7 ms·
Passkeys will be importable, exportable, cross-device, and across managers
- latexr 4y agoRicky Mondello works at apple on authentication and password management.
- theknocker 4y ago[dead]
- msravi 4y agoTOTP is already importable, exportable, cross-device, and works across managers.
- ukuina 4y agoTOTP is exportable? Google Authenticator and Microsoft Authenticator do not allow TOTP secret key export.
- msravi 4y agoJust use Aegis on mobile - it allows import/export. And add the TOTPs to a gpg encrypted pass vault on desktop/laptop.
- okramcivokram 4y agoThat's just how those vendors implemented it. There's nothing stopping you from using the TOTP apps that support the import/export functionality, as it's just strings, no secret sauce.
- boring_twenties 4y agoWhy would you even look in the direction of either one of those apps when a superior and fully free version exists? https://f-droid.org/packages/com.beemdevelopment.aegis/ https://f-droid.org/packages/com.beemdevelopment.aegis/
- stavros 4y agoAegis is fantastic.
- tzs 4y agoGoogle Authenticator added exporting a while ago, although it is annoying on some platforms except for the case where you are exporting to another device running Google Authenticator. That’s because it exports via QR codes containing information for a batch of accounts. On Apple devices you can screenshot that QR code, but I’m told that on Android it disables screenshots so you need another device to save a copy (or you use a photocopier to make a paper copy). Once you have the QR code, use a QR code reader to extract the data. There is open source software that can turn the batch data from the QR code into individual account data and individual QR codes so you can use them with other TOTP software.
- paranoidrobot 4y agoTOTP is also MITMable.
- wilg 4y agoTrue (ish). But doesn’t solve the same problem as passkeys so this isn’t very relevant.
- EtienneK 4y agoThey are also phishable and man-in-the-middleable. So not a passkey replacement.
- EtienneK 4y agoNot entirely sure why this is getting downvoted. Passkey is the only non-phishable authentication mechanism that works out-of-the-box on billions of devices. That is huge value from a security perspective.
- knaik94 4y agoI think this addresses most of my concerns regarding passkeys. The biggest remaining one is still that fingerprint locked information is not protected under the fifth amendment in the US. Even pin protected information/logins has been ruled as both protected and not protected by different courts. The "key vs combination" debate hasn't been decided one way or another. I can imagine a government push to not count fingerprint locked passkeys as equivalent to passwords, but that's not a weakness of passkey technology. I am also interested in seeing how phone secured passkeys will work, iOS currently forces the use of keychain, excluding users who opt for a third party password manager like bitwarden. I also wonder if phones will be able to be used to login without enabling bluetooth. https://www.concordlawschool.edu/blog/constitutional-law/fifth-amendment-biometrics/ https://www.concordlawschool.edu/blog/constitutional-law/fif...
- dwaite 4y ago> The biggest remaining one is still that fingerprint locked information is not protected under the fifth amendment in the US. Is this comment more about the ongoing existential concern for everyone, or wondering if this is a specific concern for yourself? The Apple implementation protects with either a biometric or passcode; you should be able to still use it if you disable the biometric features of the phone. A third-party implementation might instead support requiring a PIN rather than accepting a passcode for their users with such concerns. This is very close to the existing situation with password managers. > I am also interested in seeing how phone secured passkeys will work, iOS currently forces the use of keychain, excluding users who opt for a third party password manager like bitwarden. The system implementation uses iCloud Keychain, but a password manager can ship a web extension to supplant the existing browser API with their own implementation. On Android, there is a system level API in beta that allows third party password managers to offer passwords and passkeys to native apps and browsers. > I also wonder if phones will be able to be used to login without enabling bluetooth. There are complications to supporting USB on multi-purpose devices, and unfortunately nowhere near enough NFC reader adoption for such support to be prioritized. NFC also has some UX complications. The bluetooth support is used for proximity checks; a pure network-based approach would be open to lower sophistication MITM attacks.
- latexr 4y ago
- account-5 4y agoWhen though? Because at the minute all I see is vendor lock in and no actual advantages over my password manager, other than not having to trust the security practices of a company. I'm definitely not up for tying anything to a device or biometrics.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoWhich is precisely why this will be pushed aggressively. I'm sticking to passwords myself.
- crote 4y agoNeat, but that also means their value as MFA is undermined. It's no longer "something you have" when it can freely be copied, including by a casual passerby or a virus. You're basically reducing it to a password stored in a file called "MY PASSWORDS" on your desktop. Great for user friendliness, terrible for security. So now when you use Passkeys we'll need to add another 2FA instance to properly secure your account...
- growse 4y agoIf MYPASSWORDS.txt is encrypted and can only be decrypted with a key stored in some sort of HSM, then it is still MFA.
- charcircuit 4y agoThe point is if you can export the key from the HSM then it no longer requires that HSM as the exported key and MYPASSWORDS.txt can be bundled together. Knowing the contents of that bundle is a single factor of authentication.
- growse 4y agoYes, but this is tautological. "If I can clone a physical key, or create a copy, then it's not a good physical key" isn't particularly insightful.
- Dalewyn 4y agoSo what you're saying is it's not encrypted, not secured, and should not be trusted? Seriously, how many key leaks and other compromises do we have to witness before we do away with the notion they're secure and trustworthy?
- stavros 4y agoThere is no notion that "something is secure". It literally doesn't exist. There is a notion that something is secure under a specific threat model, and there are many threat models for which keys are secure and passwords are not.
- pabs3 4y agoKeePassXC has in-progress passkey support, which will enable part of that: https://github.com/keepassxreboot/keepassxc/pull/8825 https://github.com/keepassxreboot/keepassxc/pull/8825
- pabs3 4y ago... but probably still require (proprietary) JavaScript to be loaded from the website before they will work.
- lapcat 4y agoThe linked post is in response to "Passkeys: A loss of user control?" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35854216 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35854216 Unfortunately, it doesn't directly address the issue of the iCloud keychain requirement.
- rendaw 4y agoSo I was trying to figure this out, but basically passkeys are a private-public key pair as opposed to passwords that are a shared secret? And I guess authenticating with a passkey is basically doing a signature or some other proof that doesn't expose the private key. Since passkeys are generated using an algorithm, there's no risk of people reusing them or choosing weak ones (and will force people to use password managers). And at the root you still have a shared secret password/pin to unlock your password manager or device containing the password manager.
- znpy 4y agoSo basically are user certificates being reinvented here?
- lloydatkinson 4y agoI’ll stick to passwords in a password manager thanks.
- upofadown 4y ago>Passkeys will be importable and exportable, cross-device, and across passkey managers. Yes, but how will the users be able to do this in a way that they can understand and that is secure? The usability of stored secrets is a big outstanding issue at this point. You can't just blandly state you are going to solve the problem without any indication of how it is to be done. Just because something is technically possible does not mean that most people will be able to do it in practice.
- latexr 4y agoAs per the post: > It’s something that’s being defined and designed In other words, it’s not finalised. Whatever solution is implemented will depend not only on Apple but on the other players as well. It would make no sense to share those details on Mastodon, they’ll save them for WWDC or a press release like they do with everything else.
- rektide 4y agoStart with protocols for handling the data well. Then figure out what flows work. Start at the bottom with what already is, with what is concrete & true, and build forward from that. I both want us to be careful & considerate, but also, I find the assaults against progress like this to be impossible. We can keep tattering efforts to advance forever, create ever more gates, raise ever more concerns about any topic forever. I used to be able. To process this kind of cross examination as a tempered concern & moderation, but increasingly I feel like grace is lost, that- whatever the intent- we are suffering from a large amassed anti-will, a will against. Having the technical standards & options to do these capabilities doesn't imply that every system has to offer them. Most should, & there should be good options for managing them (and the concern here is valid that the options indeed be good & usable) . But security keys have been a miserable failure, in huge part because users have never been given options to manage their contents, because the device has been the sole authority & holder. It's non negotiable in my mind that exporting importing files needs to happen ASAP, with low barriers. We keep roadblocking progress with concern that some users will make awful mistakes. If we had forever we could perhaps make your perfectly safe & secure utopia, where power users and the lowliest end user both happily safely operate, but we do not have forever. Given this, we ought create powerful technical underpinnings that make user capabilities possible & evolvable, then let product iterate & hone on how they can best marshal & expose subsets of those capabilities in ways catered to their users. What we cannot do is gate progress on imagined self-threatening users, what we cannot do is to forever pick the lowest common denominator of options, out of fear.
- perryizgr8 4y agoSure, let me know when I can scp my passkey onto/from my Iphone.
- greatgib 4y ago"that's what she said"... Was good to avoid the fear of users so that they switched but then big tech don't have to really do it and follow their word once it becomes common. Just look at the Google authenticator that is very simple but did not have the feature for years, until recently when they were afraid that bad communication about that will jeopardize their passkey initiative!
- joekrill 4y agoOK so it will be _possible_, but will Google, Apple, Microsoft, et al actually implement this functionality? There's really no guarantee of that. I certainly wouldn't bet on it.
- nipperkinfeet 4y agoWhen will Firefox get Passkeys support? Also, does Passkeys work on Linux?
- volkovv 4y ago>Firefox According to this [0] post of Mozilla dev, no sooner than 8 versions ahead. >Linux AFAIK, the furthest efforts so far are implementing FIDO2 portal in Gnome [1] The field is currently dominated by major centralised players (Google, MS, Apple), so it it really depends on the particular Linux community to introduce any FIDO2 support. For example, Chrome has no plans for Linux passkey support. [2] [0] https://developers.google.com/identity/passkeys/supported-environments#linux https://developers.google.com/identity/passkeys/supported-en... [1] https://discourse.gnome.org/t/passkeys-in-gnome/14648/6 https://discourse.gnome.org/t/passkeys-in-gnome/14648/6 [2] https://developers.google.com/identity/passkeys/supported-environments https://developers.google.com/identity/passkeys/supported-en...
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoI hope YubiKey catches up and allows me to move keys around. Every time I register my YubiKey to a website I need to pull the other one out of the safe, register it as well, and put it back.
- eternityforest 4y agoThose were my main concerns with the whole thing. At the moment, through, passwords are good enough for most people who aren't specifically interesting targets, so I'm not super concerned or holding my breath. I just don't see people who use password managers and any kind of 2FA, even SMS, getting hacked in real life. I expect the main value of passkeys will just be that people will be forced to transition from memorizing to letting the computer manage credentials.