9 ms·
He wrote a book on a rare subject. Then a ChatGPT replica appeared on Amazon
- RobertDeNiro 4y ago"Automating DevOps with GitLab CI/CD Pipelines" is not a rare subject.
- JohnFen 4y agoI'm not sure what "a rare subject" means, but I interpreted it as "highly niche" -- and in the larger world of books, it's certainly that.
- freehorse 4y agoIt is quite well documented, as I understand, so in this context I would not call it "rare". I would call a subject rare if it was rare in the context of possible training data, like for example an obscure sport or obscure programming language.
- meow_mix 4y agooutside of hacker news, it is
- cornhole34 4y agoIs there a name of a phenomena when you expect someone to be equal or more knowledgeable as you are when discussing a topic? The Dunning-Kruger effect is when one overestimates their own ability. But is there an effect of overestimating someone else's? I feel as though that explains the reasoning.
- renewiltord 4y agoThere's an xkcd that describes this phenomenon quite well https://xkcd.com/2501/ https://xkcd.com/2501/ Overestimated Familiarity Window. There you go - an abstruse term that you can use assuming other people will also understand it, and therefore the reference fulfills the referent.
- simonw 4y agoHow many books would you expect to see about that published in a given year?
- pxue 4y agoNon because the topic is already covered by 1) countless blog posts 2) official documentation. Why do we now need it in a book format and waste trees is beyond me.
- simonw 4y agoThis kind of book content is almost always eBooks these days, so I don't think concerns about wasted trees are relevant.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- prophesi 4y agoI would also argue that this niche topic would be one of the first to be generated by AI, as someone technical enough to utilize the API for OpenAI/Claude/etc would likely be familiar with CI/CD topics in the first place.
- jasonm23 4y agoThanks, Bob, I came here for this comment. Perhaps to NYP it's a rare subject, but to me, it's trivially banal and current. There should be no surprise at all that multiple books with this or extremely similar titles would exist. But outside the tech domain it's understandably obscure, but so is the intended audience when viewed through that lens. Likewise, the guy is trying to push out a book in an age when people are just going to ask GPT what is X and get a dialog going. (full of hallucinations, but still!) Getting this juicy PR is the best thing that ever happened to him.
- Paul-Craft 4y agoI can't find "Automating DevOps with GitLab CI/CD Pipelines" by Marie Karpos on Amazon.com. I'm guessing Cowell's publisher (Pakt) had something to do with that. Or maybe Amazon took it down to avoid more bad press?
- return_to_monke 4y agoThe last paragraph mentions it was removed after the journalists asked Amazon what's up
- polotics 4y agoThe article does state that Amazon took all of the fake publisher books down after the journalist from the Post asked them about. Jeff Bezos owns both, this may have expedited the process.
- pizza234 4y agoThe article premise is relatively banal, but the topic the article describes after, is extremely important (IMO). This bits: > Several companies defended their use of AI, telling The Post they use language tools not to replace human writers, but to [...], or to produce content that they otherwise wouldn’t > We published a celebrity profile a month. Now we can do 10,000 a month. describe an undergoing mass-transition of (a large amount of) publishing towards a commodity. Cheap publishing has always existed, but it required somebody to actually write something, therefore, a minimum of creativity/knowledge has always been a requirement. With LLMs, any requirement is gone; publishing can be reduced to sending an input and checking the output. "Interesting" times!
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoFor a while now we have had formulaic writing where people write under a successful dead (or almost dead) author's name. This is just using computers to do the same. Now anyone can write the next Borne novel.
- clnq 4y agoIt’s amazing to my mind that AI can now help write textbooks on niche topics. I see that as tremendous progress for humanity. Of course, with capitalistic incentives, we will use it for spam and garbage.
- readthenotes1 4y agoOf course, without capitalism or the threat of capitalism, we wouldn't have to worry about this sort of thing.
- clnq 4y agoWhat would be the incentive to pump out garbage? It’s unproductive work that’s sadly rewarded with pay, which pays the rent. Spending resources on things like this is one of the worst aspects of capitalism. Capitalism is just growing capital at any ethical and moral cost.
- anonymousiam 4y ago"Amazon removed the impostor book, along with numerous others by the same publisher, after The Post contacted the company for comment." It probably helps that Bezos is the majority shareholder of both The Post and Amazon.
- tedunangst 4y agoBezos owns 10% of Amazon.
- anonymousiam 4y agoYes, and he is the majority shareholder (entity with the most shares) (12.3% of AZMN, 100% WaPo via Nash). https://www.investopedia.com/articles/insights/052816/top-4-amazon-shareholders-amzn.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/insights/052816/top-4-... https://money.cnn.com/2013/08/05/news/companies/washington-post-bezos/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2013/08/05/news/companies/washington-p...
- tedunangst 4y agoWe appear to have different understandings of the word majority.
- plumeria 4y agoTo be a majority shareholder he would need to own more than 50% of the shares [0] [0] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/majorityshareholder.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/majorityshareholder.asp
- danjoredd 4y agoHere is a wayback mirror if the paywall hits you: https://web.archive.org/web/20230506075301/https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/05/05/ai-spam-websites-books-chatgpt/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230506075301/https://www.washi...
- heywherelogingo 4y ago"You are charged with pirating films". "Nope, my AI did it".
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoIt would still be a derivative work.
- CKMo 4y agoThe problem comes back to incentives. If LLMs are trained on existing material, but no one pays the person who wrote the original material, we have an incentive conundrum coming. AIs have such a low cost to producing content that even if everyone agrees human-written is better, the cost to output ratio is hard to compete with. People are already loathe to pay for written content, even if it's written by a Pulitzer-prize winner. This will result in fewer writers finding it to be a viable source of income, which results in less human-generated content, and soon we'll just find ourselves in some AI-content apocalypse.
- eastbound 4y agoWe also have way too many writers vs readers.
- qwytw 4y agoWe don't really have too many writers who produce high quality content. Or maybe the market just doesn't value it, hard to say...
- garrickvanburen 4y agoMarket doesn’t value it - that’s why there’s so few
- mostlylurks 4y agoWe don't. Now that the internet is a thing [0], you wouldn't have too many writers even if every person on earth wrote a hundred books each. The only problem is that there is (AFAIK) no good place for discovering books / searching for books based on anything but the coursest categories, and the long tail of less popular books is more-or-less completely hidden. This is something that I find rather peculiar, since these days many social media sites are rather eager to expose you to the long tail of less popular content in your extremely specific preferred niches, so why doesn't any service do the same for books? I, as a reader, would be very interested in something like that, instead of seeing the same books-du-jour everywhere I go. [0] Because it removes the physical / logistical limitations that bookstores and libraries have, forcing them to only offer the most popular books, and because it allows for targeting and extreme selectiveness.
- senko 4y agoThis has nothing to do with ChatGPT and everything to do with Amazon tolerating counterfeits and plagiarism. Also, how is this a replica if it was released before the original book? Is it just title squatting or has someone stolen his draft and regurgitated it through an LLM?
- gumballindie 4y agoOpenai is selling a tool for plagiarism which itself is built upon unlicensed content. It has everything to do with openai.
- senko 4y agoCalling a LLM "a tool for plagiarism" takes some real mental gymnastics. You could similarly argue IKEA is selling lethal weapons because you can kill someone with a knife. The exact way copyright laws will apply (or not) to AI is still ambigous, until a high profile case gets before the Supreme Court or ECJ. You can certainly argue one way or another - my view is that AI learning from your blog post is similar to me learning from your blog post. That's not the problem. If I then plagiarise it (or copy wholesale), that is the problem.
- ResearchCode 4y agoIt seems like a tool for plagiarism. You could do the same thing before LLM grew in popularity by using Google Translate back and forth from English.
- gmerc 4y ago[flagged]
- gumballindie 4y agoIf ikea would be selling machetes disguised as kitchen knifes, then yeah they would be called out and their product banned. You learning from my blog is not the same as a piece of software copying my work. Ai does not “learn” as humans do regardless of how well it mimics our behaviour. My laptop outputs audio, it doesnt sing.
- zwieback 4y agoI don't understand how companies that use fully automated AI to churn out content can survive long term. Why wouldn't I just go straight to the AI to get what I want? Also, I see an opportunity for publishing brands to set themselves apart from AI generated stuff and charge a premium for that. There might be fewer of them in the future (e.g. I don't mind reading auto-generated celebrity profiles) but I predict the New Yorker and The Atlantic will exist a decade from now.
- sorokod 4y agoThey can't but that is still in the future. In the now they can't afford not to.
- zwieback 4y agoYou mean in the now content mills can't afford not to crank out clickbait with AI? That would reinforce my general belief that we've been in a transition state these past few years with the reinvention of old business models in the near future. We've already reinvented cable TV and newspaper subscriptions.
- sorokod 4y agoYes, ckickbait or any other content fit for mass consumption. Not that different from multiple franchises of the same junk food brand that are located next to each other.
- boxed 4y agoThe customers don't know they are getting AI crapware. And these "publishers" make a little money on each book. It's the same as all the other book scams on Amazon that has existed for years.
- freehorse 4y agoThe specific one is just AI-powered scam, aka take the money and run. Scamming is probably the industry more profiting from the AI right now.
- squarefoot 4y ago> In the past, Jaffe said, “We published a celebrity profile a month. Now we can do 10,000 a month.” Next step will be creating celebrities that do not exist, and I don't mean Hatsune Miku or similar virtual ones.
- WalterBright 4y agoAnyone remember Max Headroom?
- squarefoot 4y agoI do, and loved it. It was so ahead of its time. Well worth of a reboot, if done properly.
- supergirl 4y agohow is that a replica? it's just another book with the same title? the chosen title "Automating DevOps with GitLab CI/CD Pipelines" is so dull that I'm not surprised it was generated by the AI as well, probably not even the latest tech for that. I'd expect ChatGPT to come up with a better title
- bluescrn 4y agoDoes the P in GPT stand for 'plagiarism'? 'Generative Plagiarism Tool'?
- andrewstuart 4y agoWhen the applause for ChatGPT dies down, people are going to be angry about it’s data sources being hidden and possibly violating copyright.
- alden5 4y agoThe amount of value that ChatGPT has given me is enough where I don't care at all if my own tutorials and documentation has been scraped to expand the model's knowledge. I'm not profiting off my work either way, and if helps people understand things it's honestly a plus. Although I definitely understand the frustration from people having their copyrighted material used to compete against them, the pushback from artists against image generation from copyrighted data sets is 100% warranted.
- andrewstuart 4y agoThat's fine, but it's unacceptable for ChatGPT to ingest copyrighted information. I could imagine a gargantuan lawsuit in the future.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoYou might not care about yours, but I can name a lot of people who do care because that's their entire career and what feeds their family and pays for insurance. Tough shit if someone can't afford their insulin anymore, right?
- falcolas 4y agoOil companies don't much care that their products and practices have exacerbated climate change - they hid relevant data from us generated by their scientists - yet we are finding ways to hold them liable, and we generally don't think well of people who hold them up as paragons. Copyright directly enables a huge portion of most developed nations' GDP. AI will have an effect on copyright and businesses that depend upon it. And even if you care nothing for the ethics around copyright, it's worth respecting the political might and bankrolls those companies will wield.
- ilamont 4y agoSpeaking of ChatGPT-authored books: The example that someone posted on HN last month ("Tom Lesley has published 40 books in 2023, all with 100% positive reviews" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35687868 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35687868) is still up on Amazon despite the widespread publicity, fake reviews and all. Note that AI-generated books have been on the horizon for a long time, well before ChatGPT appeared. Ingram, one of the biggest print-on-demand services in the United States, specifically banned "Books created using artificial intelligence or automated processes" in early 2020 (https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry-news/manufacturing/article/82526-lightning-source-to-introduce-content-integrity-guidelines.html https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry-news/m...). Amazon clearly doesn't have a handle on the problem, and its book catalogue and Kindle Unlimited will increasingly be flooded with junk.
- throwuwu 4y agoThey allow self publishing so they are already flooded with junk. I don’t see the problem though since it’s not like you have to actually dig through a pile of books when you have a search engine and can get recommendations from other sources
- hammyhavoc 4y agoIt's the scale of the issue and diminishing the signal-to-noise ratio by many magnitudes, harming discoverability and sales of legitimate, high quality, original work.
- throwuwu 4y agoI don’t think I’ve ever “discovered” a new book or author solely through an online book seller. It’s always the result of a recommendation or a web search of reviews or a bibliographic mention. Do people actually just browse through the firehose of Amazon best seller crap to find stuff?
- hammyhavoc 4y ago
- diebeforei485 4y agoMaybe pre-orders shouldn't be a thing for technical textbooks.
- kzz102 4y agoA lot of technology disruptions happen by a "bait and switch" approach. A new technology appear that promises to produce something at a much higher efficiency and much lower cost. Only after it already took over the market did people discover that it was not the same product. The disruption, while often has genuine merit, also sneakily changes some fundamental assumptions that people held over the product. This is not new: for example, products of industrial farming are often significantly different from products of traditional farming. However, it is a better product in the sense of market competition. This mechanism is considered the engine of growth for society. I think products that consists of human communication are fundamentally different: this assumption of "disruption is good" is more likely to be false. Even existing technology that aim at changing human communications, like emails and social networks, end up having serious negative effects. AI based culture and communication product is changing one of the basic assumptions of human communications: that the communication is produced by a human. I can't help but being sad and pessimistic about that future.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoThe fascinating thing about is that while we will obviously see a rise of crap overall, organic labor will become even more expensive, because actual expertise and knowledge will be that much rarer. I try not to see it in absolutes. It appears that it will be a big shift on how things are done, but it will also further change my perception of privacy. Just the other day I read a story about Wendy's doing a test run in their drive through. I shiver at all that information hoovered down at every single step. And here I was thinking Transmetropolitan was a crazy fantasy.
- version_five 4y agoI think I understand what you mean about farming. The toppings you buy at subway that are essentially water in some limp cell matrix bear little resemblance to vegetables. But objectively, modern farming had been providing more and more for us from the neolithic onwards and is responsible for how so many of us can be fed. A more recent example of bait and switch would be Uber and Airbnb which started with some promise (cheaper, easier to use, more accountability) but once you add in all the chestertons fences that were part of the legacy industries they "disrupted" - safety, paying market wages, profitability, they revert back to the legacy system.
- david422 4y agoI searched for childrens bedtime stories on Amazon a few months ago. Found some reasonably priced ones that seemed promising. I used the preview feature before I bought. They were like ... regurgitated ... crap. I couldn't figure out if they just non-native english speakers writing stories, or if it was sort of AI produced work. It was just horrendous. I figured that they were just spamming junk and if they caught a few people unaware that bought it then it must be profitable for them.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoThe missus is a proofreader and editor. Self-publishing means people frequently don't have a proofreader or editor, and most adults like to think they wouldn't need a proofreader or editor for a kids book because they're an adult. There's also a significant trend of people who are dyslexic writing kids books because they want to feel that dyslexia doesn't hold them back from achieving their goals. Everybody needs a proofreader and editor, especially people who think they don't, or think Grammarly is an adequate substitute for a human being. The most amusing anecdote is almost everybody says "I don't think it needs much doing", then they get given a manuscript with 1,000+ recommended changes and corrections on a 32 page kids book.
- COGlory 4y agoMany children's books have been regurgitated crap for years. They're so awful. I have 20 or so hanging around that are just painful to read. I honestly don't know how to describe it. It's like the sentences all start off trying to be cute or lead into a rhyme, but then before they get there they just...end.
- bookofjoe 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35835701 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35835701
- onlypositive 4y agoI feel like if we all embraced the death of copyright in the early 2000's we would be in such a better place to handle this right now.