3 ms·
To me it would be somewhat more interesting to compare head-to-head mobile CPUs instead of comparing laptops and servers. In this particular microbenchmark, mob
by jeffbee 4y ago
To me it would be somewhat more interesting to compare head-to-head mobile CPUs instead of comparing laptops and servers. In this particular microbenchmark, mobile 12th and 13th-generation Core performance cores, and even the efficiency cores on the 13th generation, are faster than the M2.
- Dalewyn 4y agoIntel 12th and 13th gen both use the same efficiency cores.
- jeffbee 4y agoWell, on the ones I happen to have on hand the 12th gen hits 3300MHz and the 13th gen goes all the way to 4200MHz.
- Dalewyn 4y agoYeah well, the efficiency cores on a 12900K will be faster than those on an N100, so what is your point? We're discussing overall compute power differences between CPU architectures, minute differences in performance between identical-architecture CPU cores stemming from higher clock speeds is outside the scope of this discussion.
- refulgentis 4y agoNot for me, I understand and have had this reaction and it sort of undervalues the value of related info. I learned a bit from him and your response for example
- scns 4y agoEven when they are faster, the M2 is on the same die as the RAM and the bandwidth and latency are way better. That matters for compilation or am i mistaken?
- jeffbee 4y agoYou are mistaken. Just like everyone else who has ever repeated the myth that Apple puts large-scale, high-performance logic and high density DRAM on the same die, which is impossible. Apple uses LPDDR4 modules soldered to a PCB, sourced from the same Korean company that everyone else uses. Intel has used the exact same architecture since Cannon Lake, in 2018.
- ricw 4y agoI don't think that is true. Last I checked apple M1 max chips have up to 800GB/s throughput, whilst AMDs high end chips taper out at around ~250GB/s or so, closer to what a standard M2 chip does (not max, or pro version). at the top end they've got at least 2x the memory bandwidth than other CPU vendors, and that's likely the case further down too.
- wmf 4y agoThe Mx Max should be compared to a discrete CPU+GPU combination that does have comparable total memory bandwidth. It isn't automatically better to put everything on one chip.
- jsheard 4y agoIt's worth noting that Apples stated bandwidth numbers aren't really attainable in CPU-only workloads, so for the sake of comparison to discrete CPUs they're not that useful. The M1 Max is advertised as having 400GB/sec bandwidth but the CPU cores can only use about half of that - still impressive, but not as impressive as you might think from the marketing. (The M1 Ultra is the one with 800GB/sec bandwidth on paper)
- inkyoto 4y agoAnandtech has measured the 104 Gb/sec per a CPU core for the M1 Max and 210 Gb/sec circa per a CPU cluster bandwidths. M1 Max has 3x CPU clusters: 1x power effecient (2x cores) and 2x performance ones (4x cores each). Where it gets interesting is how access to the memory is multiplexed in the most extreme case where 3x CPU clusters, 32x GPU and 16x ANE cores are attempting to fetch memory blocks at different locations and at once. It is not unreasonable to presuppose that Apple Silicon contraptions use the switched memory architecture, however with such a high degree of parallelism it is very intriguing to know how the memory architecture has been actually designed and optimised. High performant memory access has always been a big deal that usually comes with big money attached to it via a, naturally, non-memory bus associated connection.