5 ms·
Wikipedia Tells UK Government It Won’t Comply with Age Verification Mandates
- sylware 4y agoAge verification to access knowledge? I don't understand. What the bottom of this?
- jjgreen 4y agoThe political driver: Tories don't like (other) people looking at porn. The real driver: age verification will entail logging of who looked at which page, information which is rather useful to the government.
- mPReDiToR 4y agoI would be surprised if all ISP's didn't log this information, and hand it over to GCHQ, maybe with a court order, maybe on request. Anyone who can stop their ISP tracking their forbidden knowledge is going to be bright enough to thwart this latest "think of the children" rubbish.
- p-e-w 4y agoWikipedia uses TLS, so which articles are being accessed is invisible to the ISP.
- 1827163 4y agoWe work around that by downloading a torrent of the entirety of Wikipedia. Then there is nothing the government can do to find out what we are reading. Same for Library Genesis, which holds over 2.5 million books, but that's rather expensive due to the sheer disk space required. For mobile usage, 1 Terabyte micro SD cards are getting cheaper by the day, perhaps someone could make a ready made torrent release of useful information, not just Wikipedia but Project Gutenberg and many other things from the Internet Archive? Complete with search built in.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoA book being around 1 Mo, wouldn't LibGen fit in 1 to 10 To ?
- throwaway67743 4y agoThey don't, the retention act was/is a mess and only really covers the big 4....
- 31337Logic 4y agoIs there porn on Wikipedia though?
- SpaghettiCthulu 4y agoYes
- renewedrebecca 4y agoDepends on who you allow to define "porn."
- Clubber 4y agoPorn is the excuse, it fits in with "for the children!" They probably want to see who's posting what they consider "hate speech." It's an arrest able offense in the UK I believe. How the mighty have fallen.
- tivert 4y ago> Is there porn on Wikipedia though? Yeah: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fisting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fisting IIRC, most sex topics on Wikipedia similarly have a weird Wiki-how style illustration as well as contributed depictions (likely from exhibitionists).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tivert 4y ago> Age verification to access knowledge? Calling Wikipedia "knowledge" is being generous. That label is mostly its self-important marketing. Wikipedia is actually a reference that's oh so cheap and easy to access that its unreliability doesn't matter. It's what you use for "answers" when it's not important that you get the right one (or for pushing an agenda onto lazy information consumers).
- hnfong 4y agoIf there's a way to pay a reasonable sum for infallible information sources that's higher quality than wikipedia besides buying out a university, let me know.
- tivert 4y ago> If there's a way to pay a reasonable sum for infallible information sources that's higher quality than wikipedia besides buying out a university, let me know. Nothing's a perfect "infallible information source," but you can do better than Wikipedia without needing to go as far as "buying out a university." Perhaps Kindle Unlimited plus a newspaper subscription for current events?
- p-e-w 4y agoI'd love to see the UK Government block access to Wikipedia over this, and then watch productivity in academia (and many industries) drop by 20-30% overnight, while the international press compares them to Turkey and Pakistan, until they eventually get slapped by the High Court. There's no way they come out on top here, unless Wikipedia folds on this issue.
- sharemywin 4y agocan it be duplicated?
- hollerith 4y agoYes, Wikipedia is under a license allowing others to publish the content, and others have over the years. In fact, Wikimedia publishes data dumps that facilitate that -- or at least they used to.
- tivert 4y ago> I'd love to see the UK Government block access to Wikipedia over this, and then watch productivity in academia (and many industries) drop by 20-30% overnight If British academia relies that heavily on Wikipedia, the UK is in worse shape than I thought.
- gumballindie 4y agoHopefully there isnt much academia relying on wikipedia. And that which can jolly go out of business.
- lampshades 4y ago[flagged]
- xyzzy4747 4y agoIn a roundabout way it would have good side effects if the UK blocks Wikipedia since it would encourage more people to get VPNs. The more that people learn to protect their identity, the better. That said, I do agree children should not be accessing adult sites, but that burden should primarily be on the parents.
- lemoncookiechip 4y agoIf anyone thinks for a second that this is done for the children, maybe stop and think to yourself why the government is so overly authoritarian and why they seek to monitor and control your life in all facets. Secondly, why shouldn't teenagers have access to pornography (which isn't even the case here)? Did the people who grew up with nude magazines, cable pornography... grow up to be dysfunctional members of society? Interest in it is a normal healthy thing, and if you're really worried about it, you as a parent should be the one to do something about it, not the government, because you'll reach a point in time where they are the ones saying how you should and shouldn't raise your kids. Use the tools given to you as a parent and block your children from accessing certain sites, talk to them, and maybe parent a bit instead of letting a computer or tv educate them for you. Also note that I'm not saying that you should monitor them 24/7. If you have a good relationship with your kid/s, if you give them just enough freedom to grow, and more importantly, if you know who they are, maybe you can trust them a bit to make decisions for themselves as they grow.
- doublerabbit 4y ago[flagged]
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoA wise man said regarding pornography: "the problem is not that pornography shows too much of a person, but that it shows too little."
- davidguetta 4y agoThis is nothing but an opinion. Most people who are pro this law think the same thing of vanilla porn that you think about bdsm and fisting. And for the extreme case, some of them think the same about basic nudity even when not sexual. And worse, the most extreme think that women should not even show their face in public. It's just a degree of rejection of the sexuality of the human as a taboo, which seems to me nothing but cultural. I'm yet to see a compelling argument that "children shouldn't have access to porn". Not that i particularly think they should have access and I'm actually fine with the 'not under 18' rule for the sake of the "Chesterton Fence" argument, but I'm yet to see an explanation that make a vague sense to me.
- throwaway67743 4y agoI already have a response prepared for my activities that will likely fall under OSB (same for every jurisdiction that asks): If you want to be China, be China, employ something similar to the gfw and quickly become less than a 3rd world nation. Difference is China have something to offer the global economy, people like my home country don't once they start doing this...
- ryzvonusef 4y agoPray tell, what's the difference between my country and the UK if you're going to pull the same tricks? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34661414 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34661414
- throwaway22032 4y agoHow pointless would this legislation be anyway? Literally every YouTube video is advertising VPN services. I would guess that if you polled age 10-18 "do you know what a VPN is" easily more than half would say yes. It's not 2005 any more, this stuff isn't niche. They should refuse to do it on that basis alone. It's just unworkable. Restricting Wikipedia for the least educated but not for the most would be exactly the opposite of their mission.