6 ms·
Instead of your Life's Purpose (2021)
- raksoras 4y agoT
- deafpolygon 4y agoLife is just a bunch of sidequest. Got it! :)
- meghan_rain 4y agoWritten by existentialpervert69...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nico 4y agoNice write up If you can “convince yourself” (ie. actually feel), that this moment right now is the most meaningful moment of your life And you can do that consistently, in the moment You are there And the weird thing is that to get there, we need to let go, not do more or make an effort, but relax into it
- mrelectric 4y agoSadly it's one of those things that you just have to feel for yourself, right? You can't explain it to someone in a way that they'll understand and be able to apply instantly. Esp since it takes conscious effort to be performing "no effort"
- nico 4y agoThis might not make any sense to you right now, and that might actually be a great thing For me, the awareness of presence lies somewhere close to the awareness of something making no sense It feels sort of like the intersection between pure feeling and thinking I think that’s why in Zen they use koans, to get us to short-circuit our thoughts and gain awareness of the feeling of paradox
- jebarker 4y agoI don't think this can be felt instantly after an explanation, but my personal experience has been that I gradually learned to feel this way through a regular mindfulness meditation practice. I used the Waking Up app for the past few years and it really changed me.
- nico 4y agoYes. Personally, it took me years to find the spot But also there are thousands of different methods and descriptions. Some of them thousands of years old This is a basic human condition and ability We just don’t practice it or teach it enough
- __MatrixMan__ 4y agoI'm reminded of a scene from Soul (a Pixar film which I recommend). > Joe: We never found out what 22's purpose was. > Jerry: Excuse me? Joe: You know, her spark. Her purpose. Was it music? Biology? Walking? > Jerry: We don't assign purposes. Where did you get that idea? > Joe: Because I have piano. It's what I was born to do. That's my spark. > Jerry: A spark isn't a soul's purpose. Oh, you mentors and your passions. Your "purposes." Your "meanings of life." So basic.
- sharmajai 4y agohttps://youtu.be/OVXTAKpmgww https://youtu.be/OVXTAKpmgww
- yt-sdb 4y agoMy favorite quote on the meaning of life, from Viktor Frankl's "Man's Search for Meaning": > For the meaning of life differs from man to man, from day to day and from hour to hour. What matters, therefore, is not the meaning of life in general but rather the specific meaning of a person's life at a given moment. To put the question in general terms would be comparable to the question posed to a chess champion: "Tell me, Master, what is the best move in the world?" There simply is no such thing as the best or even a good move apart from a particular situation in a game and the particular personality of one's opponent. The same holds for human existence. One should not search for an abstract meaning of life. Everyone has his own specific vocation or mission in life to carry out a concrete assignment which demands fulfillment. Therein he cannot be replaced, nor can his life be repeated. Thus, everyone's task is as unique as is his specific opportunity to implement it.
- whitemary 4y agoNonsense. One's life meaning is traditionally simply their social role. The reason people lack meaning now is that we started determining our social roles by way of market whims, which means our roles are temporary at best and imaginary at worst. It also creates a market for braindead individualist philosophizing to explain why everyone feels so lonely and lost. Sterile precarity is the problem, not the solution.
- aaronblohowiak 4y agoThe context in which frankl wrote this was as a concentration camp survivor, quite different than the postmodern capitalist lends you seem to be evaluating it through Notably, man’s search for meaning was 1946 iirc and postmodernism didn’t really ascend until some time later
- paulpauper 4y agoMeaning, happiness, purpose, etc. are things that I think are made needlessly complicated or abstract. I think it helps if you are good at something--good enough to make a living at it, possibly, or earn accolades and status. This does not apply to most people, hence self-help books and the like.
- codersfocus 4y agoPlenty of examples (celebrity suicides) that show that isn't true
- paulpauper 4y agoairplane meme https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EqR7AbhVQAAuuvA.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EqR7AbhVQAAuuvA.jpg celebrities who get attention for mental illness ignores all the ordinary people with mental illness who get no such coverage
- dpweb 4y agoAfter reading the terrific "Denial of Death" I asked a few friends if they felt dread knowing that would one day die. They said they don't worry about it and I cannot relate. Seems to me the entire meaning of life and the point of it all is to just LIVE. It follows that knowing of your own eventual annihilation must be terrifying. Sure you can take refuge in false delusions or just ignore it. But if you're not afraid of death, are you really living? Are you really respecting life properly when you're not terrified to lose it?
- slashdev 4y agoI think everyone faces death differently. I’m not happy about the possibility, but I don’t expect it to bother me after I’m gone. It’s just something I can’t control, and by my nature, I don’t waste much thought on those kinds of things. All one can do is accept them. That said, I love life and I wish I had a thousand more to live and choose different paths. It’s like a game where I’ll only ever play one character. I’m not keen to die, but I hope I’ll face it with grace and courage when the time comes.
- tasuki 4y ago> not happy about the possibility It's closer to a certainty than a possibility.
- jebarker 4y ago> I don’t expect it to bother me after I’m gone. Yep, it didn't bother me for ~eternity before I existed. I think it'll be the same after. Approaching death does scare me though. I thought Christopher Hitchens captured that feeling well: "It will happen to all of us, that at some point you get tapped on the shoulder and told, not just that the party’s over, but slightly worse: the party’s going on — but you have to leave. And it’s going on without you. That’s the reflection that I think most upsets people about their demise."
- slashdev 4y agoHitchens sure had a way with words. Yeah, I think that would bother me as well. It's easier if death just kind of sneaks up on you and takes you out. It's a lot harder when the doctor tells you he's coming sometime in 2-5 years.
- walterbell 4y agoA few turns of phrase from the article. > Time is not fungible – a given moment of opportunity, or a chance to respond appropriately to a crisis, might not occur again ... The need to regulate our time into a continuous flow is the result of the agricultural and industrial revolutions. It is something we do to serve economies of scale in which we are interchangeable parts. But meaning, creative power and fortune arrive on their own schedules, and imagining that you can or should devote every waking moment to something is absurd .. > the non-linear approach is .. more adaptive to the realities of power laws – of moments of high payoff or high risk - than of the day to day grind of accrual. If our lives are rich in opportunities for meaning, rather than defined by a singular narrative arc, we can act decisively at particularly important moments rather than imagining that every moment is equally meaningful .. > Your children need to be fed, clothed and educated, and they need your love and guidance – but they also need to see you happy and engaged with life .. When you are honestly pursuing your own values and vision – and not subordinating them – you are more likely to generate meaning than if you are navigating a maze of compromises with some ultimate goal in mind .. > The heroes whose lives inspired you did what they did mostly by going out into the unknown and doing what others thought was impossible. This is not, incidentally, a guarantee that if you do so you will succeed – for the world we live in to be a meaningful one, there must be uncertainty and risk.
- codersfocus 4y agoLet's take the phrase > I think, therefore I am as a starting point. I would ask them, "whose language are you using to make that statement?" and I feel that would set the proper frame for answering the question of a life's purpose.
- mistermann 4y ago> I would ask them, "whose language are you using to make that statement?" and I feel that would set the proper frame for answering the question of a life's purpose. That is an absolutely brilliant question, it casts substantial doubt on the notion that one's own consciousness is all one can know exists.
- jvm___ 4y agoThis site got linked a few days ago. https://www.philosophybro.com/archive/descartes-meditations-on-first-philosophy-first https://www.philosophybro.com/archive/descartes-meditations-...
- crickey 4y agoWhat a stupid comment from someone who clearly hasnt read Descartes original meditations. “I doubt therefor i am” is th presupposition doubt in language, doubt in reality, if there is only doubt and nothing else i am.
- accrual 4y agoIn the absence of any particular language, could one still hold the concept of self and others and still come to the conclusion of "I think, therefore I am" without ever knowing a language?
- slushh 4y agoDo you have to think to know that you are?
- fogzen 4y ago“Success is the progressive realization of a worthy ideal“ — Earl Nightingale
- 2h 4y agofor me its programming. I first learned Go in 2020, and what I discovered is how much help is needed. you would think in this day you can get any code for anything you want, but many, many items have no implementation at all. or maybe some code is available, but its years old and abandoned. or maybe its just shitty code. or maybe its a huge bloated mess and you just want one simple thing. so, if you think you might have some skill, I would strongly suggest learning to program, we could really use the help.
- tonyedgecombe 4y agoThis forum is chock full of programmers and judging by how often articles like this come up many aren't finding a great deal of meaning in this vocation.
- 2h 4y agoits not a vocation for me, its a passion. if you're approaching programming just to make money, yeah, you're probably going to have a terrible time. thats not why I am doing it.
- nly 4y agoYou're probably not passionate about programming, you're probably passionate about crafting or completing something that involves some degree of simple puzzle solving or design. Or maybe you're interested in rule/logic based systems. That's the spark. Programming was one of my interests too, but if someone offered to put £2M in to my bank account under condition I never wrote a single line of code again, well... I'd take it in a heartbeat and I'm pretty sure I could find another "passion" in the 20 years of my own life that that would buy me. Hell, if i didn't have to work, I bet I could find a half dozen passions.
- 2h 4y agoSorry man, but you're projecting. I'm not rich, but I have enough to survive, and some of the code I'm writing literally doesn't have any other public implementations, so to me it's important that I keep going.
- dmbche 4y agoIf this resonates with you, you might like Existentialism and Jean-Paul Sartes. I'm reminded of a passage in Existentialism is a humanism where he posits that objects, like tables or tree, have innate purpose by their design being made for a task (yeah - more complex than that for natural things like trees but you get the gist), while humans simply are not born with innate purpose, as they have intent and can act upon themselves instead of comforming to the world. While this might seem uncomfortable, this is to be seen as a gift - you are free of purpose, and therefore are to decide for yourself why to live. After all, while a table has it's rightful place, it also confines it. And Camus famousky said that the only serious philosophical question is that of suicide - and I think that it's the only place to start when thinking about the rest of your life.
- mattgreenrocks 4y agoI’ve never met someone who argued for the meaninglessness of life who was also what I’d classify as psychologically healthy.
- procgen 4y agoIt has no inherent meaning. You can choose to play whatever part you like. But first you might try to figure out what this "you" is - is it a body, a mind? An infinite, underlying computational substrate? Maybe there are even multiple "yous".
- bitbang 4y agoSo basically existentialism with bipolar disorder...
- bscalable 4y agoI don't think life has any meaning. People can make themselves believe that it does for a moment, a lifetime or never. But in the end we are all just striving to taste a bit of lifes sweetness. That's all.
- vgchh 4y agoIt’s hard to be an absolutist on such a big question. Everyone has distilled it in their own ways. I will throw mine: There is no purpose of life. Life is THE purpose. To experience its full brilliance is the ONLY purpose. And only way to experience that is through a healthy mind and healthy body. So do what you can to take care of those.
- zelphirkalt 4y agoI've seen this play out badly for some though. As you correctly state, hard to be absolute about such things. For some people, it can escalate to a very egocentric behavior, in turn making live worse for others. One could argue most of us wanting the best living standard all the time is perhaps the main cause for a lot of problems around the world, including global warming.
- amelius 4y agoIf you one day wake up inside a box isn't your purpose in life from that moment on to find out how to escape from the box, and if that turns out to be impossible to figure out what the box is made of, etc.? It seems that many people could enjoy a rich life, but instead they are thinking about that box all the time.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- accrual 4y agoWhat does hn think about determinism? Lately I've gravitated towards the idea that everything is a direct result of everything that came before it, down to the arrangement of atoms at a particular time and place, the forces on molecules in our own galaxy or others, etc. It's bleak in a way, but at the same time it can be comforting in the sense that everything is exactly the only way that it could be. You can not be anyone other than who you are. You are exactly as time and space prepositioned you to be.
- NhanH 4y agoThe arrangement of atom is not deterministic though. At atom level or smaller, we already have to use probabilistic description in physics (and as far as we know, the probabilistic description is probably not because of our inability to measure, but some inherent property of the universe), so I'm not sure if the argument would hold.
- MattRix 4y agoYes it’s not predictable but not necessarily non-deterministic.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoPretty much what I think about sanity. Whether or not you are sane or insane, you pretty much have to function as though you are sane.
- chris-orgmenta 4y agoIt feels to me like 1) the current probability of determinism / no free will is 'very highly probable.' 2) the probability of determinism being the case rises every time our knowledge about the universe increases 3) The statements above are gaining more and more consensus among scientists. And I am definitely agnostic on the q, but weighted on the side of determinism. But - Surely the quantum world utterly undermines the above until we know more about it. Perhaps we could be harnessing free will somehow, e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orchestrated_objective_reduction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orchestrated_objective_reducti...
- marcus_holmes 4y agoI'm always fascinated by people who achieve their purpose early in life. Because "then what?" and often they have more interesting, more meaningful, lives after achieving what they thought of as their purpose than before.
- Borrible 4y agoAnd here I thought to hallucinate meaning was the whole point of humans. To believe and to claim to be something different from the rest of the universe. The absurdist thing is, exactly that very act of hallucination proves her content, to be something different.
- cesidio 4y agoI think we suffer when we search for meaning. Albert Camus got it right, the universe is devoid of meaning.
- mark_l_watson 4y ago+1 I came here to say the same thing. I find much to like in Camus’ philosophy of Absurdism, and a lot I don’t agree with. There are several really good videos on YouTube on Absurdism, enjoyable stuff. Off topic, but I really like the author’s use of Substack and I just subscribed to their channel. For 30+ years I manually edited HTML for my web site and just a week ago switched my personal domain [1] to Substack (copying over 2000+ old blog articles) and so far I really love the platform even though I am just learning to use it. [1] https://markwatson.com https://markwatson.com
- cesidio 4y agoWhat is that you do not agree with in Absurdism?
- mark_l_watson 4y agoI am deeply spiritual, meditate a lot, etc., which is not 100% aligned with Absurdism. That said, I watched just about everything on Absurdism that I could find on YouTube.
- noncoml 4y agoIf you remove ego out of the question, I think there is little evidence to reasonably believe that life has any meaning at all. Our life is no more special than that of an insect that just crushed on your windshield while driving down the highway. When you understand that, the only thing left is to live your life in a way you feel the most happy/satisfied/fulfilled. To reach nirvana or ευδαιμονία. There is no magic sauce for that, each of us finds their way to this through different paths.
- smusamashah 4y agoAt some point I shifted my thinking from finding purpose to following goals. Then after achieving some goal, which seemed huge earlier, I realized that excitement of reaching the goal is very very short lived. The goals/milestones are not discrete as we imagine, they are continuous. Working towards few simple goals is enough to live a good life probably. Having a purpose now sounds like I am an object made to do something specific. I am not. I only need to live a good life.
- rubicon33 4y agoThis is my approach as well. I don't need to believe I have some pre-ordained mission or grand vision for my life. I'm ok with the fact that I am one in 7 billion, insignificant to most, but significant to my wife and my family. Pursuing goals is a great feeling and so generally I do my best to optimize my life around performing well in body and mind. Control what you can, have peace with what you cannot, and cultivate the wisdom to know the difference.
- moondistance 4y agoThe meaning of life is to love everyone. You first need to love yourself, then you can grow to love - and nurture - everyone you can.
- josh_ellot 4y agoWhen I was in college, a classmate jumped from the top of the library and left a letter in which he complained that life is meaningless. I hope he could have read this article.
- jdthedisciple 4y agoGiven the author's peculiar name, I was ready for a truly surprising epiphany.