11 ms·
This seems like much bigger news than it's being received as. Sure, other chip makers do sketchy things, but is that really where we're at in 2023? We're so b
by freedomben 4y ago
This seems like much bigger news than it's being received as. Sure, other chip makers do sketchy things, but is that really where we're at in 2023? We're so beaten down by proprietary user-disrespecting hardware/software that we just shrug it off?
<rant because I hoped for more outrage on this and am not seeing it>
This makes me mad. I'm so sick of this type of thing. It's a horrible time too because the embedded 5G chips are about to be part of everything, sending telemetry back about where they are and what they're being used for. I think it's utterly ridiculous that if you aren't ok with this type of thing, then you have to go way out of the mainstream to find products, and often there's no viable option. "Ownership" now means nothing.
Imagine if you bought a car from somebody, and they secretly kept a spare key and periodically used your car to run their personal errand. Would you be ok with that so long as they always had it back before you needed it so you never knew they were doing it?
That's what is happening when you "buy" a device and the device maker uses it to run code that serves only themselves (without receiving permission), to the detriment of your privacy. I can only hope RISC-V combined with people willing to care can lead to a return to a time when people actually own stuff and ownership is something we respect.
</rant>
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoIt is upsetting, but I am not sure how it can be countered. I am genuinely asking what is the alternative here. We go back to the lack of trust. You basically have to assume everything is trying to communicate with mothership. You mention RISC-V, but was it ever really tested against the same proposition? I miss the dumb everything days, where the manufacturer simply could not spare compute power on additional features like telemetry.
- freedomben 4y ago> You mention RISC-V, but was it ever really tested against the same proposition? Good point, there's no reason a manufacturer couldn't build it in. My thought was more along the lines of lower barrier of entry that would enable more competition (Qualcomm is near monopoly and has pretty anti-competitive practices that make it super hard to compete with them), and hopefully there will be more transparent options out there. As a user of GPS I'd like the option of enabling something like this because the old days of taking forever to sync with the satellites did suck. But I want to be able to decide for myself, not have the decision forced upon me by the chip's firmware. > I miss the dumb everything days, where the manufacturer simply could not spare compute power on additional features like telemetry. Oh man, me too. The nostalgia for this burns like a fire in my soul.
- ebuck 4y agoThe alternative is to drop the purposeful error in GPS positioning systems. GPS has a built-in error for the civilian use, and a higher-accuracy system for military use. The concerns when it was deployed included unwanted parties using GPS as a guidance system component for missile / drone attacks, etc. This led to the early GPS enabled phones needing an enhancement to their positioning system. The early releases (think car navigation systems) would be tuned to un-do the GPS offsets, but as that was rarely a 100% solution, they would "smart match" to the nearest viable alternative. This is why in many older car systems, you are sometimes registered as being on the feeder road (or a parallel road) until the system can no longer resolve your travel with your map position. For smart phones, the error was deemed to great to have decent customer satisfaction, so enhancements to GPS came into being. The phones would listen for nearby markers (typically wifi stations) and report them back to a data warehouse, effectively building a dynamic map of all the wifi points. Then one could anchor that map based on non-moving items (like cell phone towers) and obtain fine-grained positioning information by running relative strength matches to the nearest 3 or 5 wifi access points. The system updates eventually for broadcasters that change ids, are powered off, are relocated, etc. It has error checking built-in to reduce confusion around one or two new / missing / relocated markers. All of this was driven by customer demand, and the data collection necessary was mentioned in the past. As the maps are unlikely to ever be placed inside of phone devices, and would require intensive storage to duplicate into each phone, as well as intensive bandwidth to update each phone, odds are that the calls to the manufacturers (which are selling "enhanced GPS" positioning systems) will continue for a very long time. The solution? Pressure the government to release accurate GPS positioning, so industry will see the running of an independent positioning system as redundant and not-cost effective. Then, when you get a position with GPS, you get an accurate position, and you need not send a signal to correlate nearby signals with your true position. Does it suck? Yes. Is the current system subject to abuse? Yes. Is the current system abused? (I'm a skeptic of human nature, so) Yes, but its abuse patterns seem to be nearly identical to its use patterns, with the difference being that the companies providing this service can use it to help people find their way to the grocery or to help other people find their way to a specific customer. Qualcom and others have a very vested interest in not abusing the system, as they would lose their competitive edge should the government decide to take action against them. That said, many people worry about the government being the party abusing the system.
- JohnFen 4y ago> I miss the dumb everything days, where the manufacturer simply could not spare compute power on additional features like telemetry. Indeed. The only "smart" things that I'm willing to have anymore are those that I've built myself. Apparently, very nearly no commercial manufacturers can be trusted anymore.
- joezydeco 4y agoSorry, but trying to be optimistic about RISC-V is only going to lead to more pain. It's just an instruction set architecture and it's still going to be made in large SoC fabs by Qualcomm-class companies that want to save a buck on ARM licensing. There's no way to win here.
- freedomben 4y agoYou're right RISC-V just existing won't save us. I mentioned in a sibling comment, but my hope is that it leads to more competition so there are at least options. It probably is naive since these days there are tech startups and tech giants, and any startup that starts to gain traction will go for an exit strategy to be acquired, then it will killed. So things are probably not going to get much better. Perhaps though, with RISC-V options there could be a real solid open source option (aka a Linux phone). It wouldn't have to be nearly as mature and polished as the duopoly, but at least something that allows people to participate in modern society (much like desktop linux is now).
- inamberclad 4y agoWhat does an ISA really help with, though? Qualcomm doesn't have an advantage because of an ISA, they have an advantage because creating power efficient RF designs that keep up with the latest standards is incredibly hard. Until someone can compete with them on a bandwidth per watt ratio, they will continue to abuse their position.
- mdasen 4y ago> my hope is that it leads to more competition so there are at least options There are already lots of options within the ARM instruction set. The problem is that Qualcomm makes the best modems and the best (non-Apple) processors and uses their wireless patents and chip lead to squash competition. > Perhaps though, with RISC-V options there could be a real solid open source option (aka a Linux phone) The issue isn't the ARM instruction set. We have Linux smartphones (beyond Android) that you can buy today. You can buy a PinePhone and run Ubuntu Touch, postmarketOS, Mobil, LuneOS, and more. You can buy a Librem or Volla Phone or Fairphone. If you want out of the duopoly of Apple and Google, there are devices you could have shipped to you today! The problem isn't the ARM instruction set and getting RISC-V processors wouldn't make much of a difference for Linux (or FOSS in general) on smartphones. The ARM instruction set isn't what is keeping the tech giants in power.
- fckgw 4y agoThis article just has little to no information in it, at least not enough to get all up in arms about. Supposedly this nefarious information is sent in the clear but no analysis was done to see what it actually happening? They're just guessing? The whole article is "Qualcomm privacy policy says they can do xyz" and then extrapolating from there.
- freedomben 4y agoAgreed, the article is lacking. In some other threads it's come out that this is a GPS sync feature to speed up the time it takes for GPS to get locks. A useful feature to be sure, but IMHO not one that has to be implemented in such a user disrespecting way. It should be a toggleable switch, preferably opt-in. It wouldn't be hard to throw up a dialog on first GPS access that lets the user opt in. As implemented where the user is utterly powerless to stop it, it's an egregious privacy violation.
- szundi 4y agoI am almost sure there is this switch there and in these cases it was set to enabled.
- bee_rider 4y agoEvery time there’s some giant violation of privacy, the rejoinder is “well, it was in the privacy policy, you all agreed to it.” The moral of the story is that we have “to extrapolate from there.” And they have clever lawyers to write their privacy policies. We don’t, so we have to “round up” in a sense unless we want to be blamed for agreeing to things. The Qualcomms of the world created this situation, we just have to deal with it.
- kroltan 4y agoAlso, where in hell is anyone even expected to find the privacy policy of a part of their product? In the box manuals before turning on? By then it's too late. It's not possible to agree to something you're not made aware of.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- phh 4y ago> This seems like much bigger news than it's being received as. This has been widely known for more than a decade (Sorry I can't provide with a source. I was expecting Google search-in-the-past feature to work, but it doesn't). As to whether the privacy policy has been declared properly or not, it depends on the OEM: See for instance https://www.bsr.at/mediafiles/Handbuch/CipherLab/User_Guide_Cipherlab_RK25_Mobilcomputer_Aussendienst_EN_Part2.pdf https://www.bsr.at/mediafiles/Handbuch/CipherLab/User_Guide_... which shows Qualcomm's IZat default integration (This documentation shows an Android 7, but that screen has existed since at least Android 4.4) > Sure, other chip makers do sketchy things, but is that really where we're at in 2023? Literally all chip makers literally do that exact thing (except maybe the Unique ID part), just because that's how you're supposed to do A-GPS. For A-GPS you need at some point an oracle that is capable to give you an approximate location. There are some privacy-compatible ways to do that, but I'm not aware of anyone who even looked at it. (Looks like GrapheneOS skims that feature altogether, that's a way that works) > It's a horrible time too because the embedded 5G chips are about to be part of everything, sending telemetry back Even though Qualcomm can make things worse, the vast majority of IoS already do just that, and don't require 5G. Of course I overall agree with you on lost ownership of modern electronic devices (and as you point out, everything became electronic devices), I'm just saying that it's nothing new. I think you need to get back at least a decade to see the unstoppable start of it (though DRMs are much older than that) > I can only hope the RISC-V combined with people willing to care can lead to a return to a time when people actually own stuff and ownership is something we respect. What does the ISA change in that regards? I would guess that the currently most deployed RISC-V device are nVidia graphic cards. And you're probably very aware that you don't fully own nVidia graphic cards. I'm also aware of other RISC-V devices in the field that are even more locked down.
- ignoramous 4y ago> > This seems like much bigger news than it's being received as. > This has been widely known for more than a decade (Sorry I can't provide with a source. I was expecting Google search-in-the-past feature to work, but it doesn't). Yep. Nitrokey's post was disappointing but understandable from a marketing perspective. The thing that needs more discussion is the closed source stuff Android OEMs / ODMs run at higher ARM privileges rendering all of Google's grand ceremony around Android security moot (other than on Pixels may be).
- yakireev 4y ago> Imagine if you bought a car from somebody, and they secretly kept a spare key and periodically used your car to run their personal errand. This is happening already. Teslas can be controlled remotely, and it does not have to be the owner of said Tesla. Yes, somehow people are okay with that. The world we live in gets scarier and scarier every year.
- prottog 4y ago> The world we live in gets scarier and scarier every year. One could accurately summarize progress since the Industrial Revolution as asking whether we could (and how), and not whether we should (and why). You can see this expressed in the growing focus on STEM education vs. the liberal arts and results in things like remote-controlled Teslas. Cave Johnson said, "science isn't about why; it's about why not". The traditional counterbalance of that "why not" -- classical education, religion, etc. -- have all been falling behind.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> Cave Johnson +1 for the Aperture ref.
- ynniv 4y agoAperture Science We do what we must because we can. For the good of all of us.
- walleeee 4y agoyes, and instead of gradually retiring superstitious worldviews in favor of cautious, contemplative secularism, far too often we uncritically shift religious faith to technology this is yet another face of Moloch
- simonh 4y agoYes to liberal arts, absolutely, but it’s not liberal arts that’s trying to stick its oar in to the place of science in society. It’s made up bullshit ‘social science’ that’s one step away from parapsychology and crystal healing. Liberal arts is a natural ally and fellow traveller with science and technology. In fact much of early science grew out of liberal arts endeavours. Geometry from sculpture and perspective in art and architecture. Chemistry from developing pigments for painting.
- mouse_ 4y agoyeah but whatcha gonna do
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 27fingies 4y ago> That's what is happening when you "buy" a device and the device maker uses it to run code that serves only themselves (without receiving permission), to the detriment of your privacy. I can only hope RISC-V combined with people willing to care can lead to a return to a time when people actually own stuff and ownership is something we respect. I dont understand how this would change anything.
- JohnFen 4y agoThis angers me as well. At the same time, this sort of thing is so very common. It's hard, and unhealthy, to be in a perpetual state of outrage. This sort of thing is exactly why I won't be replacing my smartphone when it dies. The only way to avoid being abused by tech companies is to avoid using their products as much as possible. This is where I'm at. I don't see any other solution in the near term. Tech has been weaponized against us.
- soulofmischief 4y agoYour enemies want you to think eternal outrage is unhealthy. That's how they eventually win; They can play this game longer than you're willing to play it.
- JohnFen 4y agoI am not willing to live in a state of eternal outrage. It's an incredibly unpleasant place to be and what's the point? My outrage changes nothing, and I don't need to be outraged to do whatever is in my power to change things. Not giving these bastards money is a good start.
- prewett 4y agoThis article finally pushed me over to thinking that we need to start pushing for some laws to limit this sort of thing. It's just pervasive, and "not giving [them] money" is completely ineffective. And for some companies, like Google or Facebook, it's pretty hard for a consumer to actually give them money in the first place, nor is practical [0] to not use their products. [0] practical, not possible.
- JohnFen 4y agoThe main reason why I'm eliminating these kinds of things from my life is self-protection rather than trying to get companies to change their behavior. As you say, getting them to change outside of effective legislation is impossible. > for some companies, like Google or Facebook, it's pretty hard for a consumer to actually give them money in the first place, nor is practical [0] to not use their products. Well, the only Facebook product I use is WhatsApp, and that's to talk with one person in Europe who only uses WhatsApp. The only Google product I use is YouTube, and I only use that with an account that is not used for any other purpose, and on a tablet that is not used for any other purpose. So my experience is that avoiding these companies is entirely practical. All you give up is a small amount of convenience.
- callmeal 4y ago>Imagine if you bought a car from somebody, and they secretly kept a spare key and periodically used your car to run their personal errand. It's worse than that. It's like you bought a house from somebody and they secretly left cameras all over the living room, bedroom, bathroom, and kitchen so they can get 'telemetry' ostensibly to improve the next house they build, for 'safety' in case there's an accident, and to 'protect the children'. I think people are so overwhelmed and anxious that there's no space for fighting back against this kind of over-reach. And even if you did have the time and space and energy, how would you even go about it?
- wlesieutre 4y agoSo it's like buying a Tesla https://www.reuters.com/technology/tesla-workers-shared-sensitive-images-recorded-by-customer-cars-2023-04-06/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/tesla-workers-shared-sens...
- bgun 4y agoBut worse, it's like being required to own a Tesla because it's the only car available.
- namibj 4y agoAnd the cameras being integrated so the driving would break if you'd neutralize them.
- entropicdrifter 4y agoAnd the laws are written such that replacing the software responsible for sending the camera feeds back to Tesla with a FOSS equivalent is illegal, because you're less trusted than the spying psychopathic corporation.
- IYasha 4y agoAnd such people are ridiculed in the news.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- SV_BubbleTime 4y ago>This seems like much bigger news than it's being received as. Well, it's an ad for another phone. That doesn't take away from the truth, but it's marketing even if it's true.
- fsflover 4y agoI wish more ads were based on truths.
- JeremyNT 4y agoIs it big news? It might be, but we haven't seen the packet captures yet. I'm not trusting this shallow analysis (from a source I don't have any particular reason to trust) without seeing more details or corroboration.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoAs mentioned, it's now 2023 and the Snowden revelations were in... 2013, right? There have been at least a hundred similar news events since. The "healthy skepticism" bit on the subject is misdirected at this point. Backwards, really.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoThat said, the article is disappointing.
- Pietertje 4y agoI wonder how this will fly in an European Court with GDPR.
- anecdotal1 4y ago> Imagine if you bought a car from somebody, and they secretly kept a spare key and periodically used your car to run their personal errand. I wouldn't say this is equivalent to them "running a personal errand". If they were remotely enlisting your device in some computational task, sure. But modern cars do grant the car company the "keys" to your car: - Tesla's system - GMC OnStar (since 1996!) - Ford SyncConnect (since 2017) - HondaLink - BMW Assist - VW Car-Net Even if you don't subscribe to the service they can still remotely access your vehicle...
- naikrovek 4y agoGetting mad won't fix it. You putting quotes around words such as "buy" and "ownership" push people away from your view, and any view like it, unless they have already adopted it that view or a similar one. if you want this to change, stop ranting, stop scare-quoting normal English words because you disagree with the way they are used, and approach the problem logically. asking rhetorical questions and being angry is not how you get people thinking about this. state your case, (we know it, but state it anyway) without emotion of any kind, and without unanswered questions. start by verifying what this article is claiming using your own device. the entire article could be BS designed to enrage people and to see how far it spreads before it is fact-checked. it is very difficult to listen to someone who is ranting and who is speaking from a point of emotion unless you are emotionally invested yourself. it is much easier to ask someone to think about facts than it is to ask them to feel about emotions if you want them to think about what you are trying to say.
- naikrovek 4y ago> the entire article could be BS designed to enrage people and to see how far it spreads before it is fact-checked. this turned out to be the case.
- amelius 4y agoJust imagine what would happen if Qualcomm had a Chinese owner.
- matmann2001 4y agoIt almost did. There was a hostile takeover bid from Broadcom a few years back, and the US gov intervened to block it. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-qualcomm-m-a-broadcom-timeline/timeline-broadcom-qualcomm-saga-comes-to-an-abrupt-end-idUSKCN1GQ22N https://www.reuters.com/article/us-qualcomm-m-a-broadcom-tim...
- ignoramous 4y agoI see the Anglosphere has moved on from being terrorized by the Middle East to China.
- bob1029 4y agoThe reason some of us have given up on these things may be due to reaching one conclusion or another regarding true motivations & capabilities involved. We all have a finite amount of time to struggle on this planet and picking battles is an important part of living. For me, this is much broader than some specific technology device. This is about an epic struggle between the "consumer" class and some elite technocratic class. To quote Ron White: "And then they squared off with me in the parking lot, and I backed down from the fight, cause I don't know how many of them it would have taken to whip my ass, but I knew how many they were going to use. That's a handy little piece of information, right there."
- Synaesthesia 4y agoHow can we ever trust tech companies again? The whole model needs to be scrapped to one which is actually controlled by and accountable to the public.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoTrust hasn't mattered for a while. Growth and profit are the pope and king. The "whole model" runs on these companies. They have civilization by the balls, and we have to live with it unless we throw almost every computer advancement from this millenium out.
- hkt 4y agoRISC-V isn't the answer. The state's lawmaking and law enforcing powers are the answer.
- noncoml 4y agoYou have a nice green field in your little town. There is this one guy that notices a gopher every so often and starts panicking and trying to get support to bring some professional to push them out. Most people don’t walk in the field and have never seen or been bothered about the gopher or his little hole. So everybody brushes this guy off as paranoid and his fears as exaggerated. Then one day in your small walk you stumble upon the hole and start panicking yourself and trying to raise the problem. You are wondering why isn’t everyone outraged by the gophers. Even that guy that used to warn everyone daily about the seems to not care anymore. Well, it’s not that he doesn’t care. He is tired and defeated.
- dstroot 4y agoOutrage is not going to bring about a solution. Either “the gov’mint” has to step in and regulate or consumers have to vote with their wallets. Many of us own iPhones because we choose to trust Apple’s ecosystem over Google’s.
- slim 4y agoto generate more outage, we should change the title to : Chinese mobile phone Xiaomi R1 spies on it's users (or any chinese manufacturer using snapdragon 630)
- Eumenes 4y agoThis news will only appeal to very technically minded individuals, like the HN audience. Have you seen the average persons smart phone home screens or social media feeds? They don't care about privacy one bit. Its all about comfort and convenience.
- Xylakant 4y agoIt seems like much smaller news than what they pretend it is. If you open up the suspicious domain in a web browser, it does explain what it is, who it belongs to. It’s a download location for a GPS almanac, used in assisted GPS. See http://izatcloud.net/ http://izatcloud.net/ The shocking news is that modern smartphones connect to a huge list of locations for various purposes. A large laundry list of providers can collect your ip addresses. But there’s little way around that. Every phone with a GPS chip will download that almanac from somewhere. Qualcomm uses Qualcomm. Broadcom will likely use Broadcom.
- williamDafoe 4y agoI think you guys are ALL missing the point. Imagine if you bought a brand new car but later found out it had a stolen engine? This is probably why Qualcomm is collecting data from its chipsets. Qualcomm gets a 5% royalty (5% of the cost of the entire handset) payment from each vendor. Qualcomm needs to know if a vendor is lying about the number of chipsets it has used. They need to know if the vendor claims 10M cheapo handsets and 1M expensive handsets - they need to know if the numbers are actually reversed! This backdoor can get them the evidence they need to invalidate a license with a vendor - cut of chipsets shipments - and start a new negotiation. Remember, Chinese vendors will cheat like bananas. Chinese vendors asked for a HUGE discount on domestic phones - and they go it - but at the cost of a higher-than-normal royalty for exports. They are probably cheating, it's what they do.
- mattmaroon 4y agoHow do you cheat with a physical object like that? Isn’t Qualcomm selling them the chips? It’s not a windows install, it’s a physical item they buy. Don’t they just pay by the unit?
- hammock 4y agoThey might pay more for a unit that goes in an expensive phone than in a cheap phone, even if it's the same unit There are all kinds of licensing agreements that go along with physical products. For example a book or videotape that is licensed to be used in a library costs more than a book or videotape for personal consumption
- mattmaroon 4y agoIt exists, but are chips actually sold that way? And are major phone OEMs likely to violate such contracts to save some money? And is it sending any data that would be then determine it if so? It just seems pretty far fetched to me that this is at all the point. Not impossible, but very improbable.
- 4y ago
- annoyingnoob 4y agoReads like an ad to me.