13 ms·
Too many people take too many pills
- local_crmdgeon 4y agoI hate these articles. While yes, this is true, it's also true that _many_ people have severe, untreated illness that they're just "toughing it out." My friend with BPD ruined his life because he's "stronger than the disorder, I don't need to take my meds" Spent millions foolishly, genius engineer - horrible story. Easily fixed.
- valachio 4y agoThere is no guarantee that pills would've helped your friend. In fact, these medications can worsen a patient's condition.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- asdfman123 4y agoThere is a fine and very important distinction to be made here. If you have a health problem, you should do your best to get exercise, eat healthy, etc. However, that doesn't mean medicines are wasteful or pointless. People often greatly benefit from them. I've struggled with ADHD, depression, and anxiety my whole life. And indeed, yes, the best treatment I've found is diet, weight training, and long-duration cardio. Which I do. But people who are "in the hole" need medicines to dig them out. And also, people with kids/multiple jobs don't have as much time as I do. And these habits take years to finally stick. And I still need ADHD medication. And the best treatment for things like this is to try every treatment you can together, but don't overwhelm yourself in the process (and it takes wisdom to not overwhelm yourself). People on Twitter opine about this kind of stuff piss me off. They think their vague notions about what is right for society--that they have no experience with--should take precedence over my decades of (informal) research and lived experience. It's okay to have opinions and discuss things, but don't try to bully the people who actually know what they're talking about.
- gms7777 4y agoYeah, as someone with ADHD, good diet, exercise, sleep, etc. are critical for managing symptoms. They're also effectively impossible to maintain consistently without medication.
- maleldil 4y ago> They're also effectively impossible to maintain consistently without medication. This is key. As someone with bipolar disorder, I'm forever stuck in a cycle of stable with good habits -> episode happens -> can't keep the habits -> get worse -> medication changes/episode passes on its own -> I go back to good habits -> stable... With mental illness you never know when it's going to act up and ruin your life, so the least you can do is use your energy - when you have it - to keep your body in a decent baseline. Thankfully, this cycle takes many months to start again, so I live a decent life most of the time.
- escapedmoose 4y agoDiet/sleep/exercise/sunlight are always the first step, and if you don’t at least get those, you’ll be hard-pressed to feel decent no matter what else you do, regardless of whether you have other medication-dependent conditions. That said, there are way too many people out there who have no experience with conditions which require medication, who seem to think that those things are a substitute for medication rather than a baseline that must be kept up alongside medication. I’m no psychologist, but I tend to assume that a driver to thinking this way might be the sense of safety that comes with self-righteousness. Similar to victim-blaming in crimes, where people pick at the personal faults of crime victims (however slight) in order to reassure themselves that a similar thing couldn’t happen to them. Imo it’s a coping mechanism for a world where long-term suffering can be brought on totally at random.
- skissane 4y ago> That said, there are way too many people out there who have no experience with conditions which require medication, who seem to think that those things are a substitute for medication rather than a baseline that must be kept up alongside medication. It is complicated. Some people have mental health conditions which are always going to require medication. Some people have mental health conditions which are never going to require medication. And some people have mental health conditions where it depends on environmental circumstances. For that last group, lack of sleep/diet/exercise/etc can be part of the environmental circumstances which makes medication required, so fixing that can make medication less required, and may even go some way towards making it no longer required. Even if certain other things can make medication no longer required, sometimes it is still helpful in the short-to-medium term to give you the space to implement those things > but I tend to assume that a driver to thinking this way might be the sense of safety that comes with self-righteousness There are serious concerns about iatrogenic harm in mental health due to overdiagnosis, misdiagnosis and overprescribing. Some people who are critical of medication are approaching the issue, not from some sense of superiority, but rather from negative personal experiences with the topic, for themselves and/or family members. Taking psychiatric medication and being critical of it are not mutually exclusive-I myself do both. Medication is the least worst thing for me right now, but I hope one day I can solve some other problems in my life and remove some stressors and I may eventually wean myself off it. And simultaneously I believe a lot of people out there are being harmed by being prescribed the wrong medications. For example, the widespread prescribing of antipsychotics to adults and children without psychosis, by prescribers who are ignorant of the risks of brain atrophy [0] and who don’t communicate those risks to patients/parents. If you have schizophrenia, those risks may be the lesser evil; if you have a kindergartener with Aspergian traits and mildly violent behaviour, I’m not convinced it is. Maybe as a last resort once you’ve exhausted every alternative, but I know clinicians for whom risperidone is their first resort for such a patient not their last [0] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0004867418797419 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0004867418797419
- birdyrooster 4y agoWho are you to say that spending your millions is foolish this way or that way? We all end up as dirt. Why not live eccentrically and take risks? It makes for a good story which you have conveniently cast as horrible. I bet that story is plenty interesting and worthwhile as is yours.
- doodlesdev 4y agoYou clearly never met anyone with BPD.
- Zircom 4y agoWhen you say BPD are you referring to borderline or bipolar? Because borderline is usually treated with therapy as the first-line treatment, while meds are definitely the norm and most effective for bipolar. OPs description of his friend ruining his life by not taking his meds seems more like bipolar.
- throwaway743 4y agoEh, could be either really
- kevviiinn 4y agoBut they are very different in their presentations
- quintushoratius 4y ago> Why not live eccentrically and take risks? Maybe because there are dependents that needed that money for school, shelter, clothing, or food. There was a story in the news recently about a guy who spontaneously gave away $200k by throwing bills out of his car window. Seemed like a feel-good story, at first. It turns out that he gave away his family's life-savings and they're now destitute.[1] Money can absolutely be wasted and spent foolishly. [1] https://www.nbc15.com/2023/04/13/man-throws-200k-cash-out-car-window-onto-interstate-police-say/ https://www.nbc15.com/2023/04/13/man-throws-200k-cash-out-ca...
- spondylosaurus 4y agoYeah, I don't think people realize how many conditions exist that are highly treatable now but were prolonged, miserable death sentences less than thirty years ago. Taking "too many pills" sounds bad on the face of it, but it's an infinitely better alternative than letting your intestines slowly rot inside your body or your nervous system fray itself to pieces.
- 1letterunixname 4y agoExactly. Nuance is the missing ingredient here, no pun intended. I currently have untreated inappropriate sinus tach where my heart rate is continually 100+ BPM. This will require a cardiologist to sign-off, probably for ivabradine since beta blockers are giving me depression. And it's my understanding that node ablation has a low success rate and I'm not interested in a pacemaker.
- moritzwarhier 4y agoAs far as I know, there is no evidence-based treatment for BPD based in medication, except for basically what amounts to tranquilizers. What's common is to prescribe SSRIs and similar medication for all kinds of psychiatric illnesses, including BPD. The evidence that this would help in the long-term is vague to non-existant, and I'd avoid trusting it (as with almost all research on anti depressants). The best-researched facts about SSRI antidepressants are the increase in suicide rates and the "side effects", which are still often underreported, and include problems with basically all bodily systems, because serotonine is an importat t neurotransmitter. Not to forget about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-SSRI_sexual_dysfunction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-SSRI_sexual_dysfunction SSRIs can also reduce life expectancy. Personally, after being on an antidepressant (Effexor) for 6 years, I can also say that they massively reduced mental stability and self-awareness for me. There are many meta-studies about this by now, somehow ADs are still seen aa evidende-based medicine comparable to insuline for diabetes. This is far from the truth, the mechanisms of action are poorly understood and effectiveness has been painted in an unrealistic way by pharma companies who make these pills. https://www.bmj.com/content/370/bmj.m3200 https://www.bmj.com/content/370/bmj.m3200
- jvm_fan 4y ago[flagged]
- schwartzworld 4y agoReminds me of Steve Jobs. He had the extremely rare TREATABLE form of pancreatic cancer, and the money for the best treatments, but died because he chose green smoothies over medicine.
- thenerdhead 4y agoWho exactly is responsible for the patient’s wellbeing long term? The old idea of doctors and pharmacists should be putting themselves out of a job doesn’t seem to be reflected in many healthcare systems. It is also not morally responsible for patients who may not be self reliant to do so for a number of reasons(I.e. not in right health or mind). On the reverse, how many doctors or pharmacists actually recommend lifestyle and supplementation changes before resorting to a prescription through observation? My experience has been quite disappointing and I lose faith every time I get a checkup. For what it is worth, I’m not on any prescriptions and actively refuse recommended prescriptions when only seen for 30 minutes every half year. It always feels like an up sell when all you want is to be sent on your way with an acknowledgment that you’re healthy.
- irsagent 4y agohttps://archive.is/fi1L1 https://archive.is/fi1L1
- poulpy123 4y agoYes I take too many pills for my liking but I don't do that for the pleasure of swallowing pills, I do that to not end at the hospital
- Semonto 4y agoVery prominent are also homeopathy. They if you need to go to a doctor regularly and you don't have a proper diagnosis you might just like going to a doctor
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoThe fact that Homeopathy is even considered normal treatments is appalling.
- shrimp_emoji 4y agoHaving a subpar education system is expensive. https://www.thinkimpact.com/literacy-statistics/ https://www.thinkimpact.com/literacy-statistics/
- aschearer 4y agoPeople want pills or miracle diets. People don't want lifestyle changes. They're busy, stressed, strapped for cash, and anyway they like the standard American diet. Collectively, we could shape our environment so healthy decisions are easier and unhealthy choices are harder, but we can't even agree to tax sugar. So we won't make policy changes anytime soon, and individually many of us will fail to make healthier choices. What more is there to say?
- asdfman123 4y agoAs a doctor it's your job to give your patient something that will treat them. You can't tell someone "if you exercise an hour a day, your problem will go away" because at least 9/10 people won't do it.
- JohnFen 4y agoI expect my doctor to give me the best medical care. If that's telling me to make a lifestyle change, that's what I want (whether I follow his advice is an independent issue). I 100% don't want a doctor to give me medication that isn't necessary.
- asdfman123 4y agoI’ll tell you what your doctor might not be telling you: - 30 minutes of cardio, 3x a week is a bare minimum. The more cardio the better, so consider endurance sports. - Resistance training is necessary too, and can be done at home with no equipment - Get at least 10 minutes of sunlight right after you get up or right after the sun comes rises, even if it’s cloudy, if possible - Don’t drink more than 2 drinks in a day - Try to reduce stress as much as possible - Get plenty of sleep - Cut out digital distractions - In general try to eat as many natural foods as you can, especially more fruits and vegetables. Avoid eating chemicals if you can, hydrogenated oils, etc. Now you’ve heard it, as well as everyone else reading this thread. It’s up to you to do it. But odds are, for the most part, you’ve heard it before and don’t need reminding. If you’re confused about any of the details on this list, you are all people who are in the top quartile (at least) in learning things on the internet, and can figure the rest out yourselves.
- michelb 4y agoInteresting to see which countries have these problems. Reads to me like it’s very much a political problem. In my country I practically have to fight my doctor to get pills or an xray if they deem it unnecessary. Which is great in the end, as it saves our society a lot of healthcare costs.
- JohnFen 4y agoI had surgery last year, and had to give a list of the medications I currently take. My list had a single item, OTC allergy medication. The surgeon and intake nurse both independently double-checked that my list was complete. They told me that it's almost unheard of for someone of my age to have no ongoing prescriptions and they wanted to be sure a mistake wasn't made. I was very surprised by this. I was even more surprised when I surveyed my friends and discovered that every single one of them has at least one ongoing prescription. I had no idea!
- aschearer 4y agoNice going, John! Role model material. What is your secret?
- JohnFen 4y agoI have no idea. This whole thing surprised me -- I just assumed that I was "normal" in this respect. I don't have a secret, as far as I can tell. I am moderately physically active, and I do eat moderately healthy, but not exceptionally so on either count. I suspect that, rather than being a role model, I just drew a lucky number in the genetic lottery.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoLuck definitely has something to do with it. It took me a while to get that given that I thought my mom was a hypochondriac. It turned out she was just sick her whole life. I’m 48 now and don’t have any prescriptions yet, I hope I can maintain that.
- seizethecheese 4y agoBeing moderately active and eating moderately well may very well put you ahead of the vast majority of people.
- obruchez 4y agoHow old are you?
- hnburnsy 4y agoI believe the headline is a play on the line from Shoot to Thrill by AC/DC... > Shoot to thrill, play to kill, Too many women with too many pills
- hnburnsy 4y agoNote the song was recorded in 1980.
- bluefirebrand 4y agoAnd was probably referencing recreational drug use, not over-prescribed drug use.
- atchoo 4y agoProbably not. The meme of the "doped up women on prescription pills" has been a thing since probably the 50s. There was lots of over-prescription targeting "house-wives" before the opioid crisis e.g. diet pills, sleeping pills and tranquillizers. Your 80s doctor would ply you with all sorts of amphetamines, barbiturates, quaaludes etc. Lots of these have since been withdrawn due to causing medical problems. Marilyn Monroe dying from a barbiturate overdose in the 60s.
- dmreedy 4y agoAnd earlier even, though laudanum was a tincture instead of a pill. Society has for a long time felt that women's "hysterics" have warranted "medicating".
- atchoo 4y agoAh yes, Laudanum, good example of the same phenomena. Apparently it was a pill in 1618! I'm also reminded of Rolling Stones 1965 "Mother's Little Helper" which was about women and prescription pills: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mother%27s_Little_Helper https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mother%27s_Little_Helper
- chickenpotpie 4y agoAs someone who takes a pill daily that fixes my brain chemistry, I would like to clarify that it is simultaneously possible that many people are taking pills they don't need and many people are not talking pills they do need. I despise generalized statements like "xyz medication is over prescribed" because it is also in some ways probably underprescribed. I didn't seek treatment for a dibilitating illness for many years because I was repeatedly told that the medication was abused and all I needed were lifestyle changes. For me, the medication was underprescribed.
- fear_and_coffee 4y ago[dead]
- manuel_w 4y agoSlightly related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16252372 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16252372 I noticed that taking pain-killers is a very common thing in american TV shows. The main protagonist (male hero) gets hurt, goes to the bathroom, hastily pours a handful of pills into his hand and pops them into the mouth. Not one, but a hand full of pills, cleary too many. I've seen it so much, I'm starting to wonder if it's a TV trope. I'm wondering if pharmaceutical companies are sponsoring this. It's akin to product placement.
- SturgeonsLaw 4y agoLike the way toothpaste ads show them squirting 3x as much paste as you actually need onto the toothbrush
- quintushoratius 4y agoThat's just like how shampoo companies advise you to "lather, rinse, repeat". It's a great way to boost sales, but besides being unnecessary it's terrible for your hair, your water bill, fish living downstream, and your wallet.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gs17 4y agoPersonally, I've had much better results with repeating, but I haven't bothered to experiment enough to see if it's from "rinse, lather, rinse" or the full "lather, rinse, lather, rinse".
- gumby 4y ago> That's just like how shampoo companies advise you to "lather, rinse, repeat". It's a great way to boost sales. It’s no accident that they code a loop with no termination condition (except the implicit emptying of the bottle). Really boosts sales!
- ars 4y ago
- neonate 4y agohttp://web.archive.org/web/20230429132941/https://www.economist.com/science-and-technology/2023/04/26/too-many-people-take-too-many-pills http://web.archive.org/web/20230429132941/https://www.econom...
- harha_ 4y agoI'm just so glad I didn't start taking SSRI's, my doctor almost forced them down my throat but I didn't take them because I felt like I don't need them. And I didn't need them.
- fastaguy88 4y agoThis article would be much more informative if it told us more about categories of pills (or diseases), how frequently they are taken, and the ages of the people who take them. Almost half the US population has hypertension [0], and 19 million have stage 2 hypertension -- those people should be on drugs. Each year, 800,000 Americans have a stroke, and another 800,000 have a heart attack -- these people should be on drugs. My doctor's office has me on more than 5 drugs, but I only take 2 regularly -- the others are for specific short term conditions (e.g. poison ivy). In general, statins, aspirin, and anti-hypertension drugs cost effectively save lives. I have no doubt that there are too many people who take too many pills, but there are also too many people who should be taking medication and are not. The article does not make a strong case that, for a given age group, we are being over medicated. [0] https://www.cdc.gov/bloodpressure/facts.htm https://www.cdc.gov/bloodpressure/facts.htm
- WarOnPrivacy 4y agoToo many people also don't take enough pills - because they can't afford them. Myself, friends and family all have untreated conditions and aren't getting preventative care because the out-of-pocket cost of meds and treatments are more than their total earnings. Due for Shingles vaccine? $400. Need an inpatient visit to resolve something before it becomes serious? $2800. Five hundred here, $5000 there and pretty soon healthcare becomes an alternative to housing.
- ashout33 4y agomy grandpa is on like 12 different pills, it's insane. You need one of those daily pill planner, that have the pills grouped by day of week
- throwawaylinux 4y agoSo... We're okay with questioning our Lord and Savior, the pharmaceutical and healthcare industries and regulators now?
- cvalka 4y agoToo many people read too many books