7 ms·
New Study Finds a High Minimum Wage Creates Jobs
- Projectiboga 4y agoOnce you get over a certain income it gets harder to spend the money quickly locally. The wealthy in a way end up hording their income as they can and often spend it slowly. The wealthy often spend it trading for objects and property from others in their cohort. The difference is the velocity of money for a minimum wage earner compared to the top 1% in very large. In a study in my 1980s economics textbook, the annual multiplier for the bottom 20% of incomes, the money recirculated 11 times more within 12 months. The multiplier for the top cohort (I don't recall if it was a quintile too) was only 0.4 times. That top cohort might spend their money on art, brothels on the other side of the world or on international investments. This is the reason Adam Smith and John Stewart Mill advocated for a progressive income tax and for some legal restraints on corporations and banks. They spend their money slowly and in ways that harm most of us. This study is an example of how putting more money in the pockets of people who are going to spend their money quickly in their immediate neighborhood are going to actually in this case create local economic growth. We need a progressive income tax not for social justice but for better economic efficiency and getting a larger economic pie to all eat from.
- bequanna 4y agoIf the “hoarded” wealth you mention is just getting plowed into assets like existing real estate and the stock market I tend to agree with you. All it serves is to drive up those asset prices, which really doesn’t seem to have much effect and is low velocity. The tax code should discourage this type of investment but actually seems to support it currently. No more 1031 exchanges, less depreciation allowed or depreciation over some longer period, etc. However, investment in new projects, new businesses, new building, etc is very stimulating. This is what the tax code should heavily incentivize.
- Projectiboga 4y agoYes all that happens too, I was specifically referring to the issue that the inheritance exemption is so high that much of that has escaped much taxation.
- bequanna 4y agoBut I think the underlying issue most of us have with inherited wealth is the idea of the idle rich. The people who have inherited and done nothing to get the money they have and are able to passively invest and still pay low taxes. Let’s reduce the incentive to be passive with taxation changes.
- _siis 4y agoThere's some interesting reading about how the taxes should and should not work in the 5th book of the Wealth of Nations. Most copies only include the first 4 volumes. While its not complete, you are somewhat limited in what you can do with the tax code incentives, and generational wealth or concentration into a Bourgeois caste is one of many issues that affect socialism more dramatically than our mixed system (though there still is an effect). The inheritance tax is nonexistent. They kept it in entity vehicles until a law was passed excluding it then they dissolved the entities in a year where there were no tax implications (the entire amount was untaxed). Fiat and debt have their own implications when the money printer runs above capacity. Have you seen the derivative exposure for banks listed at the FDIC website?
- specialist 4y ago> better economic efficiency Yup. Keep the money moving. So weird that corporate media (the plantation class) emphasizes wealth accumulation while ignoring most other metrics like velocity of money and gini coefficient.
- consumer451 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity_of_money https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity_of_money
- panick21_ 4y agoIf a central bank targets a demand variable, changes in minimum wage does not change MV. If V changes the the central bank automatically adjusts M. And inflation targeting is a form of demand targeting. Just linking to Velocity of money is useless.
- courseofaction 4y agoIt was never "the conventional wisdom", as the article postulates, that raising wages would suppress job creation. It was a position held by a few people, which suited those with the power and will to amplify.
- pauldenton 4y agoIt prices low skill or younger workers out of the market Why hire a highschooler who never had a job before for 15$ an hour if you can get a guy with 7 years experience at the same price?
- 3np 4y agoDo you have anything to back that up or would it be some of the good old "common sense"?
- imtringued 4y agoIn classical and neoclassical economics, lowering wages stimulates employment. If there is unemployment, it is because wages are above equilibrium prices and should be lowered. That is the current mainstream of economics but you are right. People who benefit from the status quo need a theory that justifies the status quo.
- panick21_ 4y agoAre you actually an economist with real insight about the current and the last decades of labor economics? Literally all economics practices, with the exception of a few hard core marxists, and a few others is Neoclassical. The people who wrote study are also neoclassical. Its seems you have a ridiculously oversimplified view of economics and the field.
- xyzzy123 4y agoIf you model only the first-order effects (supply and demand of labour as a good, only) then sure, price goes up, it seems pretty clear that demand will go down. If you model the economy in more detail (with stocks and flows of money, and where money in different places has different propensity to be spent and so on) then you can start to talk about second or third order effects which may result in an increase in demand for labour if minimum wages rise. I think ideologically the problem is that simpler models align with "classical / neoclassical" thinking, while more detailed models - even though they may be better (of course this is not a given) - tend to be less convincing firstly because they're harder to explain, and secondly because they tend to incorporate more parameters (so you run the risk of "fitting an elephant"). Personally I have my doubts that complex economies are actually amenable to simple explanations that fit human intuition at all - perhaps we'd be better off treating the whole field more like the weather, fewer elegant theories / word explanations and a lot more computational brute force and observation. I guess a big problem with that is that economics is inherently political, and politics demands narrative.
- mnemonicsloth 4y agoI am not going to say that this is wrong, because I haven't read the study. But it was produced by the Berkeley economics department, which could well be the most left-leaning in the country. Significant parts of it are outright Marxist. Which is fine. Diversity of viewpoints and all that. But when a bunch of leftist economists tell you they've proven something that leftists in general wish desperately were true, you should be skeptical. At least wait for some corroborating evidence to come in before you start writing policy, because you'll hurt people if you get it wrong.
- CyberDildonics 4y agoWhat specific parts of the study are you trying to refute? You have a lot of labels here, you have nothing about the actual study.
- nequo 4y agoI’m curious. Who at the Berkeley economics department is Marxist?
- FranzFerdiNaN 4y agoImplement something that can help people? Surely that is Marxist nonsense!!! Economics isn’t science, it’s politics hiding behind math.
- panick21_ 4y agoEconomics used to be called political economy and split into economics and political science. Economists are well aware that things like 'property' and 'markets' are not some universal absolutes, but engaged in a larger social context. There are whole sub-fields of economics studying all these things. Sure some macro economics that try to abstract over a huge amount of things, by necessary (its literally called 'macro') but even then they are aware that high level decisions have political implications. These anti economics hate mostly generated by people who don't actually follow the discussion within the economic field rather believe in some leftist fantasy buggy man version of the economic field.
- imtringued 4y agoIf you consider human society to be the gradient between the newly created energy reserves via the big bang and the heat death of the universe, then equilibrium means death. Equilibrium models are static and don't feel alive. There is only one state and if you get off it, you make things worse, not better. Silly you, things are already perfect. In reality the economy is alive and dynamic and imperfect.
- 3np 4y ago/r/science is leaking
- billfruit 4y agoIs it an empirical study or do they have a theory?
- mrjin 4y agoI'm curious to see what kind of study can make such claim without providing evidence to support it.
- lisasays 4y agoI'm curious as to why you just assume the study provides no supporting evidence, without reading it first.
- nequo 4y agoThis is the paper, linked in the article: https://irle.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/High-Minimum-Wages-and-the-Monopsony-Puzzle.pdf https://irle.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/High-Mi... There’s both theory and evidence. The theory is that labor market monopsony (few employers dominating the market and having the market power to drive down wages) makes it so that minimum wage laws push wages closer to what they would be in a competitive market. This doesn’t reduce employment. Instead, it increases it. The puzzle that they talk about is that previous research has found zero employment effect instead of a positive effect. The paper explains why they think this is.
- spicyusername 4y agoPopular economic "theories" are starting to feel like they've just been excuses for the ruling classes to siphon off all of the benefits of technological advancement for themselves. More astrology than chemistry.
- hedora 4y agoCongress used to have a wing of non-partisan scientists (including economists). Eventually propagandists got elected and fired them.
- CyberDildonics 4y agoWhat specific part of the study are you talking about here?
- spicyusername 4y agoI'm referring to the fact that the dominant economic perspective would oppose the idea that a rising minimum wage could be a good thing.
- CyberDildonics 4y agoAgain, what specific problem do you have with the study other than going against your own personal conventional wisdom?
- paulddraper 4y agoFirst principles. Namely, supply/demand, and the effect of price controls. When you find perpetual motion, the question isn't whether it's wrong, but how it is wrong.
- CyberDildonics 4y agoOnce again, what specifically do you think is wrong with the study? If it's so easy to poke holes in it then do it instead of calling it 'perpetual motion' without even quoting any of it.
- mraku 4y ago[flagged]
- frankreyes 4y ago[dead]