8 ms·
The UK’s tortured attempt to remake the internet
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 4y agoAre these the same people behind right to be forgotten and this site uses cookies?
- wmf 4y agoNo, that's the EU.
- djoldman 4y agoIn no particular order: Age checks for porn sites: seems like if parents care about this, there are plenty of technological ways to restrict their children's access? Is there a gap between what's available as a technological intervention and parents' want? Measures to clamp down on “anonymous trolls” by requiring that services give the option for users to verify their identity: for minors it seems like parents could restrict access to websites via technical means, for adults... don't use the website/app? Criminalizing cyberflashing (aka the sending of unsolicited nudes via social media or dating apps): as long as this parallels in-person flashing law, this seems reasonable? Cracking down on scam ads: not sure what this means, but fraud is fraud whether it's on the internet or not. This feels like more outsourcing of law enforcement to companies. If there are complaints about scam ads, then law enforcement should investigate, with subpoenas if needed, and prosecute. Does there need to be a separate law for this?
- mschuster91 4y ago> Age checks for porn sites: seems like if parents care about this, there are plenty of technological ways to restrict their children's access? Is there a gap between what's available as a technological intervention and parents' want? The real problem behind that are various Evangelical groups running scare campaigns against parents and pressure campaigns against ISPs and individual sites. The US was the first with FOSTA/SESTA, the UK followed suit, and here in Germany our media regulators are going nuts as well. > Measures to clamp down on “anonymous trolls” by requiring that services give the option for users to verify their identity: for minors it seems like parents could restrict access to websites via technical means, for adults... don't use the website/app? That one is more complex. There are many different and valid points that collide: - the EU GDPR effectively demands that services can be used anonymously, and so did the old §13 TMG law in Germany. - service providers (Facebook most infamously) try to skirt these laws because they sell "authenticity" of users as part of their product appeal, and others to combat spam - the people demand the ability to post on the Internet without having to reveal their identity - say, in customer or employer review sites, or when unionizing or protesting against the government - Employers and brands do not want anonymous reviews due to the libel potential - people wish to watch porn or sext anonymously, because of the risk that a link between their porn habits and identity poses - the best example here is the prosecution of gays via Grindr - governments do not like anonymous commenting either, partially because they're oppressive, and partially because of the potential for hostile acts by enemy nations such as the Russian and Chinese "fake news" campaigns Striking a balance between these points is very complex, and the fact that many politicians are frankly way too old (or incompetent) to understand what they are regulating doesn't make things better.
- djoldman 4y agoThere are definitely multiple viewpoints on "anonymous trolls." I don't understand how allowing anonymity fails to address all of them. - the EU GDPR effectively demands that services can be used anonymously, and so did the old §13 TMG law in Germany. This allows anonymity. - service providers (Facebook most infamously) try to skirt these laws because they sell "authenticity" of users as part of their product appeal, and others to combat spam Consumers/users are not forced to use these products... as with any other product, they are forced to balance the commercial offerings' pros and cons. If they value anonymity highly, they may choose to not partake. - the people demand the ability to post on the Internet without having to reveal their identity - say, in customer or employer review sites, or when unionizing or protesting against the government This allows anonymity. - Employers and brands do not want anonymous reviews due to the libel potential They can decide (or not) to require anonymity for their offering, with attendant effects on engagement and community trust. - people wish to watch porn or sext anonymously, because of the risk that a link between their porn habits and identity poses - the best example here is the prosecution of gays via Grindr This allows anonymity. - governments do not like anonymous commenting either, partially because they're oppressive, and partially because of the potential for hostile acts by enemy nations such as the Russian and Chinese "fake news" campaigns It seems that oppression is bad, so without a compelling reason, anonymity should be allowed. "Fake news": adults should be allowed to believe in or be exposed to the information of their choice.. particularly because no one can be trusted to be the arbiter of "fake."
- mschuster91 4y ago> It seems that oppression is bad, so without a compelling reason, anonymity should be allowed. "Fake news": adults should be allowed to believe in or be exposed to the information of their choice.. particularly because no one can be trusted to be the arbiter of "fake." The last six years should have proven that most adults are not capable of judging whether a piece or source of information is trustworthy or not, hence the call for government regulation in the face of digital warfare - and yes, what Russia and China did to Western populations would have been classified as an act of war some decades ago.
- jcarrano 4y agoIt is ONLY about controlling the flow of information, all the rest are just excuses and rationalizations. If they really wanted to tackle illegal behavior then the laws are already there (that's why it is "illegal" in the first place). Governments are afraid of the internet.
- 1827163 4y agoYes, and it's not only the government, it's authorities, i.e. those with power over others everywhere that wants control over the flow of information. In the government. In the police. The workplace. The family. And the family is often where the absolute worst tyranny occurs - towards children - where our natural rights are violated the most - and this is accepted as 'normal' by our sick society. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normalization_of_deviance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normalization_of_deviance
- bodge5000 4y ago> Governments are afraid of the internet. And they don't understand it. And thats pretty insane, imagine electing a new leader who says "why don't we just print more money?". We all understand its important to elect a leader who understands economics, because they're going to be regulating it, but for some reason tech illiteracy is given a free pass
- jcarrano 4y ago> imagine electing a new leader who says "why don't we just print more money?" They did _exactly_ that in my home country. You can guess how it went...
- ta1243 4y ago> Cracking down on scam ads: not sure what this means, but fraud is fraud whether it's on the internet or not. This feels like more outsourcing of law enforcement to companies. If there are complaints about scam ads, then law enforcement should investigate, with subpoenas if needed, and prosecute. Does there need to be a separate law for this? If a newspaper printed adverts to put your life savings into some NFT scam with a picture of Martin Lewis endorsing it, they would find themselves sued out of business very quickly. That doesn't seem to apply to facebook though.
- djoldman 4y agoI'm not sure the laws governing those two scenarios are different... are they? How much liability does a print newspaper have for its ad content?
- 1827163 4y ago[flagged]
- jarym 4y agoThe current UK government are on their last legs - the overwhelming majority of the public don't trust them and we're now on our second unelected Prime Minister. IMO, they're just trying to get through the things they want into legislation before they get booted out next year. But, they've been so awful generally that the public are beginning to see for themselves why we can't trust government to 'do the right thing' for the people.
- zimpenfish 4y ago> now on our second unelected Prime Minister. Of this election cycle, even - we had one (Cameron -> May, May -> Johnson) in each of the previous two cycles as well. (We've had 5 swaps 2000-2023 compared with 12 1900-1999) > The current UK government are on their last legs I hope you're right but the UK populace does show a distressing talent for ignoring the past and electing horrific parties when it comes to a general.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> IMO, they're just trying to get through the things they want into legislation This is crowd-pleaser legislation; they're hoping it's a vote-winner. They think they have a chance in the next GE. I'm inclined to agree; I can't vote for Starmer's party, so unless something changes, I won't be voting.
- ta1243 4y agoEvery constituency will have at least 3 MPs to choose from, and most will have 4, 5 or even more.
- jen20 4y agoThis is not practically the case. Take Bath for example (I happen to vote there, since it's the last place I lived - prior to that I lived in North East Somerset where the dynamic is the same, but with different parties). There has not been a member elected for Bath since the 1800s who was not either a member of the Liberal Democrats, the Conservatives, or a party which became one of those. The margins are usually comical. Therefore, one must vote according to who they want to prevent winning if one is not for either of those two candidates. Realistically, the only hope even for _Conservatives_ in Bath in the modern era is that a general election is held during University holidays.
- jmclnx 4y agoOne good thing about this, maybe pols in other countries will learn how dumb this is when this law only causes real harm to the UK economy. With this and bexit, it is like the UK is trying to become a "third word" country on purpose. But, I fear all this will do is make other countries double down on these laws. I have said this before, "what is wrong with English speaking countries?". It is like the language makes people try stupid fixes to problems that do not exist.
- Neil44 4y agoProblems that do not exist? The Internet is the absolute wild west of crime and harm.
- 1827163 4y agoAnd so much of those problems could be solved by not using our real names everywhere, and allowing it to be a wild west for freedom of speech, as it rightly should be. Where we can debate anything without fear of censorship, which in many cases is given the euphemism of 'moderation'. There should be no excuse to delete any comment that is not illegal (i.e. threatening or inciting violence), when you can just hide it, and those who want to see it can click to see it. I am totally outraged, it is moral injury, from what has happened to the Internet in 2023, where people have just accepted routine censorship of legal speech, barely batting an eyelid to it when it happens. If it continues at this pace, where will the people who still care fundamentally about freedom of speech, as I do, have a place to go to? I guess they will end up being branded 'free speech extremists' and be subjected to surveillance by state intelligence agencies....
- mypornaccount 4y ago“Harm” seems to be a disturbingly broad newspeak term that’s getting thrown around more and more to justify censorship.
- badcppdev 4y agoThe UK government is good at passing laws but terrible at enforcing / enacting them. They want to be able to rule by waving a new law and and signing cheques (as long as there isn't too much due diligence involved in the contract). The part of governing where you have to set up institutions that provide a service or material good for the voters is not their forte.
- HPsquared 4y agoI think it's the opposite. There are far too many different regulators and quangos in the UK with overlapping responsibilities.
- okeuro49 4y agoRather than this law, I would start at banning social media accounts for under 16s. Social media has arguably had an appalling effect on the mental being of teenage girls. https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/metaverse-facebook-instagram-social-media-b2008700.html https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/metaverse-facebook-inst...
- ghusto 4y agoWhy on earth is this being down-voted? It's patently and demonstrably true. The Independent isn't the source I'd use, but there are plenty more. Personally, I'd be happy if there was some magic way to stop people under 30 interacting with me online in any way (as long as it _was_ magic, and didn't laws or "technical" fixes).
- wcerfgba 4y agoIs it "patently and demonstrably true"? This article is 80% opinion and 20% descriptive statistics. There's no experimental, quasiexperimental, or qualitative research cited. A systematic review from 2020 found that the evidence is mixed at best, and more research is needed: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02673843.2019.1590851 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02673843.2019.1... Ultimately, we have responsibilities to ourselves and our loved ones. Reflect on your life, talk to your friends and family, and if you think introducing restrictions on your social media use would improve your/their wellbeing, then do so and see if it helps. Xx
- ghusto 4y ago> Ultimately, we have responsibilities to ourselves and our loved ones. Reflect on your life, talk to your friends and family, and if you think introducing restrictions on your social media use would improve your/their wellbeing, then do so and see if it helps. Xx Absolutely, and I'm not suggesting I shirk my responsibilities as a parent. One of the things that annoyed me when I was a kid was parents wanting to restrict TV and video games, because they didn't want to take their precious "me-me-me" time and devote it to actually raising their children. This isn't the same thing though. You can be as present and involved as possible in your kids life today, but the web trumps all. It's all pervasive, all encompassing, and normalised. You could switch the TV off, or talk about problematic themes on it, but the web is a different beast. If you lived through the before-times, you saw the difference between then, during, and after the iPhone. The kids have never been alright, but as one of those kids who was on the wrong side of the outer-edges of not-alright, I can tell you that the situation now is dire in comparison.
- bodge5000 4y agoWas really betting on the tories incompetence for this not to go through. I guess fixing the looming energy crisis is impossible, but rebuilding something you have no understanding of is a walk in the park. Worst part is I doubt we'll even see any opposition to this from, you know, the opposition. I doubt the tory leader-of-the-week will face a grilling on what encryption even means from Starmer, he'll want to keep his mouth shut whilst he figures that out himself
- dreamcompiler 4y agoWill this mean that you need to use an always-on VPN when traveling to the UK, much like what one has to do* when visiting China? * Or had to. I dn't know if the VPN trick still works in China.
- nly 4y agoAs a UK citizen and resident I've been using an always on VPN on my personal laptop and mobile for 10 years. The major UK ISPs already log all DNS queries and a hell of a lot of TCP data and make it all accessible to authorities.
- ggm 4y agoA bit of history, from the cryptography legislation laws of the 90s: http://www.kuner.com/historical-materials-on/ http://www.kuner.com/historical-materials-on/ https://www.oreilly.com/library/view/web-security-privacy/0596000456/ch04s04.html https://www.oreilly.com/library/view/web-security-privacy/05...
- _2uwr 4y ago[dead]