5 ms·
Tokyo has 20 times as much WiFi as it needs
- johnwalkr 4y agoI’m skeptical that this plan will work. About 15 years ago, SoftBank used to offer public wifi using its customers routers. It was available in many restaurants locally, or you could pay to access all routers. It didn’t connect you to the internet more often than not, and I learned to not even try connecting when I saw a SoftBank sticker in a restaurant. Presumably over time connections had some issue and over time fewer and fewer worked. More recently I had a WiMAX plan with KDDI. WiMAX worked great and it also came with nationwide wifi access. While this worked in cafes, even at walking speeds leaving it set to automatically connect on my phone would cause my phone not to be connected half the time as it would be continuously joining and leaving wifi networks or occasionally get stuck on a login screen. Again I learned to leave it off. The free networks from convenience stores and JR work in a pinch but you have to stand still and remember not to set it to automatically connect because the login is not persistent your phone will happily connect which effectively disconnects you from the internet. Also note that allowable wifi transmission power is lower in Japan than many countries. Between that and congestion you’re lucky to connect 20m from the glass front of store with a router in it, let alone in any other direction.
- iraldir 4y ago"Not even the mighty power of blockchain can erase all of those issues" Maybe it's a good thing if journalists are replaced by AI after all...
- jgrahamc 4y agoThis is The Register. It’s a British publication and frequently very sarcastic. I am British and I could feel the sarcasm drip off the screen.
- defrost 4y agoThe comments carry on with the tone: > Should be a great way to demonstrate how Blockchain can scale to millions of transactions per hour every morning when the trains arrive. As an Australian I'm very not British but do share the love for upbeat backhanding.
- ghaff 4y agoYeah, there's a long tradition with a number of British tech pubs to write in a slangy, snarky style. It's probably not to everyone's taste but that's how things are.
- andylynch 4y agoThe Register is never going to be a cheerleader. They have running jokes about how Apple won’t return their calls because they are too critical. Their tagline is “Biting the hand that feeds IT” and the Vulture logo is quite deliberate. Also the BOFH is possibly their longest running segment!
- rjh29 4y agoI am in Japan and when my mobile net has run out I've had to use public wifi for a day or two and it's not a pretty picture. I find I can barely connect after multiple tries and they drop out frequently, and often have time limits like 20 minutes on them. Usually I get a sim from the airport vending machine, or for longer trips go to Yodobashi/Bic Camera and get one, you can get 30GB for less than the cost of a month's internet at home.
- yoavm 4y agoI don't know how it works on iPhone, but on Android you can easily get a new mac address and get additional 20 minutes. Settings > Developer Options > Wi-Fi non-persistent MAC randomization. Then just forget the network and reconnect.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI don't know how it's managed on your phone, but I get an option per WiFi network on my phone to control whether I use a random MAC address or a my phone's.
- yoavm 4y agoYes, but AFAIK by default (Android) it will use the same random MAC address for each network. I think it is randomly generated based on the SSID, unless you tick the aforementioned option.
- circuit10 4y agoiOS has “Private Wi-Fi Address” which I think is the same thing
- accrual 4y agoThe feature creates a MAC address for each access point and rotates them after 6 weeks without joining. It would be interesting to collect some of these and see if they have anything in common - same OUI, or from a group of OUIs, or totally random, etc. > Starting with iOS 14, iPadOS 14, and watchOS 7, your device improves privacy by using a different MAC address for each Wi-Fi network. This unique MAC address is your device's private Wi-Fi address, which it uses for that network only. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT211227 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT211227
- kwhitefoot 4y agoWhy does this need a blockchain? Fon/BT has been sharing residential WiFi for years without blockchain.
- loriverkutya 4y agoI'm not sure if blockchain is the solution to the problem, but my problem is I want to make sure it is clear that if somebody else is using my residential wifi the traffic can be clearly associated to that user in case they do something in the grey/illegal area.
- traceroute66 4y ago> Why does this need a blockchain? Fon/BT has been sharing residential WiFi for years without blockchain The difference is, as per the article, that the Japanese operator wants to re-imburse the WiFi hotspot subscriber. Something which is very much alien to BT's way of thinking. Of course, whether blockchain is the right way do implement that aspect is a different question, and in terms of implementation I would agree that blockchain is un-necessary. But you know, blockchain bandwagon .....
- sekh60 4y agoI really thought we all got off the blockchain bandwagon.
- traceroute66 4y agoSo did I, so did I ... ;( I still have memories of people like lawyers desperately asking me how they could use blockchain in their practice.
- bwesz 4y agoChuck could have used the blockchain to store the Rosella Drive address so it couldn't be tampered with. (This is only half a joke.)
- 4y ago
- bobs_salsa 4y agoCan anyone explain to me how a decentralised authentication system like this would be more efficient than just using conventional/centralised methods?
- rippercushions 4y agoIt's not, but it would have been more efficient at attracting uncritical press a few years ago. But NTT moves at the speed of the former state telco monopoly it is and that's why this is happening only in 2023.
- asterix_pano 4y agoIsn't it sort of the same question regarding if it would be better to use an open source vs a closed source solution? This way all operators can be sure the profit is shared fairly, it's transparent. However it creates probably unnecessary data redundancy. It could also be pruned after a while.
- lordnacho 4y agoCan't help but think this could be done without some Ethereum smart contract. Then again I also get the feeling this project would not get any attention without it. Isn't BT WiFi something in the UK like this? When someone has a BT router in their home you seem to be able to connect to it via the phone app.
- traceroute66 4y ago> Isn't BT WiFi something in the UK like this? When someone has a BT router in their home you seem to be able to connect to it via the phone app. Well, yeah, it is "something like" ... until you get to the part where the Japanese operator talks about financially re-imbursing the homeowner for the unwashed masses using their WiFi. Greater chances of pigs flying than BT doing that !
- senttoschool 4y agoThe problem with many non-Silicon Valley regions (countries), is that many of them don't understand software technology. Politicians and investors in those countries simply ride the hype wave. If Ethereum/blockchain is a hot topic, they will ask to include that piece of tech. You can see this in Singapore as well. The government there tried to use Ethereum to verify government documents: https://www.verify.gov.sg/ https://www.verify.gov.sg/ It's a bad idea. Slow. Much more costly. No benefit. Hard to scale. Downsides to tech flexibility.
- knorker 4y ago> should be shared with blockchain No, this is not finally a use case for blockchains. (before any zealot goes "AHA!", obviously I mean a distributed trust blockchain, not e.g. git)
- EGreg 4y agogit does not use a blockchain
- knorker 4y agoNot in a way that is relevant, I agree. But if you squint enough then it's an "immutable" ledger that appends and uses signatures. Blockchain zealots often yell out "git" as a success story of blockchain, whenever someone says "blockchain as a solution is yet to find an actual problem to be applied to". So that's just me trying to avoid a "gotcha!" from people who are talking nonsense. But it seems there's no way around it. Either I'll get a blockchain zealot replying "what about git!" or if I try to preempt that I get someone sane (like you) replying "git's not that!". Sigh.
- can16358p 4y agoWhile I love the blockchain-based solution which also probably handles payments (a nice use of crypto instead of many scam projects that give it a bad reputation), if they don't scale on a L2 network scalability will be a huge issue.
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoI live in a high-density multi-family apartment block. 300 families in a small space. There are probably at least 300 SSIDs being broadcast in this area, plus Bluetooth and other noise. This is a low-income joint, so amenities are comparatively minimal, but there's just no excuse for not forging a deal with one of the local ISPs and having their WiFi/Ethernet to blanket the property, convincing residents to shut their personal ones down in favor of a robust replacement. (I don't know how you do that, but the benefits are obvious.) In fact, when I moved in, their marketing material blurbed "High-Speed Internet!" but it turned out they just meant that the wiring was present for us to hook it up. There is already a WAP supplied by my own ISP directly below me, and I can easily, seamlessly move to using it instead of my in-home network, which is great during an electrical storm.
- prashnts 4y agoSorry but at home I would like to connect to my WiFi, with my preferences and access to my local network. The last time I was forced to use a common access point was in my dorm at the university, and even then I bought a small travel router to rebroadcast the AP. But I do understand what you mean. I guess one thing to do is to set the router to not broadcast at full power, and use 5GHz to limit the range.
- nly 4y agoMy old apartment (built to rent) had a pretty sweet scheme. You connected to a shared WiFi network throughout the building and was put in VLAN 0 with all the other unauthenticated devices, but once you signed in (captive portal) you were bumped in to your own private VLAN and you could only see / connect to your other devices. The only downside was any device where it wasn't convenient to login to the captive portal had to have its Mac address registered to your account.
- rubatuga 4y agoBut what if you spoof the MAC address?
- 4y ago
- michaelt 4y ago> If this all scales, NTT estimates Tokyo won't need to add any more Wi-Fi access points or private 5G cells, even as demand for connectivity increases. Thus achieving the dream of all telcos: Charging people without delivering any service whatsoever!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- h4kor 4y agoCongratulations NTT you invented a shitty Freifunk.
- nottorp 4y agoThe shortened title is misleading. "Private operator wants to use other people's wifis to offer service in Tokyo" seems to be a more accurate description. Btw does Japan have multiple cell phone providers or is this NTT a monopoly? Also, blockchain? This is not the current hype, it should have been AI powered!
- creshal 4y ago> Btw does Japan have multiple cell phone providers or is this NTT a monopoly? Softbank and KDDI are the biggest competitors afaik, with NTT holding about 50% market share. Big, but not monopoly tier.
- fomine3 4y agoHere's original PR article: https://group.ntt/en/newsrelease/2023/04/26/230426a.html https://group.ntt/en/newsrelease/2023/04/26/230426a.html Still I don't know how blockchain useful.