7 ms·
Texas moves to create gold-backed digital currency
- bediger4000 4y agoWhat's the motive behind wanting deflationary currency? Just a few minutes' reflection should convince you that's a very bad idea for any free market, capitalist economy.
- Finnucane 4y agoGoldbugs like deflation. Goldbugs like gold. Practical economic usefulness is not a consideration.
- quantified 4y agoThis is Texas. Why gold and not barrels of oil?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Why gold and not barrels of oil? Oil is perishable.
- bediger4000 4y agoSo just a strong belief in some superstitions? Seems really odd.
- JohnFen 4y agoTexas is a pretty odd place.
- hakfoo 4y agoI suspect there are three flavours of gold bugs: 1) Wealthy + Paranoid + Stupid. They'd rather keep their money in sovereigns under their mattress, than put it into any sort of productive economic activity. On a long term, especially in the US, you could pretty much throw darts and build a portfolio that competes with, or beats, inflation. 2) Conspirational: "fiat currency is a grand scheme to undermine our savings for (insert nefarious bugaboo of the day)" 3) Arguably a subset of 2) but Apocalypse Enthusiast. "When civilization crumbles, the obvious trade unit won't be something like grain, alcohol, or bullets, but my bags full of low-grade silver dimes! I'll be King of the Wasteland!"
- brnaftr361 4y agoCouldn't we bifurcate it, though? I mean, I'm fucked. I've effectively lost between 10-20% of my purchasing power out of what ultimately equates to a relatively small sum in the first place because my time horizon was pretty small, I put a trust fund together for myself. Whole I was doing this bond yields were negative, and had been for a long while, and I'd posit they still are (last I looked the $1 pound loaves at Walmart were $1.50). I just did not and do not have the buffer money for investing, not to mention a need for liquidity and possible penalties. It would be nice to have something more stable. Of course, Au and Ag haven't yet reared their imaginary powers yet in any case, though many portend they will. Ideally though, an ounce of gold is an ounce. But a dollar can be anything. The question is one of making gold, silver, or some other fixed-quantity, portable, arbitrarily valuable substance into legal tender, right?
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoGold coins are beautiful liquid assets. Why not keep part of your retirement or emergency fund in gold and silver? I can just go down to one of many local coin stores and sell them if I need the cash.
- bheadmaster 4y ago> fiat currency is a grand scheme to undermine our savings How exactly is it not? Inflation = stealing value from people, that they have already created, time-limiting their spending power so that there's no way to actually save money in the long-term. Money printing is theft, indirect taxation without consent.
- qwytw 4y ago> no way to actually save money in the long-term The idea is that you'd save by investing into productive enterprises (and or government bonds) obviously that doesn't necessarily function as well as one would hope for but it's an better solution than hoarding cash/gold/bitcoin/etc.
- throw0101b 4y ago> so that there's no way to actually save money in the long-term. Besides equities? Besides TIPS? * https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/tips.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/tips.asp Do you literally keep bills under your mattress or buried in your backyard? There's your problem.
- lamp987 4y agowhats practical about your wealth being stolen from you?
- throw0101b 4y ago> whats practical about your wealth being stolen from you? It forces you to invest it productive assets. What social value is there in locking away wealth in non-productive forms? Buffett in 2011: > Today the world’s gold stock is about 170,000 metric tons. If all of this gold were melded together, it would form a cube of about 68 feet per side. (Picture it fitting comfortably within a baseball infield.) At $1,750 per ounce – gold’s price as I write this – its value would be $9.6 trillion. Call this cube pile A. > Let’s now create a pile B costing an equal amount. For that, we could buy all U.S. cropland (400 million acres with output of about $200 billion annually), plus 16 Exxon Mobils (the world’s most profitable company, one earning more than $40 billion annually). After these purchases, we would have about $1 trillion left over for walking-around money (no sense feeling strapped after this buying binge). Can you imagine an investor with $9.6 trillion selecting pile A over pile B? > Beyond the staggering valuation given the existing stock of gold, current prices make today’s annual production of gold command about $160 billion. Buyers – whether jewelry and industrial users, frightened individuals, or speculators – must continually absorb this additional supply to merely maintain an equilibrium at present prices. > A century from now the 400 million acres of farmland will have produced staggering amounts of corn, wheat, cotton, and other crops – and will continue to produce that valuable bounty, whatever the currency may be. Exxon Mobil will probably have delivered trillions of dollars in dividends to its owners and will also hold assets worth many more trillions (and, remember, you get 16 Exxons). The 170,000 tons of gold will be unchanged in size and still incapable of producing anything. You can fondle the cube, but it will not respond. * https://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/2011ltr.pdf https://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/2011ltr.pdf What social good does encouraging hoarding attain?
- api 4y agoThat's one of the crazier political rabbit holes to go down. There are reasonable and/or reasonable-sounding arguments for pretty much every position and those arguments have been rehashed in every imaginable way for decades and decades. Online there's probably tens of gigabytes of debate between "hard money" advocates and "fiat" or inflationary currency advocates. After seeing endless debates between various schools of economics for decades, in the end I've come to the conclusion that nobody really knows what they're talking about. A big problem is that history is an experiment with no replications, no controls, and no good way to tie complex causes to complex effects. "What would the past 100 years have looked like had we kept the dollar pegged to gold?" We don't know and we'll never know. All you can do is tell just-so stories. Did having an inflationary currency help us achieve the remarkable growth of the past hundred years? We can't know that either. For all we know all that growth was due to demographics and technology and would have happened regardless of the monetary system. I wonder if maybe it doesn't matter that much, and so in that sense both sides are wrong. Maybe the real basis of the economy is the real economy (people, capital, resources, technology) and what you use to price it is secondary. So as long as your monetary system avoids extreme failure modes like hyperinflation or extreme deflationary collapse, the system will just adapt to whatever monetary base it's given and price signals will do their job.
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoAll money is fiat money, in the sense that value is based entirely on social negotiation and agreement, not inherent use value. Anyone who doesn't understand this should try eating gold. Or an ETF. Or a dollar bill. Of course gold does have some use value, but so do plenty of other metals. The only special thing about it is that it has a history of being valuable - already a social agreement - and it gives a very clear agreed social signal when used in jewellery.
- qwytw 4y ago> We don't know and we'll never know. All you can do is tell just-so stories You can compare the permanent boom and bust cycle the global economy was in prior to the Great Depression to the relatively stable inflationary environment of the last several decades. Just look at: https://www.officialdata.org/us/inflation/1800?amount=1#:~:text=Value%20of%20%241%20from%201800,cumulative%20price%20increase%20of%202%2C295.52%25 https://www.officialdata.org/us/inflation/1800?amount=1#:~:t.... Specie based money (with not meaningful monetary policy) is not stable, in fact it's less stable than Fiat money it's just that periods of high inflation are followed by periods of very high deflation. And unpredictability is clearly an obvious downside... (to be fair I almost thoroughly disagree with your reasoning).
- qgin 4y agoPeople want to get rich even if that means killing every incentive for productive use of capital in the process.
- Geee 4y agoGold is not deflationary from monetary perspective. More gold is mined constantly. Due to its high stock-to-flow ratio, the monetary inflation is very low. From the perspective of CPI (consumer price index), gold would be "deflationary", because prices would get cheaper. However, this is not a property of gold; it's the property of a capitalist economy, where companies compete to offer better products at cheaper prices. There's no good reason for diluting the currency to keep prices increasing, other than corruption and greed of those who control the money supply. Inflationary currency means that someone is profiting by creating money, and that profit is paid in the increasing price of products.
- zpeti 4y agoI don’t understand the entire first principles these anti deflationists stand on. Like every single electronics product in the last 50 years has been deflating in price (either literally or increasing in core value). Does that stop people buying them? No! But perhaps someone here who’s anti deflationist could explain to me why I’m wrong.
- jfengel 4y agoDeflation mostly matters with currency. Deflation of products is a good thing. The problem with deflating currency is that it encourages you to sit on it. Economists don't want you sitting on a hoard like a dragon. In the extreme case, GDP goes to zero today because everybody is expecting prices to be cheaper tomorrow. Then all the workers get fired because there's nothing to produce. Now they have no money, and buy nothing, so it gets even worse. Obviously the extreme case doesn't happen, but the thought experiment illustrates the problem. A tiny bit of inflation encourages purchasing and investment, which keeps money moving. You may want to stop working as an individual once you've acquired enough money, but the nation as a whole never retires, and relies on consumption to give everybody work. Prices of goods coming down is OK, because goods are consumed. You have to buy new goods tomorrow. Durable goods wear out; real estate is maintained; intellectual goods get boring. The economy rolls along, and people continue to make investments to get a bigger share of it for themselves. So economists aim for low but steady inflation. It benefits the economy as a whole, at a cost to those who want to accumulate cash and not spend or invest it. tl,dr: Sitting on cash removes it from the economy, and deflation encourages people to spend money tomorrow rather than today.
- ur-whale 4y ago> Just a few minutes' reflection I believe the person who has to spend - likely more than - a few minutes reflection isn't who you think. IOW, burden of proof is on you.
- walterbell 4y agohttps://schiffgold.com/key-gold-news/texas-committee-passes-bill-to-create-100-reserve-gold-and-silver-backed-transactional-currencies/ https://schiffgold.com/key-gold-news/texas-committee-passes-... > On May 2, a Texas House committee passed a bill to create 100% reserve gold and silver-backed transactional currencies ... HB4903 will now move to the Calendars Committee. This committee determines which bills move to the House floor for a vote.
- nobody9999 4y agoIANAL, but doesn't Article I, Section 10 of the US Constitution[0] bar Texas from creating such a currency? [0] https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/artI-S10-C1-2/ALDE_00001098/ https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/artI-S10-C1-2...
- walterbell 4y ago> No State shall .. make any Thing but gold and silver Coin a Tender in Payment of Debts the legislators are looking to require the state comptroller to establish a digital currency that is fully backed by gold and fully redeemable in cash or gold. The U.S. UCC (Uniform Commercial Code) was modified in July 2022 to recognize CERs (controllable electronic records), a flexible definition that may encompass current and future digital currencies. It's now up to individual U.S. states to ratify the proposed UCC changes in state legislation, https://www.clearygottlieb.com//news-and-insights/publication-listing/ucc-digital-asset-amendments-finalized https://www.clearygottlieb.com//news-and-insights/publicatio... > Control under Article 12 is designed to be a technology-neutral functional equivalent of “possession.” It generally encompasses circumstances when a party has the “private key” or other mechanism to avail itself of substantially all of the benefits of the record, prevent others from availing themselves of such benefits, and transfer the record and associated benefits.
- HillRat 4y agoThe use of the term "currency" in the bills is probably ill-advised for just that reason, but states can, under certain circumstances, issue bank notes that act essentially as currency or bills of credit; Briscoe v. Bank of Commonwealth of Kentucky, 36 U.S. 257 (1837) found such bank notes constitutional so long as they aren't issued under color state sovereignty -- that is, they must trade on "no pledge of the faith of the state, in any form." (The federal government eventually killed off state bank notes, not by attempting to outlaw them directly -- AFAIK! -- but by taxing them aggressively, though I don't believe those laws are on the books any more.) Having said that, the fact that these bills direct the state to establish the program, fixes in law the redemption of the "currency," and directs the state to hold gold reserves for the currency all suggest that this is Constitutionally questionable, because the bill is trading on "the faith of the state." Consider that, if Texas establishes a gold-backed stablecoin then executes a rug-pull, your legal options as an aggrieved party are limited due to state sovereignty, which is precisely the issue that the Constitution seeks to prevent (though at the time the question of sovereign immunity was somewhat less settled in the absence of the Eleventh Amendment).
- lotophage 4y agoThe state run Perth Mint in Australia created a gold backed crypto 2019 and they are already trying to shut it down.
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agohttps://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-03-21/trivio-dumps-perth-mint-cryptocurrency-questions-for-goldpass/102120160 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-03-21/trivio-dumps-perth-mi...
- roenxi 4y agoPoliticians: "Capitalism is unstable and we need regulators to control it and promote stability." Capitalists: "We want to make something more stable than the current system." Regulators: "Whoa there! Hold those horses! That ain't a move in the playbook! What will these madmen think of next, a full reserve bank? Shut that scheme down now!" The 3 act play making sure the system is safe unprincipled men since ... I dunno, maybe forever. I doubt this Texan scheme will have a long life either.
- everybodyknows 4y ago> When someone holding the digital currency wants to redeem it for cash, all they would need to do is present it to the comptroller or a designated agent, who will then sell gold held in the depository account equal to the redemption amount and transfer the funds to the redeemer, minus any fees. > The value of each unit of the digital currency will be determined at the time of a transaction and “must be equal to the value of the appropriate fraction of a troy ounce of gold at the time of that transaction.” If this were actually put into effect, expect intense interest from current long-term owners of gold ETFs e.g. GLD. GLD steadily declines relative to spot bullion, as a means of charging to holders expenses of storage, security and management. The Texas proposal would apparently cover such costs entirely with fees on exchange transactions, making long-term holders something like free riders on the system.
- soulofmischief 4y agoThere are existing coins like PAX Gold worth looking at as well.
- ilaksh 4y agoI hope they use an existing, leading-edge project. There are some very advanced and capable cryptocurrencies. Or Ethereum which is catching up and would be amazing. It seems like the US would just try to block something like this on principle though. Having your own currency puts you in competition with other countries, doesn't it? And that's not part of the concept of a (US) state. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_secession_movements https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_secession_movements
- KRAKRISMOTT 4y agoIf the fiat conversion endpoints are subject to the same regulatory KYC and AML regime then it is no different from the US dollar
- kangaroozach 4y agoStill different because it wouldn’t be fiat. There is no ability to print more gold.
- KRAKRISMOTT 4y agoThe Bretton Woods are calling and want their policies back.
- johngladtj 4y agoThey control the redemption process, hence can devalue it any time they want
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dotcoma 4y agoIs Texas getting ready to secede from the union, or what ?
- bovermyer 4y agoWhile it wouldn't surprise me if Texas decided to secede, I doubt the creation of a cryptocurrency is a preparatory step for that. This just feels like cryptobros convincing legislators to back their latest pet project.
- _8j50 4y agoI mean the popular support isn't there but they'd in reality only need the support of the texas national guard. A traitor president also helps. And you also have a ton of people who go "who cares, let them leave" like they're breaking up with a romantic partner lol, absolutley no sense of patriotism. I mean, I don't care if it is texas, missisipi or claifornia, I am an american and all of it is mine. Whether it is a buch of small skirmishes or a full on civil war again, sececession can only be accomplished by a lot of blood spilled. I can't stand guns and I don't even care enough about politics to vote but if any state tries to secede, I would join whatever military opposing them or just buy a gun and find a secessionist armed soldier to kill and hope that I have a death as honorable as fighting to defend your homeland, sure bests rotting in a bed or in a hospital. Even if I can't get others to join me I can contribute just my tiny drop of blood to the price that needs to be paid to separate a land from its people. Now, there is exactly one scenario where I'd have no opposition to them seceding: if the constitution is changed to get rid of the electoral college, senatorial representation or if religious rights are infringed upon (even by a SCOTUS decision), and I don't mean protections for miniorities who disagree with a religion but anything that prevents people from sincerely believing (not satanists whose belief according to themselves is fake! For example) in a creator and acting on that belief (including voting). Because before you are a citizen you are a human and before you have legal rights you have natural rights that supersede legal rights(see: declararion of independence) which were the foundation and reasoning used to justify America's secession from Britain. For Texas secessionists though, all they can acheive is destabilization of the US and as a result the whole world. Russia and China's wet dream but my take on it is that secession is as realistic as a neo-nazi white nationalist state.
- yardie 4y agoIn 2006/2007 I was paid for a project in e-gold[0]. Another currency backed by gold bullion. I never saw the gold, never touched it, but was assured it was there, really. The whole thing went tits up because it was a scam. Being in Texas and not Panama I guess this is slightly less scammy. But I suspect the people who want to hold gold will simply buy gold. And skip the questionably middleman. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-gold https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-gold
- silverpepsi 4y agoThe problem is fraction reserves, as soon as that fraud is legalized, the entire marketplace is by definition fraudulent. If they did have reserves and fraction reserve was suddenly legalized, you get retroactively robbed in a sense. Holding gold would appeal to me but is impossible. I won't dedicate my life, hell or high water, to one country. You can't just up and carry stuff across nation borders. It is a total nightmare. In fact, every time I enter Thailand (and who knows how many other countries) I break the law. The limit for undeclared personal affects is exceeded by a single tshirt or pair of jeans in my luggage, since, well I wear all designer. Strikes me as beyond absurd how the world works ever since the idiocy of passports, permission, and visas was introduced:( One of the worst inventions in history imo. I think Ukraine should remind us all not to trust everything to one country. All your eggs in one basket
- zpeti 4y ago> One of the worst inventions in history imo. As opposed to what? Roaming tribes of mongols, and castles where you couldnt leave if the king didn’t let you? What did you think happened if you left your tribe in hunter gatherer tribes? You got eaten by a jaguar on the next tree, or you starved. What romantic notion do you hold of the world before visas and passports?
- silverpepsi 4y agoFair enough. To be specific, as opposed to immediately before passports were invented I imagine it was similar to what it was like: 1. Before police patrolled in America 2. Before driver's licenses (you can still experience this in Cambodia, low CC scooters don't require a license) 3. Before tattoo artists needed a medical license in Japan and Korea Ya know, liberty and basic rights that have now been abrogated to such a degree that the herd not only doesn't remember what they were like, but actually questions the validity of even being that "free". (Populations like China tend to think a central authority not controlling speech is absurd too.)
- rdxm 4y ago[dead]
- torgian 4y agolol what? Seriously? Where is all that gold gonna come from? How are they going to back it? When 1 TexanGoldUnit eventualy devalues to 1000 TGU, does that mean my gold becomes dust too?
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoReading through it sounds like the comptroller may not be buying physical gold to be delivered and stored at the texas facility. But buying paper representing gold stored somewhere else. I see a future filled with financial shenanigans where more and more complex layers of papers/futures/derivatives/etc become allowed to 'represent' gold, all ripe for exploitation and fraud (just like the the existing crypto, real estate, stock market, and fiat systems!). The more things change, the more they stay the same.
- viro 4y agoThe constitution is pretty clear on this.
- everybodyknows 4y agoThe state of Texas has run a "depository" for precious metals since 2018. In practice, it operates as a sort of specialized safe deposit vault, with holdings of each account kept segregated: https://www.texasbulliondepository.gov/faqs https://www.texasbulliondepository.gov/faqs Fees are 0.5% of value per year: https://www.texasbulliondepository.gov/pricing https://www.texasbulliondepository.gov/pricing Apparently there is no per-transaction charge, unlike the proposed digital instrument.