12 ms·
Searches for VPN Soar in Utah Amidst Pornhub Blockage
- LinuxBender 4y agoMirror [1] [1] - https://archive.is/a9wlZ https://archive.is/a9wlZ
- MuffinFlavored 4y agoDo we think VPNs will ever be banned in a state like Utah?
- detaro 4y agoThe "TikTok ban" draft (RESTRICT Act) is providing a template on federal level according to various comments on that.
- MuffinFlavored 4y agoIs the "TikTok ban" draft (RESTRICT Act) for consumers/regular people or only government personnel? Aka, are they really going to ban TikTok for regular people or just make it so govenment personnel can't install TikTok on their device? aka, only ban TikTok for government people and not regular people
- beepbooptheory 4y agoIts for everyone, not just government personnel. https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/686?s=1&r=15 https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/686... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35369075 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35369075
- detaro 4y agoHopefully the thing is going to fail and they are not going to do anything. But yes, it provides for banning government-choosen foreign sites entirely, with heavy penalties for assisting in circumventing blocks. (Although I guess VPN services could avoid it by filtering their users traffic themselves)
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> it provides for banning government-choosen foreign sites entirely, with heavy penalties for assisting in circumventing blocks I recently heard the argument that TikTok is a media control issue. Rupert Murdoch famously had to become an American to buy Fox. Applying that precedent seems cleaner than the RESTRICT Act.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI'm generally pro-migration but in Murdoch's case I don't think it worked out well for his new neighbors.
- swamp40 4y agoDon't you just have to move the VPN offshore? China could even spin up their own VPN companies.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Don't you just have to move the VPN offshore Payment would still be a problem.
- throwaway742 4y agoI pay for my VPN with cryptocurrency.
- smolder 4y agoIt doesn't appear to have much to do with TikTok at all, from what I saw. It looks more like a regular old power grab by the federal government over tech generally, moving us towards censorship and overt surveillance and punishing circumvention.
- seanp2k2 4y agoI'm 100% sure that no one who works for the government knows how to acquire and operate a separate smartphone either /s
- struanr 4y agoI feel like a VPN ban might be difficult to enforce due to corporate usage of the same technology
- freedomben 4y agoI doubt they try to ban them, but I could absolutely see them push an age verification requirement for "personal" VPNs that allow you to get an out-of-state IP address since it "illegally circumvents state laws". So you can have a VPN, but if you are in Utah the exit node must also be in Utah. Corporate VPNs wouldn't be a problem legally because they already verify your identify for state tax purposes so there's nothing more for corporate to do. Bonus: while your every access to porn is being logged for the state, they can log your VPN use too just in case there is anything relevant for law enforcement to care about.
- BeFlatXIII 4y agoHow would a law like that be enforced if none of the VPN's personnel or physical assets are in Utah or if they're entirely outside the US?
- jrockway 4y agoI think they think they can just block them on a case-by-case basis, but that is harder than they think it is because IP bans will get most of AWS, and therefore the Internet blocked, and then the only option is an HTTPS MITM proxy, which would then break any site with cert pinning. Past options that don't work anymore include SNI inspection (replaced with ESNI/ECH, but wasn't hard to circumvent; say you want good.com when you're doing SNI, say you want evil.com when sending a Host: header), and DNS blocks (but now DNS-over-HTTPS is a thing, so as difficult to control at the state level; would require a court to compel in-state DNS-over-HTTPS providers to publish fake facts, which violates federal law; but irrelevant because AWS, Cloudflare, and Google don't have any assets of value in Utah). I'd say it's basically impossible to ban VPNs. If it happens, you'll see random VPN employees detained/arrested while on vacation or something like that, unless the news cycle blows over. China can do it, because they can just kill tech execs that won't cooperate, but we typically don't do that in the US.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoA few years ago, Walmart stopped stocking (some) beer in Utah because it was too difficult for them to bother getting the 3.2% alcohol by weight beer which had been the limit in Utah at the time[0]. Ultimately Utah's legislature decided to change the 3.2% restriction. I suspect this will go that way; more services will just say that they don't need to serve that population and move on. There will be a lot of people saying they like using their VPN totally because it keeps me private online and VPNs will just be normalized. [0] https://www.fox13now.com/2018/12/11/walmart-joins-the-push-for-utah-to-ditch-3-2-beer-as-six-packs-start-disappearing-from-shelves https://www.fox13now.com/2018/12/11/walmart-joins-the-push-f...
- freedomben 4y agoIt will certainly be interesting to see. Utah is an interesting case because generally speaking high percentages of the population will praise and promote "freedom" and "liberty." Of course with humans often stated/conscious beliefs and actions are often disjointed, but there's still an interesting angle there where the state is a lot more limited on what it can do in the enforcement arena before people start pushing back. That said though, porn access in Utah would be a hard one for the average person to stand up for because the social pressure there is immense (speaking from experience here). The dominant religion teaches that "free agency" is an important and indeed essential aspect of our lives. We are here on Earth to grow and develop and learn to make good (i.e. obedient to God) choices. They even believe that a War in Heaven happened that split the masses because Satan (aka the Devil) wanted to force people to be righteous, but Jesus' plan was to give them choice. You would think they'd be a bunch of libertarians then, but no they clearly believe that God shouldn't force you to be righteous, but the state should. Furthermore God has told their prophets that things like alcohol, marijuana, porn, are wicked and sinful. Reducing or eliminating your access to them is for your own good (and the good of "society") and is therefore justified. I've tried pointing out that when it comes to enforcing your morals on others it can literally be taken to China-level authoritarianism with the same justication of "good for society," but that never seems to get anywhere.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y ago
- spacebanana7 4y agoBanning VPNs would be very difficult for a US state. In China VPN restrictions are somewhat effective because of compliance from consumer platforms, ISPs and cloud service providers all operating inside a largely isolated pocket of the internet. If any of those stakeholders refused to play along or could operate outside of enforcement range then the VPN ban would fail. A ban isn’t truly impossible, especially with support from courts and the federal government, but I think it’s similar to the difficulty level of banning pirated content.
- ignoramous 4y agoThat will accelerate the coming of on-device AI generated porn apps.
- olliej 4y agoThe many (one would hope most?) tech and tech-adjacent businesses, the federal government, etc all require VPNs, so it would be hard to see how "ban VPNs for this already banned thing" would even work.
- paxys 4y agoProbably not, but only because it would be too technologically complex for them to do. VPN companies don't operate in their jurisdiction and don't care about Utah law.
- mindslight 4y agoThis is fantastic news! Thank you government of Utah! Your authoritarian grandstanding isn't likely to do much over the long term, given basic American values like freedom of expression. But in the meantime it will encourage people to get educated on basic ways of evading censorship, while simultaneously discouraging other sites from hassling visitors based on IP address.
- _8j50 4y agoThis is such an HN comment. Democratically elected politicians enact laws that reflect the conservative views of their voters and that is totalitarian because they are controlling every aspect of government centrally with all decisions made my unelected leaders? No, because you disagree with it, that's it. You know, I dislike both liberalism and conservatism but in the US specifically, I feel like there is a particular misunderstanding with liberally minded people about what the US is supposed to be. If your fundamental human rights or other protected rights are violated I get it, but watching porn is not a right if any kind, states can restrict any aspect of your life that isn't protected as a right. There is already a restriction on adult material that involved minors or unwilling participants, this simply expands it to all people, and there is plenty of research and reasoning that indicates porn is harmful to everyone, period! Personally, I find it more reasonable if you argued cigarettes are healthy compared to what porn does to your mind and therefore life. The whole point of a federal union is you move to other states when you don't like the laws, and everybody gets to exist with the most ideal liberty vs restriction ratio. For the "land doesn't vote" people who think the electoral college should be abolished? this is exactly why it exists, so crazy states line utah or missisipi don't have to leave the union. I am far from a secessionist but the electoral college was literally a critical component of the contract that states agreed to when joining the union. You need to understand that short of a global nuclear war, there are few things that are worse for humanity as a whole (even more so for americans) than a civil conflict between american states. The whole point of post here is that so long as these crazy state laws reflect the views of those who live there and existing (not future) rights of protected individuals are not violated, drop the exaggeration and tolerate them as you vehemently disagree with them.
- 4y ago
- yegor 4y agoNordVPN is probably raking it in right now with the amount of BS marketing that they do....
- graypegg 4y agoReally gives some insight to why VPN companies have been fighting for mindshare the past few years. Just waiting for a case like this to pop up and be the first service people think of.
- millzlane 4y agoIt worked for https://greenhealthdocs.com/ https://greenhealthdocs.com/ in Maryland. They advertised heavily before legalization framework was in place. People didn't know they just needed to fill out a state form that's approved automatically pay $50 to the state, and pay a small fee $75-$80 to a certified doctor, dentist, nurse, or midwife for a cannabis recommendation. Instead, they greenhealth charges 200 bucks to people.
- loeg 4y ago$200 vs $130, billed by one provider instead of several, and you can figure out how to do it via the internet seems... fine?
- post-it 4y agoLeast profit-gouging healthcare provider in the country.
- jermaustin1 4y ago$70 convenience fee that is one time seems like an ok amount to spend for a one time specialized shortcut.
- mardifoufs 4y agoIs it BS in this case though? VPNs are the best tool in this scenario, and when you want to avoid geoblocking in general.
- commandlinefan 4y agoSomewhat ironic that they're going to be paying for the VPN (on top of already paying the ISP) while still not actually paying for the content itself.
- smolder 4y agoPaying for porn would support the industry! That would be immoral! Just looking is okay, though.
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoAh yes, in fact looking for free costs the providers something, so it's clearly an ongoing campaign to drive them out of business, hallelujah.
- barbazoo 4y agoHow do you know that they aren't?
- zsz 4y agoGiven how well the porn industry does regardless of the rest of the economy, it would be interesting to see how they would do if a sizeable portion of "users" actually paid for their services. Enterprising individuals might consider next how the same industry could counterintuitively profit from such legislation, by starting their own VPN service (which would, for example, not suffer from similar dropouts, connection resets, bandwidth related issues, etc. as competing services). I guess it would finally put to rest the question we've all been asking ourselves all along: are people using VPN services primarily to hide their piracy-related activities, or has it been mostly to hide their sexual fetishes?
- booleandilemma 4y agoWhat kinds of porn do Mormons like?
- knicholes 4y agoThere's a site that caters exactly to Mormon-themed porn, and having been a "Mormon," or a "member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints" for a couple decades, I can vouch that it is truly hilarious. Here's some stats per state, in case you were wondering about any others: https://wour.com/nsfw-pornhub-reveals-most-popular-searches-by-state-really-new-york/ https://wour.com/nsfw-pornhub-reveals-most-popular-searches-...
- nashashmi 4y agoIt is unbelievable the amount of targeted advertising they do to religious groups to somehow dislodge them from their previous strictness. Mormons are not alone.
- scooter7364 4y ago[flagged]
- walrus01 4y agoHeterosexual missionary position in a dark room under a blanket between married couples for the purposes of procreation only
- themitigating 4y ago[flagged]
- 0zemp2c 4y ago[flagged]
- reducesuffering 4y agoSoaking
- notfried 4y agoIn March, why was Virginia the highest state in the U.S. for searches for VPN, with a score higher than Washington, California and New York, per the article?
- boc 4y agoGovernment employees and contractors
- m463 4y agospies doing remote work
- kibwen 4y agoCIA operatives in Langley inflating the numbers, clearly.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> CIA operatives in Langley inflating the numbers, clearly This was my first thought, too. But these aren't data for VPN usage. Just searches. Why would Langley have a bunch of people Googling VPNs in March?
- yftsui 4y agoMy hypothesis: people who are already using VPN egress traffic in IAD (which has the largest AWS region), thus the results based on IP address is skewed by people who actually live in other countries or maybe even continents.
- anonymouscaller 4y agoWouldn't int'l users choose the location closest to them? If you're in China for instance you're probably going to be using SIN or TPE. Besides, most VPN providers avoid Amazon and use colo providers that give much better deals on bandwidth.
- esotericimpl 4y ago[dead]
- erenyeager 4y agoActually I think this is really good that we see more regulation around access to pornography, because many damaging aspects of it have been raised more in public awareness and these companies have made a lot of money off of addicting populations from a young age with harmful content without paying for the consequences. Social media companies should be included also, considering how many children and teens are on social media platforms looking for sexual activity with adults.
- atleastoptimal 4y agoThe issue is porn is a natural addiction. Young people, especially young men will always be horny and seek out porn. The only deterrents to it are religious and cultural shaming. Is the solution to regulate porn with "education" so people know what healthy use is or not? Because while it seems reasonable to provide guidelines, 99% of people will ignore them.
- erenyeager 4y agoSometimes what seems natural is because the water was poisoned for so long. Yes, it is natural to have sexual desire, but is unfettered spread of porn with a few taps easily accessible at any age really something we should accept? And young men need a lot of support, in my anecdotal experience it is too easy for so many to fall down negative paths with little support network to prevent it. Now with AI it is even more dangerous, we have deepfakes (see recent Canada news on deepfakes of children), and the spread of more isolation and addiction with the internet “drugs” compared to genuine in person interactions with friends and family. Technology like smartphones helped us in many ways but also they became a new way to suffer and amplified some existing problems. Shouldn’t we regulate the worst of it? I found more dangerous than porn is the ability to communicate with random adults online as a child, with often sexual endings. I remember growing up as a teen, there were sites like Omegle and then chat apps like kik and Snapchat and then Reddit, all these places had avenues for teens and children to communicate and swap pictures with adults, etc. with little to no regulation or consequences for these companies.
- 4y ago
- wepple 4y agoWhat is the device based authentication the PH page mentions? I’m a little scared to search for it whilst in a public space
- banana_giraffe 4y agoIt's a call out in the law that allows access to such material if authenticated with a Mobile driver's license, aka mDL ( https://dld.utah.gov/utahmdl/ https://dld.utah.gov/utahmdl/ ), aka ISO 18013-5.
- selimthegrim 4y agoYou would think Louisiana would follow suit as they have one as well
- wcoenen 4y agoI'm not seeing any such trend at trends.google.com: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?geo=US-UT&q=VPN&hl=en https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?geo=US-UT&q=VPN&hl=...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Waterluvian 4y agoAh I found it. Adjust query to a much shorter window.
- mirekrusin 4y agopast 7 days
- danielodievich 4y agoI have a favorite Utah story that is I think appropriate here. Many years ago as a young and green consultant I was sent to Salt Lake to help with some ASP.NET/C# app with Utah Department of Liquor. I was told to look for the tallest building in SLC and the warehouse did not disappoint, it was huge (well, SLC is really flat and squat too). They showed me the warehouse full of really fancy robotic stuff (all made in Utah, and they were correct to be proud of it). We got to work looking over the code of the app, and along the way they learn that I am originally from USSR/Russia. "Oh" the devs say, "do you want to see our Russia module"? I am of course intrigued, and discover that during the process of organization of 2002 SLC winter Olympics (Mitt Romney's baby/rise to prominence), there was a huge diplomatic incident. The rules of State of UT at the time limit the number of bottles sold to any one in a given transaction, and the Russian delegation was refusing to come to Utah because they would not be allowed to buy as much liquor (likely vodka) as they wanted to. This got escalated to the highest levels of State department, and the intrepid UT legislature found a way! They [very quickly] passed the law that any person with Russian citizenship could buy whatever the heck they want in any amount. Now it was up to the poor saps in the UT Dept. of Liquor to implement it. But you couldn't just rely on people showing passport! No, the software team feverishly coded up the "Russian Module" that implemented passport number validation, making sure that if you did show a red passport with double-headed eagle, its number was valid. There was serious collaboration on the numbering schemes and maybe even some proto API validation to the Russian Federation servers. Yeah, legit module. Used for 2 weeks, and then decommissioned as the law sunset very rapidly. So, where there is a will, there is a way. And a VPN.
- cpursley 4y agoFunny story if true. But honestly, the whole "Russian vodka bears blyat" stuff is disrespectful (and wrong). Because Russians actually prefer whiskey & brandy!! Also, Russia is not even in the top 15 countries in terms of alcohol consumption. Ukraine is higher, Finland is higher, Ireland is higher. But the worst offender: Russian vodka is not made of potatoes!! They use grains. It's actually the Polish who use potatoes.
- baybal2 4y ago
- xutopia 4y agoI'm just so surprised by how bad politics has become in the USA. It's like they want to have charia law... or Christian law as it were.
- Fauntleroy 4y agoUtah is a remarkably special part of the US, in this regard.
- asdff 4y agoThere's the landed elite ski crowd in Utah, but I guess they just fly into their timeshare in park city for 5 days a year and don't much care what happens outside that idyllic vacation.
- a-user-you-like 4y ago[flagged]
- buffington 4y agoI can't imagine why, with claims this juicy, you wouldn't share your sources. I'd recommend showing the data, or be prepared to defend these ideas without it.
- a-user-you-like 4y ago[flagged]
- jp57 4y agoThis two-post thread is a microcosm of American politics on all issues.
- a-user-you-like 4y agoGlad you can sit above it all with your third wayism while these women suffer.
- ubermonkey 4y agoGiven that VPN services typically require a credit card, and credit cards are unlikely to be available to most minors -- or at least provide plausible deniability to the providers -- this is probably 100% okay with the porn-banning Utahns.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoThe Opera browser has a free VPN built-in. It would be interesting to see data on Opera and Tor browser downloads there in the last week.
- ubermonkey 4y agoI had no idea! Yeah, that would definitely be interesting.
- coretx 4y agoOpera is no longer Norwegian. It's Chinese these days so that's exchanging one security problem for another.
- missedthecue 4y agoOpera is a private company traded on the norway stock exchange. What do you mean owned by China?
- plorkyeran 4y agohttps://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1737450/000143774922016090/opra20211231_20fa.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1737450/000143774922... > We have been a public company since 2018. In 2021, Kunlun, a Chinese public company and our largest investor, increased its ownership stake in us beyond 50%, and as a result we became a consolidated subsidiary of the Kunlun group. [...] As of the date of this annual report, Kunlun, a Chinese public company traded on the Shenzhen stock exchange, indirectly owns 55.60% of our issued and outstanding ordinary shares. As such, we are a consolidated subsidiary of Kunlun.
- paulpauper 4y agoI used to use VPNs. What a waste of money. Nothing but captchas, broken functionality, slowness, etc. It's obvious that at least some VPNs use low trust IPs and are blocked and filtered. You are better off just getting an E2 instance
- aqfamnzc 4y agoThat's not been my experience. I run an always-on VPN on my laptop and phone and never have issues. What service did you try?
- paxys 4y agoYou need to find a better provider. I have regularly used Private Internet Access, PureVPN and Torguard and have never had this experience with any of them.
- NikolaNovak 4y agoI don't understand pornhubs statement. What is device based authentication and why is it the best?
- seydor 4y agoSo this was all a plot of the VPN industry? Educating people how to use VPN is a very double-edged sword, because people will also learn that they no longer need to pay Netflix et al.
- themitigating 4y agoNo, it's Christian facism or were you joking?
- lolinder 4y ago> It will be seen that, as used, the word ‘Fascism’ is almost entirely meaningless. In conversation, of course, it is used even more wildly than in print. I have heard it applied to farmers, shopkeepers, Social Credit, corporal punishment, fox-hunting, bull-fighting, the 1922 Committee, the 1941 Committee, Kipling, Gandhi, Chiang Kai-Shek, homosexuality, Priestley's broadcasts, Youth Hostels, astrology, women, dogs and I do not know what else. > ... Except for the relatively small number of Fascist sympathizers, almost any English person would accept ‘bully’ as a synonym for ‘Fascist’. That is about as near to a definition as this much-abused word has come. > But Fascism is also a political and economic system. Why, then, cannot we have a clear and generally accepted definition of it? Alas! we shall not get one — not yet, anyway. ... All one can do for the moment is to use the word with a certain amount of circumspection and not, as is usually done, degrade it to the level of a swearword. -- George Orwell, What is Fascism?, 1944 https://orwell.ru/library/articles/As_I_Please/english/efasc https://orwell.ru/library/articles/As_I_Please/english/efasc
- tomrod 4y agoDecry the use of an accurate term, but recognize that the use of the state to control society is what folks are describing as fascism. I'd argue in Utah it's just plain Ole theocracy.
- lolinder 4y ago> the use of the state to control society is what folks are describing as fascism The vast majority of people who casually throw around the word "fascist" are very happy to have a large, interventionist state that controls society. All "fascist" seems to mean here is that the interventions chosen don't align with the speaker's values. > I'd argue in Utah it's just plain Ole theocracy. I can definitely go for theocracy as an accurate description.
- andrewclunn 4y agoConversely, one could set their VPN to Utah as a quick child protective measure
- knaik94 4y agoBlocking porn in this way doesn't meaningfully improve the protection of children. This kind of law often also negatively impacts access to sexual education.
- kelipso 4y ago[flagged]
- bigmattystyles 4y agoIs the law written such that the vpn is liable now or is it treated like the ISP?
- b8 4y agoLot's of Porn sites don't follows Louisiana's/Utah's ID laws etc. Including Reddit for now. I found out that my Google Fi data connects to an out of state tower which lets me bypass the sites which did implement law abiding walls/blocks. I wonder if more states interact such laws if Usenet/Torrenting will have higher demand as well.
- Thorentis 4y agoSad that porn use has become so widespread. People don't like to think about it, but I think the mass exposure to porn of the high speed internet generation will have serious negative effects.
- capableweb 4y ago> Sad that porn use has become so widespread Has it really though? Based on Google search traffic, "porn" as a keyword is actually declining since ~2013: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=porn&hl=en https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=porn&hl=... And before internet porn, the same people watching it online today would have browsed magazines or watched VHS/betamax with the same content.
- eternalban 4y ago> have browsed magazines or watched VHS/betamax with the same content. Who was this guy with stacks of new magazines on demand to say nothing of thousands of VHS/betamax to go through. /g HN needs to discuss these matters with a bit more honesty: Porn consumption is driven by the dopamine reward system. Porn is not music. You can listen to a song a zillion times (if you like it) but a specific item of pronography will very rapidly fail to arouse in repeated viewing. New material is required. Another aspect of porn consumption is that this 'need for variety' also creates plateaus at the content genre. Stronger material is required, progressively. And strength in porn is not a mere matter of explicitness (which also plateaus in a given genre). Taboos and norms operate at this level, when the genre gets stronger, which by the perverse inherent mechanics of how porn and male brains interact, it must get more subversive. So, yeah, back in the day you could get your Playboy at the 7 eleven but other materials required a visit to dodgey quarters. You also paid substantially for the privilege. And kids most certainly did not have access to hard porn. So at say 20 bucks a pop for DVD (2 hours of happy time max?) or close to 10 for a magazine (these are 20th century dollars btw) not that many people were even practically capable of getting hooked on porn. It could not even happen. Today you have free porn on tap, and algorithms (based on well understood mechanics of porn by its peddlers) that continually goade you into 'stronger' content.
- deet 4y agoThese stories about Utah and the comments people make here on HN disappoint me. So many of them are based on prejudices and biases. I've lived in many places in the USA, from SF to Chicago to NYC to Utah. And honestly, they're just not all that different. People's sterotypes of the predominant LDS (Mormon) religion make them believe that Utah is unique and a theocracy. In reality much of American law is based on very similar Christian moral standards. Most states are majority Christian, the laws reflect that. The difference in Utah is that it's mostly _one_ religion, rather than say a mix of various protestant and Catholic faiths. Try walking around fully naked in any of the places I mentioned above, like into an office building or a university or other establishment, and I guarantee you that those more liberal places will also not tolerate that behavior. Not due to any direct harm you'd be causing, but due to moral standards encoded into culture and law. Same with alcohol, tobacco, and all the other "vices" people believe are banned in Utah (they're not). If you drive around downtown Salt Lake City, you'll see bars, signs for cannabis cards, smoke shops, and even a some decent breweries. It feels a lot like most American cities. (Granted that elsewhere in Utah like in Provo, you see many fewer of these). Nearly every state allows, but restricts and limits all of these substances and activities in various ways, from licensing to age limits, and Utah is not really very different. For porn specifically, there have been laws on the books in many states to restrict access to minors for a long time. In the age of magazines, do you think it was legal for a business in California to sell such materials to a minor? If not, why not? Because it was either deemed harmful or immoral, beliefs eventually rooted in religion. Beyond that, is Utah actually different than other places most Americans would respect for being more "level-headed", like the UK (https://www.wired.co.uk/article/uk-porn-ban-digital-economy-act https://www.wired.co.uk/article/uk-porn-ban-digital-economy-...) or Germany (https://www.wired.co.uk/article/germany-porn-laws-age-checks https://www.wired.co.uk/article/germany-porn-laws-age-checks)? Now, this specific law is impractical, Utah simply does not have the market power to induce a player like Apple or Google to make device-level age verification the way that Pornhub is suggesting. So the state of Utah has put into effect a law that will result in reduced access to porn (followed by subversion through VPNs) rather than actually age verification. And in the process the state is hurting its reputation. But the generalizations here about the state due to religious and political biases are just not helpful.
- 4y ago
- AbraKdabra 4y ago[flagged]
- tflinton 4y agoUtah actually has a rolled out Mobile ID program where you can choose which data to share, including just if you’re over 18 or 21. It can be validated via Utah’s public mID certificate. Easiest solution would be to implement that on sites requiring a DOB. Maybe then more than a miserable 24K of people would have them.
- sophacles 4y agoLots of people on here claiming vague "porn does damage" hysteria. Curiously, not one mention of what the damage actually is though. This leads me to believe it's pure nonsense born out of some religious delusion. Maybe not though so in all seriousness: * What is the damage? (not yet another "it's harmful" sentance, I'm literally asking for details to learn what you mean, if anything). * What is "widespread"? Presumably this can be presented in terms of % of population or other actual data shaped way. * What is the "addiction" boogeyman in this context? What are the dreadful consequences you hint at? (again, please don't just bring the vague bullshit about "its addicting, lots of companies make money from it" - actual data is my request) * What are the actual studies backing whatever articles you got your information from - do they even exist? Were they put out by some religious think-tank or by people who do science? I'm going way out on a limb here, trying to assume you all are making good-faith claims rather than faith-based wishes. Currently I really suspect this is more motivated by a cult that has old dudes interrogate children about their genitals grasping at control over those genitalia than any reasonable problem solving.
- davidgh 4y agoHere are a couple of references for you. Compulsive Internet Pornography Use and Mental Health: A Cross-Sectional Study in a Sample of University Students in the United States https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7835260/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7835260/ Is Internet Pornography Causing Sexual Dysfunctions? A Review with Clinical Reports https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5039517/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5039517/
- hgsgm 4y agoMen can't win. After centuries of being regarded as sex fiends who can't last nore than 2 minutes in bed, now "difficulty achieving orgasm" and "decreased libido" are considered dysfunctions.
- onion2k 4y agoThose states are two ends of a spectrum. There's a big 'normal, expected behavior' bit in the middle of that spectrum.
- uptownfunk 4y agoAccess to porn destroyed a lot of my friends lives growing up. 20+ years later they still haven't picked up the pieces. The lack of self-control, addiction, relationships, social life (no I am not saying porn caused it explicitly, but it is hard to deny there is some relationship). Can I think of any examples of people it helped? Not really. Does that mean we should block it? Ultimately that's for the courts to decide. Should we think about the impact to children? Once adults have fully formed brains and self-control mechanisms built up porn is probably not as high of a risk, but for children in middle and high school it doesn't seem like this is the right thing .
- kaba0 4y ago> no I am not saying porn caused it explicitly Then that’s just a baseless claim on which a law was made.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- didibus 4y agoSeems personal freedoms are being restricted at an all time high in the country who values freedom the most. I would hope this eventually rallies people from both sides of the political spectrum, civil liberties are the bastion of a free and democratic country. When it comes to liberties that affect one self, it should be a no brainer, government has no business there. When it comes to liberties that one person doing something can impact negatively others, than courts and legislation can come into play to make sure everyone's liberties are upheld, but honestly I'm seeing much too many things being taken up here, the bar for harm to others should be pretty high, it should follow a similar reasonable doubt process as criminal charges, you should show harm without reasonable doubt.
- mariojv 4y agoI’m curious, how would laws like the one Utah passed be enforced if a company doesn’t have a presence in Utah? Do Utah courts rely on the cooperation of courts and banks operating outside Utah to enforce fines and the like? I suppose if your bank operates in Utah or wants to do business with Utah entities, it could be enforced coercively that way. As laws in different states diverge further and further, it makes me wonder to what extent states stopping cooperation with each other is possible, or if entities will start operating entirely within a particular “safe harbor” state to protect themselves.
- MrBigOcean 4y agoSeems like the type of porn that is popular is problematic for some reason? "Lesbian Porn Is Utah’s Porn Of Choice" https://www.bustle.com/articles/156093-heres-the-most-popular-porn-in-utah https://www.bustle.com/articles/156093-heres-the-most-popula...