6 ms·
Can someone remind me why Apple is so anti-VM in seemingly every instance? It just seems so arbitrary and unhelpful, and I have a hard time imagining that the
by crazygringo 4y ago
Can someone remind me why Apple is so anti-VM in seemingly every instance?
It just seems so arbitrary and unhelpful, and I have a hard time imagining that the amount of hardware purchased it forces outweigh the benefits from making macOS/iOS better platforms for development and computation.
It just seems like such an odd stance to take.
- techdragon 4y ago1: This will likely lead to a small (and I do mean small) hit to their sales from people taking advantage of a VM who would have previously had to buy a device… 2: Control over the platform.
- musicale 4y agoApple is not anti-VM. It is anti VM-on-non-Apple-hardware. ;-) Presumably they have determined that lost hardware sales would offset any increased app or service sales from allowing VMs on non-Apple hardware. Though I don't actually know what platform macOS and iOS VMs run on in GitHub Actions and Azure pipelines. Edit: apparently Azure pipelines uses Mac pros. https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/devops/pipelines/agents/hosted?view=azure-devops#hardware https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/devops/pipelines/age...
- saghm 4y agoExactly. At an old job, we had basically a glorified closet full of Mac minis for running our Mac CI builds on; the Linux builds just used EC2 instances.
- 13of40 4y agoConsidering a couple years ago, "Apple Hardware" was an intel CPU with an nvidia GPU I've always wondered why you couldn't just throw a million dollars at them so they could stick apple stickers on your rack and let you run MacOS VMs. The company I used to work for had to do crazy gymnastics just to test software and scan for malware on their OS.
- throwaway2990 4y agoNvidia? Which apple product had Nvidia in it?
- cpuguy83 4y agoMacBook pros did for awhile until they leaked some detail about an upcoming product and Apple switched vendors.
- windowsrookie 4y agoI'm not sure where you heard this from? Back in 2007-2009 Nividia shipped defective GPUs to everyone, including Apple. Every MacBook Pro from that era was affected. Nvidia and Apple couldn't come to an agreement to who should pay for the bad GPUs. It cost Apple a lot of money and Nvidia din't seem to care. After that, Apple slowly started removing Nvidia GPUs from their products. AMD also shipped bad GPU's around ~2011 and Apple went back to Nvidia for a generation or two until AMD sorted their issues out. From Then on it was AMD GPUs only until the M1.
- cpuguy83 4y agoCan't reply to the child comment, but... I only found one article about this from back in 2008. It was definitely a thing back then, I just can't find it.... But indeed likely second fiddle to the gpu issues around the same time, I totally forgot about that.
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoThe comment time stamp is clickable, you should see the reply button there.
- alvarezbjm-hn 4y agoThank you! I need the cheatsheet for this site.
- withinrafael 4y agoGitHub uses macOS VMs as part of some agreement under NDA (that supercedes the terms outlined in the EULA). See previous discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29419610 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29419610
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoTIL wtf? Has there been anything new on this front? Very interesting.
- saagarjha 4y agoApple makes it pretty annoying to run VMs on Apple hardware too. Their license agreement has restrictions in it that are kind of unfortunate.
- lostlogin 4y agoWhy are people so hung up on the licence agreement? VMs run fine all on all sorts of hardware, Mac’s, Nucs, NASs, actual servers etc. I often see posted that using VMs violates the agreement, has someone been sued or something?
- janosdebugs 4y agoThe post is literally about someone getting sued for providing this very service. Are you missing a /s?
- lostlogin 4y agoA poorly written comment by me, as I was thinking of macOS and trying to ask: “Has an individual running a few VMs ever lost a lawsuit?” Obviously fighting Apple would be terrible, but has an individual (as opposed to a company) ever run into trouble?
- ijidak 4y agoIt's probably more about lock-in. They likely don't want a migration path out of their walled garden.
- qwerty456127 4y ago> Apple is not anti-VM. It is anti VM-on-non-Apple-hardware. ;-) Do you mean they allow VMs on iPads already?
- Mad_ad 4y agoworks okayish on iPad Pro https://getutm.app/ https://getutm.app/
- eptcyka 4y agoApple is anti-VM - there is a soft limit on how many VMs one can run on their M1/M2 Macs. The number is 2.
- pasc1878 4y agoThat is the number of macOS VMs. Linux windows etc is not limited
- eptcyka 4y agoIf I cared about Linux VMs, I wouldn't be running macOS as my host.
- jraph 4y agoMaybe you don't, but it's common for macOS users to run Linux VMs to get shit done.
- eptcyka 4y agoSure, but for getting shit done, you can always use nested VMs or SSH into a real linux machine if need be. Regardless, the fact that you can run an unspecified amount of Linux VMs yet macOS VMs are limited to 2 is even more egregious. It's far cheaper to get Linux VMs anywhere than macOS VMs.
- matwood 4y agoApple almost went out of business allowing macOS to run on non-Apple hardware. I think there are still people there who have an irrational fear from that time. From a current financial/business standpoint, Apple considers itself a hardware company that includes their custom OS with their hardware. From that angle it makes no sense to allow it to run on non-Apple hardware. Sort of like Sony being ok with the PS OS running on Xbox.
- red_trumpet 4y agoBut it also makes no sense to forbid it. If Apple were a hardware company, letting people use their software on other devices wouldn't cut their baseline. After all, people buy Apple because of the hardware, right? Apparently not, and because they subsidise the software using hardware sales, they don't want to decouple the two. The Sony/PS situation is exactly the opposite: Sony subsidizes hardware using software (games) sales. Which is why they don't allow you to use different software on a PS.
- alwaysbeconsing 4y agoNow that Apple leans into services revenue it might make sense to license the OS for clones, if they could still sell you an Apple Music subscription on your Samsung iOS device. But as matwood said above in the 90s they traded high-end hardware sales for much less lucrative license fees and lost badly. It was one of the very first things Jobs tried to fix when he returned, and he ended the program because he couldn't get terms he liked from the licensees. (Which in retrospect is weird because it put them entirely out of business, but shrug.)
- brightball 4y agoBest guess? They don’t charge for their OS because it is attached to their hardware.
- Gigachad 4y agoDoesn't seem to make all that much sense though. The value of their OS is how perfect it works with their hardware. Sure some people want to run MacOS on a standard desktop, but that doesn't seem to be a significant group of people.
- brightball 4y agoWould it be more if it was easier though?
- garbagecoder 4y agoProbably from almost going out of business because they didn't control their own platform.
- chrisshroba 4y agoOne guess: if macOS could be virtualized, it would be even easier to run things like Messages, FaceTime, and Photos on non-Apple hardware, which reduces some of the lock-in effect that keeps people from leaving the ecosystem (i.e. Green Bubble Effect)
- csharpminor 4y agoYes, and would lead to iMessage spam and FaceTime robocalls.
- lostlogin 4y agoWould it? Have a crack and you can probably get a macOS VM running on whatever hardware you have in short order.
- dzikimarian 4y agoThere's ton of other instant messaging apps that can run on anything or even have an API. I use some of them and weirdly spam is not a problem at all. Also you can run iMessage without mac if you really want to.
- vlovich123 4y agoNot necessarily. iMessage & FaceTime AFAIK are cryptographically locked onto Apple HW. I could be wrong, but my understanding is that each piece of Apple HW ships with a burned in unique private key that Apple records the public key of in it's internal database. That private key would be missing in a VM context. It's possible my data is out of date though because iMessage spam is real & I'm not sure how that's done if it needs a valid private key that Apple can ban.
- jonpalmisc 4y agoI haven’t looked at this in detail in a while either, but I don’t think the claims here are correct. It is true that Apple employs some efforts to prevent/discourage you from using those services illegitimately, but using iMessage and FaceTime from a Hackintosh has been possible for years, largely without jumping through any hoops.
- l8rlump 4y agoThey want to sell hardware. I'm reminded of this every day when I can't use Apple Reminders and Calendar properly on non-Apple devices. I have an Apple phone but use a non-Apple computer. You used to be able to have a web interface to Reminders, but they changed it and now you can't add tasks in the web interface. No worries then, let's use Caldav. Hmmm, can't add a Caldav server to iCloud anymore. Ahh, we can add a Caldav account to iOS! Nope, it doesn't obey the sync schedule. You can set the schedule to anything but it just syncs when it wants to, maybe every couple of hours if you're lucky. I might be cynical but I wouldn't be surprised if it's a ploy to get more people into buying more of their devices.
- ElFitz 4y ago> I might be cynical but I wouldn't be surprised if it's a ploy to get more people into buying more of their devices. I’d bet on just not testing that use case because they don’t care enough about it. Thus not catching and never fixing any arising issue or regression.
- l8rlump 4y agoMaybe, but combined with the downplayed stripping of features from the iCloud web interface, I'm still skeptical.
- scrollaway 4y agoThis shit is why I use Google products on my iphone: gmail, calendar (with reminders), contacts, etc. (Paid version at that: I pay for google workspace, even for personal use) I'm not locked in to the Apple ecosystem: I can use it on my Linux desktop, or switch to an Android phone at any time.
- lawn 4y agoThe walled garden is absolutely essential to Apple's business idea. If you want to use an Apple product, then they want you to commit to their ecosystem completely. It makes perfect sense that they'd be against anything that circumvents their walled garden, and a VM does just that by allowing users/developers to use their OS without buying their hardware. I personally hate it, and it's why I'll never touch any Apple product.
- poulpy123 4y agoThat and their price is why I will never have an apple product too
- kaba0 4y agoThey have a very good price-to-value ratio, especially when you account for their high resale value, so that's not really a good reason to avoid apple. It is simply unbeatable on the laptop market currently, imo.
- poulpy123 4y agoI was more thinking to the iphone (I don't have laptop). You can't find a cheap new iphone, and even the cheapest iphone is more than I would put in a phone myself. It's true that now high end android phones are as expensive than high end iphones, so on this point of view it's not a criteria
- windowsrookie 4y agoI purchased two brand new iPhone SE's for $100 each around black Friday from Straight Talk. Required one month of prepaid service and then they were unlocked, I used them down in South America. The iPhone SE is better than any comparable Android phone and will receive updates for another 5 years. So "You can't find a cheap new iPhone" is not true. If you're willing to take 1 extra step and get a month of prepaid service you can get a cheap iPhone.
- andyjohnson0 4y ago> Can someone remind me why Apple is so anti-VM in seemingly every instance? Apple is primarily a hardware company. If people are using VMs then they're not buying hardware.
- HybridCurve 4y agoApple is mostly a hardware company. Aside from aesthetics, people are attracted to their products because of the UI for the OS. If you get that for little to nothing, why would anyone buy their overpriced hardware?
- michaelcampbell 4y agoThey don't make money on non-Apple hardware.