8 ms·
Google Analytics alternative that protects your data and your customers' privacy
- BaudouinVH 4y agohttps://umami.is/ https://umami.is/ does the same, free tier available.
- marban 4y agoC'mon there's like a thousand threads on these already.
- throwaway2056 4y agoIn all these threads, there is never a project manager from a large establishment telling - Thanks. we will migrate - we did and it was <good/bad> More or less everyone is after $.
- ZacnyLos 4y agoMore alternatives: https://european-alternatives.eu/alternative-to/google-analytics https://european-alternatives.eu/alternative-to/google-analy...
- iLoveOncall 4y agoHalf of the "alternatives" there are dead (website is offline) and the rest is not free. Those are hardly alternatives, more like band-aid solutions.
- hobo_mark 4y agoI'm going through the list at random (I'm on the market for such a service) and none of them appear offline so far.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoYeah you're right actually. From my phone most of them appeared online but from my computer, on the same network, they're all fine.
- paulcole 4y agoA paid alternative to a free service is still an alternative. They may not be alternatives you like, but they are alternatives. And for many people a paid option may be better once they start looking at why the free thing is free.
- graftak 4y agoThis website is off to a bad start when the first item says > Because it does not use cookies there is no need to show cookie banner for this service. which is a blatant lie/misinformation. The ‘cookie law’ has nothing to do with the actual use of cookies.
- jhpacker 4y agoTo defend this site, that is the claim of the vendor and I wouldn't expect a site that focuses on listing EU alternatives to be critically evaluating a claim like that which hasn't been explicitly nay-sayed by any regulatory agency. Plausible uses a visitor id based upon a hashed + salted user agent plus IP address where the salt is rotated daily. The choice of whether consent is required for that is for the individual implementing site to make up their mind upon, but I don't think the vendor claim is unreasonable. A similar (but better, IMHO) site that focuses just on analytics is: https://newmetrics.io/ https://newmetrics.io/
- mpldr 4y agoThe cookie law™ clearly lays out that technically required cookies can be set without explicit consent. Performance measurements are not a requirement though. So if you are not using anything but essential cookies on your site, you don't need a banner.
- herunan 4y agoWhy is this at the top of HN?
- haunter 4y agoGoogle bad
- viraptor 4y agoI'm guessing because of this: https://blog.google/products/marketingplatform/analytics/prepare-for-future-with-google-analytics-4/ https://blog.google/products/marketingplatform/analytics/pre... > All standard Universal Analytics properties will stop processing new hits on July 1, 2023.
- EGreg 4y agoSo what is the main difference between Universal Analytics and Google Analytics 4? We currently use Google Analytics to understand how users move through our app. We also used Matomo (previously Piwik) 5 years ago. Now Google Analytics on iOS will stop working for users unless they update our app? It doesn’t seem to say anything: https://developers.google.com/analytics/devguides/collection/ios/v3 https://developers.google.com/analytics/devguides/collection...
- devjab 4y agoAnalytics are widely used in communication departments in European enterprise, and where that previously was very often Google Analytics, it’s hard to use it because of Google’s inability/unwillingness to change their enterprise targeting business model to be GDPR compliant. I’m not personally convinced you really need an analytics tool in most European communications departments. As long as saying something like that is akin to heresy, however, I think it’s safe to say that a lot of people are interested in alternatives to Google Analytics. It’s likely not just in Europe anymore. Privacy seems to be a tend that is on the increase everywhere. But as I understand it, things move to the top of HN if they are interesting to a lot of people, and privacy is interesting to a lot of people these years. Not just to the “nerds” either, at least I tend to see more and more discussion on it outside of tech circles. In the EU specific you do have the very real “motivation” of dropping Google Analytics because using it puts you in the lovely area of breaking the law.
- pastage 4y agoMatomo is not trivial run on prem, there are lots of stuff that do not work on larger installs unless you do lots of manual optimization, what those optimizations are is not obvious. The problems only shows after some time when you have to redo reports for multiyear periods, or handle hug of death. That said people love analytics, it is a powerful tool.
- viraptor 4y agoAny links? I'm assuming you mean something more than the periodic rollups?
- pastage 4y agoThe biggest issue is actually that the analytic part is so removed from the performance part. There is no good way to know what will be a fast analytics report, no feedback in the UI for the creator of the report. I am stuck with policing that. Not sure what you mean with rollups. And not sure what I am supposed to link. These are just some of the things you have to manually install, this is except all the plugins you have to buy. Upgrade Matomo and not miss analytics. Good db performance. Secure installation. What is both bogging down performance.
- preinheimer 4y agoI wish some of the privacy focused GA alternatives had SOC 2 reports, or ISO 27001. We’re working towards our first SOC 2, which makes it hard to incorporate anything without one into our product. On prem is a lot of work, and not something i want to approach lightly.
- npace12 4y agowhy? Having gone through a few SOC-2s, I don't see any value it other than it being a racket.
- ian0 4y agoHaving gone through ISO 27001 and PCI DSS level 2 I kind of assumed all of these security focussed compliance standards are just that. Anyone have any exceptions?
- vlovich123 4y agoYes it’s a huge racket that’s likely does little to solve the problems it was enacted to prevent. But have you tried making deals with large SOC2 companies without your own certification?
- jhpacker 4y agoPiwik Pro is SOC2 certified.
- riogordo2go 4y agoI'm using the matomo self hosted version and like it overall. I love you can track all outbound clicks without having to specifically add Dom elements to outbound links to make this possible. Unfortunately matomo is blocked just like Google Analytics by every ad/tracking blocker. Doesn't matter if you host it yourself and only track global stats vs tracking users across the web like GA does. The only solution seems to be writing your own analytics.
- chpatrick 4y agoYou can usually rename the tracker to something that's not on the blocklist.
- riogordo2go 4y agoThat used to work but current block filters analyse js variables and url parameters and are much harder to circumvent.
- jeroenhd 4y agoWhy spend time undermining people's preferences?
- RHSeeger 4y agoIf I build a web site, and it is my preference to know what pages get clicks on what elements (presumably, so I can make my site better)... whose preference gets priority; mine or my users? It's not as black and white as your question makes it sound.
- EGreg 4y agoI don’t get it, how can they stop you from recording this on your own server? Are you talking about CNAME cloaking? Pretty sure Apple only cares if one specific server gets all the CNAMEs. It doesn’t block CNAMEs in general.
- gerenuk 4y agoUsermaven.com does the same and covers product insights as well. Free tier is pretty generous (1M events per month).
- prithsr 4y agoThanks for sharing this! Just got it set up on one of my domains and very pleased.
- nologic01 4y agoIdeally the different self-hosted web stacks would have built-in analytics that would not have to hit the client with javascript. But they don't, or if they do each has its own inconsistent approach to as what data is collected and how it is presented. So the second best if you care about your user's privacy (and, if applicable, your own commercial or institutional privacy) is something like matomo.
- colesantiago 4y agoLet's all just stop tracking all together. We don't need tracking at all and bloating up and slowing down websites.
- nicbou 4y agoThis would be nice. I don't track users on my personal blog. I don't give a flying duck about what people do there. However I make money from running a website which is really useful to a lot of people. I absolutely need to know what works and what doesn't. I can't write and edit in the dark, possibly missing by a mile what my readers really need. It would be like flying a plane without instruments. For instance, I see that a lot of people use the search to find a single guide, which should definitely be linked on the home page. Without basic tracking, I wouldn't even know which pages are important to my users. There are many gaping holes in your website that you could be completely blind to without a basic sense of what your users do on your website. I also caught many illegal copies of my website through referrer tracking. Three of them were phishing websites, and I got them shut down. So there are many legitimate reasons to have basic traffic counters, and you can have those while respecting your users' privacy and following the spirit and the letter of GDPR.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI wonder if someone's made an AdNauseam for tracking libraries yet. Going on the defensive clearly doesn't work, some more offensive action is required. Send a whole bunch of plausible events, pretending to click every link, changing your identifiers and stuff like resolution every time, make it impossible to determine what data is real and what isn't. Bonus points for leaving websites alone if they don't load tracking scripts until you've consented. We can't stop trackers, but we can try to make them useless. Even if they filter out such tracking they shouldn't be able to figure out what data was real, making their tracking attempts worthless.
- jhpacker 4y agoI believe AdNauseam uses EasyList, so if it doesn't include the EasyPrivacy part of that (which contains the trackers) by default it seems like it would be easy to add. That said, I don't think this is an effective strategy at all. Safari has placed a big giant hole in tracking (like 20% of users) and lots of sites are still proceeding like nothing has changed. Google referrer spam was run at mega-scale dumping billions (at least) of spam hits into millions of profiles and didn't effect tracking efforts. A plugin run by .0001% of users or whatever that adds in a bunch of slop to the numbers just makes more analysts pull out their hair rather than leading to change.
- jacooper 4y agoBeware, Matomo by default isn't very privacy friendly, you will need the GDPR banner for any advanced features. If you want a GDPR compliant analytics you have to disable many of its flagship features, or use something else like Plausible, designed to work with no consent.
- viraptor 4y agoYou need a GDPR banner for sharing information with third parties. Why would you need one for self-hosted Matomo?
- jacooper 4y agoIts not only that, its also about the data collected. Real time data like visitor data and heatmaps aren't allowed, also IP tracking is not allowed too. Because matomo can be very powerful, more powerful than Ganalytics. You can let it assign a unique id to every visitor if it visited a subdomain and logged in, so you can now exactly who each visitor is on all of your sites. https://matomo.org/faq/how-to/how-do-i-configure-matomo-without-tracking-consent-for-french-visitors-cnil-exemption/#you-can-use-matomo-with-tracking-cookies-for-visitors-located-in-france-based-on-the-following-conditions https://matomo.org/faq/how-to/how-do-i-configure-matomo-with...
- jeroenhd 4y agoYou'll need consent for any data collection not essential to your site's functionality, even if you host stuff yourself. If all you so is collect how often your pages are being visited then you're not collecting any PII and you don't need a banner, but if you're tracking visitors based on unique identifiers (cookies, IP addresses, etc.) you'll need to get consent first.
- zichy 4y agoIt is really easy to protect everyone's privacy by not using advanced analytics platforms at all.
- earth2mars 4y agoTheir usage of word "On-Premise" instead of "on prem" or "on premises"!!!
- ezekg 4y agoThe terms on-premises and on-premise and on-prem are synonymous within enterprise lingo.
- TechBro8615 4y agoThe one that grinds my gears is "bottoms up" instead of "bottom up."
- nobody9999 4y ago>The one that grinds my gears is "bottoms up" instead of "bottom up." Why does that "grind your gears?" The term "bottoms up" is (unless I'm missing something important -- am I?) just the plural of "bottom up." And given that the phrase is an admonition to drink what's in your container (hence seeing the bottom of the glass pointing up), it's usually (although I suppose it could be more prevalent when drinking alone, but I guess we'll never know) offered among a group (two or more) of folks, making "bottoms up" appropriate as it refers to more than one "bottom." Again, I could be missing something important here. If so, please enlighten me. Edit: Fixed typo.
- Terretta 4y agoIt's not a plural, it's a different expression that happens to sound similar. "bottoms up" means to turn your alcohol glass upside down, so the bottom is up, a euphemism for drinking from your glass "bottom up" is an order of operation, starting at the bottom, working your way up
- nobody9999 4y ago> It's not a plural, it's a different expression that happens to sound similar. >"bottoms up" means to turn your alcohol glass upside down, so the bottom is up, >a euphemism for drinking from your glass >"bottom up" is an order of operation, starting at the bottom, working your way up That makes more sense now. Thanks! Makes me wish I hadn't taken a tops-down approach to my initial reply. :)
- algustionesa 4y agoI have reviewed many Google Analytics replacements in terms of features and capabilities. Matomo may be suitable for you, but its data presentation is not user-friendly. If you only need basic metrics to track, there are many alternatives that present analytics data more clearly. For more information, see https://algustionesa.com/google-analytics-alternatives/ https://algustionesa.com/google-analytics-alternatives/.
- TekMol 4y agoI tried Matomo. Self hosting is easy. That's a plus. I also like the interface. Took a while to get used to it but after that, I liked it even better than Google Analytics. But one problem that seems unsurmountable is that it tries to be clever. And while trying, it messes up your data. If you have pages with a parameter in the querystring that is called "q", Matomo does not count those as pageviews. It tries to be clever and only count those as "searches". Probably because many site searches use a parameter "q" for what the user is searching for. Even if a page is a search result page, it should be counted as a pageview. The problem gets even worse when you have users bookmarking pages with a "q" parameter. Then things get really messy when you try to understand which pages users use, where they come from etc. I have searched a lot, but have found no way to disable this "cleverness". And no way to retroactively fix the data.
- SquareWheel 4y agoThat's an odd choice as WordPress, which is by far the most popular CMS, uses ?s= as a search query. I would expect those pages to be included in the data. They could offer some sort of segmentation if they think they they can separate out searches, though.
- ethor 4y agoJust disable website search or change the search parameter inside website settings to stop Matomo from interpreting the 'q' parameter as search.
- ehnto 4y agoIt is bad default, but nice that it is configurable.
- dmw_ng 4y agoRecord tracking pings independently of any solution and figure things out later, a 1x1 GIF can absorb an unlimited number of query strings, and S3 storage for log files is extremely economical. It doesn't matter which analytics solution you end up with, you'll always be throwing away data. IIRC even GA enterprise doesn't allowing pulling the original click log back out of it, only some form of sampling or another. Put a 1x1 GIF in an S3 bucket, create a CloudFront distribution and enable logging for it into another bucket. Tada, unlimited scale achieved for pennies. Matomo and GA's trackers both allow sending the query to a URL of your choice. Treat the analytics system as an index over the logs, rather than treating the logs as an auxiliary artefact of the analytics system
- jhpacker 4y agoMatomo is decent, but my main issue with it is the performance when run at any sort of scale. It's PHP/MySQL, which is nice for ease of self-hosting, but it means a lot of things need to be pre-calculated. Most of the newer and more performant GA alternatives out there are using things like ClickHouse. ClickHouse: Piwik PRO, Plausible, PostHog, Yandex, Cloudflare Snowflake: Amplitude, Piano, Snowplow SingleStore: Fathom I've written a book on the subject including evaluating the 15 most widely used options: https://gaalternatives.guide https://gaalternatives.guide
- KronisLV 4y ago> Matomo is decent, but my main issue with it is the performance when run at any sort of scale. It's PHP/MySQL, which is nice for ease of self-hosting, but it means a lot of things need to be pre-calculated. I've never actually run into performance issues, neither when using it in production professionally, nor for my self-hosted sites (with Matomo always running on-prem). I'd say the performance of PHP and MySQL/MariaDB is most likely decent as long as you don't go too far into specialized workloads, for example log aggregation/tracing; though even some APM solutions like Apache Skywalking also support using traditional RDBMSes for this purpose as well: https://skywalking.apache.org/docs/main/v9.0.0/en/setup/backend/backend-storage/#mysql https://skywalking.apache.org/docs/main/v9.0.0/en/setup/back... That said, I can't help but to wonder at what actual scale (number of logged events/second, given certain hardware) you'd run into issues. Luckily, because adding basic analytics is usually quite easy, testing this for your own workloads shouldn't be out of the question - then you can let the data speak for itself.
- jhpacker 4y agoThe performance issues aren't with the measurement requests but with reporting. When I eval'd it for my book last fall there were big delays in reporting waiting for segments and then also issues with custom reports. I think they have changed the default behavior to get around some of the former, but with MySQL it's always going to be tough for larger queries. (if there's any performance issue on the measurement side it has more to do with the JavaScript payload because they include a lot in their standard JS bundle).
- nmstoker 4y agoHaven't used it in six years but back in the days it was Piwik it was ideal: easy to set up locally, a good range of features and a friendly community (v. responsive to an upgrade issue we experienced but apart from that everything worked exactly as expected).
- acidburnNSA 4y agoBack in my day it was awstats. Still works great. I have 18 years of data. https://www.awstats.org/ https://www.awstats.org/
- jhpacker 4y agoLoved AWStats! Still can be useful — but bots, client side caching, CDNs, and did I mention bots..? have made the data hard to rely on for much. A while ago I switched from AWStats to GoAccess (https://goaccess.io/ https://goaccess.io/) for this kind of thing. I prefer its interface, and it's way way faster to churn through big log files (C vs. Perl).
- stoicjumbotron 4y agoThoughts on Microsoft Clarity? https://clarity.microsoft.com https://clarity.microsoft.com
- hodgesrm 4y agoClarity is awesome--the metrics and the way it combines a visualization of our site with user session data is amazing. It shows you the actual locations on the page that users visit as well as the path they follow to get there. The insights are far more actionable than Google Analytics from my experience. (We use both.) p.s., Under the covers Clarity runs on ClickHouse.
- victor106 4y agoI think we learnt enough when big tech offers something for “free” and when they call it “absolutely” free it just means you are absolutely the product. So thanks but No thanks
- jmduke 4y agoA while back I built out a quick guide comparing all of these alternatives, because the core value prop was pretty similar and it was annoying to compare between pricing plans. (My personal vote goes to Fathom.) https://buttondown.email/comparison-guides/google-analytics-alternatives https://buttondown.email/comparison-guides/google-analytics-...
- 6ak74rfy 4y agoLast I checked, Fathom’s open source product hadn’t been updated for a couple of years. So, I switched to Plausible which is more reasonably updated.
- graeme 4y agoHow does Plausible compare to Google's Universal Analytics? And are there any SEO effects? GA4 migration seems not aimed at general users, so I'm looking at alternatives. Ideally could import my data.
- jhpacker 4y agoNo SEO effects. If anything there could be a slight advantage to using Plausible over GA because the JS tracker is much smaller, though in practice I would not expect any SEO impact. Plausible is much simpler than UA, all the reporting is on one page and it has much more limited config options. It also can import your UA data. If you're looking for a simplified GA alternative it's a very good choice. (Full disclosure, I recently published an article on their blog about UA vs GA4: https://plausible.io/blog/ua-vs-ga4 https://plausible.io/blog/ua-vs-ga4)
- graeme 4y agoThanks! Hmm, can you drill down into sets of pages like you can in UA? That was a pretty key feature. I'll have a look, seems promising.
- 4y ago
- RobotToaster 4y agoWorth noting that it seems to be only "open core", there's a bunch of paywalled features that I presume aren't open source. https://matomo.org/pricing/ https://matomo.org/pricing/
- encoderer 4y agoWe (cronitor.io) have a really great all-in-one solution to analytics and website monitoring with a generous free tier. https://cronitor.io/real-user-monitoring https://cronitor.io/real-user-monitoring
- johndhi 4y agoI'm not an engineer. Can someone please specifically explain to me how this protects data and privacy more than Google? Does it use cookies and browser storage?
- jenadine 4y agoOne thing is that it doesn't send any data about your users to Google.
- dfsl 4y agoI have integrated my site with matomo. The matomo analytics are captured and stored on-premises on my server (nothing goes to the cloud). Performance is good with my configuration. You can see page performance for yourself by loading this page: https://freesoftware.life/how-to-install-kubuntu-23-04/ https://freesoftware.life/how-to-install-kubuntu-23-04/
- jpalomaki 4y agoYou can also run Matomo without tracking Javascript and instead feed in log files [1]. This works with the Cloudfront log files (and many others). [1] https://matomo.org/faq/general/requirements-for-log-analytics/ https://matomo.org/faq/general/requirements-for-log-analytic...
- hrpnk 4y agoRudderstack claims to be a GA alternative [1] and accepts server-side data allowing this to be a 1st party integration skipping the consent complexity. Any thoughts on this one? It also made it to the Thoughtworks Tech Radar [2]. [1] https://www.rudderstack.com/replace-google-analytics-4-guide/ https://www.rudderstack.com/replace-google-analytics-4-guide... [2] https://www.thoughtworks.com/en-us/radar/platforms/rudderstack https://www.thoughtworks.com/en-us/radar/platforms/ruddersta...
- gcanyon 4y agoI just want analytics that don't require a Ph.D. in obscure user interfaces to get anything out of them. TBF, I haven't used GA in 8 years, maybe it's gotten better -- but I still have flashbacks.
- IanCal 4y ago> Google Analytics alternative that protects your data and your customers' privacy It's not your data, this data about me. > Your customers will love you because their valuable personal data is protected. I guarantee you your customers will not love you for tracking them.
- eek2121 4y agoAnalytics platforms are a dime a dozen, and they all suffer from the same flaws. Either they are too expensive for everyone, or they add too much overhead for everyone. I've actually been debating getting into this space for a while due to this fact, especially after interviewing with one of the top companies in this space and noting how cocky the CTO was about their product. Google Analytics is FREE and won't cost most us a dime. If you want to charge me a dime, you need to make your product worth that extra dime to ME. Note that even healthcare companies use Google Analytics here in the US.
- gmsiperx 4y agoTry usermaven.com as an alternative to GA, I am sure you'll love the simplicity and easy of use/maintenance because of the auto-tracked events functionality.