13 ms·
Students can’t get off their phones. Schools have had enough
- ethbr0 4y agoThere's a phrase for something that people can't stop using -- addictive substance. We (and companies) need to ditch the equivocation and be honest about what we created. (Edit) > Parents have been split on the issue, with many critics insisting their children need phones in case of an emergency. Is a red herring and justification for helicopter parents to normalize their micromanaging. Someone shouldn't be texting or calling on their cell in an active shooter situation anyway. One phone per teacher/room, with the ability for anyone to dial emergency services, is better.
- jtreminio 4y ago> Is a red herring and justification for helicopter parents to normalize their micromanaging. We live in Plano, TX, just a few minutes south of the Allen Outlet massacre. Yesterday my son texted me at noon "Shooting threat at school" and "It’s a rumor though but a lot of people are leaving anyway". You can bet your life I was in my car and speeding down the street to get him out ASAP within 60 seconds of receiving the text. The reality of schools and public life in the USA today means my family not being without a way to contact each other immediately, in real time, is a no-go.
- abraxas 4y agoSo how in heavens did your country manage to survive the 300 years prior to 2008?
- ethbr0 4y agoMuzzle loading firearms? It makes mass shootings a lot harder.
- hypertele-Xii 4y ago285 children have died in US school shootings since 1764. In 2021, 50 million students were enrolled in public schools in prekindergarten to grade 12. That's a 0.00057% chance your kid dies in a school shooting. You are being hysterical.
- jtreminio 4y agoWe WERE at the Allen Outlets on Saturday. We left 5 minutes before the shooting began. If I had purchased one more item from a store we would have been right there. Tell me again how I am being hysterical. This country is going down in flames and not everyone can see the fire.
- hypertele-Xii 4y agoA traumatic experience for sure. One might almost think that after such an experience, you'd overreact at the slightest hint of anything like that ever happening again. You are being hysterical. (I am sorry for sounding dismissive. I pray for the safety of your family.)
- giardini 4y agoYou are hysterical, possibly b/c your interpretation is pessimistic. But most people interpret such an occurrence as a sign they are lucky. I recommend you adopt such an attitude b/c it is healthier and b/c, when your story is retold, people will often want to touch you (so that the "good luck" rubs off on them)!
- WithinReason 4y agoAn even better statistic would be: how many children were saved by a smart phone in a school shooting?
- pupppet 4y ago74 have been hurt or killed in a school shooting in just 2023.
- 4y ago
- heartbreak 4y ago> You can bet your life I was in my car and speeding down the street to get him out ASAP within 60 seconds of receiving the text. There are multiple layers of “bad” with this. If there is a threat, you’re hindering emergency response. Regardless, you’re putting everyone at risk by “speeding down the street.”
- jtreminio 4y agoI know the general consensus is that I did a bad thing with my reaction. I get it. I don't trust law enforcement to do the right thing. I don't trust that grown adults sworn to serve and protect would act quickly to neutralize a threat that's not against themselves or their loved ones. I see Uvalde playing out more than once in the future.
- giardini 4y agojtreminio says:"I don't trust law enforcement to do the right thing. I don't trust that grown adults sworn to serve and protect would act quickly to neutralize a threat that's not against themselves or their loved ones." Your decision, were it properly weighed, would have to also assume that you could do better somehow but that is impossible (even if you were John Wick or Jason Bourne). The hubris you display is enormous! Imagine that the American embassy had dropped an Chinese-American citizen into the middle of the square during the Tiananmen Massacre and demanded that he rescue the man under the tank! Emotions got the better of you - you're in denial. There are a few more steps before you'll admit that retrieving your child was a futile and risky act for you, him and everyone else.
- heartbreak 4y agoHow would you take down an armed assailant yourself? In this hypothetical scenario where you are rushing to the school, are you carrying a firearm as well?
- throw9away6 4y agoThere will be no emergency response. Just a clean up crew. If you get there first you might get in before they Block the entrance and wait for the situation to resolve.
- williamcotton 4y agoHere’s why I downvoted: It actually would have been better if neither your son nor you knew about nearby shooting. It had nothing to do with the school your son was attending. That you responded in a panic is due to a common pattern of miscommunication during an emergency. The least effective response to an emergency is everyone panicking and operating independently of each other and ignorant of the ground truth. How did the rumor of the school shooting begin? Probably from another student responding to some quick take on their socials? What if they didn’t have their phone? Would this even have caused a false panic in the first place? Everyone take the time to look up the road death statistics to remind yourself what you really need to worry about. Always use your turn signal, even for your driveway. Slow down, but not too much… drive with the flow of traffic. Don’t change lanes in an intersection. Don’t swerve out of the way of a white-tailed dear, just try and punt the thing with the front of your car and count the hang time. Yield to the right at a 4-way intersection. Again, always use your turn signal, even for your driveway… why the drive way? Force the good habit! I live in Texas. My wife is a public schoolteacher. We are coming for your son’s phone and we will convince enough people to agree with us.
- williamcotton 4y agoSpeak of the devil... I just checked my messages and saw this from my wife an hour ago: "ACC north ridge has an armed person on campus. Don’t go out" I checked the news just now and found this out: "AUSTIN (KXAN) — A shelter-in-place order was lifted for the Austin Community College Northridge Campus. The campus issued the order at 8:50 a.m. amid reports of a possible armed person nearby. Police investigated the reports and issued an all-clear. The shelter-in-place was lifted at 10:20 a.m., and the campus returned to normal operations." So literally by just spending my time being nerd sniped on the internet and tweaking a Dockerfile I missed the entirety of this nothingness.
- ethbr0 4y agoTo me, this is the "past generations" litmus test I measure any of my personal preferences against. If people were able to handle not-it in 1920, it's probably a "nice to have" rather than a "must have." Which, we can all feel very strongly about things that are nice to have, but people were also doing just fine before constant connectivity was a thing.
- ethbr0 4y agoI'm a parent of two school aged kids, one of whom attends school 10 minutes away. In a state that's had multiple school shootings as well. I still accept that if something happens, it's going to play out before I rambo in and fix things. I have firearms in the house and am trained in their use, but I'm not a professional. In a chaotic, lethal situation, even my presence as a transporter is only going to increase confusion and delay professionals doing their job. What's going to save lives (including my kids') in a crisis is their knowing (1) how to handle themselves, (2) stay present and think critically, and (3) follow good directions when they receive them.
- alistairSH 4y ago(4) preventing crazy people from acquiring firearms in the first place.
- ethbr0 4y agoNever going to happen in the US, because it's antithetical to the current interpretation of the Constitution and because half the country doesn't trust the government to define "crazy" (or uses distrust as an excuse because they actually don't care / NRA). Sadly, I think statistically it would help a lot. Obviously wouldn't completely solve the problem, but you have to have something pretty wrong with you to want to murder a lot of people at your school. And that likely shows up in other behavior. But then, to me, "temporarily take guns away from a small segment of the population who has demonstrated, serious mental health issues" doesn't seem like a slippery slope. So I guess I'm on the "other side" of the issue. :/
- alistairSH 4y agoOf note, the current interpretation of gun rights (the individual right to own) is a relatively new construct largely created by the gun lobby (roughly 1977, when there was an internal rebellion in NRA leadership) and a conservative court (Heller, 2008). https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/how-nra-rewrote-second-amendment https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/how-... And FWIW, I'm in the camp that we can't define "crazy" adequately. So, I'm all for limiting access to all semi-automatic firearms. Regulate them all similarly to automatics and other "NFA" weapons.
- tcgv 4y agoI understand your concern towards the difficult situation and your immediate action to look out for your family. However, your anecdotal experience is still a "false positive" (fortunately), which doesn't allow us to conclude that, in the case of an actual emergency such as a school shooting, children with phones are statistically safer than children without phones. But I'm genuinely interested in such a study, and I believe data is already available for us to compare the differences in these kinds of occurrences before the emergence of smartphones in schools and after. That would provide a north for making decisions that truly improve security for us and our loved ones.
- jtreminio 4y agoI feel like a drama queen, because we (my immediate family) have had two near misses in 3 days. We were at the Allen Outlets and left 5 minutes before the shooting happened. 2 days later there's a school shooting threat at my son's high school. Nothing physical has happened to _us_. I can't stand up and say, "I lost a family member due to gun violence!". I still feel like things are spiraling out of control and there's nothing I can do about it. How do you stop going outside where other people are for fear of a shooting? How do you send your only child to school knowing what's going on? I hope I can cope and hope that everything turns out OK.
- tcgv 4y agoI think the main challenge is that true a solution can only be reached if the society as a whole faces the issue together. Meanwhile families are left on their own to try their (suboptimal) best. I recently saw this youtube piece that shares the Swiss perspective on the topic of Gun ownership, and apart from some intended sarcasm in it that can bother viewers with distinct political views, the content has been worth watching: - https://youtu.be/EkuMLId8SqE https://youtu.be/EkuMLId8SqE
- yamtaddle 4y ago> The reality of schools and public life in the USA today means my family not being without a way to contact each other immediately, in real time, is a no-go. You have badly misread the statistics on this, if you're that worried about it.
- Balero 4y ago> You can bet your life I was in my car and speeding down the street to get him out ASAP within 60 seconds of receiving the text. "Road traffic crashes are a leading cause of death in the United States for people ages 1–54"[0] I wonder if you speeding in your car increased the likely hood of death for someone more than collecting your son from a rumored school shooting. Not saying you were wrong to do that, obviously this is something that comes to the front of your mind when something is wrong at a school. The disconnect between risks we find acceptable, and those we don't is interesting though. [0]https://www.cdc.gov/injury/features/global-road-safety/index.html#:~:text=Road%20traffic%20crashes%20are%20a,citizens%20residing%20or%20traveling%20abroad https://www.cdc.gov/injury/features/global-road-safety/index....
- yamtaddle 4y agoSome enterprising individual should figure up how many highway miles driven with a kid in the car it takes to exceed the annual risk from school shootings. I bet it's not many, but nobody thinks a thing of driving their kids around.
- Brusco_RF 4y agoUSDOT says 1.34 deaths per 100,000,000 miles driven. Assuming 32mph average speed[1] that's 1 death per 2,332,089 hours driven. There were 40 students killed in school shootings in 2022 [2]. Assuming 50M students and 2K hours/year in school that equates to 1 death per 2,500,000,000 hours spent in the classroom. The difference is a factor of 1,072 meaning that if you drive with your kid for 2 hours, you have exposed them to a higher risk of dying in a traffic accident than an entire year of risk from school shootings. Definitely a stat I'll keep in my back pocket. [1] my ass [2] https://www.edweek.org/leadership/school-shootings-this-year-how-many-and-where/2022/01 https://www.edweek.org/leadership/school-shootings-this-year...
- otachack 4y agoI understand your point of being able to react to situations faster. The key word is "react". It's disappointing and shameful that there's an apparent need for kids to have phones because of prevalent school shootings. If you aren't advocating for gun reform yet I hope you and others jump on board soon so that we can squash that fear and move on to mitigating the damage these computers in our pockets are causing to children and teens. There was a time where school shootings weren't a primary concern and it was in my lifetime. It is possible to get back to that. We need to fight for it because it's not fair to the students that are traversing the school system, their families, and the ever climbing numbers of dead or harmed babies, children, teens, young adults, adults, and elderly and all living relatives affected by gun violence.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoYou really don't see how phones made this situation worse for everyone involved? It just seems so obvious to me.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>active shooter situation I feel like active shooters shouldn't be a situation in a school in the first place.
- rtkwe 4y agoSure it shouldn't be but it's the America we have and it's constitutionally difficult to do anything about it with the current interpretation of our second amendment in the Supreme Court.
- vuln 4y ago> constitutionally difficult to do anything about it with the current interpretation of our second amendment in the Supreme Court. Could you explain what’s “difficult” about “SHALL NOT BE INFRINGED?” It appears to be pretty clear cut to me. I’m not sure how anyone can conclude the opposite.
- rtkwe 4y agoDoes the lack of that language in the other amendments mean they're not really protected? There's similar language in the other amendments in the bill of rights, "Congress shall make no laws" in the First Amendment for example, where we have and accept some limitation on those rights. Does the "well regulated militia" clause imply an individual right to bear arms or only that the Federal government can't make laws to disarm recognized militias? Ultimately in the US system it doesn't really matter what you or I think a particular phrase means the only opinion that matters directly is that of the majority of the Supreme Court. Even the current Court's interpretation of 2A accepts there are reasonable restrictions on gun rights they just need to be similar or comparable to restrictions around the founding.
- greedo 4y agoSCOTUS held quite a different view of the 2nd Amendment for many many years until the efforts of the NRA and gunmakers succeeded in altering this in the last 30 years.
- justrealist 4y agoI think it's more to justify refusing to parent. Kids will refuse to give up their phones, make a big fight about it, so some parents would rather invent an excuse to give up and let the kid win.
- reaperman 4y agoI agree that phones/apps/social media/video games are addictive (the ones that aren't just don't get popular) but I disagree with your proposed framework for identifying "addictive" things for children in schools. Schools are very artificial environments with a massive lack of stimulation and self-agency for young developing human children. Damn near anything is "addictive" in that environment - books, doodling, origami, annoying people around you, etc. Would be interesting if phones would be "addictive" to children used to playing outdoors in autonomous groups in (semi-nomadic, not city-based) pre-colombian civilizations.
- spacephysics 4y agoReminds me of a rat study that I forget the details on, but essentially they gave cocaine to rats in a sterile basic cage, and they went ham Then years later, a researcher refuted the claim of the original landmark study (regarding addition), by giving the rats a sanctuary with other rats, area to roam, basically a mini park, I believe the rats either didn’t take the cocaine, or did it once and didn’t like it after. Addition isn’t in a vacuum. Anything can be addicting. It’s the environment that matters as well. Soldiers coming back from Vietnam were doing opium like mad, to a point where the US government was preparing for an opioid epidemic (ironic now), then found that rates of opium addiction were FAR below than perceived, most likely cause the soldiers weren’t fighting in a terrifying jungle 1000’s of miles away in a war forced upon them that was a losing battle.
- hypertele-Xii 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_Park https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_Park It was morphine, and failed to replicate.
- jstarfish 4y ago> Damn near anything is "addictive" in that environment - books, doodling, origami, annoying people around you, etc. False. If any of that were addictive, the student would continue doing it even when other options exist, and continue doing it despite negative consequences. > Schools are very artificial environments with a massive lack of stimulation Correct but misguided. Schools are artificial environments with imposed constraints. You're supposed to derive stimulation from being interested in the nature of the world around you, but that's boring, so at least derive stimulation from entertaining yourself within the constraints. Everyone here has a story about hacking the school computers to play Doom (a learning experience and achievement, however subversive), but 30 years from now, none of these kids are going to be talking about how awesome it was to mindlessly watch TikTok during math class. None of them will remember what they even watched. The phone has endless "stimulating" content, but it's not stimulating you to actually do anything but repetitively scroll through content you'll quickly forget. It's junk food for the brain, and only "stimulating" in the way stool softeners stimulate a bowel movement-- you shit it out long before you absorb anything of nutritional value.
- thefz 4y ago> Parents have been split on the issue, with many critics insisting their children need phones in case of an emergency. Then buy a 30€ dumb phone. 100% of the parents I spoke with justify themselves with "all his/her friends have it, I don't want to create a social pariah".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LanceH 4y agoIt has a real social impact if they don't have a phone. They will miss out on things. You might argue "but if they were real friends..", but the issue is they may never get to be real friends if they keep missing out on things. My kids get phones in 9th grade, but it is clear they aren't to be on them during school. What sets me apart from a lot of parents, though, is that I'll believe and support their teacher.
- hammyhavoc 4y ago> What sets me apart from a lot of parents, though, is that I'll believe and support their teacher. Having been abused at three different schools, I hope that there's more nuance to it than simply "I'll listen to the adult".
- thefz 4y ago> They will miss out on things. Like what?
- LanceH 4y ago"everyone's meeting up at the pizza place to hang out" There are obviously ways around that -- a lot just won't bother. And sure, someone that isn't that courteous might not be worth being around, but if it's a loose social group with a common interest there will be others there that might be. Their social lives revolve around their phones. Not having a phone impacts it greatly.
- saiya-jin 4y agoI think this goes a bit deeper on a forum like this. Like it or not, many many many folks here work for companies enabling this addiction. One thing I've noticed over my 20 years in business - many, often very bright folks need to feel they work a moral job, doing good for the world. So far so good. But then we meet reality of gray office jobs with unclear positive/negative rating, ie working in bank is bad? But which type of bank and which job? Classic retail ones don't do crises, they store money for common folks so they don't keep it under mattress, and give loans to start businesses. Or working for google, is it the great-maps-for-free or tracking-the-hell-out-of-ya one? Same for facebook etc. I am fairly strict on this topic and agree with you - we've created unparalleled addiction devices. Don't trust me, random stranger, check almost any kid with phone, which is almost any kid. Check their habits, ask parents, ask at school. Its pretty consistent and dark picture. There are ways to lesser the problem, but problem at its core is seemingly too hard - maybe kids actually shouldn't have their phones, rationing is already dealing with addicted (=fucked up for life) situation. Fucking up entire generation isn't balanced with saving few lives, even as a parent that's a completely stupid approach from any angle. Maybe we shouldn't listen to only most vocal folks in our communities? The loudest ones often have unresolved mental issues that distort otherwise good discussions badly. But then we go even deeper - growing up kids these days is darn hard. State doesn't help much actually, if you are far away from close family and are not one of those few family-only types who can find life fulfillment for 2 decades straight, without any meaningful break, in just parenting. So folks little by little give up on being a perfect parent, and to have some time off they allow it. And then there is peer pressure. Remember a generation ago kids spent their lives in front of TV? And our parents didn't care that much, did they (little yes, but actually going and finding a new cool hobby for their kid? rare)
- welshwelsh 4y agoStudents don't spend time on their phones because they are "addictive," but because school is boring and doesn't provide them with anything of value. Schools need to radically overhaul how they operate so that they can compete with TikTok for student's attention. Banning phones is lazy. I want to see: - Gamified learning, using apps like Duolingo. TikTok-style short form videos produced by top content creators instead of boring lectures from mediocre teachers. - Opportunities to earn real money, power and status as a reward for school achievement. Good performance should grant perks like the ability to freely skip class to play videogames, study from home or earn an income during the school day. - Autonomy: give students control over how they learn, holding them accountable only for the results.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoIt's a bad habit rather than an addiction since there is no substance.
- scythe 4y agohttps://archive.ph/0oPuO https://archive.ph/0oPuO
- throwaway22032 4y agoThis article is super surprising. You mean phones weren't already banned? I would have expected it to be like taking a Game Boy or a laptop into a lesson, instant confiscation until the end of the day.
- coldpie 4y agoA many-hundreds-of-dollars device that is the core nexus of all of one's social, parental, scholastic, and entertainment lives, which every student has on them at all times every single day, and which every single adult in the country is glued to at all times during the day, is a very different problem from one or two kids fiddling with GameBoys, yes. It's a new problem. It's going to take some time & experimentation to find the right balance.
- hypertele-Xii 4y agoAdjusted for inflation, the Game Boy cost $215 upon launch.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoBut still, it's not a thing that should be used in most classes, and it doesn't belong there. Even back in time when "snake" was the best mobile "app" around (so old nokia times), if a student used a phone in class, the teacher would take it away, and a parent would have to come and pick it up in school.
- coldpie 4y ago> Even back in time when "snake" was the best mobile "app" around (so old nokia times), Yeah, it's not 1998 anymore. Taking away Snake is not the same as taking away a student's entire social network. It's a hard problem, certainly, and we need to find solutions for it. But the situation has changed and the old solutions aren't acceptable anymore.
- yamtaddle 4y ago
- scythe 4y agoSeparate comment, because I don't want to hijack the archive comment: >with many critics insisting their children need phones in case of an emergency. >[...] >But educators and experts say students need to focus on their surroundings during a crisis, not their cellphones. It's pleasing to see the rhetoric shift on this one. Hopefully, in a few years, we'll all regard it as a funny mistake that phones were ever allowed in schools.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoOut here, in some schools they don't even allow phones on multi-day school field trips. The class teacher has a single, dumb, "class phone", all the parents know the number, all the kids can use it at apropriate times to call their parents, so all the "emergency" needs are covered, but the kids are not glued to a phone half the time there.
- RocketOne 4y agoIts overdue. As a principal I used to ban phones in our school. Back before every kid had one. If they were caught playing on them or if it rang during class, the phone went to the teacher's desk til the end of class. If it happened a second time, it came to my office til the end of the day. And a 3rd violation meant it stayed in my office til the end of the week. That last one rarely happened as any child who lost access for a whole day nearly went into panic mode without their pacifier for an entire day.
- coldpie 4y ago[flagged]
- kayodelycaon 4y agoDon't worry. I've seen lot of school administration treat students as things to be controlled, not people.
- smolder 4y agoThey're half-formed people who do often need their behavior controlled in some way. Some students or student bodies may be mature enough to be responsible for themselves, but not all.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoThere's a stark difference between setting boundaries and treating people like objects. I've experienced both. Some schools are really good. The private K-12 religious school I went to treated kids like people and still set boundaries. The local public high school did the same. The public grade school was a horror show. College was particularly interesting. Most of the administration did not care about students as people. Everyone else did.
- LanceH 4y ago> There's a stark difference between setting boundaries and treating people like objects. You need to talk to work with some high schoolers then. There is a large chunk of that population that the school is in their orbit. They casually treat people like objects. They don't just tune out, but actively disrupt anything going on, ruining the days of teachers, staff and students -- for sport.
- Octokiddie 4y agoParents have not idea whatsoever of the destruction that phones have wrought on the education system, both in the large and in the small. Students who claim otherwise are gaslighting their parents. Parents are unfortunately all too willing to believe the lies because of course their child is above average and would never completely tune out of class for another hit on the electronic crack pipe. At this point, the problem has become too entrenched to actually do anything. Parents have come to the mistaken conclusion that Johnny needs a smartphone to keep in touch during the day (why exactly is a great question). Administrators have more or less given up. And without backup from administrators, teachers are left to fend for themselves. The ones who step in to take phones away, or deal with the problem in any meaningful way face threats to their physical well-being. The tethering of kids to parents via phones is a tragedy of biblical proportions, but the effects will not be obvious for a few years yet. Education is just the obvious flash point.
- GalenErso 4y agoI didn't get my first real phone until after high school, while everyone else had one. I graduated salutatorian. I was able to focus on my homework after school for hours without distractions. I had a computer at home, but it was pretty crappy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tymekpavel 4y agoThere are also many students who have phones in high school and graduate valedictorian, so I’m not sure we can draw any conclusions.
- ungamedplayer 4y agoQuality measurements and citation needed.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoSure you're able to complete school work without a phone. You're not able to have a normal social life though and for many parents that is more important than academic success.
- williamcotton 4y agoBut many students — who use their phones for listening to music, arranging rides home, checking on grades or assignments — are unhappy with the crackdowns. Some check in with parents or coaches by text. Some think the decision should be theirs, not a school dictate. Parents have been split on the issue, with many critics insisting their children need phones in case of an emergency. What kind of emergency can’t be handled by calling the school or, as a student, asking for your phone or access to a landline? What kind of private emergency decisions need to be made by 10th graders sitting in English class that require them to respond within seconds?
- alistairSH 4y agoThis is American, so presumably school shootings. We should probably solve the root cause, but the 2A death cult does a fabulous job keeping people convinced that MORE guns is the solution, completely ignoring damn near every statistic shows more guns lead to worse outcomes.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoI don't understand how students having a phone helps in the case of school shootings. The school will call the police and any parents of students injured/killed will also be contacted by the school.
- alistairSH 4y agoIt doesn't (and likely hurts, by clogging cellular infrastructure and roadways). But parents want to know ASAP so they can rush to the school and "help". Probably because police in the US aren't actually required to actively protect people. And have proven incapable of doing the job.
- throw9away6 4y agoIn practice you will show up and wait outside while your kid dies and the police prevent you from helping.
- Mimmy 4y agoWhy do parents need to "check-in" on their kids during school hours? The fact that some parent are calling students in the middle of class is particularly egregious.
- chankstein38 4y agoBecause it's hard to trust that the kids won't be put in a dangerous situation by way of an active shooter. And with some of the incident within the last year it's been clear the school may not notify anyone until hours later.
- ryan93 4y agoParents can be histrionic. Thats good, your kids are important. Doesn't mean the administration cant decide phones are almost entirely a net negative.
- germinalphrase 4y agoFormer teacher. There is no reason. Parents can always get in touch with students via the office if there's a legitimate need. That never stopped parents from calling and texting their kids during class time of course.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoThe issue is more of what happens after and before school if you aren’t helicoptering them between school in an SUV. In my district, kids take city buses to middle and high school, which I think is fine, but a phone is useful in that case.
- throwaway50603 4y agoAs a student (over a decade ago) I had hundreds - maybe even thousands over the 13 years of education, actually - of phone calls with my parents, siblings, grandparents, uncle, friends etc about various stuff I was doing after school, during school (and sometimes instead of school). I'm sure the school office would've loved to handle all the calls for us, lol.
- ilikecakeandpie 4y ago> many critics insisting their children need phones in case of an emergency The school could always call the parent, or the parent could always call the school, right? Does the minute it might take the kid to answer the phone at the teacher's desk or walk to the office make that much of a difference? The only way I see this being something that's truly time critical is if they're using "emergency" as a euphemism for school shooting.
- phyllistine 4y ago> The only way I see this being something that's truly time critical is if they're using "emergency" as a euphemism for school shooting. Parents are regularly getting notified about school shootings several minutes before the police. I absolutely do not want a school taking my kid's phone in this increasingly common case.
- ilikecakeandpie 4y agoI get that, and maybe I'm being incredibly naive, but can't the schools utilize existing pipelines to inform the parents immediately? When we had a snow day, they'd call with an automated message and let us all know. Isn't there something in place to do the same for emergency situations? If not, wouldn't that be something relatively simple to build?
- mkr-hn 4y agoThe existing pipeline is increasingly an app. (anecdotally from friends with kids in school)
- cududa 4y agoI hope your kid is never in a shooting, but what would you knowing 3 minutes before cops about a school shooting accomplish?
- tomjen3 4y agoThats easy: get out before the cops gets even more killed like Uvalde.
- BananaaRepublik 4y agoAccess to phones and social media is a global phenomena. Is the supposed academic issues equally global too?
- yamtaddle 4y agoParents in other countries may back teachers and admin in banning or heavily restricting phone use in schools, at higher rates than they do in the US.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoDo they though? It seems easy enough to get data on this rather than speculating
- snvzz 4y agoAnd, if not, what are the measures they have in place?
- karaterobot 4y agoWhen phone addiction gets brought up, someone usually says that phones just serve the same function newspapers used to. I don't remember being in high school and everyone in class was reading the newspaper instead of paying attention to the teacher. Or that they would carry a spare newspaper in case one of their newspapers was confiscated.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoNice strawman.
- hypertele-Xii 4y agoI definitely smuggled comics into class to hide inside school books though. Specifically sat in the back whenever possible so no-one could see what I was actually reading.
- exabrial 4y agoA relative of mine, Substitute-teacher (usually inner city), brings a "mesh pocket shoe hanger" to each classroom. During roll call, each kid must show the phone is off, and she hand writes (in cursive) the child's name on a piece of masking tape across the screen and back, while noting which kids phone was put in which pocket. The kids are allowed to have their phone back at the dismissal bell, and not a second earlier. She allows the kids to send a text to their parents letting them know their phone will be off for the day, and if an email list is provided, also informs parents that any emergencies should be directed at her phone or the school office. Obviously this creates quite a reputation with kids and school administrators... but what is a surprising is the occasional protest from parents wanting to talk to their kids all day. Her stance is "take it or leave it, I'm not changing", and she doesn't always get invited back by certain schools.
- pseudolus 4y agoOn a related note the American Psychological Association (APA) just released a "Health advisory on social media use in adolescence". [0] [0] https://www.apa.org/topics/social-media-internet/health-advisory-adolescent-social-media-use https://www.apa.org/topics/social-media-internet/health-advi...
- stainablesteel 4y agothey don't have the option to do anything better, they should be outside socializing and/or exercising for at least half their day if that's what they want to do. but NO, class and indoctrination is more important. sitting in a classroom was like sitting in a jail cell in my experience public school was trash, the people who went there were trash i'd much rather start a private community of people who actually give a shit about their children, fuck associating with all the violent randoms you get in public schools youtube > teachers starting a business in high school > college diploma if your kid is capable of learning and inventing on their own, or in a group of ~equal peers, then you're only destroying your kids potential if they're in the public school system i'd rather my kid use their phone than listen to one of the "education professionals" who use anti-empirical means while experimenting on other peoples kids
- haunter 4y agoWhat's the situation in China, Japan, Korea, India, Nigeria, Brazil? Phones and social media are global and I think there are school children there too.
- Macha 4y agoMy understanding is that Japan is pretty similar with differing policies per school, and from what I've learned of Indian education from coworkers, there's so much difference from one school to the other (or possibly region to region) that I doubt you could come up with an "India does XYZ" generalisation either.
- andersa 4y agoStrange. Phones were banned when I was in school. As in, obviously you'd have a phone, you just wouldn't have it out and be messing with it during classes. Almost all the students were reasonably following this. We also used to have a rule where if your phone made noise during class you'd have to bring the whole class a cake the next day. That was pretty fun.
- jb200 4y agoFormer US public HS Math teacher here. The summer before I started teaching I obtained a cell phone signal jammer (from the EU, where they're legally available) and quietly kept it in my desk. I didn't have to confiscate a single phone over the three years before I walked away from the job. Lots of internal chuckles from me brought on by complaints about the signal quality in my room. Granted, this only worked because we had no student accessible WiFi. I did worry about students being unable to reach out during an emergency, but cell phones were supposed to be left in their lockers during the day anyways and there was a landline in the classroom. I wonder if any schools are thinking about legal jammers or even building new classrooms that are effectively large Faraday cages?
- yamtaddle 4y ago> I wonder if any schools are thinking about legal jammers or even building new classrooms that are effectively large Faraday cages? Some US districts used to jam, but the FCC doesn't like it. Something about blocking devices capable of calling 911 is the main trouble, I think.
- throwaway50603 4y agoThe device might be legally obtainable but using it in a way that affects the public (which includes the students) is a serious crime anywhere in EU. I'd guess it's the same in the US.
- oska 4y agoI'm prompted to remind you of this part of the site's guidelines : > Throwaway accounts are ok for sensitive information, but please don't create accounts routinely. HN is a community—users should have an identity that others can relate to. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html What's prompted me to remind you is that I've observed this 'throwaway' account commenting quite combatively throughout this thread, which makes me think you've created the account to 'give you the freedom' do just that. Which is against the culture here.
- deleted 4y ago
- automatoney 4y agoI have a feeling that bans are not the most effective approach long term. Maybe there's a solution where we educate young people on responsible phone use and work with them to design practices that work for everyone. After all, outside of high school people have to actually self regulate their phone use. Whether they do so effectively varies, but maybe it's a skill we need to think about teaching and developing. Just a direction I've been thinking in, I don't have any concrete recommendations. Of course schools are already way overburdened, but maybe a solution here has large enough positive externalities to be worth it.
- yamtaddle 4y agoAt the very least, we're trapping a bunch of kids with a bunch of other kids and some of the hormonal monsters with underdeveloped impulse control will do horrible things with cell phone cameras. Can you imagine what they might do? Got some ideas? Every single one of those things is happening all the time in schools with weak policies on cell phones. We owe the many, many victims a phone ban in schools.
- flat-pluto 4y agoI'm in favour of keeping phones away from students during school hours - Yondr pouches or storing them in a locker makes sense. It's very unlikely that there will be an emergency that warrants the immediate attention of a school student as it is. Plus, in my high school parents could call in to the school landline to speak to their kids if need be. Teachers have a difficult job as it is, not to mention that they are already mistreated - they have almost no authority over students since they never have backing from parents or school administrators. I recently came across a post on Reddit[1] where a student pepper sprayed her teacher because he confiscated her phone during an exam. One of the commenters claimed that the same teacher was previously punched in the face by a different student for taking their phone away after catching them cheating on a test. It is disconcerting to say the least. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/facepalm/comments/1397n4l/teacher_takes_students_phone_away_and_she_pepper/ https://www.reddit.com/r/facepalm/comments/1397n4l/teacher_t...
- throwaway50603 4y agoA phone contains private photos, conversations, has authorized access to email, chat and social media accounts, it's a second authentication factor, it has payment cards, saved passwords, browser history, potentially health data (for example, period tracker and medication notification app) and other data that they might not want anybody else to access, or could even cause them problems if the wrong person saw some of (which doesn't mean it'd be something illegal or inappropriate - but some teachers have really weird ideas about how the life of a student should look). Touching it without permission is unacceptable. Ask the student to put it away, pull them out of the class if they don't - but don't touch the phone.
- r00fus 4y agoHonestly the sovereign student BS needs to stop. If it's disrupting the class the student needs to answer for that. The student isn't being asked to open the phone, just to put it away. If I were a teacher I'd ask the student to power the phone down and put it on my desk face up. Of course, teachers have to do tons that have nothing to do with pure instruction - they're essentially running an org of 20-30+ kids all day.
- Tozen 4y agoIt's about time to start calling it an addiction. I've seen people that can't walk down a street and look where they are going, because their head is glued to the smartphone. Some people can't even focus on a conversation, because they are constantly checking on their smartphone every other second. Smartphones are great, but as the old saying goes, "moderation is best in all things". Kids/students do have to learn control, discipline, and focus. Otherwise it is very likely to have a negative outcome.
- NickC25 4y agoI think it's just a result of society insisting that their entire lives revolve around a phone due to convenience. Kids these days (I feel old saying that at age 33!) now are raised by parents who were around for the first wave of everyone having a phone, except those parents' phones up until college or later were dumb phones that could call, text, and take pictures (and play snake!). Thus, their well-intentioned move to give their kids a phone is self-defeating and will only hurt in the long run. I went to a public school and don't really remember at any level of classes where my classmates were outright addicted to their phones - some would occasionally text or take pictures or whatever, but perhaps that was due to the limitations of what the device could do. I do understand that modern problems need to be addressed with modern solutions, and smartphones, in a vacuum, aren't a bad thing - they open up a lot of avenues of education that were simply not possible when I was growing up....and I'm all for that, I think its better to prepare kids for the world of tomorrow rather than the world of yesterday. However, there needs to be a limit to how intertwined technology becomes with modern educational practices. I dread the US becoming like China, where people's lives revolve around a smartphone from a very early age. Sadly, we might have missed that boat already.
- ecshafer 4y agoSchools need to ban phones entirely, and probably parents should be strongly encouraged to not give them phones. Realistically it should be banned before 18 except basic calling. >But many students — who use their phones for listening to music, arranging rides home, checking on grades or assignments — are unhappy with the crackdowns. Some check in with parents or coaches by text. Some think the decision should be theirs, not a school dictate. This line is absurd. Why do you need to check in with parents or coaches during the day? You are at school, that is obvious. If parents need to get in touch, call the office and they can get the student. Or the reverse. It worked perfectly fine for the 100 years that phones existed before cell phones.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoJust because students don’t need something doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be allowed. That’s quite a weak argument.
- ecshafer 4y agogiving children a source of constant distraction, full of apps made by billion dollar corps whose sole goal is taking their attention and money, while in an educational environment, is not a good idea period.
- dang 4y agoRelated ongoing thread: Health advisory on social media use in adolescence - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35874670 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35874670 - May 2023 (45 comments)
- asdajksah2123 4y ago> “We’re not trying to infringe on anybody’s freedom, but we need to have full attention in the classroom,” said Nancy J. Hines, superintendent in the Penn Hills School District, in the suburbs of Pittsburgh. It's disappointing that a school superintendent needs to make this statement. School is entirely about infringing about students' "freedoms". No child would be sitting through any class if their freedoms were not highly infringed upon. Learning (at least initially, and for most kids), is not fun. It's boring. And kids don't like boring. What's disappointing is that parents today also don't seem to understand this basic fact, hence the need for statements like these.
- Laaas 4y ago> It's boring. And kids don't like boring. While true, I don't think this _has_ to be the case. Learning can be fun, so can school. But it's probably harder to make _more_ fun than TikTok...
- romwell 4y agoIt's not harder as much as it is more expensive. But looks like paying teachers enough so that they could afford such luxuries as checks note renting an apartment for themselves is off the table.
- sourcecodeplz 4y agoNo, learning is not at all boring. Even for primary grades. Sure maybe some kids prefer other subjects over others. Can't deal in absolutes like that, come on..
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- grapesurgeon 4y agoif i ever become a parent, i wouldnt give my kids a phone until highschool, and even then i would be heavily restricting their ability to use it for anything besides basic communication and browsing - block social media and porn via dns, disallow installing apps without my permission. signal, email, calls, maps, a browser, notes and camera+pictures. thats it. no stupid social media apps, no games, music would be a maybe if they could demonstrate responsibility to stop listening to it when its time to do a task. fuck phones.
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoI’m fascinated by the new generation. Some of them seem like creatures rather than humans. They just screech and twitch and swipe around their phone. A lot of them don’t even have any form of language. I have no idea what’s going to happen when they start reaching their teens and above. How are they going to have a job or sit an exam?
- egberts1 4y agoPhone rack on teacher's desk arranged by seating chart.
- Ccecil 4y agoA local tech school I work with the teacher does attendance by the phones. They are to be put in a cabinet in a small bin. If they are not there...the kids do not get listed as being in class. Yes...There are a couple kids with no phone...but sadly only a couple. I personally think this is the way to handle this. In this class's case it is a machining/manufacturing program it is especially important to have the kids paying attention due to safety issues. They are quite literally running machines that can kill people. When I was young we were told to not bring anything that was a potential distraction from learning...for me or others. If we did, it was taken away. This also applied to hair and dress code...not that I am against free expression or anything like that...but the point was that anything that took away from the educational process (again...of you or others) was not allowed. I remember kids being sent home for wearing inappropriate Tshirts or haircuts (dyed mohawk). This was not the 50s...this was the 80s-90s. Not sure what changed...but in my case it is time as a parent to make an effort. There is no reason for my kids to have phones at school...They don't answer when I need them to anyways.
- albert_e 4y agoI have a junk drawer with easily 12-15 old unused phones that I just ignore. I am sure today's kids can easily get their hands on a junk throwaway phone to use as an "attendance" marker if that is really the rule (while still keeping their actual functional phone with themselves).