9 ms·
Health advisory on social media use in adolescence
- b800h 4y agoOr just don't let them use it. A lot of verbiage there; no reason to let your child use social media. I wonder if they've been lobbied.
- omginternets 4y agoI think they were probably just asked to be as accurate as they could, and no more. There's no clear and compelling reason for a blanket recommendation to avoid social media altogether. But I'm largely with you. As a practical matter, it's easier just to avoid it entirely.
- bilqis 4y agoKids may be socially isolated if they’re not present online.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- uoaei 4y agoThat doesn't happen in a vacuum. Parents are responsible for enabling their childrens' social lives, it's part of their duties as parents. Friends live far away? Organize with other parents to drive kids back and forth, or go home together from school. You live in SFZ suburbia? Well, that requires a more drastic change but it's doable.
- b800h 4y agoI think the downsides outweight the upsides. If they're doing sports and clubs, the social isolation will be minimal, other children will have phone bans too, and they won't be at risk from a load of horrendous stuff online.
- bnj 4y agoI’ve experienced a lot of exasperation recently as the sports and clubs that my kids are involved with only communicate the practice schedule and meeting times over WhatsApp.
- slothtrop 4y agoIf a parent takes the intervening effort to limit time online, they can take the intervening effort to ensure their child takes part in social activities. The connection is not lost on them. Social media is addicting in large part because kids are addicted to each other. It's often used as a substitute for hanging out. That barrier doesn't need to be there all the time. Adults get complacent with tech and will bias towards the convenience of staying at home versus going out-into-the-world to do things - if we want to lead by example, changing our own lifestyle helps, but simply accommodating a kid's extra-curriculars will get you out of the house too. And really, if you prevent a kid from watching 3 hours of television, are they going to do "nothing" instead? No, they'll figure something out to keep entertained. By the same token, they'll want to satisfy their social needs. One problem is that opting for online chat can be a defense mechanism against going out and being vulnerable in front of other people.
- hgsgm 4y agoAre you pro or anti Remote/Work From Home?
- slothtrop 4y agoPro do what you want. Personally I end up working from a coffee shop once a week, I'd be alright with flexible hybrid. I do get some social needs met from family, but I clearly benefit from getting out of the house. With kids, it's easier this way than having your own weekly extra-curriculars (though I try to set time for some). Friends in this city are few and weekends get repetitive.
- 31337Logic 4y agoThat's true only if the majority of kids spend the majority of their time online. It's a circular argument. And while one might argue that that is indeed the case today, the question is SHOULD it be the case, tomorrow? I think it's just an objective fact: given the way social media sites intentionally try to grab and hold onto our attention at any cost, the cons far outweigh the pros and we all (not just children) would be better off consuming less social media. Once the media companies restructure their business model and make their platforms more ethical and sustainable for society, then I have no problem with widespread adoption again.
- tboyd47 4y agoYet, this argument doesn't seem persuasive to the creators of such technology. https://www.businessinsider.com/tech-execs-screen-time-children-bill-gates-steve-jobs-2019-9#google-ceo-sundar-pichais-middle-school-aged-son-doesnt-own-a-cell-phone-and-the-tv-can-only-be-accessed-with-activation-energy-1 https://www.businessinsider.com/tech-execs-screen-time-child...
- omginternets 4y agoMaybe. And maybe you can work around that. It's a judgement call.
- kingkawn 4y agolobbied by their children, as i've seen in all my friends who've tried to limit internet access with their pre-teen and teenage kids
- b800h 4y agoHah. I might be a terrible curmudgeon, but my answer is just a flat no.
- kingkawn 4y agoHope it works out once they're free of you
- sarchertech 4y agoThen they’ll be adults and hopefully able to manage their social media use better than children can. Worst case, they’ll be no worse off than those of us who came of age before social media existed.
- hexis 4y agoThere’s zero chance this message was not shaped by social media companies. Any message like this, regarding any industry, would get that industry’s input. That said, it sure seems like social media companies got this to be as neutral as they possibly could, considering the very strong evidence that social media is extremely bad for kids. We’re definitely soft rebooting the tobacco experience, this time with psychology instead of lungs.
- b800h 4y agoIn the UK the standard combination appears to be vapes and Tiktok.
- basch 4y agoIt's interesting to see beauty, appearance, and eating disorders called out, along with racism and bullying, but little else. Those are absolutely problems, and rabbit holes to keep out of, but I'm not sure that calling some specifics out really encompasses the whole problems, or the higher level problems that exist above the topic of content. At a higher level, short video content has become a super refined version of americas funniest home videos and mtv. There is no narrative between videos, and it just constantly presses the dopamine button. Then you get the split videos where you have a sensory video playing alongside someone talking. It also doesn't talk about faux excitement. Every other youtuber that isnt Miss Rachel is yelling or screaming, and basically producing entire videos of hysterical feigning of shock, mouth agasp. That transcends nearly any topic. It also doesnt talk about learning to navigate youtube vs being fed youtube by youtube. It also doesnt talk about advertising, especially the organicish kind. Teaching kids that the video about a guy making pancakes with Prime is a Prime ad. It also doesnt talk about replacing friends with celebrities.
- flangola7 4y agoA vital amount of social interaction that kids and young adults experience is online. For reclusive or socially anxious individuals it may even be the majority of interaction. It isn't like how it was 20 or even 10 years ago, blanket banning will leave them significantly socially isolated and stunted. IME anyone over the age of 25 will not fully appreciate this unless they regularly interact with and (critically!) actively listen to what kids have to say.
- tgv 4y agoTaking away heroin from addicted people will leave them feeling bad. That's not a reason to keep supplying it to them. > blanket banning will leave them significantly socially isolated If they get that much of their interaction online, they're already socially isolated. That it happens to be called social media doesn't mean it's actually social.
- flangola7 4y agoUnilaterally taking heroin away from individuals (especially without investing in the necessary support structures) is also a wrong and doomed strategy (I think everyone here is familiar with the abject disaster that was the War on Drugs), so that's not very encouraging. Government does have a place here, but it's in the form of banning hyperoptimizing attention/advertising algorithms and other business models that rely on precision crafted human manipulation, not micromanaging as a parental stand-in.
- tgv 4y agoBut it's not a reason to just keep supplying addicts with heroin, which is the implied laissez-faire solution of the parent comment. > the War on Drugs That's not a one-dimensional topic, and in the case of social media, the suppliers are very, very well known.
- williamcotton 4y agoOk, so if the world has changed to the point where these kids cannot live satisfied lives without their phones… then we need to start progressively raising the voting age now so they never have any input into how the rest of us live. We can make them leper colonies filled with screens with up-arrows to click on.
- EvanAnderson 4y agoAgreed. It might help the mental health of the parents, and increase interaction with their children, if they cut back on their social media use themselves. It would definitely serve as a good example. (I realize I'm saying this via a social media channel while being a father. I get that it's not easy. I am also aware I'm committing hypocrisy.) My wife and I promised each other not to "share" much (and absolutely no photos) about our child on the Internet (even as the child, getting older, has started asking us to "share" things). I think not being able to use my child for sweet, sweet Internet points was useful in helping me disengage from the least rewarding, most mentally taxing social media (which, for me, was Facebook). I caught myself replying HN comments during evening read aloud time. I decided to start using the dedicated e-reader, instead of my phone, so that it won't happen again.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- barbazoo 4y agoWhat's the downside, kids miss out, might be excluded by their peers maybe even bullied? Would the parent/child relationship suffer? But would the compound effect be better or worse than exposing a young child to social media? I have no idea but my gut feeling is that people would be better off overall without social media. Just a gut feeling though and we shouldn't make policies based on gut feelings obviously.
- Brusco_RF 4y agoYou don't need to go to the extreme in either direction. Everything is fine in moderation. Kids are terrible at moderating (adults aren't great either), so use the screen time limits that Apple gives you.
- trasz4 4y agoNo reason to let your child any media, unless you want them to be literate or sth. And social media is less harmful than some traditional ones. It's just that you've been conditioned by the traditional ones to believe they are somehow normal.
- concordDance 4y ago> no reason to let your child use social media. It's nowhere near that simple unless you're living with the Amish. No social media results in isolation from peers, a cure worse than the disease.
- Minor49er 4y agoWhat's stopping kids from simply hanging out with one another?
- ohdannyboy 4y agoCulture has changed a lot since we were kids. Online communication is integral, disturbingly so since covid. They'll still hang out, but less than we did and they'll miss a lot since everyone except them was part of the online component. Pre-social-media I grew up with no TV, only Christian music, limited movies and a whole host of other things that isolated me from my peers. It didn't do anything but build resentment towards my parents and make me thankful they have no say in my life anymore. I don't now the best approach with kids these days since I don't have any. But I strongly doubt it's the "strict no" route.
- hospitalJail 4y agoI'd like to see more tools on how to quit addictive behaviors. I read Power of Habit, so I can easily quit things, but not everyone was lucky to be gifted a 300 page book and read it. If that was taught as a class in high school, it might eliminate long-term drug addiction. How many times are people subjecting themselves to social media they don't really want to view because they habitually unlock their phone and check their notifications? These kind of things are fighting fire with a squirt gun. Telling people to 'use less' and 'monitor' are easy to beat with addictive platforms.
- safety1st 4y ago> 8. Adolescents should limit use of social media for social comparison, particularly around beauty- or appearance-related content. Or we could just throw up our hands at the epidemic of teen girl suicide and say "oh they shouldn't do that" What a joke the APA has become
- nomel 4y agoI don't think this is fair. Knowing what should be avoided is a prerequisite for figuring out how to avoid it. Communicating what should be avoided should be done even if the "how" isn't really understood/thought out.
- anonymouse008 4y agoHave a high level summary? The whole place the gym bag in front of the door as success I feel is misplaced (yes) without a reward loop (unique to each person).
- hospitalJail 4y agoI don't. I have tried to find web pages that summarize it, and they do a disservice. I tried writing my own blog post, and I don't think I got any positive feedback. There might be a bit of nuance that a summary doesnt catch. Anyway, I'd pay 100k to read Power of Habit, you basically can do whatever you want when you learn how the brain works.
- xpe 4y agoI don’t personally have a good sense of the how well the writing captures the scientific evidence. As a positive, I see indications that the report is attempting to identify the specific patterns and activities that are known to be damaging. One of the many challenges with these kinds of reports is remaining relevant and useful as these tools evolve and society adapts. What kinds of social media patterns, features, or risk factors do you notice in kids?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xpe 4y agoThe web page shows a photo of a mom sitting alongside her daughter while she’s using social media. I’m not in that situation, but that general approach seems awkward. (Maybe it shouldn’t?) The related text doesn’t offer much detail on how this could work. I’m open to ideas, but I’m not seeing them in the page. Perhaps the linked PDF has more? If so, some hyperlinks to details would help.
- edbaskerville 4y ago"...designs created for adults may not be appropriate for children." Seems right, seeing as the designs created for adults aren't good for adults either.
- bhawks 4y agoSeems like Big Tech hasn't been following the other Big $INDUSTRY playbook fully yet - you gotta buy your own competing medical studies. Newbie mistake. I am sure they'll learn, they figured out how important buying politicians was in the mid 2000s.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoThis feels so weak and inappropriate. It's easy to say don't do X or don't do Y. But then what? What are they supposed to be doing instead? God only knows how they'd feel if they instead watched the "news". Perma-war, climate change, constant political cluster fuckery, the latest fear-mongering narrative, stranger danger, etc., etc. The APA should prescribe a mirror for every adult, and ask them to spend time thinking about the world we're creating for future generations (i.e., current adolescents).
- camelNotation 4y agoWhat are they supposed to be doing instead of social media? Social media was invented like 10 minutes ago. And they certainly don't need to watch the news on a regular basis. Play sports, build things, read books, create art (write, draw, paint, design, play music, etc etc), learn new things worth learning, and - God forbid - be BORED sometimes and have to come up with their own adventures and activities. Parents need to be actively providing children with avenues for their own development and creativity. There are infinite options.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoI'm simply pointing out that "Don't _____" is not a solution. Just like "Don't be sedentary" worked out so well. I'm also pointing out, that they didn't create the shit-show they're going to inherit. The least we can do should be 5x or 10x better than "Don't _____". How about "Don't just say don't"?
- niels_bom 4y agoThat the research here was mostly non-longitudinal really undermines how useful the results are. Even though our society has this data, it’s just in Big Social’s data vault. Would be nice if we could enforce them to let scienctists use this data for research.
- orhmeh09 4y agoThis recent article suggests other factors might be more important to adolescent mental health: Time spent on social media among the least influential factors in adolescent mental health: preliminary results from a panel network analysis https://www.nature.com/articles/s44220-023-00063-7 https://www.nature.com/articles/s44220-023-00063-7 > There is growing concern about the role of social media use in the documented increase of adolescent mental health difficulties. However, the current evidence remains complex and inconclusive. While increasing research on this area of work has allowed for notable progress, the impact of social media use within the complex systems of adolescent mental health and development is yet to be examined. The current study addresses this conceptual and methodological oversight by applying a panel network analysis to explore the role of social media on key interacting systems of mental health, wellbeing and social life of 12,041 UK adolescents. Here we find that, across time, estimated time spent interacting with social media predicts concentration problems in female participants. However, of the factors included in the current network, social media use is one of the least influential factors of adolescent mental health, with others (for example, bullying, lack of family support and school work dissatisfaction) exhibiting stronger associations. Our findings provide an important exploratory first step in mapping out complex relationships between social media use and key developmental systems and highlight the need for social policy initiatives that focus on the home and school environment to foster resilience.
- 908B64B197 4y ago> Time spent on social media among the least influential factors in adolescent mental health But it's the one that's easy to assign blame to: it's the evil (sometimes foreign) big tech companies fault. Increasingly poor economics prospects, environmental crisis and over-competitive society are much tougher issues to crack, and perhaps, in the case of housing for instance, certain demographics would prefer to blame the "evil screens" rather than their own generation's behavior over the years...
- orhmeh09 4y agoalthough I believe the big tech companies are doing their very best to capture attention at all costs, it is a good question to ask why people are in a position to spend so much time on social media and are doing so in place of other activities. For example, the lack of public spaces where one can spend time without spending money, relatively recent parenting practices and legal obstacles to having unsupervised time outdoors, etc.
- dang 4y agoRelated ongoing thread: Students can’t get off their phones. Schools have had enough - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35874246 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35874246 - May 2023 (133 comments)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vrglvrglvrgl 4y ago[dead]
- JohnMakin 4y ago> To minimize psychological harm, adolescents’ exposure to “cyberhate” including online discrimination, prejudice, hate, or cyberbullying especially directed toward a marginalized group (e.g., racial, ethnic, gender, sexual, religious, ability status),22 or toward an individual because of their identity or allyship with a marginalized group should be minimized. Ok, there goes 95% of the most popular games out there.
- WanderPanda 4y agoLet’s put aside hate, Twitter can‘t even filter raw violence (people shooting eachother) nowadays. It‘s really disturbing and I press I‘m not interested every time but these viral videos still pop up every once in a while. Sure the number of regrettable minutes might be minimized as Elon wants it to be. But the magnitude of regret of the few regrettable minutes is just off the charts
- JohnMakin 4y agoTrue. What this advisory recommends doesn't really seem feasible without cutting off an adolescent entirely to the internet - which isn't necessarily a bad idea, I'm just not sure how feasible that is without destroying their peer relationships at the same time. When I was a teen it was not unusual to see extremely graphic violence go viral in ways that made it much easier to find than it is nowadays (like beheading videos and stuff). I want to say I came out pretty unscathed, but I'm not sure.
- blinded 4y agoYa my kids wont be using any of it until they are adults.
- nilespotter 4y agoThis is the same APA that in 2019 published guidance on toxic masculinity. While they're likely right on this topic as social media is a cancer, this is not a serious organization that should be paid attention to.
- hamilyon2 4y agoSo basically shepherding adolescent online life is impossible given current reality of Facebook, whatsapp and friends and if it was, it would be a full-time job? Or did I miss something?
- khazhoux 4y agoMy kids thankfully are not into (and we don't allow) "social media" -- no Instagram, TikTok, etc. So they're not posting selfies and waiting for the Like count to go up. But they do spend a ton of time in online chats (Discord, Google Hangouts/Meet/whatever). Only in groups with friends, never in public rooms with strangers. On the one hand, it is essential that they be allowed to participate in these chats, since that is how they kids are hanging out now. On the other hand, holy crap the new ways to bully and mean to each other!!
- hackernewds 4y agoThey probably do. But you just don't know? There are a _lot_ of strange chatrooms with "strangers" on Discord, including a lot of porn on Discord for example.
- khazhoux 4y agoNo, they’re definitely not chatting with strangers. They spend a lot of hours on chat (teen/preteen), and some parents might cut them off at night -- but we don't. We can clearly hear that they're talking with friends. So we let them burn the hours in chat because it's how they socialize... and as a side effect it doesn't leave any time left over for random stranger forums.
- golemotron 4y agoKudos to Jonathan Haidt for popularizing the research that led to this statement.
- Trencin 4y ago>As researchers have found with the internet more broadly, racism (i.e., often reflecting perspectives of those building technology) is built into social media platforms. For example, algorithms (i.e., a set of mathematical instructions that direct users’ everyday experiences down to the posts that they see) can often have centuries of racist policy and discrimination encoded.9 There's something ridiculous about this statement.
- xcdzvyn 4y agoThank you for pointing this out. I'd love to hear their explanation of how any given algorithm is "racist".
- stewartmcgown 4y agoThis is just for YouTube shorts, but I notice a huge swathe of right wing content being blasted at me whenever I foolishly stray onto that part of the app. I'll get anything from Tate to Rogan to obscure 'Woke-critical' content straight away. There is a study on the right wing nature of the Shorts algorithm: https://firstmonday.org/ojs/index.php/fm/article/download/10419/9404#p4 https://firstmonday.org/ojs/index.php/fm/article/download/10... Nothing about it suggests other sites do the same thing, but if right wing content is driving more engagement than left wing content through outrage alone it stands to reason that any reinforcement learning would prioritise it.
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoOverall this seems to be a very odd study with - basically no recommendations. It boils down to, you’ll need to judge for yourself and every child is different but the internet, while great, is terrifying and can be traumatic. So I’m not sure what we learned here.
- mwbajor 4y agoI think it can be summed up in the following ways: 1) Parenting takes effort, use that effort to do 2-4 2) Know what they are looking at, prioritize face-to-face interactions. 3) Know the parents of the kids they are hanging out with. 4) Make sure that the parents of friends have the same values as you when it comes to social media.