10 ms·
As a non-hiker, I had no idea access to national parks was gated behind some unholy combination of Ticketmaster and gambling. This is asinine--but a uniquely Am
by ryandrake 4y ago
As a non-hiker, I had no idea access to national parks was gated behind some unholy combination of Ticketmaster and gambling. This is asinine--but a uniquely American flavor of asinine. The fact that a private business consulting company collects most of the money makes it even more American Asinine. I feel like my fingers are turning red, white, and blue just typing that out.
I (naively) always thought you just drove to your destination, parked and went hiking.
- ploxiln 4y agoMost places in the US are like that - just show up. Some places are too popular and would be way too crowded, and the situation is pretty dire for the most majestic and famous places around SF. I did the popular half dome trail in yosemite, jeez ... 10 years ago, and despite the limits it was quite a crowded line, at the cable you hold while climbing up the slope of the dome. My family goes hiking in Shenandoah in Virginia almost every year (probably 15 times in my life) and we don't reserve entry or trails or anything, and there's no lines. Anyway, it's a kinda funny situation - do you want to promote the outdoors to the general populace? Do you want them to be accessible to all? Well you just can't, the popular places will be absolutely crushed and destroyed and quite dangerous too. There's plenty of un-popular places people could go, but they're not popular ...
- zhoujianfu 4y agoThey should just make it a raffle instead of first come first served. That’s what all the online drop collectible places do now after a few years of fighting the bot arms race.
- cldellow 4y agoCanada has some national parks that do something like this. Lake O'Hara's booking system this year is a random queue: > In lieu of a random draw, Parks Canada will be employing a queuing system to help manage the expected high demand. Users may navigate to the reservation service webpage beginning at 7:30 AM. At 8:00 AM all users waiting will be randomly assigned a place in the queue. This is not influenced by how long users have been waiting. Any users arriving to the website after 8:00 am will be placed in the back of the line. When users reach their turn, they will be alerted via an on-screen message. At that point, they have 30 minutes to proceed to the reservation website and make a reservation.
- geraldwhen 4y agoIf this is queue-it, there are mass automation tools. Even if it isnt, $50 in resi proxies will give you 100 positions in the queue vs 1. Source: I won a lot of queues by Sony, AMD, and Walmart.
- Retric 4y agoHolding a lottery without limiting people to one entry by say requiring your name to enter is dumb, but I am not surprised this happens.
- geraldwhen 4y agoGerald, Gerrald, Ger.ald. Sony was restricting PS5s by address at one point, but adding an apartment number (to a house) or a 0 to an address got around the limit for the first year. Depending on how valuable the item is, an incredible amount of manpower will go into defeating bot protections. I made a lot of money after spending a lot of time doing adversarial research and bot development.
- Retric 4y agoIt’s easy enough to require the name to exactly match the credit card name used or your kicked out of the fast queue. That’s the thing about these lotteries, rejecting people isn’t an issue.
- geraldwhen 4y agoCredit card name can also be fudged. And with 200 valid queue positions with <1 minute timers, that’s a lot of attempts. I’ve beaten every queue system I’ve come across, and that includes at least 8 different retailers.
- Retric 4y ago> Credit card names can also be fudged. Not really, in cases where it actually matters like car rentals they don’t let you do many things that “fool” the half assed systems. Frankly most queue systems aren’t designed to be robust because the company doesn’t care they are making the same money either way.
- oh_sigh 4y agoWhat would stop bot makers from just having thousands of their bots enter the raffle?
- bluecalm 4y agoThis happens for material things all the time (collectibles, snickers, limited edition of anything) but in case of experiences (concerts, access to trails) the id verification at entry is a good mechanism to defend against it.
- tshaddox 4y agoCharging a nominal fee to enter the raffle might. Like how all raffles work by definition.
- kwhitefoot 4y agoJust make the ticket personal and non-transferable. No need to disadvantage the poor to make it 'fair'.
- throwaway049 4y agoGlastonbury Festival does non-transferable by having a long period to register interest and upload a photo of yourself, then if you snag a ticket your photo gets printed on it and checked at the entrance. Their primary problem was resellers - it's still a scramble when the ticket sale begins.
- oh_sigh 4y agoGood to fight against resellers but bad for normal users - some people might get sick, or have something else come up, and not being able to give a ticket to a friend is a bad experience.
- Thiez 4y agoOTOH since this scheme eliminates scalpers tickets may be significantly cheaper, which is a good experience. I imagine it is a net positive.
- bluecalm 4y agoIt's not like raffle solves the problem. Instead of bots you can multi accounters/users. The logistics is more complicated but doable if the item is desirable enough.
- greiskul 4y agoFor something physical, specially something run by the government, you can ask people during account creation for some identification like full name + date of birth, not allow duplicate accounts to enter the same raffle, and check the id of the winners when they get there (so you don't have companies creating bots).
- throw9away6 4y agoHarder to game, if desired enough people will still game it by buying entries for others
- cowsandmilk 4y agoGrand Canyon’s river lottery doesn’t use recreation.gov and has measures to prevent multi accounters including lifetime bans (which have been enforced) if you apply with multiple accounts in the same lottery.
- bluecalm 4y agoI was answering to a comment any collectibles. There multi-accounting is rampant and little can be done about it. When it comes to non-physical goods then a lot more can be done about enforcement.
- eru 4y agoWhy a raffle and not an auction? Auctions are the standard way to find a price that balances supply and demand. (Give poor people money, if you think they need the help. No need to decide for them what is best for them by giving them help in the form of tickets. Are you afraid they'll buy booze instead?)
- xnorswap 4y agoAuctions are terrible because of the uneven distribution of wealth. You end up with a situation where the wealthy can do everything and the poor can do nothing. And then there's the super rich, who could buy out the possibility of anyone else participating, literally turning such places into their private playground for eternity if they so wished. Like, what price could you price it at where: 1. You could afford to go occassionally 2. Elon Musk couldn't just buy out every single ticket for the next decade to make it their personal playground. There's simply no feasible solution to that. Just auctioning everything and letting capitalism take its course just denies a vast segment of society from participating at all for activities where demand outstrips supply. Supply & Demand only works if supply can be increased, so that as prices rise there's incentive for greater supply. For things like National Parks or Taylor Swift concerts, price discovery through "supply and demand" does not work because supply can't increase to match supply no matter the price.
- eru 4y agoGive poor people money, if you want to help them. Giving them a park ticket is equivalent to giving them the auction price for the ticket but restricting them to use it on park tickets. Very condescending and paternalistic. > Supply & Demand only works if supply can be increased, so that as prices rise there's incentive for greater supply. No? Where did you get that idiosyncratic notion from? Auctions work just fine for eg van Gogh paintings, and they have been in decidedly fixed supply since 1890. Auctions also work well for things that are in fixed demand. Of course, in that case you have suppliers bid, not buyers. You can also have a two-sided auction where both suppliers and buyers bid.
- 4y ago
- refurb 4y agoThis is what they do with The Wave. I believe they allow 20 per day. 10 are first-come first-served and 10 are a lottery you can enter for a few dollars in advance. Seems pretty fair to me.
- shp0ngle 4y ago...that is exactly what the actual article is talking about. The lottery makes most money go to Booz Allen Hamilton.
- refurb 4y agoHow do we know the money goes to Booz Allen? Presumably there is some sort of contract between BAH the government to run Recreation.gov? Does BAH keep the whole fee? Do they keep some of it? Did they get paid $0 and only get the fee?
- giantg2 4y agoA lot of that is in the article. Nice little graphs of it too.
- refurb 4y agoPlease point it out? All I see is how much goes to the park, with the assumption the rest goes to recreation.gov, but just because the recreation.gov gets it doesn't mean Booz Allen keeps it all.
- jfengel 4y agoBooz is recreation.gov.
- refurb 4y agoI get that, but Booz is a government contractor providing this service. Presumably there is some details in the contract that lay out where money collected goes. Some fees collected go to the Park Service, and some don't. Does Booz keep everything else? What are the contract details with the government?
- shp0ngle 4y ago...do people actually read the articles before commenting? There is a raffle. And the money from the ruffle goes to Booz Allen Hamilton.
- giantg2 4y agoNo, it appears half the people here did not read the article nor even look at the graphs.
- jefftk 4y agoThe article doesn't say that Booz's contract lets them keep the lottery fees--do they?
- lifeonlars 4y agoWho do you think gets them if they don't go to the parks service?
- 93po 4y agomaybe the hat and tie wearing bears in the parks are running the lotteries and stealing the money for themselves
- clusterhacks 4y agohttps://www.wsj.com/articles/national-park-fees-booz-allen-68d4d6d8 https://www.wsj.com/articles/national-park-fees-booz-allen-6...
- klempner 4y agoThe legitimate "raffle" structure in question does not typically require people to pay if they don't win the raffle.
- ghaff 4y agoSo long as people have to pay if they win the raffle, I'm hard put to see the justification for a raffle entry fee.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoWhat if we tackled the bot arms race differently? Instead of fighting it, embrace it - and fight the market for support services instead. That is, let people script their way if they want to, just make them do it in the open, and treat it as a match-making problem. The scheme would be as follows. There's N levels on the ladder, with some amount of tickets allocated to each level. Bottom level is for normal people without tech augmentation; most tickets are allocated there, and aggressive bot detection is employed. You can implement a raffle there if it feels more fair. Remaining levels on the ladder are for those who want a chance to get ahead with automation. Apply Elo or whatever chess players or Overwatch uses to make sure people compete at their level of sophistication. This would reward and incentivize individuals learning useful life skills, while making selling the tools less useful. Of course I can think of 10 reasons why this wouldn't work in practice, but hey, I never heard anyone even considering this idea before, so maybe it can be rescued somehow.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoI want to go hiking, not play some stupid game.
- rob74 4y agoThe exception that confirms the rule is The Wave, which is located somewhere in the middle of nowhere on the Utah-Arizona border and only accessible via a lengthy hike, but has the distinction of having been the epitome of "instagrammable" already years before Instagram was invented: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wave_(Arizona) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wave_(Arizona)
- tshaddox 4y agoI’m not sure what you mean about that being an exception. The Wikipedia article details an extremely strict application process to access that place.
- rob74 4y agoWhat I meant is that it's not one of the "majestic and famous places around SF", like Yosemite, it's really remote - but due to the strict limitation to only ~64 people per day, it's still the most sought after destination (making the most money for Booz Allen Hamilton).
- allturtles 4y ago> My family goes hiking in Shenandoah in Virginia almost every year (probably 15 times in my life) and we don't reserve entry or trails or anything, and there's no lines. I went to look up hikes in Shenandoah since this sounds like it could be part of a nice road trip with my family, and ironically I found that the most popular trailhead requires getting tickets through recreation.gov: https://www.nps.gov/shen/planyourvisit/faqs-oldrag.htm https://www.nps.gov/shen/planyourvisit/faqs-oldrag.htm So perhaps the problem is spreading? Luckily it seems it's not nearly at "The Wave" levels of scarcity, you can actually get tickets on most days: https://www.recreation.gov/ticket/10088450/ticket/10088451 https://www.recreation.gov/ticket/10088450/ticket/10088451
- ghaff 4y agoDay hiking permits are fairly uncommon on US federal lands in my experience. Backpacking permits are significantly more common but except for the extreme cases as are mentioned in the article are fairly easy to come by--except maybe at the most extreme times--and are commonly free (except for maybe parking).
- alistairSH 4y agoOld Rag is a fairly unique hike for the area. The upper part of the hike is an exposed rock scramble with good views. The hike, in total, is long enough to be challenging, but not really technical or dangerous. And it's close enough to DC (<2 hours) that weekends were a madhouse, especially during COVID. The remained of the park, and all the surrounding areas, are first-come, either free or with minimal permit/entrance fees.
- foobar_______ 4y agoReservations only became required for Old Rag somewhat recently. I think this is a covid thing. I'm really torn, I want people to be happy and healthy outside but covid and social media has made doing this a mad house. Regulating day tickets is a necessity at most places nowadays
- 0_____0 4y agoIt's getting to the point where areas that are under consideration for becoming National Park land get significant pushback from locals — we don't want to become another Yellowstone, they say! In the Northeast you do see some spots getting a little crowded but it's absolutely nothing like the tourism-industrial complex that are the big western national parks. Acadia is about as bad as it gets here, but mostly it looks like "theres a lot of folks here." Yellowstone is a mess of badly driven RVs, yahoos ripping around on rented side-by-sides, just a lot of really ugly concentrated MURCA.
- ghaff 4y agoAcadia is broken up enough that, if you stay away from certain sections of the park loop road and Mt. Cadillac, it's pretty manageable. Though even the western parks are a bit like that. The Yosemite Valley is a mob scene for much of the year. But there are actually pretty large and very nice sections of the park that aren't nearly as bad.
- InitialLastName 4y ago> Acadia is about as bad as it gets here, Acadia is about all there is in the northeast, in terms of National Parks. The positive side is that there's a ton of wilderness in the northeast that doesn't suffer from the National Park marketing badge (and thus any draw from the rest of the country), and so are less insane. Even so, some of the state parks within a reasonable trip of NYC (notably Harriman/Bear Mountain) can get a bit crazy.
- ghaff 4y agoThere is now the Katahdin Woods and Waters National Monument in Maine--although that was (and probably still is) controversial among some locals. It's fairly remote by northeastern standards. It's adjacent to Baxter State Park but the latter significantly limits cars in the popular area of the park. The issue for locals wasn't so much crowding as I recall but concerns about restrictions to traditional sporting uses of the land. I haven't really followed how all that played out.
- 4y ago
- eru 4y agoThey should just auction the ticket off. Very straight-forward, and all the money can go to the park. (Give poor people money, if you think they need the help. No need to decide for them what is best for them by giving them help in the form of tickets.)
- refurb 4y agoThat doesn’t make a lot of sense. If you give poor people money so every can equally bid on the auction, then why not just make it a lottery and not bother giving poor people money they’ll just give back through auction?
- maxerickson 4y agoPresumably they are talking about giving poor people money out of a different bucket, so it isn't "just" going back through the auction, the people that receive it have the opportunity to allocate it to their needs and desires.
- eru 4y agoYou give poor people money, so they can make their own decisions on what they want to spend it on. Instead of restricting them ad hoc to eg national park entries or whatever you think should be provided in-kind by raffles.
- refurb 4y agoIf your goal is to make national park entries more fair that seems like a very indirect way of doing it.
- greiskul 4y agoIf all the money goes to the park, none is going to the poor people. Seems like you are advocating for a system where rich people get to go to public parks, and poor people get nothing. And if you are doing a raffle for park tickets, you are not deciding to "help them in the form of tickets" for them. They signed up for the tickets. They want to go to the park. Is it a bad idea to allow poor people that want to access a park to have a chance of doing so? And auctions are a way of optimizing pricing of stuff. But not everything in life is about money. For instance, organ donation recipients. Do you think an auction system for organs would be a better world than the existing systems? Should we just give the poor people that wouldn't be able to afford an auction for an organ some money, and then let them die?
- elbigbad 4y agoThe post to whom you’re responding definitely overstates it. Most places are mostly just show up, there’s regularly or always ways to simply day hike anywhere — including the Enchantments, which are unrestricted for day hiking and I’ve personally day hiked in a day. Not allowing all comers on all days is prudent because our national parks are a precious resource. I’ve personally seen trails being eroded over years, it stinks, and more people on those trails cause more erosion. But yes you nearly always can simply drive out, park, and hike. BAH is a scourge and absolutely a problem though.
- throwaway2037 4y agoI’ve personally seen trails being eroded over years, it stinks, and more people on those trails cause more erosion. Why don't they rotate the trails? I've seen this done on Jeju, South Korea. They close an over-worn section, then open a parallel section.
- whinenot 4y agoOftentimes, there is only one physically possible route to the most popular Instagramable view, like Vernal Fall in Yosemite NP or Angels Landing in Zion NP.
- throwaway2037 4y agomost popular Instagramable view Oh, that makes sense. Ok, then close the trail for 6-12 months. That should do.
- ricw 4y agoYou can quickly complain to governor newsom via this link (the article lists mostly Californian parks - hence this being appropriate): https://www.gov.ca.gov/contact/ https://www.gov.ca.gov/contact/
- greenie_beans 4y agoi think you'd need to complain to your federal representatives since the national parks and the booz allen contract are overseen by the federal government
- tiedieconderoga 4y agoYou can just show up and park. You can buy an annual pass directly from the government for ~$100 that covers campsite/entrance fees in pretty much every national park, or put some cash in an envelope with a form and leave it in a dropbox at the lot. The problem is peak seasons. If you show up to Yellowstone without a reservation on the 4th of July weekend, you'll be lucky if you can even get into the park, much less stay there or appreciate its natural beauty. So if you want to visit a park during a holiday, school vacation week, or most of the Summer, you need to deal with the bloated mess of a ticketing system which was created by the cheapest new grads that the lowest-bidding rent-seeking leech of a contractor could come up with. My advice: get used to cold weather and visit in the off season. Nobody is making reservations to hike in Bryce Canyon in the middle of December.
- ghaff 4y agoOne caveat. The America the Beautiful pass does not cover campgrounds that have a nightly fee. In general, I agree about trying to go to parks off peak season (and getting away from the more popular trails). That said, your hiking and other options can be a lot more limited at many parks that get a lot of snow in the winter relative to other seasons even if you have winter gear. (I've been to Bryce in the winter and it was hard to follow a trail in the canyon.)
- patrickwalton 4y agoThat said, Bryce canyon is stunning in the middle of December (if there's snow).