12 ms·
Half of vinyl buyers in the U.S. don’t have a record player: study
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- escapecharacter 4y agoI’m sure 50% of record player buyers don’t own vinyl, so it evens out. In micro-econ, these are called “ironically uncorrelated commodities”.
- iancmceachern 4y agoSo only 25% of people are playing music using vinyl
- conro1108 4y agoOnly if you assume that everyone is either a vinyl buyer or record player buyer :)
- vondur 4y agoHa, I gave away my vinyl records about 20 years ago. Recently picked up a Fugazi record just 'cause it looked cool. I no longer have a record player.
- thefourthchime 4y agoMaybe that half that doesn't own a record player bought a vinyl as a gift for someone who does?
- crazygringo 4y agoI got rid of most of my LP's over the past few years as I realized I'd gradually just started to play them from Spotify instead (convenience slowly converted me), over the same speakers. Then I sold my turntable. But I kept around 20 of my favorites and just rotate them for display on my bookshelf. If I'm playing one of them on Spotify, I'll even rotate to show that LP while I play it. The really bizarre thing is, there's a particular old album I'm thinking of purchasing just to be able to display its cover, because of what it means to me. It's the same with books -- my favorite ones are in my bookshelf, but even if I read a book I own physically, I pull it up on my iPad because I prefer to be able to highlight, look up words, adjust text size, read in a dark room, etc. So I'm shocked to discover that I like having the physical artifacts even when I still consume them digitally. It's almost like bringing back souvenir knick-knacks from a vacation. This is not an outcome I ever would have expected.
- pasta-menu 4y ago[dead]
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoPatience! Try putting on a record and listening with friends or dancing to the beat with your significant other. Don't try to cherrypick just one song or conversely listen to endless AI generated mix while your mind is elsewhere. Afterwards, have a conversation about what the artist was trying to express and moments in your own life the songs reminded you of. THEN tell me you didn't have a unique experience compared to what Spotify provides you with.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- monkeywork 4y agoWhy can't you do that EACT same experience on spotify? You realize you can pick a specific album and play it in order correct? The only difference between the two is that with spotify you have options if you lack the self control to go for the experience you are suggesting.
- inamberclad 4y agoDeliberate restriction is the point of still using a lot of analog media. You can't pop open another app on your book, you can't look at the photo you just took on film, and you can't easily skip a song on a record.
- KyeRussell 4y ago“You realise you can…” Just admit that you don’t yet understand the other perspective. Resorting to this sort of snark really isn’t in service of reaching a shared understanding.
- endorphine 4y agoOften times we just try to prove that the other person's taste/preference does not make sense. However that is a fool's errand: you can't convince me that I don't like chocolate, for example. I do! True, most people doesn't find meaning in using vinyl records, others. Why do we have to prove that either of them is right/wrong? Trying to understand the other's perspective is the way to go, if you care about getting closer to the truth.
- iancmceachern 4y agoI own one record, a used Chuck Mangioni record I bought as ironic art from a goodwill that sits in a frame on my wall. So I'm afraid I'm adding to this statistic somewhat inadvertently.
- uptown 4y ago“Feels So Good”? Great album if so.
- rnd0 4y agoI have Judas Priest's "Sad Wings Of Destiny" and Dead Kennedy's "In God We Trust, Inc". I bought them back before vinyl died and have held on to them as keepsakes of years gone by. I haven't had a record player since the 90's so I guess I'm part of the 50% as well!
- defrost 4y agoI bought as a record to play Small Faces Ogden's Nut Gone Flake back in 1978 (released in 1968) .. the cover is a gem, round carboard layers with a common one inch spine all modelled on an old school tobacco tin. As one of the few not square record covers released I have it out in a double perspex holder and rarely handle it as it wouldn't take much to tear the hinging 50 years on after its creation. https://www.discogs.com/release/2980551-Small-Faces-Ogdens-Nut-Gone-Flake/ https://www.discogs.com/release/2980551-Small-Faces-Ogdens-N... https://www.amazon.com.au/OGDENS-GONE-FLAKE-SMALL-FACES/dp/B07CQL33V8 https://www.amazon.com.au/OGDENS-GONE-FLAKE-SMALL-FACES/dp/B...
- juve1996 4y agoNot really surprising. Playing records is a really inconvenient way to listen to music and is more about the aesthetic than anything else.
- AdamJacobMuller 4y agoI have a handful (50 ~~ 100) of vinyl records. Limited edition type stuff or just eclectic music I enjoy. I bought an Audio-Technica AT-LP120BK-USB (and a cartridge, because, the one which came with my 300 record player was "trash") after I had accumulated a handful of them. Picked out the TRON: Legacy soundtrack and got it all hooked up. For some context, I have a nice sound system which is optimized for movies/tv though I listen to a fair bit of music too. If you're not aware, the TRON: Legacy soundtrack was produced by Daft Punk and Daft Punk was made for TRON: Legacy and TRON: Legacy was made for Daft Punk and the result is magical. Started playing and the sound was great. Flipped over to Spotify and played the same album and the sound was also great. Honestly, couldn't tell the difference. Played one or two other things, but, the record player went on a shelf that day and is still there. I still collect records, especially rare or limited ones of things I particularly like, or ones where there's something unique or special about the vinyl copy, but, I don't listen to them anymore.
- vineyardmike 4y ago> the record player went on a shelf that day and is still there. When I moved I never plugged in my amplifier and speakers for my record player because I couldn't figure out where to put them. Eventually I realized that they didn't need to be on the floor "waiting" for me to set them up -now they're in the garage while the records/player are out on display. I just listen to music via a smart speaker and streaming most days. I still buy the occasional vinyl though. I like them as gifts because they're physical and also personal. I tell everyone to give me a record of an album that means a lot to them so I can think of them when I play it (because gifts are about emotions, even if I don't play them directly).
- jvanderbot 4y agoI've tried to have a good sound system. I've been to friends' houses that have nice ones. I got an array of Sonos speakers and ask an Echo to play things on them. It's a wonderful, maintenance-free experience and, combined with Spotify's access to most things I'd want, makes intentional listening a zero-friction experience.
- notduncansmith 4y agoSlightly longer and more substantial original article this blogspam was copied from: https://www.musicbusinessworldwide.com/50-of-vinyl-buyers-dont-own-a-record-player-data-shows/ https://www.musicbusinessworldwide.com/50-of-vinyl-buyers-do... Interesting trend overall. I got my dad a vinyl record for Christmas, and he only recently got a record player to listen to it. I wonder about vinyl buying vs listening demographics and how age correlates: my partner and I, along with some similar-generation friends, are avid vinyl listeners. We still use Spotify to listen to music together, either collaborative or generated playlists, and we generally set a high standard of matching the music we select to our mood, but the process of discovering and listening to records together has become one that we treat differently from digital listening. We are more forgiving and open (less “you picked this?” and more going with the flow) and have some irreverent discs that have established themselves as favorites through this process :)
- stuart78 4y agoIt’s great that musicians can sell a high cost item (vastly greater revenue vs streams per customer), but I do worry the labels are over-indulging here and heading the market towards a Funkopop like crash. Most record stores I go into have reoriented towards very mainstream new releases and overpriced ‘rare’ vintage albums. Meanwhile the more serious collectors market has moved to Discogs and Bandcamp/direct. So when the market turns on vinyl, physical stores will be the biggest direct losers. And even an average shop in the neighborhood is better than none at all.
- Gigachad 4y ago>a Funkopop like crash. Could you explain this?
- ftxbro 4y ago[flagged]
- anigbrowl 4y agoDon't go throwing your weights around here
- artificial 4y agoCrash as in they made too many and nobody is buying them. Funkopop has more vinyl characters than demand resulting warehouses full of inventory that isn’t moving.
- kugestu 4y agoThis answer doesn’t explain at all what a "Funkopop like crash" is and sounds straight from ChatGPT. Particularly the jump from "crash" to "Crash Bandicoot like figurine". I am really sad that even high quality discussion platforms are flooded with low quality, non-content AI comments like this.
- vertoc 4y agoThis sounds like a gpt bot almost exactly?
- 49erfangoniners 4y ago>3,900 US-based respondents surveyed 84% of surveys aren't statistically significant (clickbait.edu)
- don-code 4y agoFor several years, I bought older vinyl not for the vinyl itself, but for the cover art, which I hung on my living room walls with Records on Walls: https://www.recordsonwalls.com/ https://www.recordsonwalls.com/. Many of them have an aesthetic quality all of their own, like the gatefold of Led Zeppelin IV, or the subtle yet iconic "EKG" from Dark Side of the Moon. It's much more recently that I acquired a turntable and a preamp, so that I can actually listen to them.
- slg 4y agoI have bought maybe 10 or so records over the years without having a record player. It supports the band more than streaming. It is a relatively cheap physical souvenir and is a better display piece than a cd. And they usually come with a download code for the same music. Actually listening to the vinyl wasn't even much of a consideration when making the purchases.
- devindotcom 4y agothis is me - most shows I buy a shirt and/or a record. got the DL code... play it in winamp. I have had a turntable or two but not right now - but when I do, I'll have a great collection of records to listen to. Everybody wins!
- ramraj07 4y agoWhy not just give them money though.
- slg 4y agoI generally haven't seen an avenue to do that. Bandcamp has the pay what you want option, but I'm not aware of a donating option. I also listed multiple reasons for buying vinyl and supporting the artist is only one of them.
- olivermarks 4y agoI bpught the Say She She vinyl off the band when they were in town (signed!). I have a turntable but the vinyl included a download album mp3s link, so I've never played the vinyl. Pretty common I suspect. I have quite a lot of rare vinyl and a good turntable but it's a pain constantly getting up to change records unless you're in the mood.
- kstenerud 4y agoI lived through reel-to-reel, vinyl, 8-track, cassette, CD, minidisc, and now digital files. Of those, only reel-to-reel came even remotely close to the sound quality of digital. I can now fit my entire music library onto a storage medium smaller than my thumbnail, at better quality than anything before it. I get that many people like the vintage aspect (like folks who carry around pocket watches or walkmans), but there comes a point where it crosses over from eccentric to just plain weird (like going out in a top hat and tails).
- georgelyon 4y agoI am a proud owner of a top hat and tails. I also enjoy a somewhat direct mechanism for giving money to artists I admire, and having an attractive physical artifact of that transaction is a plus. For the (ahem) record, not all vinyl purchases are a somewhat-direct-to-artist transaction (though those at the merch table of a small-to-medium sized show probably are).
- School-Cotton 4y agoVinyl isn’t higher quality than digital, but it certainly sounds different.
- steve1977 4y agoIt sounds different than a pristine digital version of the same track, although often vinyl tracks are mastered differently due to the limitations of the medium. If you were to digitally record the output of a record player and play it back, there would be no discernible difference.
- School-Cotton 4y ago> If you were to digitally record the output of a record player and play it back, there would be no discernible difference. That’s probably true, but nobody does that.
- 4y ago
- dhosek 4y agoI only bought stuff on vinyl back in the 80s if I was pretty sure I’d never find it on CD (this was back when being able to buy music relied on it being in whatever record store you happened to go into). In the early 90s I sold it all and it turned out my expectation of not being able to find most of that stuff on CD was correct. On the plus side, there’s very little of that which I can even remember (the only ones I can remember are some Mike Rutherford solo albums from before Mike + the Mechanics). I do still buy music, but it’s now almost exclusively in the form of digital downloads. I know a lot of what I have is not on most of the streaming services and quite possibly never will be.
- paulpauper 4y agoThis is just more evidence that new technology never completely destroys old technology. It simply creates new formats that coexist with the older ones, but the older ones never go away and may even fetch a premium by collectors or people who need it.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoI (sometimes) buy vinyl and don’t (currently) own a record player. I like to support artists however I can, and especially for works I particularly appreciate. I also like to have the physical liner notes and accompanying artwork, especially in large format. Having the actual recording on a physical medium which I control is a nice bonus and can come in handy even for lifetime purchases when access to digital purchases might expire or their providers might vanish (this happened with one of my albums before I ever got a download code, but since it came with the physical album I don’t need to go online to try to resolve it by whatever means I might need to).
- Marsymars 4y agoHey I spent years buying games on Steam without owning a gaming PC and lately have been buying Switch games without owning a switch.
- komali2 4y agoWhy lol? Are you planning on buying a gaming PC or switch?
- jimmcslim 4y agoI feel the GP comment applies to me and my answer to this question would be… “eventually” hah Might be sooner rather than later if Valve hurries up with official Australian distribution of the Steam Deck.
- Marsymars 4y agoI have bought (built) a gaming PC. And do fully intend on buying a Switch... still working through my Wii U collection currently though.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lawgimenez 4y agoI have bought CDs, cassette tapes, download from Napster, burn CDs, etc. but Vynil hasn’t really attracted attention to me. Turntable seems to be an inconvenient and overpriced device, I could be wrong though.
- ryancnelson 4y agoPretty sure there’s a lot of vinyl gifting going on. Rich dudes are hard to shop for, but they don’t shut up about their record collection, simple solution for secret Santa this year. Buyer doesn’t have a turntable.
- rufus_foreman 4y agoAs a rich dude, there's pretty much zero chance that anyone is going to be able to buy me a record for my record collection that I don't shut up about unless I specifically tell them what to buy. For the bands I really like, I mostly have everything I want. But if you did manage to figure out a record I want, you would need to know which version of the release I want. For some records there are dozens. Maybe I want the first release, maybe I want the first US release, maybe I want a higher quality reissue, maybe I want a colored vinyl release. But whichever one I want, if you get me a different one it goes in the trash and I keep the release I want on my want list. Then you've got to figure out what condition to buy it in. If it is something I'm getting to collect rather than to listen to, it needs to be near mint. If you get me very good condition instead of near mint, it goes in the trash, and I keep it on my want list. If it is something I'm getting to listen to rather than to collect, VG+ is fine. You can get it near mint, but you just wasted $50 because near mint is hard to find, and it isn't going to be near mint after I listen to it a few times. So skip the vinyl for Xmas, if you're going to get me a gift, money works. I'm not picky about condition or version. Cash, money orders, bonds, it's all good. Or real estate. But if you insist on gifting vinyl, I'm looking for the Weirdos "We Got The Neutron Bomb" single, 1978 release, near mint, the unofficial colored vinyl Beastie Boy singles from Paul's Boutique, I want them all but if you can only get one, "Car Thief", near mint, and the 1987 "Gimme Fever" single by Shake Appeal (first band Adam Franklin from Swervedriver was in, along with his brother), VG+ is fine.
- silisili 4y agoSorry if this is going over my head, but why would a rich person want money for Christmas?
- 4y ago
- shrubble 4y agoThe artwork, notes etc. on LPs was often very cool. I could see buying favorite albums just to look at front and back while playing the music electronically...
- mrweasel 4y agoThere's an album I love that have the most amazing retro 60s, early 70s inspired cover design. I wanted to get the LP to have the cover in larger format, sadly it was never release on anything but streaming platforms.
- InCityDreams 4y agoEr....name, perchance?
- mrweasel 4y agoApparently it's just a single, but "La' Mig Rulle Dig" by Pharfar.
- ndeast 4y agoI collect a significant amount of new vinyl and listen to it relatively frequently, but digital music is so much more convenient. That can be a detriment though, I find a lot of the value I get out of listening to vinyl is the "intentional listening" experience. I think Henry Rollins called it carbohydrate listening or something to that effect, listening to things you like that you've heard a million times and isn't exactly stimulating in the same way a new album or artist would be. Music feels a whole lot more consumable and disposable when its just on constant instant playback. Forcing yourself to flip the record and drop the needle keeps you more engaged I feel. All that to say I mostly just like collecting colored vinyl, and supporting small bands and artists you like by buying a product significantly more profitable than millions of Spotify streams is pretty cool.
- Rincon15 4y ago[flagged]
- endorphine 4y agoIt's exactly the same for me. Yes, vinyl is more inconvenient, expensive and may even sound "worse" unless you have an expensive audio setup. That said, the deliberate experience of sitting in your couch, doing/thinking nothing else but the music you're listening, is for me an invaluable ritual. It's like meditation.
- nend 4y ago>It's like meditation What you're describing is mindfulness meditation.
- giantrobot 4y ago> That said, the deliberate experience of sitting in your couch, doing/thinking nothing else but the music you're listening, is for me an invaluable ritual. It's like meditation. Just imagine if you could do that with a CD or even an album of MP3s! But that's just not possible, it can only be done with vinyl records.
- 4y ago
- augment003 4y ago[flagged]
- kdksrnrb 4y ago[flagged]
- theandrewbailey 4y agoExcept vinyl has better resale value than NFTs.
- topranks 4y agoPlus records have audio on them. NFTs just contain a link to the content elsewhere.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cyberferret 4y agoI don't know if it is guys like me skewing the numbers here, but I have a not insignificant LP collection that I've had for over 30 years now. I got rid of my record player decades ago when moving house but carted my LPs around, with the intent to buy a decent home stereo setup once I got established again and had the disposable income to buy something decent. I am at that stage now, so will invest in a decent HiFi kit sometime this year. I guess I am also a bit old school in that I don't really listen to music while working etc., so things like Spotify and Apple Music etc. are not my thing. I treat listening to music as a bit of an event, that harkens back to my younger days of having album 'listening parties', so I expect I will still consume my music that way again once I get my record player.
- frostyj 4y agoI have a record player and I don't always play the vinyls that I have bought :)
- at_a_remove 4y agoI have a very, very small amount of vinyl. It's almost all "albums which do not exist on CD." I typically buy them still sealed, if at all possible. At some point, I will pay to have them digitized by a professional. I get it for old stuff, as the technology did not exist then, but for new stuff, the artists who insist on only releasing on vinyl and cassette, well, that's irritating.
- lukas099 4y agoHaha, I just bought some cassettes because the cases they came in were cool and they were cheap. The new vinyl??
- kazinator 4y ago> “50% of consumers who have bought vinyl in the past 12 months own a record player, compared to 15% among music listeners overall.” No way in hell do 15% music listeners own record players. Assuming Luminate's numbers are not entirely made up, their sampling method must be deeply flawed, which brings into question their ability to determine how many record buyers own a record player. Maybe they asked the question in some idiotic way that confused the respondents.
- mrweasel 4y ago> No way in hell do 15% music listeners own record players. That's also a weird statement in general, sure there might be a group of people who actively avoid music, but aren't most of us music listeners. Perhaps there's some special meaning to "music listeners" as a term.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- evilspammer 4y agoAt most 95% of the world population listens to music (the rest are hard of hearing)
- mrweasel 4y agoSome of those remaining 5% do like the vibrations, but I'm not sure that counts as listing.
- xboxnolifes 4y agoDefinitely seems nebulous, but I would consider myself not a music listener. Outside of it being paired with a movie/game/video/etc, I practically never listen to music just to listen to music.
- pavlov 4y agoA lot of people over 60 own a record player even if they never use it.
- cfeduke 4y agoIn the late 80s and early 90s the way I got punk was at local stores that sold vinyl - usually punk rock only, or in the 90s both punk and ska. It was inconvenient because as a teen I'd want to listen to my music on cassette with a Walkman but not every band could afford a cassette release - especially local punk bands. So intentional listening became a part of my music culture. I still have a record player I bought years ago and I listen to vinyl records on it from time to time. I will usually buy a record of an album that's particularly special to me. I've fought enough with jammed CD players to probably never consider the same approach with compact discs.
- prpl 4y agoI’ve been listening to a lot of Spotify the last 5 years for a few different reasons. I actually unarchived my mp3s yesterday because there is some stuff not on there. I have a lot of random things that never showed up on Spotify, and even more random cds I never ripped from bands in Salt Lake City during the ‘00 which probably nobody will ever care about. If it was a decade earlier or later it would have been tape or vinyl+download, but DIY releases from 2000-2010 was all CD.
- Rincon15 4y ago[flagged]
- Rincon15 4y ago[dead]
- stephencoyner 4y agoI buy a lot of new rap vinyl because having a physical copy is the only way to guarantee the music doesn’t change (unless you can find and download the files online which can be hard) Many artists don’t clear samples and are forced to make updates or remove them entirely. While streaming has given us quick access to almost any music, it has also created a new impermanence in the industry that’s very frustrating. On top of that, it’s not uncommon for rap albums on vinyl to come with the instrumentals that are never made available on streaming at all. I’ve been ripping them to have the MP3s on the go
- gpvos 4y agoCDs work just as well for that though, and they're easier ro rip.
- endorphine 4y agoAn excellent point. A prime example of this is "Captain Murphy - Duality", which currently costs 1300$ on Discogs. It's a record released in 2013 in limited copies with high unlikely chance it gets reissued due to sample clearance restrictions.
- ummonk 4y agoIt's CDs that ensure music doesn't change. The music changes every time you play a vinyl record, as well as simply while the LP is on the shelf. CDs by contrast store an immutable copy of the music.
- siquick 4y agoOP was referring to multiple versions of a track due to licensing and censorship changes rather than the media itself altering.
- jvanderbot 4y agoGP was being pedantic, and probably knew what OP meant.
- 4y ago
- HelixEndeavor 4y agoI don't own a good record player, but I like to support small artists that I really enjoy. I do usually also buy the CD if I can and rip it to FLACs to play on my phone.
- ehnto 4y agoI have a bunch of vinyl left over from my DJing days that I likely won't get rid of, but I have already digitized it all so I likely won't keep the decks forever. I have also considered collecting skateboards because I think the art is awesome, but canonically I was a rollerblader when I was younger. I think that's probably the same thing for vinyl collections.
- Animats 4y agoWhy put a record inside? Just sell the album cover with a card inside that pays for the download.
- RileyJames 4y agoHaha yep, I’m in that category at the moment. I’ve been buying a lot of albums on Bandcamp, and in most cases I get the vinyl or cassette, which comes with the digital download for free. I plan to get a record player, and full hifi. I do have a cassette setup, tho I use primarily for recording. The few tapes I bought were to a/b test against the digital on my cassette recording setup. And the fact that it’s often only a few $$ difference in price. I got sick of “owning nothing” via the Spotify model. I like that Bandcamp gives me the option to get the files so I can do as a please with them.
- Fricken 4y agoIn a millenium the vinyl records will be playable, and the players buildable.
- mrweasel 4y agoAnd mass produced CDs will have lost their coating and no longer be playable in ten years.
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoWhen I was young, I amassed an extensive and impressive collection of vinyl both common and rare, bankrolled mostly by my saintly grandmother. I would stroll around the mall with her on a Sunday and pop into the Wherehouse or the indie record store, and enjoy chatting up a much older blonde clerk before filling my arms with more music than I could ever listen to during the ensuing week. When I was older and shopped for myself, I'd drive my friends to Tower or the far-flung indie stores, and it was at the latter where I really developed a taste for the rare and near-unobtainables. Then I began to purchase Goldmine magazines, which was the sine qua non for collectors, and I got hooked up with "Record Finding Services" in the UK, which was some dude who'd walk into a store on your behalf and pick up something that wasn't even available on import in the US. I don't know how many records in total I had, but I proudly boasted of over 100 items by The Cure alone. And you know that old question "Did you read all these books on your shelves?" well I did certainly get around to listening to almost all of the music... at least once. When CDs came out I embraced the tech and branched out. That didn't entirely put an end to my vinyl purchases, as that was still where the rare and desirable stuff was at, for a long time. Fast forward to my move to the desert, and in the throes of impending homelessness, I began to sell off my vinyl for pocket money. I wasn't able to keep this up and make rent on the storage locker. My records were eventually sold to the highest bidder. It was a tragedy to be sure. Then I entered a period where I realized that I didn't need to consume massive amounts of music, and I didn't purchase anything. In fact, my choral activities gave me many opportunities to make my own music, such that it was much more interesting than passive grooving. Fast forward to 2023: I don't own any device that plays music other than my computers. I have no turntable, no CD drive at all. My music purchases remain firmly at $0. The best music is all over YouTube as much as I want, and on-the-go I am very satisfied with public domain cuts of prayers, classical pieces, and ambient instrumentals while I work. I am rather glad to be relieved of an insatiable thirst to consume new music; it was an expensive vice, and I was often exploited by my favorite artists as they released endless "collectibles" that I had to catch like Pokémon.
- milchek 4y agoI’ve always bought cds to support artists i like, even during the napster days, and even now in the world of streaming. I used to buy digipaks, since they were more limited, had cool artwork and more features. These days, i buy records for the same reason. Mostly, it comes down to being able to own something physical that is well crafted and beautiful. Vinyl fits this well also, since you get things like limited press special vinyls etc. I find myself buying more vinyl, and i’m also in the same boat as people in the article as i don’t have a record player (yet)
- throw_m239339 4y agoIt's funny how in the early 2000's, everybody was selling their Technics and buying expensive Pionner CDJ 2000 (like $2000 a pair), and now the CDJs are basically worthless while a pair of MKII can fetch $1000 on Ebay.
- topranks 4y agoCDJs still are the go-to thing for 90% of DJs though. The difference is, being a digital thing with some sort of basic computer in them, they keep updating them. So your CDJ1000’s with no support for USB drives are worth very little. Pioneer realise they’ve a nice racket and will keep releasing newer models with slight improvements to make the older ones “obsolete”. But CDJs in general are still very much sought after. Whereas your 1210 is just as useful as it was back when you first got it. Also the fact they stopped making them helps.
- snvzz 4y agoIn the digital era, vinyl have but one purpose: Be digitized for preservation.
- yieldcrv 4y agoI just bought a cassette tape the other day, I don't have a cassette player
- taeric 4y agoWait til they study how many book buyers read the books. :) Or gamers actually play the games they buy. :( Looking at my mostly aspirational collection of each.
- jaggederest 4y agoThis makes me feel like I'm taking crazy pills. I've read 95%+ of the thousands of books I have owned, many read multiple times, and played all but a bare handful of the 214 games I have on steam. I'm not a completionist on games, so by no means have I beaten/completed the majority, but still, do people just have free money hanging around?
- taeric 4y agoAh. Yeah, to be fair, I was taking a completionist view. I've read most of my books. I have not done most of the exercises in them. Akin to how I have played many games. But completed far fewer. That said, I'd guess I'm in the 70% realm of both. Who knew having a family was so much time? :)
- jaggederest 4y agoYeah that's legit. I mean, I count even booting a game up and throwing a few hours into it and not feeling it, same with a book - if you get a chapter or two deep, the author is just not getting there, that's a solid attempt. I read and enjoyed a big chunk of Tolstoy but you don't have to get to "The End" to be able to honestly say you're reading Anna Karenina. I know there are lots of people out there that buy books and never read them, not even page one, same as there are lots of 2200-game steam libraries where most are not played, but at the end of the day those people are playing a different metagame, I guess, so more power to them.
- DharmaPolice 4y agoYes, some people do have free money hanging around. It's what drives a large part of the economy. If you don't have an ethos of saving, don't have a family then (assuming a decent wage) your money will tend to go to your hobbies. For a lot of people, their hobby is basically buying things. Steam sales encourage this behaviour though. I will have an intention to play a certain game. If I see it's heavily reduced now, it might make seem to make sense to buy it now even if I don't have the time to play it, rather than get it later when it might be full price.
- pgreenwood 4y agoThere's a lot to like about vinyls. I could list many things but the thing that stands out for me is that it forces careful curation. It also leads to a unique form of selection in that I can browse my selection and find something that I really want to listen to that I would not have otherwise thought of. Sure you can browse endless lists of digital music, but the visual cue of the cover and the labels and the idiosyncratic sorting methods (or lack thereof) leads to a different kind of set list.
- hestefisk 4y agoI used to collect vinyls a lot. Then music streaming services happened and I sold my record player to make space for other things. 10 years after doing that I have rediscovered my passion and bought a new Rega Planar I turntable. Best investment in years. I’m very fortunate I kept all my records. I now listen to music intentionally again and got rid of the “instant gratification” that streaming services provide.
- 1letterunixname 4y agoI do both. Tidal and Spotify. The amp I have supports 20+ services. The 4 channel mixer I have is c. 1996 but it can add basic effects. I would never scratch on these turntables because the arms are all wrong for it. Having 2 tt's is primarily for gapless playback.
- drumhead 4y agoThe crackle, pop and hiss from a vinyl record is such a warm and comfortable sound, I can see why people would want to go back to something so imperfect after sterile digital.
- crossroadsguy 4y agoI am planning to get into this whole record player thing just because I can enjoy music and focus on just listening to what I like. These music streaming platforms apply too much dark patterns to trap me into just keep browsing and keep checking new/unknown and mostly shitty music that it is genuinely frustrating. In fact I had a good deal going - finally had a decent collection of playlists on Spotify and I enjoyed it for few months but then they keep changing their UX and everything else keeps coming in the way - podcasts, some smart shuffle of the library curated by me. One mistake click and there you have unknown god-knows-what songs in your library and you are wondering where the fuck they come from. Then one song you clicked by mistake or forgot to skip or dislike and for next few weeks your entire home screen is filled with shit like that. I mean yes one can say just go to the library and skip the home page and recommendation but you see it every time you open it and distracts and disgusts. I mean it has just one job - let me listen to the music I want and get out of my way and it keeps putting its foot in the cracks, not on every opportunity, but by manufacturing opportunities. Apple Music has its own downsides. It's just sad. The most I loved my music experience when I used to listen to using the radio and cassette players. I never got into CDs - it was straight to curated MP3 collection from cassettes. So the hope is vinyls will at least some of that experience and the feeling of my own curated collection. One downside is vinyls are prohibitively expensive and no easy to procure in India. So no the convenience of streaming services is not really a convenience - it's just we pay to hear and see an ad platform or listen to explicit ads to again experience an ad platform if you don't pay a fee. That is really what the likes of Netflix and Spotify are - ad platforms.
- beardyw 4y agoI started buying vinyl when that was all there was, at first only in mono. Having accumulated a wide shelf full, plus tapes, and CDs I gave away my vinyl to my son in law with the advent of streaming. Being a music lover, not an audiophile, I have no regrets other than I should have (or should now) make a list of what I had. That said, there is a definite excitement in rediscovering lost favourite tracks.
- chinaman425 4y ago[dead]
- futurecat 4y agoVinyl is imperfect, heavy, fragile, and difficult to maintain. The sound is objectively less precise than digital, and playback comes with surface noise, pops, and all. Choosing a cartridge affects the quality of the sound so much that it can be an expensive part of the setup (and needles need to be regularly changed!). Vinyl has a lot of drawbacks but vinyl is offline, private, and a cherished possession. The lack of dynamic is actually what I love about it. I have 2 20years old record players (Technics MK2), a mixer (Rane TTM56) and Taruya Cartridges. I love to play vinyls selections with very little mixing technique. I record each little session, and broadcast them on my very own little icecast server. The Vinyl culture is a great one. We don’t always need what is the most convenient or the most precise. We just need what feels good to us.
- 1letterunixname 4y agoI laugh at the fragile part. What's fragile are turn of the 20th century Soviet 78's and wax records. The only things that will fuck up regular records are: sitting on them, leaving them in a hot car, or pilling them up outside of sleeves. If you're not a careless slob, regular records are pretty damn forgiving.
- futurecat 4y agoFragile might not be the right word. But you need to clean them and care for them.
- worrycue 4y ago> vinyl is offline, private, and a cherished possession But so are CDs without any of the drawbacks.
- dymk 4y agoVinyl records are a way to display the album art in a large-ish format. CDs are tiny and not as good for displaying.
- 4y ago
- cesaref 4y agoI stream lots of music, but am aware that the artist receives a very small payment from this, certainly not enough to make a living. I tend to therefore view purchasing vinyl as a way of funding the artist as they get a decent cut from this, certainly compared to streaming services. I do own a record player though, and do play the purchased records, but this is a continuation of a hobby back from the days when this was the only decent way of buying music.
- Semaphor 4y ago> but am aware that the artist receives a very small payment from this That’s (part of) why I don’t stream and instead buy the music digitally on bandcamp (or Amazon if I’m forced to, but that’s mostly major label stuff which I don’t buy often).
- meindnoch 4y agoUmmm, yeah because in some scenes, often the only digital version is available with a download code attached to the vinyl.
- 1letterunixname 4y agoThis sounds absurd. Are that many people compulsive hoarders or using them as hipster decorations? If so, no wonder I can't find El-P's early shit on Discogs. I've got a tiny-ass collection of maybe 500 records. 2 turntables with AT microline cartridges and all the damn leveling, mirrors, gauges, and force measuring accoutrement. Then there's the shit for dust including the static gun and the toxic chemicals. And you got your giant Orbeeze needle cleaner. I could give a left rat ball about analog purity or vacuum tubes of know-nothing audiophile snobs. It's ADC'ed at the mixer and sent 100' (~30 m) around the room over an active HDMI cable to the amp.
- whstl 4y ago"This sounds absurd. Are that many people compulsive hoarders or using them as hipster decorations?" Indeed. I know plenty of people like this. In some rare cases they have a record player but it's less expensive than individual albums, and they don't really use it, except for listening to it once or twice.
- vr46 4y agoI couldn’t afford to get into vinyl now. I have bought quite a lot of records over the last five years, mainly to support the brand new record shop that appeared in my town - the first place selling vinyl in twenty years - but gone are the days when I could come back with a literal bag full of records from a holiday in Toronto taking advantage of the exchange rate, and my turntable has more than doubled in price over the years. They are still wonderful artefacts, the artwork in its full glory, and so much of my record collection isn’t getting anywhere near Spotify or Apple Music - or my CDs for that matter. And on that front, I’ve been frequenting my local charity shops where CDs are only £1/€1 and walking out with stacks of great music. I gather CDs are becoming cool again
- kdksrnrb 4y ago[flagged]
- gurumeditations 4y agoVinyl albums are great art pieces. Terrible and expensive to try to listen to but the cover art looks great on a wall or shelf.
- reillyse 4y agoI definitely do this. I miss having a physical manifestation of my music and so I've bought a bunch of my favorite albums on vinyl and mounted them in my office. The vinyl albums are much bigger and have much more of a presence (than say a cd) and generally have more artwork etc. I can always play the music digitally so it's not actually about the playing of the music.
- danielrpa 4y agoI don't want to start a flame war. This said, I think vinyl sucks; it's my opinion and not some absolute statement about the universe so please respect it! It was the state-of-the art technology when I was kid, but I was so glad it was gone. Digital music is SO much better and I remember the joy of replacing vinyl by CDs and then by high quality digital files. And because of all of the above, I understand why a lot of the buyers don't have actual record players. Vinyl is a bit like 8-bit cartridge gaming, it's a mix of nostalgia with physicality, holding something fun and cool in your hands. It's more like buying a book... The albums had pretty covers, and I do remember liking to hold them in my hands, read lyrics (often included in an insert) while listening to the music. That was a nice aspect of it, but it was overall so cumbersome and lossy that I'll keep my FLACs, thank you.
- prmoustache 4y agoMost vinyl records are sold as vinyl + digital anyway. The appeal to the vinyl is the ritual that we kind of lost buy going digital. I've also gone back to start reusing CDs, at least the little I kept. I donated most of my CD collection when I moved country and kind of regret it. People keep talking about quality to praise digital media. But most people saying this listen to music through crappy bluetooth speakers nowadays. There is a very small amount of users still using decent hi-fi equipment.
- evilspammer 4y agoSo if people grew up with digital media, they would never have "lost" that ritual. No wonder they don't care about it. Its only purpose is nostalgia. When mass produced media first became possible, people probably said you could only listen to live music and the experience of not being in a venue was lost. Then everybody who grew up with a gramophone, modern turntables, Sony Walkman, etc, think the version they grew up with is the best because of nostalgia. > People keep talking about quality to praise digital media. But most people saying this listen to music through crappy bluetooth speakers nowadays. There is a very small amount of users still using decent hi-fi equipment. Lossless digital recordings are the _closest_ way to listening to the originally produced audio authentically. (It still will have artifacts from the equipment itself - the media is the message after all) You can use crappy equipment to listen to any audio, but digital is closest to ideal.
- ZoomZoomZoom 4y agoOf course they don't. About half of my modest modern vinyl collection were gifts. It's also a collectible, meaning lots of people buy for reselling, and lots of people treat vinyl the same way as Lego or comics, never taking it out from the wrap.
- pavlov 4y agoThe vinyl record is a physical NFT for these buyers. It’s a way to support the artist, it’s perhaps collectible, and (unlike a digital NFT) it looks and feels nice.
- antoine-unity 4y agoWhenever I play music for myself, I care less about convenience and more about the overall emotional experience. Vinyl means many things to me. It’s a reminder of my father’s collection, a memory from a visit to some new place that had a record shop, the proud of owning something tangible from an artist you love. The premise is not rational at all to me. However I have also spend a lot of time (and money) obsessing about the quality / condition of the vinyl, the cartridge setup and matching to the preamp and the overall turntable setup. That part is a rather good mix of theory and manual adjustments, and honestly makes for a fun hobby on top of record collecting or music listening. But yes vinyl can be frustrating. Receiving a poorly pressed disc only to have to return it kind of sucks.
- Connor_Creegan1 4y ago[dead]
- petecooper 4y agoI have vinyl. I don't have a turntable yet. I live in a rented house and there's no room. My vinyl lives in flight cases[0] so when I move out (and I may have to do that in a hurry when the time comes) I can put them in a truck and know they're safe. According to Discogs, I have 115 releases in my collection[1]. According to Bandcamp, I have 600+ releases in my collection[2]. These two are closely linked. I started buying vinyl (for the second time) near the start of lockdown in 2020, spurred on in part by all the live events being cancelled. >95% of all my vinyl comes via Bandcamp, and ~90% of that is saved for Bandcamp Friday[3] (the ~10% being short run or a limited purchase window where I can't really wait). Vinyl pressing plants were backed up with orders, sometimes the wait time was months, and that became the norm for a while. Shipping charges were…OK…but there were delays with couriers being swamped. Then the Ukraine situation happened and fuel prices went into orbit. Shipping charges for these plastic discs got a lot more expensive. Even now they're pretty insane in the UK compared to a few years ago. Shipping internationally? Brace yourself, that's gonna sting. Moving plastic stuff around the world in a way that it doesn't get damaged involves thought about the materials, courier track record, etc. Legend has it that Adele's 2021 album was pushed to the top of the pressing plant queue thanks to a considerable financial incentive from her record label, which had knock-on delays across the industry[4]. A subsequent legend has it that the demand was significantly overestimated and the surplus stock ended up in goodwill[5]. Me? I'm still waiting optimistically for Special Request's "Zero Fucks"[6] on vinyl, but as each day passes I'm less sure it'll actually happen: >Vinyl editions to follow in 2020 and will be released and deleted on the same day. Pay 0.00 for these downloads. Enjoy life. credits (released December 30, 2019) 2020 didn't really pan out as we expected, after all. [0] https://www.swanflight.com/lp100-recordbox.html https://www.swanflight.com/lp100-recordbox.html [1] https://www.discogs.com/user/petecooper/collection?header=1&sort=added&sort_order=desc https://www.discogs.com/user/petecooper/collection?header=1&... [2] https://bandcamp.com/petecooper https://bandcamp.com/petecooper [3] https://daily.bandcamp.com/features/bandcamp-fridays-update https://daily.bandcamp.com/features/bandcamp-fridays-update [4] https://www.nme.com/news/music/whats-causing-the-vinyl-delay-adele-is-not-the-problem-say-music-industry-insiders-3094213 https://www.nme.com/news/music/whats-causing-the-vinyl-delay... [5] https://old.reddit.com/r/vinyljerk/comments/11q1gk2/i_dont_even_know_what_to_say/ https://old.reddit.com/r/vinyljerk/comments/11q1gk2/i_dont_e... [6] https://specialrequest187.bandcamp.com/album/zero-fucks https://specialrequest187.bandcamp.com/album/zero-fucks
- bandrami 4y agoI'm a part-time DJ and turntabling is so much better on vinyl than on a jog wheel. But of course you're limited to the physical crate you're willing to lug with you, and one PLX-1000 weighs about three times as much as a DJ-505. Timecode vinyl solves the crate problem but not the weight problem, so nowadays I only do vinyl when clients specifically ask (and are willing to pay more). That said, Numark and a few others have battery-powered portable turntables for 45's (or rather 7" 33's, which is a thing now) and holy crap are those fun.
- topranks 4y agoDJing since the early 90s. 1000% get that turntablist / scratch DJs prefer turntables. But for the kind of beat-matching and quick mixes I do (reggae/dancehall mostly), CDJs are much better imo. Finer control for every degree of turning the platter, plus cue points to get back to quickly. It’s a preference I guess. I still buy LPs to listen to at home, but when it comes to performing 100% digital.
- bandrami 4y agoYeah, when I do an EDM set I love the jog wheel for tweaking the phase and tempo (though nowadays you just press the sync button, kids today, get off my lawn, etc.) But I'm mostly doing geriatric hip hop, and one thing I love about the vinyl resurgence is a lot of 80s and 90s stuff got reissued. That is one thing I love about Mixxx and Xwax: with timecode vinyl a drop really sounds like a drop.
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoI own a bunch of laserdiscs but don't own a player.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoI can see this. I owned a record store in the 90s, and an ecomm spin off of the store from 97 to 07. In any case, "diggin in the creates" as its said is an adventure. It's a ritual. Thumbing through bins, holding and admiring the cover art...maybe talking to other shoppers. It's unique. And certainty can't be duplicated online. As something to do with friends. As something to collect (a la baseball cards), I can see it. I guess that's why there are used records stores popping up.
- boomskats 4y agoAnecdatally, I have a collection of ~50 vinyl records and don't own a record player. I have some pretty high-end audio gear, so I'm sure one day I'll get one, but until then it's just my preferred way of supporting the artists I like. I've never really thought about it, it just happened that way.
- plantain 4y agoThis is obviously bunk, but I'm sure these people do exist, because I was previously one of them (in a pre-Spotify era). I felt guilty for pirating some of my favourite albums, so I bought them on vinyl because it seemed cool to get a tangible, physical representation of my contribution. Meanwhile I continued to listen to the FLAC's.
- saba2008 4y agoI've done this even with CDs. 50% figure for vinyl sounds plausible to me, considering cost of turntable and hassle of actually using it (unless you enjoy the ritual and experience of physical media). And vinyl makes great merch.
- dist-epoch 4y agoWhy do people find this shocking? Many buy records for the aesthetic, for the Instagram. You know, the counter-cultural, non mass-market, non mainstream, "I don't watch TV, lol", underground "think different" kind of thing. Just like many buy books that they never intend to read to use as a nice video call backdrop. It's important to have the proper mix between eclectical and practical books, some technical, some art. Honestly there is a startup in here, creating a "proper" book list, suitable for your ingroup.
- thom 4y agoJust wait until you hear how often most of the books on my bookshelves get read.
- Loranubi 4y agoI buy films on Blu-ray but didn’t have a Blu-ray player for a long time. I never really intended to use them. They are backups.
- ralphc 4y agoI'm an old, I grew up with vinyl, walked into stereo stores with dozens of turntables to sell, have about 200 records from back then. I was glad to leave it all behind, first with CDs then digital. My main memories of vinyl was constantly trying to keep dust off the needle, off the records, not touching them with my fingerprints. There was a special brush that you put some special liquid on that, got the dust off, waited for it to evaporate...I just wanted to listen to music. I did buy a USB turntable a few years ago but that was to capture music from the obscure Atlanta new wave bands that didn't make it to digital. And even those I can now find on YouTube, someone's done the work for me.
- modzu 4y agowell since nobody here has mentioned it one of the big draws of vinyl (certainly to us djs) is that on a turntable like a technics you can adjust the tempo with no loss in quality. this isn't possible digitally. that means put on your favorite rap album, drop the speed 2% and now the bass hits 2% harder ;)
- crazygringo 4y agoIt's entirely possible digitally, although I've never encountered consumer playback software that did it. Digital audio editors will do it with resampling and there's no loss in quality. You can learn about digital signal processing to understand why quality is unaffected.
- modzu 4y agoso actually i've built digital signal processing software :) the argument becomes a little nuanced at this level -- we should define what we mean by "quality".. and i think the explanation for "why/how" the sound is affected in the digital vs analog case is quite interesting for anyone with the time to explicate! that said, agree my choice of words was too strong. really just mean as far as what is accessible for an average listener, there is no comparison to the simple analog control of a vinyl record.
- topranks 4y agoWhut? Give me that sweet digital time stretching over analog pitches up/down on a turntable which affects the tone. Preference I guess.
- nazgulnarsil 4y agoThey're identity totems
- 999900000999 4y agoI don't see the issue. You buy it to support the artist and have something to hang up on the wall or collect.
- s1mon 4y agoI wonder how many of these fans without record players call them "vinyls" [sic]? Seems like that Venn diagram might be close to a circle.
- davidgerard 4y agoreblog of https://www.musicbusinessworldwide.com/50-of-vinyl-buyers-dont-own-a-record-player-data-shows/ https://www.musicbusinessworldwide.com/50-of-vinyl-buyers-do...
- user00012-ab 4y agoAnd? * People that buy action dolls/funko, keep them in the original packages and don't play with them. * People that buy NFTs... I have no idea what you do with NFTS. But you don't use them. * People that bought beanie babies also just keep them in the boxes.
- cocacola1 4y agoI am one of them. I only ever paid for one vinyl – $5 for the soundtrack of The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly. The others I got as gifts.
- mistyvales 4y agoIf you invest a small amount over what you would with a Crosley into playback, you'd get why people seek out vinyl, especially older or really good modern pressings. Sadly, a lot of pressings these days are pretty bad, so it taints the listener's concept of what vinyl could sound like (in addition to the Crosley). That said, if people want to spend $30-50 on a random color variant they'll never listen to, then mozel.. they could act as an investment or just art.
- mjgoeke 4y agoMy first thought is, are they differentiating between people who buy vinyls for themselves vs someone who has a record player? Seems like they may be jumping to conclusions here.