7 ms·
That chart is... bad. I'm not sure if there's a legitimate reason to represent the data as "percent change from Q2 2004" or if it was done intentionally to make
by lolinder 4y ago
That chart is... bad. I'm not sure if there's a legitimate reason to represent the data as "percent change from Q2 2004" or if it was done intentionally to make the comparison to other currencies look worse. I don't have access to look at the data in more detail because the only way to view the full report[0] is to email Eurizon SLJ Capital.
I pulled the data from the IMF for a better chart that shows how the currencies actually relate to each other [1]. Yes, there's been a substantial decline in the use of the dollar, but that's not because some other currency is shooting up to take its place. It looks like countries are diversifying their portfolios, not fleeing the dollar for another currency.
[0] https://www.eurizonsljcapital.com/dollar-smile/rapid-erosion-of-usd-dominance-as-a-reserve-currency/ https://www.eurizonsljcapital.com/dollar-smile/rapid-erosion...
[1] It's a bit slow to load, but here's the link: https://data.imf.org/?sk=c22e624f-ce09-4c9e-a70b-647defa52159&hide_uv=1 https://data.imf.org/?sk=c22e624f-ce09-4c9e-a70b-647defa5215...
- 0xDEF 4y ago>Yes, there's been a substantial decline in the use of the dollar, but that's not because some other currency is shooting up to take its place. It looks like countries are diversifying their portfolios, not fleeing the dollar for another currency. The bulk of the "diversifying their portfolios" is being done by China. The de-dollarization happening in other countries is a rounding error. Generally it is misleading to talk about the rise of "BRICS" and the "Global South". In most contexts it is only China that is relevant and the other countries are rounding errors.
- thriftwy 4y agoRussia has a good incentive to dedollarize now. It's actually harder for China because holding Yuan is not an option for them.
- generic92034 4y agoAnd I think it is misleading to treat a country like India, with the 5th highest GDP in the world, as rounding error.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoI think the rounding error is in relation to the amount of de-dollarization happening in these countries.
- rippercushions 4y ago> diversifying their portfolios, not fleeing the dollar for another currency Aren't these literally the same thing? Selling dollars and buying something else is dedollarization, regardless of whether it's for diversification or some other reason.
- aardvarkr 4y agoIf there’s nothing replacing the dollar as the dominant global currency then yeah, it’s a wildly different story. One is a story of diversifying investments so that your country’s wealth isn’t tied to a single country. The latter would mean a global shift in power with massive geopolitical ramifications.
- Phlarp 4y agoOne empire can crumble into nothing without another empire immediately taking it's place. Previously the rest of the world tripped over one another to put all their eggs into our basket. Now we are getting sideways looks with a mixture of "You doing OK America?" and quietly diversifying their portfolios.
- WeylandYutani 4y agoApparently nobody in the US seems to understand that debt ceiling shenanigans and government shutdowns makes them look like Argentina.
- chii 4y agoThe exact same sentiment was had last time. The consequences from these shenanigans last time had very little real impact - a _very_ slight increase in interest rate on treasuries. And i predict that this time, at the last minute, the bill will pass again, like every other time. Unless the republicans truly believe that it's worth going down with the ship for.
- 4y ago
- raverbashing 4y agoAlso I think people are confusing the two uses of the dollar: one as a reserve currency (money in your mattress) another one is for international trade It seems it's the latter that's most affected (as per the link 1 you posted) > While the Global South seems unwilling to continue to hold dollar assets, they do not seem to have the ability to divest from the US dollar as an international currency, particularly for financial transactions. We suspect it will be very difficult to overcome the strong network effects that have been behind the dollar’s international currency status. Well no crap Sherlock
- vbezhenar 4y agoAn issue with dollar as international trade currency is that all transactions are performed via US banks. And US is not a reliable party anymore, because they could freeze your accounts or decline your transaction if they don't like something about you. So governments which want to have some degree of freedom and independence in their actions will naturally move to other currencies. Good alternative could be a P2P currency which does not require any particular center to handle a transaction. Switching dollar to ruble or yuan does not seem like it could change something drastically. Though I don't really understand why governments need a single currency. Just use your own currency and exchange other currencies, it'll settle down eventually.
- zamnos 4y agoThe problem is it doesn't. It does balance out if you're a big wealthy nation with imports and exports. If you're a small poor nation with limited resources, money only ever flows out, and barely ever in, depleting the nation's treasury.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoIf they are instead buying things with US dollars, where do those dollars come from?
- stephen_g 4y ago
- aww_dang 4y agoIsn't part of this countries dumping their dollar reserves to defend their currency with buy-backs? Maybe a better metric would be: How much dollar denominated debt is out there?
- fredgrott 4y agoNote the reason the dollar works is that USA past wwII became the number one importer due to the baby boomer generation of consumers. Past the demographic shift, i.e. when Z gen become full time consumers, the country that has the most of those is still the USA, followed by Canada and Mexico. So its somewhat a false narrative on those basic facts.