11 ms·
Why is it so hard to pull off a lunar landing?
- neom 4y agoIf you wanna see the disappointment in the control room, here is the video: https://www.youtube.com/live/CpR1UUnix3g?feature=share&t=4284 https://www.youtube.com/live/CpR1UUnix3g?feature=share&t=428... Scrub to 1:11:20 And at 1:35:33 the folks in the background look like they're holding back tears.
- fuzzfactor 4y ago>the United States and the Soviet Union were racing to land there, they crashed spacecraft after spacecraft before each finally succeeded in 1966. The government space agencies were able to learn from each landing attempt. Roger. >Today, by contrast, private companies are expected to repeat these successes, without government resources and without lessons gleaned from many failed and successful missions Misplaced expectations. They're going to need more crashes. >the folks in the background look like they're holding back tears. This was not in the background when NASA astronauts were tragically lost before they got to the moon the first time. I expect anyone to repeat these failures until they have enough lessons learned themselves. >why is it so hard to pull off a lunar landing? Mother Nature is a bitch.
- mulmen 4y ago> This was not in the background when NASA astronauts were tragically lost before they got to the moon the first time. I don’t follow. Are you suggesting NASA mission control didn’t mourn the loss of Chaffee, Grissom, and White?
- hgsgm 4y agoIt was in the foreground.
- fuzzfactor 4y agoDefinitely what I had in mind. The whole world was heartbroken as awareness was universally raised about remaining risks even after such extensive and successful efforts had intentionally and brilliantly greatly reduced the possibilities. Lurking risks still exist and unforseen failure modes remain as defined. Space Shuttles were not fatality-free either.
- sidlls 4y agoOn the one hand we have people lauding SpaceX/Musk as super geniuses able to achieve great feats without the supposed waste and largesse of the government, and on the other we have the same group wringing their hands when expectations are set based on their gushing praise.
- fuzzfactor 4y ago"Naturally", it can take so much time to accomplish something working with nature, time is one of the most likely natural forces to cause expectations to exceed accomplishments or even possibilities. And when nature is working against you . . .
- eql5 4y agoRelated: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KpuKu3F0BvY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KpuKu3F0BvY
- gonzo41 4y agoI think people forget how much US national effort was dedicated to the space race. These guy's did incredibly well, even with modern advances for the money they are working with.
- ghaff 4y agoYes. And with a little less luck/skill, the Apollo 11 lunar landing could have ended up as a disaster too.
- bell-cot 4y agoA bit of backstory on just how far they went, to prepare for that mission-critical bit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_Landing_Research_Vehicle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_Landing_Research_Vehicle Note how willing they were to risk life and limb in training exercises, and Armstrong's comments on how important the skills gained there were to their actual mission success.
- bell-cot 4y agoThat...but also the generation which had (so to speak) stepped up and won WWII was running the show. Their skills at, experience with, and dedication to giga-scale technological development programs and bleeding-edge aerospace missions made an enormous difference.
- gonzo41 4y agoYou're overestimating an older generation and underestimating the impact of what you can do with unlimited money, and 400K people working on one problem.
- bell-cot 4y agoPerhaps. But ~unlimited money and ~unlimited people are the backstory for pretty much every massive government or corporate boondoggle, ever.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- machina_ex_deus 4y agoThe Apollo moon landings were such an insane achievement. They did it in a time where digital processing was in it's infancy and barely existed, minimization technology was undeveloped, many modern materials which are much stronger and lighter weren't invented yet. And they managed to live broadcast from the moon! Storage was in it's infancy, so even storing a video from the moon was impossible (they would need many reels of film that just wouldn't fit. Digital cameras weren't invented, you only had analogue cameras. Most of them required film - and can't be developed on the spot, it requires special equipment. So to get video from the moon, the used cathode ray tube cameras - and even the cathode ray tubes of TV news were huge at the time, you can look at pictures, these things used to take a whole truck to carry. But they managed to get a very small cathode ray tube camera there, and to film long videos of hours of missions on the moon. And get managed to broadcast it all with analogue RF all the way from the moon to earth. With no digital signal processing, because that wasn't fast enough back then for any real time use. And with surprisingly low noise for an analogue transmission. They made a whole network of receivers on earth to be able to do it. Today all of that would be cheap, but back then it must've been quite the achievement. They also had pretty minimal computational power available compared to newer attempts. But maybe putting a human in control is enough. Google's moon challenge is pretty cool. They actually wanted to give a bonus for taking pictures of the original moon landing site. That could've been really nice. But sadly, NASA was afraid that the site would be disturbed and declared no fight zone over it.
- CrampusDestrus 4y agoThis was a commercial vector, not some experimental top US priority stuff. It's unfortunate that aboard the commercial craft there was stuff from national space programs, but this was not comparable to NASA's mission. It's just like SpaceX exploding a ton of rockets to further their research instead of obsessing over getting everything perfect on first try. Unfortunately they should have done more mock missions, but there wouldn't have been enough funding I fear
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- eternalban 4y ago6 landing attempts, all successful, late 60s technology: mission launch land days since last successful landing --------------------------------------------------------------------- Apollo 11 July 16, 1969 July 20, 1969 - Apollo 12 November 14, 1969 November 24, 1969 126 Apollo 14 January 31, 1971 February 9, 1971 431 Apollo 15 July 26, 1971 August 7, 1971 272 Apollo 16 April 16, 1972 April 27, 1972 347 Apollo 17 December 7, 1972 December 19, 1972 316
- propogandist 4y agohas any of the recent attempts to the moon given us footage of the lunar lander and other machinery that was left behind from the prior missions? this would easily put the conspiracy theories to bed
- infradig 4y agoYes
- hgsgm 4y agoAnd No to the second question.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoYou can see the stuff left behind from earth, especially the retro reflectors.
- Silverback_VII 4y agoThe whole thing is not as clear-cut as you are portraying it here. Furthermore, not even the best-equipped amateur astronomer can verify it. And also: "Therefore either all retroreflectors have degraded such that their return signals fit to the scattered return from the lunar soil or the measurements were indeed taken to the lunar surface only." https://arxiv.org/abs/1805.05863 https://arxiv.org/abs/1805.05863
- emmelaich 4y agoHardly saying it's easy but ... >What makes landing on the Moon so difficult is the number of variables to consider Compared to Earth, surely it's easier. Less terrain difference, lower gravity. It's getting there and the remoteness is what makes it hard.
- Delk 4y agoOn the other hand, there's no atmosphere on the Moon to speak of, so you actually have to slow down using propulsion against the gravity for a soft landing. Heat from the atmospheric entry when getting back to the Earth is certainly a concern but the atmosphere also takes care of the vast majority of slowing the descent (or ~all of it, if you count the use of parachutes at the end).
- TeMPOraL 4y agoEarth gives you a stupidly wide margin of error, where the Moon gives you none (and Mars very little) - because of its dense atmosphere. Landing on a world with an atmosphere means there is a passive force that tries to get you stop (relative to the surrounding medium). So, as long as you survive the hell of reentry, you can help yourself with lifting surfaces and parachutes. In contrast, on the Moon, you have to zero out your velocity at exactly the right moment. Do it too late? Crash. Do it too early? Crash. Run out of fuel just a little bit too fast? Crash.
- bitL 4y agoDumb laser distance measurement should solve that easily for you. You can literally use some very basic math with thruster output based on your downward distance/speed.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoWhat was different about the Apollo missions that they were so overwhelmingly successful, but similar efforts fail today?
- azlev 4y agoTotal Apollo workforce: 400,000. https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20190617-apollo-in-50-numbers-the-workers https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20190617-apollo-in-50-num...
- cubefox 4y agoThe most important difference is probably the budget.
- T-A 4y agoAn unwelcoming view glared at Armstrong. Where the orbital maps indicated a smooth plain, there was instead a vast crater field and collections of truck-sized boulders. Flying manually and low on fuel, Armstrong leveled off and searched for a smooth spot. https://www.space.com/26593-apollo-11-moon-landing-scariest-moments.html https://www.space.com/26593-apollo-11-moon-landing-scariest-...
- 4rt 4y agoI scrolled down far enough to find something mentioning this, dozens of comments above just saying that robot landers must work better just because.
- aflag 4y agoThe budget, for one. It was 2-3% of the GDP at the time. These commercial efforts have nothing remotely close to that. Also failure was seen as a bigger deal for all involved (due to the soviet threat). So, they'd rather waterfall the hell out of that program rather than fail and do things iteratively. I'm sure these commercial projects will eventually succeed. But it takes time.
- spaceman_2020 4y ago
- chrisweekly 4y agoFun tangent: this moon lander game was posted here on HN recently: https://ehmorris.com/lander/ https://ehmorris.com/lander/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AbsoluteCabbage 4y ago[flagged]
- 7373737373 4y agoWhat stands out to me is: > Even if a lander makes it to the vicinity of the Moon, it still has to navigate its way down to the surface with no global-positioning satellites for guidance Was/is such a constellation ever planned? If not, why - due to the difficulty orbiting the moon?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- m4rtink 4y agoMoon is indeed hard to orbit (without constant course corrections) due to its lumpy gravitational field: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_concentration_(astronomy)#Effect_of_lunar_mascons_on_satellite_orbits https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_concentration_(astronom...
- williamDafoe 4y agoCruise missiles have an incredibly good terrain following navigation software - I don't think it's hard to navigate without GPS people get fat dumb and lazy because of GPS...
- wolverine876 4y agoThe US government is working on PNT (position, navigation, and timing), communications, awareness (tracking objects, the beginnings of 'space traffic control' (my term), etc.) and much more via multiple agencies, in order to 'domesticate' (my word) cislunar space, defined as from geosynchronous orbit out past the Moon. The best starting point I know of: National Cislunar Science & Technology Strategy https://web.archive.org/web/20221119151907/https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/11-2022-NSTC-National-Cislunar-ST-Strategy.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20221119151907/https://www.white... The Artemis program's infrastructure is expected (per some plans, at least) to be the foundation of permanent communication and PNT. The US Space Force is also working on 'Space Situtional Awareness'.
- bitL 4y agoFrankly, why is it so hard? The article doesn't really show anything outside dust playing role in the very final stage but most landings failed higher above ground. These days we even have lasers to instantly detect distance to the ground that could be incorporated real-time to thruster output. There is almost no atmosphere for friction so basic Newtonian mechanics should be able to make a decent landing. Orbital mechanics is also out of the question near the ground. Why is this still an unsolved problem?
- joshuahedlund 4y agoStill going to have margins of error with both the measurements and the corrections, right? If those margins are higher than what the Moon forgives…
- rbanffy 4y agoFully autonomous landing in unknown surfaces is still pretty difficult. Still, the Moon should be more forgiving than the Earth - no wind, lower gravity...
- m4rtink 4y agoNo atmosphere - need to brake all of the velocity difference with engines & can't use aerodynamic surfaces or parachutes. On a body with atmosphere you can essentially just drop a payload up to some maximum size with a proper heat shield and a parashute and it will end up (somewhere) on the surface in one piece. On an atmosphere less body you essentially need to run precisely controlled flight all the way to touchdown. Everything has tradeoffs. :-P
- messe 4y agoA thin atmosphere like mars can make it worse. The actual amount of braking you get is a bit unpredictable, and the size of the aerodynamic surfaces you need to make a significant impact can use up quite a bit of your mass budget (example: despite the size of the Perseverance/Curiosity parachutes, they still needed a sky-crane for final touchdown).
- cubefox 4y ago> Only three entities have successfully soft-landed on the Moon — the government-funded space agencies of China, the Soviet Union and the United States. And only China has done it since the 1970s and on its first attempt. This sounds as if the journalist tries to downplay the fact that NASA managed to do it a) first, and b) actually landed humans on the moon, not just unmanned vehicles. The only thing which makes it less impressive is the enormous budget of the Apollo program.
- f6v 4y agoIt’d be much easier if all we care was humanity’s achievements.
- Freire_Herval 4y agoDarwinistic tendencies will always be part of human behavior, it is ingrained in our biology. People will be competitive, and they will form groups and take sides and compare technological achievements.
- wolverine876 4y agoLots of tendancies are part of human behavior. So is cooperation, eusocial behavior, etc etc etc. NASA relied on the cooperation of many, many people, and the funding of everyone in the US.
- Freire_Herval 4y ago[dead]
- so-and-so 4y agoThought it was the soviets to first "land" a ship on the moon. Remember they had a lot of internal dicussions on if the Moon had a solid surface.
- 4y ago
- jmyeet 4y agoMany of us have an overly simplistic view of orbital mechanics that fall well short of how it works in the real world. Take the example of India's failed Vikram lander [1]: > The official said that predicting orbits below 50 km is very tricky and usually they are estimated with an accuracy of plus/minus 1 km. If the lander`s predicted height was at 30 km, the actual orbit height may remain anywhere between 29 to 31 km. > Similar will be the error in horizontal direction. Such errors occur as local gravity varies widely due to large variation of density of mountains and plains. Newton's gravity equations deal with bodies like the Moon as having uniform mass. That's not he case and it matters. Fun fact: China's Three Gorges Dam slowed down the Earth's rotation by 0.06 microseconds per day [2]. That's actually not a big deal because the rotation has variance all of its own from tides, weather, etc. So even if you had a density map of the Moon you'd still have to account for variance added by rotational variation. [1]: https://www.zeebiz.com/india/news-on-indias-vikram-lander-did-navigation-system-fail-111393 https://www.zeebiz.com/india/news-on-indias-vikram-lander-di... [2]: https://www.kinetica.co.uk/2014/03/27/chinese-dam-slows-down-earths-rotation/ https://www.kinetica.co.uk/2014/03/27/chinese-dam-slows-down...
- grog454 4y ago> China's Three Gorges Dam slowed down the Earth's rotation by 0.06 microseconds per day [2]. That's actually not a big deal because the rotation has variance all of its own from tides, weather, etc I'm confused, how is the mean changing less impactful due to relatively high variance? If the was no variance at all, would .06us be a disaster?
- ordu 4y agoIt may be a disaster, but if we manage to live with variance that are higher than 0.06 microseconds per day, we should manage this small change in an average.
- krisoft 4y ago> Newton's gravity equations deal with bodies like the Moon as having uniform mass. Let’s not make a joke of ourselves. Newton’s gravity equations deal perfectly well with non uniform masses. You just need to integrate properly. But all of this is beside the point. Obviously you are not going to land open loop. You need sensors which tell you where you are and how fast you are going.
- Dah00n 4y agoIt is sad that every time there is a discussion online about something like this it always ends up with some anti-USSR / pro-US talk.
- uguuo_o 4y agoWhy is it so hard? Plume-surface interaction plays a major role during the landing sequence. Most projects "test,test and more test" like the ones mentioned in the article, but they clearly have no idea how unforgiving the environment is. When the vehicle gets closer to the surface, the engine exhaust gets redirected upwards, accelerating regolith to ~ 1km/s speeds. Any sensitive hardware that is hit can easily be taken out. Additionally, the closer the vehicle gets to the surface the more difficulty landing sensors will have in looking through the induced regolith cloud.[0] NASA has been studying the problem through experimental and computational campaigns for a long time, but just recently has put significant resources into understanding PSI on extreme environments. Edit: reference [0] https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/game_changing_development/projects/PSI https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/game_changing_de...
- mjevans 4y agoAlso see the most recent first SpaceX Starship launch attempt. Widely accepted current theories about likely failure mode root cause involve exactly this sort of thrust ground interaction kicking up debris. I am a huge proponent of sending robots first, to build safer landing and launch structures, possibly also bases or better places to situate bases.
- uguuo_o 4y agoThere are many projects looking into building landing pads before any large vehicles, from both private and government. [0] is one I know. Interesting approaches but I have not seen anything yet that can withstand human class landers. These also pose significantly higher risks if the pads break up.
- WalterBright 4y ago> Compared with Earth, for example, the Moon has reduced gravity, very little atmosphere and lots of dust. But no weather. Weather is an enormous risk factor for Earth landings.
- WalterBright 4y ago> early indications suggest that this week’s ispace failure could have been caused by the lander running out of propellant just before it touched down I practiced a lot with the Lunar Lander game in the 1970s. The trick is to let it fall until the last second, then hit the thrusters full blast to hit 0V as it hits the surface. Burn too soon, and you run out of propellant and crash.
- renewiltord 4y agoInteresting that the SpaceX rockets have the same behaviour when landing. I read somewhere that was because they have no throttle control and are on/off, but I'm no authority.
- Galxeagle 4y agoThe key reason is that an extra second of time spent hovering or close it is another second of resisting gravity, which takes fuel, so the most efficient hypothetical ‘burn’ is one big bang ‘hoverslam’ right at the end and 0 seconds spent fighting gravity The SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket does have throttle control, but at minimum thrust the thrust-to-weight ratio is still greater than 1, which means they have to hit 0m/s at exactly 0 feet of altitude or they start going up again. I’d imagine they time their ‘hoverslam’ to take 2x minimum thrust (or some other multiplier) and then adjust up or down through the manoeuvre.
- sbierwagen 4y agoThey have throttle, but not enough throttle range. Merlin is a 845 kN engine that can throttle down to 338 kN. When the rocket is mostly empty, that's too much thrust to hover. So they have a very short window to start the landing burn, and also not enough fuel to abort and try again. Given the constraints, it's surprising they don't lose more rockets during the landing phase.
- exaphis 4y agohttps://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/suicide_burn https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/suicide_burn
- 4y ago
- Animats 4y agoBecause you don't get to carry enough fuel. Like most things in rocketry, it would be straightforward if you had plenty of fuel. It would be comparable to landing a helicopter, although you'd need more stabilization. Fuel-limited, you have to come in too fast, decelerate too hard, pick a landing site too quickly, and can't go around and try again. When the Apollo landers touched down, they had fifteen to thirty seconds of fuel left. Space-X boosters returning to the takeoff site have even worse constraints.
- Arainach 4y ago>When the Apollo landers touched down, they had fifteen to thirty seconds of fuel left This was true for Apollo 11 but not later missions. And it was that close to the safety margin, not an absolute limit.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]