15 ms·
Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to the Silicon Cesspool
- GigabyteCoin 15y agoThis post sure struck a chord. Good job, Dan.
- lukeholder 15y agoI stopped reading techcrunch about 9 months ago, after realizing that the majority of articles were friends of the author - and realizing it was almost impossible to get featured on there unless you were connected in some kind of monetary way.
- potatolicious 15y agoAnd finally, in 2012, after mocking and lambasting traditional reportage and journalistic standards for years, the Internet finally learns that journalistic standards, expectations, and ethics are a set of rules learned the hard way, that are as relevant on the web as they were in print. Hopefully this is the beginning of the end for "it's just a blog, man".
- yuhong 15y agoPersonally, I think the mixing opinions and facts that blogs does is not a bad idea, but this don't mean conflict of interest isn't still important.
- philwelch 15y agoIt's not that proper journalism is irrelevant, and it's not even that not everyone should be expected to be proper journalists. It's that proper journalism is a very small niche, not the norm. There isn't much actual market demand for proper journalism compared to the other crap; most readers and viewers are undiscerning and everyone else is willing to pay, so why bother? It was probably this way even before the internet. I mean, they award themselves the "Pulitzer Prize"--go look up the guy that one's named after.
- man1sh 15y agoI stopped reading it two years back, but still get linked to that website. Whenever I land over there, the post contains some or other of BS. It's no co-incidence. Techcrunch is the same as it was 2 years back, probably venom from Siegler has increased
- mattdeboard 15y agoCool, so for the billionth example, makers make something -- good or bad -- that creates a commotion and the chattering class gets to ride the waves. This time, it's Path. What is this article in the OP, 3rd, 4th degree of separation from the actual event in question? It's enough to toss it all in the shitter and just judge things on their own merits: products, apologies and whatever else. Journalists bickering at each other over what exactly? Who cares. Ugh. I think my work life frustration is spilling over into my comments.
- jfruh 15y agohttp://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lxjlw4AnIX1rn1xxfo1_250.gif http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lxjlw4AnIX1rn1xxfo1_250.gi...
- TamDenholm 15y agoThis isnt reddit...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- bdhe 15y agoPlease don't resort to these kinds of comments. Its hard enough to keep the signal-to-noise ratio high in "gossip stories" posts such as this one.
- mdg 15y agogarbage in, garbage out
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- benologist 15y agoAlthough this was a beautiful piece I can't help but feel Dan Lyons just gave Uncrunched, ParisLemon, TechCrunch and PandoDaily another million pageviews between them for the many rebuttals we're about to see.
- mattdeboard 15y agoThat's the game.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- espeed 15y agoIt's like the Republican presidential debate rules -- anytime you mention an opponent, the opponent gets airtime to respond.
- tucson 15y agoThis is a "whistleblower" article. I think it is very important. And I hope there are or will be laws to prevent what the article describes.
- _delirium 15y agoHN already auto-deads submissions from several domains; wonder if it'd improve quality around here if those were added to the list, adding some friction into the game they're playing.
- yuhong 15y agoI wonder how do you think about Arrington being forced out of AOL now, after reading this.
- theblogdoctor 15y agoYou really believe that Arrington was "forced out" of AOL?! Duh.
- mcantelon 15y agoThey conned AOL... committed to staying there in exchange for a big pay then violated the spirit of their agreement by launching a tech fund: a clear conflict of interest.
- reidmain 15y ago"Siegler is constantly mocked by readers as a laughable troll – a mean-spirited, egomaniacal buffoon who is not very bright but thinks he’s the smartest guy in the room, and who, in all of his manic blogging, has left a string of cock-ups and false “scoops” behind him." I feel you could replace the first word in that with Lyons and it would also be an apt description. Is there any better mudslinging match in the tech-blogosphere than Lyons vs Apple bloggers?
- krakensden 15y agoI think the phrase you're looking for is "The unspeakable in full pursuit of the uneatable."
- heyrhett 15y agoHow do I pitch my startup to the Dan Lyons angel fund?
- potch 15y agoGlad to see Lyons getting in on the conversation. And by conversation I mean grab for pageviews.
- bishnu 15y agoPersonally, I'm really happy to see the tech blog echo chamber start slinging mud at each other instead of whatever the tech company to hate du jour is. The more they make themselves the story the more irrelevant they become.
- jwwest 15y agoI've never understood the enormous popularity of M.G. Siegler. His articles are often published without any attributions or even basic spell checking. Yet somehow he's ridden on the coattails of Apple's ascent by positioning himself among the fandom as a "champion of good taste". In interviews he doesn't even come off as particularly pleasant.
- reuser 15y agoPleasantries aren't part of this kind of "good taste".
- bluekeybox 15y agoExactly. Whoever said that good taste has anything to do with appearing pleasant?
- jwwest 15y agoIt's hard to imagine someone enjoying his level of celebrity without even trying to appear pleasant. Even Steve Jobs reserved the bulk of his ire for those that worked for him, and appeared caring to his audience (customers), even "patronly".
- oldstrangers 15y agoFanboys on either side of the aisle love to pat themselves on the back and reaffirm--almost daily--that yes, they did buy the best product imaginable. It's the same reason Gruber makes half a million a year writing snarky one liners. Some sort of subconscious need to find superiority in consumer purchases and brand loyalty. It's kind of disturbing.
- amartya916 15y agoWhile there is some truth to what you said, I don't think dragging John Gruber is appropriate. One can at least see that a post is well written (I actually think that in terms of plain English, Gruber does the best job within the tech. blogosphere) and that some care and thought has been put into framing a cogent argument. From there, it's up to you to agree or disagree. I am not referring to the links he posts, but the actual writing that he does. MG Siegler on the other hand has been perfectly described by Lyons. All he does is generate venom, and copious amounts of it, followed by a couple of "Fuck You's"" and so-on. I think he's the National Enquirer of tech. reporting. And hence, ankle biting Chihuahua is more than correct. If Dan's reading this, good-luck mate. I am glad you called out Siegler's bluff. What he was trying to do with the Path issue was simply 'diversion'. Rake up an issue that can get people talking - loud enough - that it drowns out the issue at hand (callous and selfish handling of privacy in the Silicon Valley).
- mycodebreaks 15y agoBrave article by Dan. Please keep them coming.
- cenuij 15y agoNasty little ankle-biting Matty the Angry Chihuaha, hoho how wonderfully droll :) It may very well be verging on the meta-hypocritical but unlike Siegler at least this man has a flair for the written word.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- martythemaniak 15y agoIt's tempting to dismiss this as just e-lebrity gossip, but I think that this kind of rottenness is probably more dangerous to the Valley than threats from Washington or talk of bubbles. If who you know and how well you can politic overshadows what you did and the results you got, then you're in trouble. If somebody is an unscrupulous douchebag, don't to business with them, don't read their blogs, don't upvote their articles. Treat them like the trolls they are.
- avoutthere 15y agoNothing is more dangerous to the Valley than threats of force from Washington.
- sumukh1 15y ago"As a rule, the only thing that can kill a good startup is the startup itself" - http://www.paulgraham.com/superangels.html http://www.paulgraham.com/superangels.html As a rule, the only thing that can kill a good _ecosystem_ is the _ecosystem_ itself Edit: We live in a democracy. If there is something that stands to significantly harm us, then we should (and can) do something about it. A recent example would be SOPA. The biggest threat we face is not from Washington, it's ourselves. If we become so torn-apart that forces from Washington can destroy us, it's our fault. It's rather easy to focus on problems being caused from an external force, but there are often larger and more dangerous threats internally. That brings up back to the startup quote, it's easy for a startup to focus on competitors (external threat) instead of working on their own product (which is really the biggest thing that will make or break them).
- jamesaguilar 15y agoIs there any rational reason to derive this from pg's statement? Word substitution does not work in all cases. For example: > As a rule, the only thing that can kill a good _human_ is the _human_ itself.
- deleted 15y ago
- davidtyleryork 15y agoSo basically it's only a matter of time before the ideals of the "gold rush" go away and everyone's just in it for the money? I came to Silicon Valley to escape that (the alternative, at the time, was Wall Street). Unfortunately, this kind of behavior (and these kind of people) seem to 'follow the money'. *Note: This is both about the conversation that companies are abusing consumers and then apologizing later, and the tech blogger community and Lyons' accusations
- siavosh 15y agoI get the same exact feeling. The frequency of lax startup ethics seems to be increasing by the count of HN articles reporting it. I left wall street for the same reason you mention. More and more we hear 'this time it's different', but from SV investors. Always a troubling sign.
- apaitch 15y agoWhat would people do if, as you say, everyone gets into it just for the money? Would enough people consider leaving somewhere else?
- davidtyleryork 15y agoI doubt it, there's no greater opportunity in the US right now than there is here
- beedogs 15y agoMaybe it's time to look past the US.
- palish 15y agoWhy do you say that? (I'm just interested. It would be nice to hear more.)
- davidtyleryork 15y agoWell, I can't back this up with hard numbers at this point, but I'm pretty sure that the SF Bay Area has lead the nation in hiring since 2008. Also, where else in the US are you hearing about people becoming rich beyond their wildest dreams? Or about how a new company IPOing will bring about 1000 millionaires? I dont see it anywhere else Granted, I think it's more accurate to say that "tech" is the one doing the hiring and making people rich, not the SF Bay Area itself. But since this is the nexus of the (consumer internet) tech industry worldwide, I think its safe to say that a lot of that opportunity is found here
- throw911 15y agoInvestors in PandoDaily: Marc Andreessen, Peter Thiel, Chris Dixon, Saul Klein, Josh Kopelman, CrunchFund, Greylock Partners, Accel Partners, Menlo Ventures, Lerer Ventures Many of these are top class investors and certainly don't expect a return on their money from a startup tech blog. But they might expect favorable reviews of their portfolio companies when launch time comes or when shit hits the fan.
- dotBen 15y agoExactly, I fear this too. I like Sarah Lacey, and I think she does have integrity. But I can't help but feel this is the investors simply moving up the food chain to protect their startups. Rather than rebutting against the media when their own startups are attacked, they have obtained an inside position at source. I don't believe Sarah thinks this will happen (or she feels she can push back and mitigate) but I'm [sadly] confident this kind of internal pressure will occur at some point. Fuck it, if I'd invested in her media venture I'd want preferential treatment. And I'm ex BBC with a 'no bias' agenda beaten into me it hurts.
- temphn 15y agoBut the BBC gives preferential treatment to the BBC. It's not about to print all of its own internal emails. All news channels are "biased". You can only integrate and filter.
- dotBen 15y agoI spent 6 years reading internal BBC emails. Can't comment for the rest of the BBC, but nothing comes close to the integrity of BBC News. >But the BBC gives preferential treatment to the BBC Go read any BBC news story right now and scroll to the bottom. They even link out to other news sites covering the same story. I can't think of another news website that links to competitors like that. BBC News certainly doesn't give preferential treatment to BBC.
- thewisedude 15y ago<Quote> Not big investments — maybe $100,000. They don’t need your money; they can raise money from anyone. </Quote> I dont agree with this. Many startup companies have to prove their mettle to get an investor want to invest in them. Also, there are significant chance of any startup going bust. He does not supplement what the odds are in making 10x/100x returns. So its difficult to buy the concept that just investing in them will make you richer in a few years. However, I do think Michael Arrington is doing what he can to protect his investment. But I dont think its the other way round..i.e -> Startups are not necessarily filtering investors based on the influencing ability of the investor.
- alain94040 15y agoThe real question is whether CrunchFund is leading or following. If they just follow, once other big names are committed, then frankly the value-added for startups is close to 0.
- apaitch 15y agoThis kind of thing - not the exact events or people described, but the atmosphere conveyed - is exactly what's been turning me off from Silicon Valley. I've interned here twice, and I know that it's full of the top engineers in the world. Yet the underbelly seems to be full of these ridiculous cutthroat business practices and an atmosphere of self-indulgence, self-importance etc, most likely because Silicon Valley is where the money is. It seems like it's turning into the Hollywood of the tech industry, and not in a good way. T'would be a shame.
- PaulAnunda 15y agolet's get back to hacking/the technology.
- aakarpost 15y agoI fully agree with Dan!
- xpose2000 15y agoThis is a fantastic article. I think the start-up industry and the bloggers who report on them is increasingly tiring. I'm glad this guy had the guts to call people out for who they truly are. Though I am sure this is far from the end of it all....
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- moocow01 15y agoI feel like this is a part of the larger conversation of how the dynamics of Silicon Valley are changing (at least from my insulated perspective). I'm not going to sit in my arm chair and smatter Silicon Valley but I enjoyed and respected the culture and environment of SV much more 5 to 10 years ago. It may be untrue but I feel like SV is becoming increasingly dominated by hustlers and scheisters and it has become more difficult to effectively collaborate with the many true technologists there. Actually took a job last year outside of the traditional SV circle of companies to take a break from the atmosphere and have found it to be surprisingly more fun from a technological perspective than the consumer internet products I was building previously.
- alapshah 15y agoHow about we start to act on this by not posting and/or flagging every post from pandodaily, techcrunch, and uncrunched? I think we'd have a better HN experience all around.
- r00fus 15y agoDan isn't innocent here - some of his older posts are sickeningly obvious puff-pieces or hit jobs... of course, he's not excusing himself here or claiming he's not part of the muck he's deriding. But every once in a while (esp. when he did FakeSteveJobs), Dan hits it out of the park, and this is one of those articles. The crunchfund conflict of interest is concerning.
- justinlau 15y agoGood piece. I think of Arrington, Siegler, et al. as the Swift Boaters of tech journalism. They just throw FUD everywhere and they never clean up after themselves.
- snowwrestler 15y agoDan Lyons is afflicted with the combination of being a very talented writer, but a terrible journalist. He's late to a lot of stories--I mean, he's JUST NOW writing about Arrington's conflicts?? And, he's frequently 180 degrees wrong about the stories he does cover--see his coverage of SCO for the most infamous example. I remember my reaction when it was revealed that Dan was behind the Fake Steve Jobs blog. It was approximately, "Huh? Who's that?" And every time I read a non-Fake-Steve-Jobs piece from Dan I am reminded of why I had that reaction. The guy is just not a good tech journalist. He's an incredibly entertaining writer though. I wish he would take his talents south and put out a sitcom or movie or something creative.
- nikcub 15y ago> I mean, he's JUST NOW writing about Arrington's conflicts?? That is because he wanted to work at Techcrunch (there was a perennial discussion within TC on hiring him, and his wage demands were massive). now that Arrington can't give that to him any longer, he can speak out against him. Speaking of conflicts.
- tucson 15y agoIf what Dan Lyons wrote here is correct then this article is the most useful and interesting I have ready in years about Silicon Valley. It is describing / implying a widespread problem of "payola" (pay for play) in the tech media.
- yalogin 15y agoWhat you are saying is kind of outside the scope of this article right? Without going into his shortcomings or strengths do you agree or disagree with anything he says in this specific post?
- javajosh 15y agoThe key question that arises in my mind is simply this: why is perception so important in Silicon Valley? It seems clear that money influences tech reporting to a fairly high degree, but what is the economic incentive? In a universe of makers, shouldn't the things made speak for themselves?
- cbs 15y agobut what is the economic incentive? Getting users. Tech isn't the meritocracy everyone likes to pretend it is.
- davidu 15y agoIt's as if people think that any journalist is unbiased. At least MG, MA, and SL all share their bias so openly. You don't think Dan is biased in his reporting? Please.
- faithful_droog 15y agoMichael Arrington's response: http://uncrunched.com/2012/02/13/we-are-better-than-this/ http://uncrunched.com/2012/02/13/we-are-better-than-this/
- fatbat 15y agoMG's here: http://parislemon.com/post/17587323277/bat-shit-crazy http://parislemon.com/post/17587323277/bat-shit-crazy
- andrewhillman 15y agoBrilliant piece.
- jfarmer 15y agoI agree with the overall argument and sentiment of Dan's article. My ideal blog about technology startups would be about Silicon Valley as it is. It would be hard to run this blog. I'm not even sure it could be profitable, because most interesting information about what's happening in Silicon Valley is not written about. It's shared directly between people working here, and there's very little reason for those conversations to go public. You see the same problems with journalists covering Washington and national politics. The journalists are willing to be used by politicians because it furthers their careers. It's so tempting to just give in. It's certainly more profitable. On the other hand, if you take TechCrunch for what it is, I don't think it's unethical per se. You just have to know how to read between the lines. Dan's article would be better if he didn't confuse angel and VC investment, though. Michael Arrington is certainly an angel investor, and he was one long before he started CrunchFund. He's probably an investor in CrunchFund's first fund, but as a General Partner he's acting as a VC, not an angel investor. The key distinction being whether he's investing his own money (an angel investor) or LPs' money (a VC).
- ericflo 15y agoI'm surprised by the amount of cheering going on over this article. I found it in very poor taste, resorting to ad hominem attacks and slander. Even if it were in good taste, I don't agree with the general idea behind the post. I don't understand this pent up hatred for Arrington, M.G. Siegler, and the other TechCrunch writers who, despite what people continually say, do genuinely seem to care about startups. Is this a case of wanting to knock successful people down a peg? Is it jealousy? What is it? Sure, they are biased, but everyone is. At least they make it clear where their biases lie. Please help me to understand this anger.
- justinlau 15y agoI'm surprised that you're surprised. Read the comments, it's pretty unambiguously spelled out here.
- bri3d 15y agoI think a lot of this anger stems from the way many tech bloggers write - a combination of a "fuck the haters" and a "told ya so" attitude. It's easy to breed hatred with thinly-veiled disdain for those who criticize you, and I think that's a good part of what's happening here. A lot of dislike for TechCrunch and affiliates also forms because these bloggers are part of a "good ol' boys" crowd in Silicon Valley. While the article casts this effect as one of VCs indirectly paying for stories and conflict of interest, I think personal ties are more important. Most of these tech bloggers spend a lot of time with a small group of VCs and founders-turned-investors, and it shows in what they choose to write about (and in who funds them when they go to found their own sites). For many, especially those outside this close network who are founding a startup or those who choose to eschew venture funding, it's frustrating to watch an already quite small echo chamber (tech startups in general) grow even smaller thru the lens of the VC-affiliate media.
- tlrobinson 15y agoTech journalists sure do love writing about themselves.
- beaker 15y agoThe interesting thing to me here is how the story is no longer about Path and whether their actions were right or wrong. In the course of attempting to defend their portfolio company, Arrington and Co. have created a new debate about the role of journalism in the tech world, pitting the VC-backed insiders and their well-oiled hype machine vs the hordes of unconnected outsiders seeking to break down the gates. This dynamic is reflected by the passionate reactions coming fast and furiously from both sides. It could get ugly, but in the long run it's probably a good thing for everyone to have this discussion.
- feralchimp 15y agoAs Lyons notes, the debate around pay-to-play or other more subtle conflicts of interest in tech journalism has been around for a while, and is probably here to stay. I'm still trying to wrap my head around the fact that anyone publicly sided with Path after their app behavior was exposed. There just is no spin spinny enough for that job. That it was Arrington and MG giving it the old college try just adds some extra lulz/wtf to the scene.
- tucson 15y agoI don't agree that this debate necessarily will stay. Legislation can change that. Infomercials on tv have been reigned in because consumers associations came to defend consumers. Ads desguised as journalism (which is what this is all about here, I believe) are very efficient ways to sell. Check out Dan Kennedy's work, or any direct marketer's tricks.
- onemoreact 15y agoPeople spin things that actually kill thousands of people every year. Why do you think your privacy is going to be more respected than your life?
- onemoreact 15y agoPeople spin things that actually kill thousands of people every year. Why do you think your privacy is going to be more respected than your life? EX: Clean Coal
- mkramlich 15y agoI view all of that kind of thing as noise and try to filter it out.
- callmeed 15y agoI'm curious how close this resembles the Payola scandal and if it would ever warrant legal/political intervention. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Payola http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Payola
- donnawarellp 15y agoThis sounds like a lot of bitching to me. Get back to work.
- Jayasimhan 15y agoAnd now these writers occupy HN. 597+ upvotes. Seriously? Sigh.
- felipemnoa 15y agoIs probably more a sign that HN now has a much bigger diverse audience. Not so long ago it would be really rare to get 597 upvotes in a single story.
- Jayasimhan 15y agoWe should start flagging users who post sensationalist stories on HN. Not reward them with karma.
- fatbat 15y agoKind of ironic that this story was right above another TC story.
- ilamont 15y agoI was with him until this: The real secret to Siegler’s traffic, however, is that he is pals with Gabe Rivera, who routinely drives traffic to Siegler by giving his pieces top billing on Techmeme. (That’s right, kids. Techmeme is rigged.) Unlike his criticism of Siegler, Lacy, and Arrington, the statement about Rivera and Techmeme is not backed up by any evidence. If he has some -- an analysis of Techmeme placement of Siegler's posts, sources who have knowledge of the alleged "top billing", or some other information -- it should be stated or linked from the post.
- orthecreedence 15y agoThis is why I feel like a lot of startups raising their hands in a "ohhh write about me!!! write about me!!" frenzy of desperation seems to get them the users and followers (edit: and investors) they deserve. Sure, if your market is the tech crowd, go for it. If you're market is not the tech world, then I believe it makes sense to avoid the shitty tech press altogether. Getting a Techcrunch piece about your app doesn't mean you're successful in any measure. Having a business model and making a profit does make you successful. Sure Techcrunch is marketing, but in most cases it's the wrong kind...not all eyeballs are good ones. Know your market.
- AznHisoka 15y agoI totally agree. There's also hidden dangers involved. If you're a company like AirBnB or Path, and something disastrous PR-wise happens, it'll appear all over TC if you're a Silicon Valley darling. If you're not known among SV, maybe 1-2 minor publications will pick up the story, but there won't be a huge commotion. If they're not your target audience, is it really worth a write-up in TC?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- vl 15y agoAnd this is a click-bate title I'm not going to click out of principle.
- functionform 15y agoIt isn't click bait. If you follow the network of blogs Dan talks about you saw the blatant self-interest machine hard at work in realtime. I was disgusted by it, but I'm not a tech writer, thus no platform to weigh in on. I'm glad someone picked up on it and gave it to them, and you only have to glance at the comments he got to know that I'm not the only person who felt this way.
- vl 15y agoArticle might be worthy, but this title gives me no insight into the content of the article and thus doesn't allow me to decide if I want to see it or not in a first place. How would I guess that it's about "network of blogs with the blatant self-interest machine"?
- VonGuard 15y agoOh... My... God.... Lyons is a fucking god. As a journalist in the valley, I can just say that the first paragraph he's written here hits the nail right on the fucking head. ---"It’s tough being a journalist, especially if you’re covering technology and living in Silicon Valley, because it seems as if everyone around you is getting fabulously rich while you’re stuck in a job that will never, ever make you wealthy. What’s worse is that all these people who are getting rich don’t seem to be any brighter than you are and in fact many of them don’t seem very bright at all. So of course you get jealous. And then you start thinking maybe you could find a way to cash in on this gold rush. But how do you make gobs of money when your only marketable skill involves writing blog posts?" I feel this way all the time! But there's a distinct difference between acting on these feelings and just feeling them. Arrington would be just fine and above reproach, these days, if he'd keep his fucking mouth shut now that he is ludicrously compromised and un-objective. If he'd quite being a "journalist" he'd not look like such a douche... Perhaps this is why I haven't jumped the fence yet... I don't think I could give up the journalism. It just gets in your blood. And once it's in, the thought of compromising yourself is sickening. Unless you're Arrington.
- glyph 15y agoBut that's the whole point of the article: the whole value of the CrunchFund (and its ilk) is that Arrington (and his ilk) will be a douche on your behalf. If it were just the money, it wouldn't be worth it for the companies they invest in: the amounts are too small. It's an alternative compensation scheme for a PR flack who masquerades as a journalist. There's no ethical way to run the fund, because it would be worthless if it were ethical.
- VonGuard 15y agoYah, obviously that's the value he's adding. I think it's a zero sum game, however. Shilling isn't going to help a crappy product out in the long term, only the short term. And it brings up all manner of ethical grey areas: is blogging journalism? Do influencers lose influence when they lose objectivity? What the fuck is an influencer, anyway? If a journalist is ever an influencer, he or she is doing it wrong... Buh, I could go on a giant rant here about how journalism is dead, or at least, extremely sick... How am I going to write about people places and events when those people places and events are writing about themselves? Fortunately, it would seem there is still a consumer for quality, deep journalism on specific topics. I don't even know what I'm really saying here, anymore... Just that Lyons really hit a nerve. It's super frustrating to be in an interview with someone who makes 10X what you make, and is completely unaware of what's really going on in their industry.... All too common an event.
- eurohacker 15y agothanks for explaining not only how the Silicon Valley media channels work but pretty much how the whole American mainstream media cesspool works , GENERAL ELECTRIC --(donated 1.1 million to GW Bush for his 2000 election campaign) Television Holdings: * NBC: includes 13 stations, 28% of US households. * NBC Network News: The Today Show, Nightly News with Tom Brokaw, Meet the Press, Dateline NBC, NBC News at Sunrise. * CNBC business television; MSNBC 24-hour cable and Internet news service (co-owned by NBC and Microsoft); Court TV (co-owned with Time Warner), Bravo (50%), A&E (25%), History Channel (25%). The "MS" in MSNBC means microsoft The same Microsoft that donated 2.4 million to get GW bush elected. http://la.indymedia.org/news/2003/04/47530.php http://la.indymedia.org/news/2003/04/47530.php DISNEY / ABC / CAP (donated 640 thousand to GW's 2000 campaign). When Pixar deal closed - Steve Jobs became The Walt Disney Company's largest single shareholder with approximately seven percent of the company's stock.[12] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Jobs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Jobs Disney Television Holdings: * ABC: includes 10 stations, 24% of US households. * ABC Network News: Prime Time Live, Nightline, 20/20, Good Morning America. * ESPN, Lifetime Television (50%), as well as minority holdings in A&E, History Channel and E! * Disney Channel/Disney Television, Touchtone Television. Media Holdings: * Miramax, Touchtone Pictures. * Magazines: Jane, Los Angeles Magazine, W, Discover. * 3 music labels, 11 major local newspapers. * Hyperion book publishers. * Infoseek Internet search engine (43%). Other Holdings: * Sid R. Bass (major shares) crude oil and gas.
- smokinn 15y agoHopefully more people will start realizing that this is what techcrunch has always done. I remember watching a techcrunch50. I showed some people I knew the swype demo and everyone was blown away. That's so cool! What won? Yammer. Twitter for the enterprise. There's no way Yammer could possibly have won other than silicon valley tunnel vision/influence circle. That was the only tc50 I watched. I also only ever read tc very briefly because the quality was awful. For the occasional scoop they got (and fewer right) it's just wasn't worth wading through the drivel. At least now they have a new business model I suppose.
- functionform 15y agoNeeded to be said. Bravo Dan Lyons.
- angelortega 15y agoVery funny, but... isn't Lyons himself click-whoring with articles like this? He is (or has become) a part of the circus.
- deepakprakash 15y agoIt started stinking from the time CrunchFund was announced and I couldn't understand all the "moral highground" support bullshit that Arrington was getting - most notably from the TC staff. Journalism is a lot about perspective - I dont care if you occupy the highest moral grounds, your perspective changes dramatically once you have significant interest and money invested into something you are talking about. What you would normally call a Spade now becomes a Diamond. Arrington's and MG's responses to the Path issue is proof enough for this - can you imagine both of them so mellow and supportive if Path was not CF funded was not around? I think not. And ohh yeah, I nearly puked reading MG's "rant" few days back. For someone who is so hypercritical of anything on the borderline of wrong (except if its from Apple - or any CF company it seems now), it felt especially nauseous. To their credit, they do have disclosures - which definitely make a difference - if that is enough, I'm not sure. Credibility is built by calling a spade a spade. It also tends to take the fast route down if you stop doing that.
- ChrisNorstrom 15y agoHow about a few of us here get together, throw up a wordpress install, and start a self-serve tech/startup site. I've got RobotSays.com. Basically anyone can be an author, they create a guest post, upload their content and their picture, and submit the post for approval and we the editors fix up anything out of place and approve only the best content for the front page. A lot of design blogs allow guest post submissions and it works out very well. Basically when it comes to tech/startup news this is all I want to know: 1 - when new startups launch 2 - important new game changing features that existing startups are implementing 3 - advice and interviews (Ask me anything) from startup founders 4 - new game changing gadgets coming out 5 - when startups are hiring 6 - when startups are sunsetting and why That's it, no dirty laundry being aired, no drama, no egos, no kings, no divas.
- JackdawX 15y agoWell, you just invented slashdot. It's fallen by the wayside now, because places like this, with (largely) unmoderated user generated content, can distribute news faster.
- ChrisNorstrom 15y agoI do agree with you, but if HN were so go at news then why does TechCrunch, ReadWriteWeb, GigaOm, AllThingsD, Mashable, etc... exist? HN isn't really a content creator, it's a distributor of content that has already been created at those sites mentioned. HN is a great community of news commentators, but HN is terrible at allowing people to generate content and articles themselves. And those types of content creators (editors) put so much hard work into their pieces they want to find a good home for their articles, a permanent place of existence. People writing guest posts for TC, RWW, GO, ATD, Mash, can just as easily make a post here on HN. But they don't. No one wants to put in so much hard work and research just for it to disappear into the jungle of links and never be found again.
- brandnewlow 15y agoPeople are too busy trying to make "product money," not "blog money." Never forget, TechCrunch itself started as a sideproject to help Arrington learn about the startup space while he worked on one of his own.
- nextparadigms 15y agoI'm really surprised that Google trusts and would still let MG Siegler review their products before launch (like they just did with Chrome for Android), when 80% of his posts now are about trashing Google. It's like begging for attention from an abusive boyfriend or father: "Come on, MG..just one little nice word about our new product...please?" They must think that it's better this way, than to give it to someone who already likes Google, because it's more "fair" and he'd be seen as more "objective". Seriously, MG objective? Does anyone still think that by now? There's not a paragraph in his reviews where he doesn't compare anything to Apple, whether it's necessary or not, and of course Apple always comes out on top in his view. Apple on the other hand gives out their products before release only to people who are totally on their side like Pogue and Walt, so the initial reviews of the product always come out favorable, and they get to influence other laggard reviewers, too.
- ChrisNorstrom 15y agoBecause if they can get him to like their product that would be a huge achievement for them. They want to be the ones that win him over.
- dgregd 15y agoYou get what you paid for. TC blog is free so all you get is simply product placement blog.
- ultimatewarrior 15y agoReality hit him hard.
- myspy 15y agoFunny to see that much praise for Lyons, which is far away from being a good writer. Many things coming from him are link bait articles and insulting for a reader trying to make up his mind.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mrbill 15y agoSomewhere, Gruber, Lyons, Arrington, and Siegler are sitting back, smoking cigars around a poker table, and laughing at all the income from ads that their little "dispute" and junior-high name calling is earning them.
- grellas 15y agoSilicon Valley once was home to scientists and engineers — people who wanted to build things. Then it became a casino. Now it is being turned into a silicon cesspool, an upside-down world filled with spammers, liars, flippers, privacy invaders, information stealers — and their grubby cadre of paid apologists and pygmy hangers-on. Silicon Valley has not fundamentally changed over the decades and I can say that from the perspective of someone who has lived here for over 40 years and who has been in the thick of the startup world since the early 1980s. Opportunism has always existed and always will. But great ventures are not fundamentally built upon opportunism. They are built upon incredible skills, daring forms of risk-taking, amazingly hard work, and like traits that are quite admirable. Those traits showed themselves strongly here in the Valley 30 years ago and they continue to do so today. Indeed, the heart of the Valley consists of anything but the "upside-down world filled with spammers, liars, flippers, privacy invaders, information stealers" that the author here attempts to depict. Sleazy elements exist as they do whenever money is at stake but to suggest that they are what most defines the Valley is to slander a lot of good people who are doing great things and who have nothing whatever to do with the world of which the author writes. The author is an excellent writer but this piece is seriously flawed by an intemperate tone, extreme ad hominem attacks, and gross overstatement. In my view, such flaws seriously weaken it as a piece of advocacy. And the lurid headline does not help either, especially when one writes to criticize "click whores." It is not that the piece is bad on substance. It just could have been so much better had the author chosen to strike a more judicious tone.
- heyrhett 15y agoCan anyone explain why this post got buried on reddit? I thought they live for controversial stories like this. Is Arrington a reddit investor too?