11 ms·
> YouTube premium perfectly showcases why ads dominate the internet, because even when there is a paid option for a service much cheaper than any alternative, p
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
> YouTube premium perfectly showcases why ads dominate the internet, because even when there is a paid option for a service much cheaper than any alternative, people do not want to pay
There's also a factor of quality and trust. I don't trust YouTube Premium enough to even try it. This is mostly colored by their constant, invasive disruption of my YouTube experience (particularly apparent on mobile) with YT Premium ads. Yes, I know it exist. No, I don't want it - the more you try to trick me into activating the trial, the less I want it.
> So what is the alternative? (Peer to Peer for streaming doesn't seem a reasonable alternative at any scale, since most people own phones and then laptops, and much fewer desktops).
Proper ad blocker on the desktop. yt-dlp for archiving/off-line playing. NewPipe or some other alternative YouTube players for mobile.
Yes, I know you meant a non-free-riding alternative, but hey - I have no problem paying for services, even for premium tiers when free tier is available. But I'm not getting bullied into subscribing.
- pb7 4y ago[flagged]
- LukeShu 4y agoI spend more supporting YT creators than what YouTube Premium costs. I'm fine paying for things when I say "I like this, I want more of it." YouTube itself is the worst part of the experience, it's the part I want less of. YT would have to have way fewer dark patterns and bad behaviors for me to even consider paying for YouTube Premium.
- pb7 4y agoThen stop using it. The content creators you watch use it and that means you are obliged to follow the platform's terms. If they didn't need the platform, they would self host their videos and monetize via other means like Patreon but they don't. That means your contributions compared to the revenue via YouTube pales in comparison.
- daedalus_j 4y agoNot OP, but: I have no desire to steal from /content creators/, which is why I support them via other means. (Patreon etc) YouTube on the other hand, is an untrustworthy middleman who's going to to their level best to profit off of me and not pass the money on to the content creators. It's YouTube that's stealing from the content creators. If YouTube was a utility that would deliver me the bits that I wanted from the content creators I wanted I'd be happy to pay some sort of volume pricing for the resources they use to do it, however I have no problem "stealing" from them by using an adblocker considering all the user-hostile crap they do to both viewers and creators.
- waboremo 4y agoI have a very hard time believing someone is regularly contributing to creators patreons while also being annoyed by the "invasive" reminders of YouTube Premium and would go through means of using a handful of external tools to keep watching YouTube for free and without ads. Surely such a person would avoid YouTube entirely and just stick to supporting their Patreon creators?
- anon-3988 4y agoThis is such a misguided and confused perspective on this whole matter. > It's YouTube that's stealing from the content creators Really?? And these content creators willingly post their content on the site so that Youtube can steal from them? Do you really think that Youtube does not provide any service here? It is really a parasite? My God, try setting up a video hosting platform for a week and see how that goes. It's amazing people can think this way, the ad-based "free for all" internet have ruined multiple generations conception of basic common sense. Please tell me how Youtube is supposed to stay in business without using ads, without having premium services, without selling your information and all that? Please share with me this secret business strategy that no one bothered to explain how. The only reasonable alternative that I can think of is making Youtube non-profit ala Wikimedia. But even then, people STILL hate on them because....they have so much money??? Why the fuck not, do people not realize how valuable Wikipedia is?
- daedalus_j 4y ago
- wkat4242 4y agoIt's not stealing. They get into this business knowing that adblockers are a thing and are fully legal. Most of them even shill ads inside their video like shady VPNs. It might not be so ethical but it's not illegal, which is what stealing is.
- pb7 4y agoIt is stealing. You're stealing the bandwidth from the company, and you're stealing the commission for video play from the content creator.
- vehemenz 4y agoYour understanding of theft is so broad that viewing parties would be theft too.
- pb7 4y agoPlease enlighten me, what payment do you provide in exchange for the services you are using? You are circumnavigating the payment system in place and providing nothing in return. That's theft.
- wkat4242 4y agoNo, it's legal. That makes it not theft. In fact Google and all other big tech themselves do similar things too. They funnel all their proceeds through tax havens so they avoid paying corporate tax in the countries they turn over in. Yet it's fully legal, because tax avoidance is not evasion and loopholes are loopholes. And thus they're not stealing from the countries they're depriving of their tax revenue. When they do it it's totally fine. When I avoid paying it's not? You're confusing your moral sense with the law. Sure it's unethical, depending on your views immoral but it's not illegal.
- pb7 4y agoUnprosecuted theft is still theft. You are breaking the terms of service, it's just not practical or cost effective to go after every person that does so because each individual damages are low. I'm glad you agree it's unethical though. Keep that in mind when you see companies do unethical things because they think just like you. Everyone wants something for nothing. In any case, this is why they're testing blocking ad-blockers. It's cost effective.
- striking 4y agoI've been a subscriber ever since Google Play Music bundled it in, and it's fine. Sorry to hear you're getting bullied, but the paid experience really is rather nice.
- acdha 4y ago> I have no problem paying for services, even for premium tiers when free tier is available. > I don't trust YouTube Premium enough to even try it. These two statements seem to be mutually incompatible unless you're trying to argue that a premium tier doesn't really exist unless you can write the terms of service and audit the company providing it. It's also somewhat hard to follow the logic here: if you don't trust YouTube, why are you watching them at all? It's not like Google tracks you less that way and if you're under the impression that your ad blocker is helping there you can certainly subscribe to Premium while leaving the same blocker enabled.
- Ygg2 4y agoI like premium stake and would pay for it. I'm not eating premium stake at Cockroach Joe. His sandwiches are alright. How are they incompatible?
- endisneigh 4y agoPeople will make all sort of excuses to rationalize not paying for digital content that they can easily get for free.
- Ygg2 4y agoFunny part is. I actually got YT premium from family member. It's indistinguishable from using adblock.
- pulvinar 4y agoI don't make any excuses-- if the content is handed to me for free, I take it. They also hand me ads for free but I don't care for those, thanks. It's really a strange concept that we're somehow cheating someone for not looking at an ad. And yet somehow it wouldn't be cheating if we poured over every ad but never bought anything in them.
- pb7 4y agoBut you are cheating someone. The creators of the videos you're watching don't get anything when you block the ads. That means you've cheated them of money, on top of cheating the company of money. It's not handed to you for free, there's an implicit condition that you watch the content and the ads that are served with it. Too many people don't do that and that's why YouTube is now testing blocking ad-blockers. You reap what you sow.
- falcolas 4y agoWhen I heard how much more a YouTube Red view was worth to a creator than an ad impression, I was convinced that it's a reasonable compromise. I don't necessarily trust Google, but creators are vetting that Google is holding up their end of the bargain. So why shouldn't I?
- hkt 4y agoIn terms of Google holding up their end of the bargain, the reason you shouldn't trust them is simple: it is the CEO and board's fiduciary duty to the shareholders to make the most of Google's immense market power. The legal requirements governing their behaviour are such that they have to ensure that of all the participants in a transaction, they win biggest and most often. See: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiduciary https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiduciary
- crop_rotation 4y agoSo you shouldn't pay at a grocery store also? At any other big company shop? Because as you said so eloquently: "The reason you shouldn't trust them is simple: it is the CEO and board's fiduciary duty to the shareholders to make the most of any company's immense market power. The legal requirements governing their behaviour are such that they have to ensure that of all the participants in a transaction, they win biggest and most often."
- defrost 4y agoDunno about you but the (only) local grocery store in the small W.Australian town where I live is owned in majority by the local community who hold shares and see the books - the employees and store manager (all locals) get paid well and money is set aside for growth and infrastructure investment after which everything goes back to keeping prices low and supporting local farmers | business.
- hkt 4y agoThat sounds lovely and idyllic - things like that rock and there should be more of them.
- shadowgovt 4y agoFWIW, I've had it for years and it's great. I've basically forgotten YouTube has ads.
- swapfile 4y agoSo have I because of invidious[1]. [1]: https://docs.invidious.io/instances/ https://docs.invidious.io/instances/
- stephen_g 4y agoThat’s a shame that they’re apparently a bit pushy (I have Premium so don’t see any of that), because it’s been 100% worth it in my experience. I feel I get more than enough value from YouTube Premium to have it for myself, whereas Netflix I would cancel if I didn’t share it with my parents and two siblings. If they crack down on password sharing, it will go and YT will stay…
- mozman 4y agoI pay exactly $0 and see no YT ads, and I am a pretty heavy YT viewer. I just don't think it's right to have to pay. Advertisers use their dollars to influence and make statements, also forcing stupid age restrictions just because someone swears. It's 1984 in 2023.
- arp242 4y ago> I just don't think it's right to have to pay. What makes you think it's right to be entitled to a free service? You don't want to pay. You don't want ads. So ... then what?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dendriti 4y agoWho said anything about "entitled"? Folks are ALL OVER this thread using emotionally-loaded language, because it's hard to argue for ads any other way.
- decremental 4y agoI watch so much YouTube on my TV that Premium just makes sense. I can't block ads on my TV. It's really worth it in that case. The experience of watching brain rotting ads is such an undesirable prospect I will gladly pay them to avoid it.
- fy20 4y agoSame for me. I don't think I've ever watched any of the Premium content, I just subscribed to hide ads.
- ajhurliman 4y agoSo YT is too greedy and shows you a lot of ads and loses trust, but if they were to play it cool and stop showing ads you’d sign up for premium?
- myself248 4y agoI think it's more nuanced than that. Personally I love/hate YouTube: Love: * Most of my favorite creators are there * Ahh, that's it. Hate: * Seems to have no actual humans working there, or no way to reach them in the event of disputes. If someone posting to HN about their business locked out of their account is the best way to get support, there's a problem. * Keeps getting better and better at..... pushing extremist content and crypto scams. * Removes tools (like dislike counts) that helped users spot bad content. * Charges $23/mo for premium which bundles a bunch of stuff I don't give a rat's ass about (youtube music? no thank you!), in addition to just removing ads. (That's only $2 less than I pay for my cable modem, like, seriously ridiculous territory.) * Doesn't disclose how much of that subscription actually ends up in creators' pockets. If they solved those last two issues, would I sign up? Ahh, no. They're still a net negative. I'd much rather try to drag my favorite creators into posting elsewhere. I've signed up for Nebula and I support roughly two dozen creators on Patreon and similar tipjar/support systems. I'm trying to put my money where my mouth is, because IMO YouTube is circling the drain and getting desperate, and the sooner we develop viable alternatives, the better. So, no, there's nothing YouTube (and their parent corporation DoubleClick wearing a Google mask) can do at this point would make me cut them a check. I'm working as hard as I reasonably can to make them obsolete.
- pb7 4y ago>Most of my favorite creators are there >Doesn't disclose how much of that subscription actually ends up in creators' pockets. Enough for your favorite creators to be there. >Charges $23/mo for premium It's $23/mo because people like you block ads. The ad blocker-blockers can't roll out soon enough. Fingers crossed.
- pierat 4y ago
- cryptoegorophy 4y agoYouTube premium was probably the best decision I did. Amount of time saved on ads alone makes it worth it. Other bonus feature - downloading videos. If you make enough money it is a no brainer together with things like extra cloud storage from google, Apple and now ChatGPT
- deebosong 4y agoThese days, I'll happily not use a service/ product/ whatever if I have to pay for it. But YouTube Premium, ad free, is wonderful. I bought it for my parents because they watch a lot of niche stuff. But now that I have it, it's worth even the crazy price increase (to like, $22/mo or something). I like it better than Netflix/ Disney+/ HBO Max, as it's half entertainment, half educational (whereas the other streaming services are more entertainment and often doesn't keep me interested in spite of their catalogues).
- naikrovek 4y agothe Family sharing of YouTube Premium is worth every penny I pay for it times 5. easily.
- alwayslikethis 4y agoYou can save even more time by using SponsorBlock. I believe premium only gives you fake downloading -- you can't take it out of their app (correct me if I'm wrong). In contrast yt-dlp gives you direct access to the files.
- naikrovek 4y agoYouTube premium downloading does store the video in the browser data store I think, yes. I use yt-dlp for videos I want to keep a copy of, which are few and far between, and I use YT premium's download feature to queue up stuff I want to watch on my phone later when I know I'm going to a poor coverage area. there's room for both solutions in my world.
- 4y ago
- jasonlotito 4y agoNot sure what you don’t trust about it. I love Premium. I’ve had it for years, and YouTube is the best streaming platform there is in my book. It honestly just seems like something you are being stubborn over for no good reason. Stop hitting yourself sort of thing. No one is bullying you. Oh, they are advertising a service in their app that dramatically improves the experience and supports the channels you watch. But no, they are bullying you. Please.
- danShumway 4y agoYou're not missing anything. The really weird thing about Youtube Premium is that even if you do pay for it, you're better off not signing into your account and still using uBlock Origin and NewPipe. I paid for Youtube Premium for a pretty long while, and the only reason to pay for it is because you want to support Youtube. The official app for Android was awful the last time I used it, I've never been tempted to go back to it from NewPipe. You'd download videos and sometimes Youtube would just decide, "no, that's not downloaded anymore." It was way more battery hungry than NewPipe. I had less control over mobile data. It was glitchier and I couldn't turn off distracting features like comments or recommendations. There was also this weird problem where signing in on both desktop and mobile would occasionally mess with playback and Google would tell me that I needed to only have a video on one device at a time. NewPipe doesn't have that problem. And there's the privacy angle: Youtube Premium necessarily requires you to be logged in and to have your videos tracked, that's part of how the funds get distributed to creators. --- So for a while I just gave Youtube money and literally didn't use the service at all, because adblocking was better in every way. But I gave them money because I wanted to pay for the service. And eventually I realized I couldn't figure out what I was paying for. I wasn't paying for content, because I wasn't logged in, so the people I was watching weren't getting subscription revenue from me. I was giving Google money, but it wasn't clear to me that giving them money was proving anything or making Youtube better or encouraging them to do anything -- whenever I looked at Youtube Premium it seemed like the service was actively getting worse and that a lot of the annoyances I was supposedly paying to avoid were creeping back into the service. And I eventually realized that Youtube does provide Google value even if I'm not paying for it. It allows them to effectively hold a near-monopoly on independent video hosting online. And so I stopped paying for it because the only reason to pay for it was for an idealistic reason, and I realized that I'm actually be fine with Youtube failing and more independent sites popping up, and I don't actually want to encourage Youtube and if anything I'm happy for it to be a loss-leader for Google. For the creators themselves, direct donations turn out to be a lot more valuable, and I try to do that now when I can. But every once and a while it comes up as an example of "people won't pay for anything" and like... I just don't think that's true. The reality is you are paying for less than nothing when you use Youtube Premium. You are paying for a worse experience than you would get from an adblocker, and in some cases you're paying for even more annoyance when Google starts getting snippy about how you use your accounts between computers. Idealism is one thing, but is it actually surprising to anyone that people don't feel motivated to donate money to Google? Because that's what Youtube Premium is. There is no reason to use it unless you want to donate money to Google. The price isn't even the main issue -- even if Youtube Premium was free, I wouldn't use it. It's a worse experience than 3rd-party clients and adblockers. It exists so that Google can try to tie it into existing services or make a case to the public that they need ads, but this is not a serious effort by a company that actually wants to offer a real service for money.
- renonce 4y agoYouTube Premium means you are paying YouTube for content made by someone else than YouTube, while YouTube generates lots of ad revenue from non-Premium users. Makes me feel I’m compensating the wrong person. I wish a higher percentage of my fees go directly to video makers and that they indicate clearly how much I gave each creator.
- zamalek 4y agoAccording to many creators, YT premium views are extremely lucrative for them.
- AkBKukU 4y agoYoutube is my living, Premium pays out a LOT more than ads do per view. It might be nearly 3X for me. So a Premium subscription definitely helps out the creators, a lot more than even watching ads.
- boojums 4y agoIf you don't mind sharing, how does Premium income compare to say Patreon?
- Jach 4y agoGoing from 1-10 cents per view to 3-30 cents per view (and this is generous, some estimates put the low end at 2/10 cents per view) doesn't seem that big of a deal. Encourage your subscribers to buy a single $5 superchat/superthanks/1 month membership instead (of which you get $3.50) every so often instead and continue to enjoy a life of improved sanity from no ads via adblock without paying an egregiously large monthly fee for Premium.
- ThatPlayer 4y agoBut viewers don't want to have to be constantly bombarded with "encouragement" for superchats. It's a bad experience no different than an in-video sponsored read, or any other YouTube ad.
- askafriend 4y agoYouTube Premium is my #1 favorite subscription. YouTube is unusable without it. I also get immense value from YouTube. It's really a win-win in my book.
- lfkdev 4y agoNah, Vanced (now ReVanced) is the way to go for mobile