pretty obvious what comes next: people talking to each other. Journalism as it was structured is mapped one-to-many. The internet is not structured that way, and attempting to simply disseminate information is not going to cut it. This change necessarily includes echo chambers. We had the early spirit science lizard people ones and we have the ones we have now, but when people can choose who to talk to and share information with you will get this phenomenon. The age of a common narrative binding a diverse society is over. Journalists are simply not going to get paid to do it anymore. You'll have to do the independent journalist thing, find sponsors for your content, host your own website, do the legwork to get an audience, but the corporate ladder for journalists simply no longer exists.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tomjen3 4y ago> “There will always be stories that need assigning,” I told the students in my lecture, “always be an audience who needs something to read.” I still believe that’s true. But with the industry being what it is, career seems like the wrong framework—it’s more like a monetized hobby. No, there isn't. Because print news doesn't, just, compete with social media, it competes with games, with youtube and netflix and, yes, Facebook. I realized some time ago that I only really need to know about specific news that is very local (impact <5 km from me at most) and global news. There is no newspaper that will only give me the first, and most give way too much news for the latter. If you want something to cover local news, you are better of with an AI or a local Facebook group. For the global news, you can take you pick from any of the big media companies, they are pretty much identical.
- fauxpause_ 4y agoSome irony about the request at the bottom: > Fund the journalism we need now > We need you now more than ever. In turbulent times, it is crucial that reliable media remains available to everyone. That is why we depend on your support to keep our journalism accessible and independent. From economic uncertainty to political polarization, the challenges our society is facing today are too important for half-truths. > At The Walrus, the future of journalism is funded by engaged citizens like you. Together, we can preserve the integrity of Canadian media and ensure that our democracy thrives. Will you join us? Anyway. I personally hope we see more orgs that are dedicated to niche topics. They do one thing and you go to them to read their one thing, like the institute of war for Ukraine (and iran/Iraq/Taiwan to lesser degrees). Most news will find its way into the public consciousness if it’s important without journalism.
- tootie 4y ago"Most news will find its way into the public consciousness if it’s important without journalism." That seems wildly inaccurate. Rumors, misinformation and nonsense fly around faster and more freely than news. Citizen journalism has a place but they'd be nowhere without professional newsrooms with wide reach and deep resources.
- fauxpause_ 4y agoWhich is why I like specialized orgs for niche topics.
- andrewclunn 4y ago[flagged]
- nearmuse 4y agoBuzzFeed and Vice were exciting?
- HDThoreaun 4y agoBuzzfeed news had great investigative journalism. Sure it was reputation washing for the rest of the site, but I don't think that makes its content bad.
- jeremyjh 4y agoThey were the very soul of digital journalism apparently. Doubtlessly they will be missed if anyone else notices they are gone.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jjtheblunt 4y agoOriginal title says “All the Exciting…” then cites Buzzfeed and Vice. That’s some clickbait misdirection with reworking the title.
- hef19898 4y agoBuzzfeed, the legit news arm that is, avtually owon a Pulitzer.
- flappyeagle 4y agoProving more the degradation in the quality of the Pulitzer than anything else
- scrollaway 4y agoWhat do you think Buzzfeed News is exactly? Edit since people are flagging this: It’s incredible how the right amount of cynicism can drive you to be utterly blind to the benefits certain things have. Be those high quality news reports, or curing polio. And blind to their structure. Such as, for example and regardless of the organisation’s name, different people working at Buzzfeed News and Buzzfeed. Or Microsoft and the gates foundation.
- flappyeagle 4y agoIt’s reputation washing for a link farm.
- scrollaway 4y agoWhat is your evidence for this claim?
- flappyeagle 4y agoWhenever anyone correctly observed that buzzfeed has made the internet worse, someone always comes galloping in on their white horse with the meme “but buzzfeed news is a real serious outlet!” This has always been its purpose. It exists for the same reason the BP and Exxon have nominal investments in “clean energy”. The same reason that Koch industries donates to the arts. They’re paying for indulgences and the HN well-akchually crowd buys it hook line and sinker. If you don’t want to take my word for it you can take Peretti’s and the words of the Washington post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/media/2022/03/23/buzzfeed-staff-cuts-digital/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/media/2022/03/23/buzzfeed-sta... “I don’t think they ever gave news a real chance to make money,” she said. BuzzFeed chief executive Jonah Peretti long touted the news team’s burnishing effect on the company’s overall reputation“ They never intended for it to be a self sustaining business. It existed for reputation enhancement of the parent brand.
- pembrook 4y agoA big factor in the decline of internet media companies that nobody talks about—every single dominant social platform (except this one) now aggressively penalizes external links in their algorithms. This should be illegal for any dominant platform IMO, external links are the lifeblood of a free and open internet. They are the only release valve from the walled gardens the inevitably result from human power-law clustering and network effects.
- flappyeagle 4y agoWhat are you on about? I have to link to external websites from mine? Lost the plot on this one.
- karaterobot 4y agoCan't tell if you're joking, but it seems pretty clear. If you are a news outlet, reporting on something written by someone else — for example, a government report, a scientific article, even a tweet — it makes sense to link to that external resource in the article. Yet, many websites refuse to do that, because it takes eyeballs away from the ads they're serving. I'd cite a reference supporting what I'm saying here, but I don't want you to stop reading my comment and go to a new page, just take my word for it.
- tester457 4y agoFacebook, Twitter, Elon etc have said external links rank more poorly in the algorithm. That is why facebook is rampant with people stealing others videos and reposting it on the platform.
- flappyeagle 4y agoThere is nothing wrong with this. They get to moderate what’s on their website. If I don’t want X on my website, I can downrank it. Doesn’t matter if that thing is “hate speech”, “porn”, “links to other websites”, “off-topic comments”
- candiddevmike 4y ago
- Fellshard 4y agoThe article uses the qualifier 'exciting' and cites specific examples of what the author considers 'exciting'. Leaving that qualifier in the headline makes this far less panicky than it first sounds.
- incone123 4y agoHopefully someone can fix the title on here. I was misled.
- javajosh 4y ago>"So what do we do for money now? I get this feeling when youtubers complain about being demonetized. Like, why were you monetized in the first place? Shouldn't this be a hobby for you, where your day job is actually helping people? Once a profession is named, there seems to be an expectation of durability. But market fundamentalism allows for no such constants. All professions are subject to the market; if there is no demand, if there is no money, there is no profession. In any event, it's a problem that definitely sorts itself out.
- roer 4y agoI don't understand your comparison to youtubers? They get paid for their work, and complain when the platform demonetizes their videos without being transparent in their reasoning. I understand if you meant that they were complaining about their views decreasing, or their content not being compatible with the guidelines of the platform, but that is in my experience not that common. It feels to me like that part of your argument is just a subjective stab at the value of youtube as a job in society.
- javajosh 4y ago>...a stab at the value of youtube as a job in society Yes. Not to pick on youtube - it's just the strongest of the group of entities of which I'd include buzzfeed, vice and the rest. The world is saturated with entertainment, and it's not good for anyone. It's not good that kids grow up wanting to be youtubers not scientists. It's not good for the entertainers who chase the algorithm instead of building things or helping people.
- the_only_law 4y ago> It's not good that kids grow up wanting to be youtubers not scientists. To be fair, it’s not like being scientist is overly appealing. You have years of education which is potentially very expensive all for what? Crappy paying postgrad work and a modern academic career m or maybe a meh job in industry research that still is probably not paying that great. Not that I think they’d be better off in YouTube, at least on average.
- lr4444lr 4y agoOne of the silver linings to AI mass generated fake news IMHO is that the professional gatekeepers of traditional media will once again be appreciated for the value they add in verification. The so-called "new media" with few exceptions is totally parasitic on them to do the real work which they would use just enough to maintain respectability over their clickbait editorializing. I don't think it's at all a positive that trad med. had to start adapting to some of that, and I'll be happy to see them less encumbered by it.
- tomjen3 4y agoI doubt it. People generally want to be told what they believe, not what is right. I also doubt the journalists do enough real fact checking to matter.
- capableweb 4y agoWell, time will tell if it's a silver lining or not. In my experience, the traditional media tries to follow the trends instead, like clickbait was just done in scammy websites at first, then more and more "legitimate" websites started doing it and now I sometimes see even The Guardian doing clickbait titles sometimes. My fear is that they will start using those AI tools instead of doubling down on quality, because they didn't double down on quality before so why would they now?
- stainablesteel 4y agoestablishment media does nothing but gaslight and ignore important information i'm a little ways west of east palestine and when that train derailed it was twitter and reddit that warned me, the media did nothing plus there are now a ton of individuals across multiple social media sites that are showing information as proper data for a more intellectually honest interpretation of various global trends, crime rates, and economic factors to anyone who looks at it. the news will literally tell you the opposite of what the data says while presenting nothing but the caked-up person who reads their teleprompter. I want better, higher quality information, not gatekeeping.
- cafard 4y ago
- roenxi 4y agoThe major problem I've observed is that the most important topic is politics - ie, what should we do next? The world of journalists is nearly the last place on earth people should be looking for political information. There are lies, few serious attempts at understanding the views of opponents, disinterest in the implications of the policies expounded and not even straightforward reporting of what people actually said. A major problem that the journalists face is that we live in an era where any person with a microphone can broadcast their opinion, and it turns out the thoughtful, intelligent and intellectually honest types don't work in media outlets. People are going to start organising to listen to people of higher quality than journalists. We need high quality information to make informed political decisions. People with journalism degrees, as a community, are not providing that quality. The internet has revealed just how deeply the misdirection and dishonesty extended. There is too much sunlight now for journalism as an institution to survive in the form it always has. We're going to be better off with a mix of economists, religious leaders, political personalities, technical experts, longform discussion and a melange of small- or big-time podcasters.
- pkd 4y agoHonest question: how many people employed as journalists do you personally know? I ask because this sort of comment against an entire profession is generally a symptom of a level of separation that allows for the lack of nuance like "journalists are dishonest". I am troubled by these views shared by so many on HN too. Journalism, especially the editorialised version, as a profession is extremely valuable. There are certainly problems it is facing with the advent of the internet but a replacement that consists of "individuals broadcasting their views" is going to be a worse deal because there will be no expectation for having an editor that sounds out their views. There is no check valve for individual ambition. I would like to see a system that incentives factful reporting instead of sensationalism of course, but I have seen enough to believe that we can't do that with individuals for similar reasons we choose democracy over autocracy most of the time.
- jfengel 4y agoI do know a bunch of journalists, real journos from the 70s and 80s. They'd really hate to be characterized by "misdirection and dishonesty". That was absolutely not what they did, and their editors would not have allowed it. None of them had any financial incentive to be exciting or polarizing. They all very much wanted to get out the truth of the situation, which was a lot more work. But they are also acutely aware how bad their profession has become. Even before the Internet, 24-hour news made journalism about attracting attention. They expected to put out one newspaper a day, or one TV broadcast in the evening. They competed against a small handful of other local media outlets -- they wanted to be the first, but did not expect people to come seeking their specific version of the story. They thought their audience viewed the news as a dull duty, not entertainment. The Internet has made it so, so much worse. The real news outlets still gather news (the wire services, a few major newspapers), but practically everything labeled "news" is secondary, tertiary, or worse. The real primary-source journalists are much like they always were, but few people read those directly. They are mostly fodder for people making entertainment, which does indeed come with lots of "misdirection and dishonesty". If you want factful reporting it's still out there -- via the same few wire services and primary-source newspapers. It's not hard to find -- start anywhere and click on their supporting links until you get to the boots on the ground.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- morkalork 4y agoIt's a shame since Vice's "Motherboard" was pretty good and even broke a few big stories. They understood hacking and tech in ways that traditional media didn't and weren't afraid dig in and involved. Print papers always were so passive, reporting other's investigative work.
- blululu 4y agoIt’s a matter of costs. Publishing long form online is cheap and can generate more revenue (a good article can generate a ton of engagement). Publishing long form in print is very expensive and maybe serves as marketing for a daily. Serious investigative work was always expensive. Only large papers could afford to do it and mostly did it for honor/prestige.
- RobotToaster 4y agoThe related posts at the bottom of that article partly explain why it's happening...
- 7174n6 4y agoThe referenced organizations were so one-sided and biased that they alienated over half of the potential consumer base. It's like they can't see their own face in the mirror.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zpeti 4y agoAs much as many people here will hate this, it’s worth looking at what daily wire does and why it works, they have $200m+ revenue and are profitable. In a recent interview Ben Shapiro said it was never about building a publication but building an audience who you can sell products to. Which is why they are selling films and other content like lectures too. Many left wing orgs could do the same, but all they do is news and advertising. That clearly isn’t enough. So I’d argue the ones that are dying are the ones that haven’t been able to adapt with a new business model.
- wesapien 4y agoThey've become so incompetent that they can't even use their hegemony's victim ideology for their own profit
- mindslight 4y agoSelling low quality products to low information readers/viewers/listeners based on a political message doesn't work in the mainstream context. Rather "right wing news" isn't actually news but rather editorial for the largest "persecuted minority" group, which can be used as an angle for businesses that support the cause. Some examples from the talk radio I was listening to on a little road trip I just took: An "anti-communist" MVNO. "Avoid giving your money to those big companies that hate your values". With rates that are higher than Tracfone or even Cricket, and ultimately just reselling big carrier service. "Invest in gold". I own a bunch of gold myself, but paying higher commissions (and/or management fees) to support radio ads and other hand holding is most certainly not the way to go. "Avoid probate". Not important (and perhaps even harmful) in most states that have adopted the Uniform Probate Code. But it's a good avenue for upselling expensive trusts and the like. (And of course much self promotion by the hosts, and promotion of other media in the same sphere) The equivalent for the left wing would be something like a site for LGBTQ+ people that was marketing small businesses owned/staffed by LGBTQ+ people who understand you. Which I'm sure does work. But it doesn't work for mainstream news outlets that target a broad audience, regardless of how much the right wing insists that those outlets are "leftist".
- vandyswa 4y agoWe stood up a failed local newspaper (yes, newsprint and everything). Local news, local color, but also local commentary on national issues. Who would have thought--human scale and decentralized still has an audience? vashonloop.com if you're curious
- NullInvictus 4y agoIs the story of how the paper was stood up documented anywhere?
- hersko 4y agoIt bothers me that I do not trust any main-stream news source to give me accurate news without molding it into a specific narrative. It's sad that the institutions I should trust the most i tend to trust the least.
- wesapien 4y agoThis is a good thing. Both have overstayed their welcome. Vice made interesting stories in the early 2010s and I watched some of it. The founder of Vice has been so far removed from where he started that he just DGAF. I really didn't care for BuzzFed at all except for the food videos. It was great to see those group of people spin up their own an channel (About To Eat). Another example is the Bon Apetit YouTube channel. Before Covid hit they were one of my favorite channels to watch. They just had a great mix of personalities and ideas. The sum was greater than its parts and they imploded. The channel has never been the same post Covid.
- iudqnolq 4y agoThe other founder of Vice Media left to found the Proud Boys. I don't think their early years were the hight. The mid 2010s were pretty good though.