10 ms·
'Delete Act' seeks to give Californians more power to block data tracking
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hadrien01 4y agoJust copy-paste GDPR, and enforce it.
- taosx 4y agoGDPR doesn't work as described and companies have found many ways to make the process difficult. There is a clause (last case scenario) where the company can say that the data is critical to the system and can't delete it.
- anticristi 4y agoNo, they cannot https://www.enforcementtracker.com/ https://www.enforcementtracker.com/ You probably refer to "legitimate interests". If you play that card, you are required to show a "Legitimate Interest Balancing Test", in which you show that your interests are arguably more important than the interest of the consumer: https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protection/guide-to-the-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr/lawful-basis-for-processing/legitimate-interests/ https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protectio... Source: I love to watch Facebook becoming the first GDPR unicorn, i.e., a company with more than 1 billion € GDPR fine.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoGDPR isn't a good fit for the American system. The principles that animate it [i.e. rights of access (Art. 15), erasure (17) and objection (21)] should be incorporated into law. But a combination of public and private enforcement, plus a strong civil regulator (but one who isn't obligated, by law or practice, to respond to complaints), is a better start. > watch Facebook becoming the first GDPR unicorn They're paying $725mm to users in America [1]. Difference being the damages go to users, not a regulator. [1] https://www.popsci.com/technology/meta-725-million-lawsuit-cambridge-analytica-settlement/ https://www.popsci.com/technology/meta-725-million-lawsuit-c...
- mindslight 4y agoThe problem is that no form of data personal protection is really a good fit for the American (political) system, because the US leans heavily into the fallacy that if it's legal for one individual to do some as private activity, then allowing to be scaled up to mass corporate behavior is inherently reasonable. So telling Surveillance Valley to stop building Stasi 2.0 is akin to telling your friends that they must forget your birthday. Furthermore, the American concept of "consent" mostly functions as a legal fiction whereby less powerful parties are coerced into signing a bunch of binding legal documents. Hence the desire to copy the GDPR verbatim - because if a privacy law used the American version of "consent", why even bother? One way to port the overall idea of the GDPR into the US legal system might be to define a non-transferable property right in personal information (information about yourself), which could only be licensed revocably. Those two key bits would be tough though, given widespread deference to the Coase fallacy that has blessed much corporate looting.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> no form of data personal protection is really a good fit for the American system Not true. We have the Privacy Act of '74, HIPAA, GLBA and COPPA, to say nothing of e.g. California's CCPA and Virginia's CDPA [1]. Or Illinois' biometric privacy protections [2]. > the US leans heavily into the fallacy that if it's legal for one individual to do some as private activity, then allowing to be scaled up to mass corporate behavior is inherently reasonable This is true for rights, which don't get diluted through assembly. Not rules or the law. Plenty of laws exempt small businesses and natural persons. > the American concept of "consent" mostly functions as a legal fiction whereby less powerful parties are coerced into signing a bunch of binding legal documents Not entirely true. See: EULA enforceability as it pertains to natural persons [3]. > to define a property right in personal information (information about yourself), making it non-transferable and revocable at any time One generally defines a property right to enable transferability. Revocable property isn't property, it's a license. Making information one's inalienable property that can only be revocably licensed sounds neat, but it doesn't add value over enumerating data rights. [1] https://www.comparitech.com/data-privacy-management/federal-state-data-privacy-laws/ https://www.comparitech.com/data-privacy-management/federal-... [2] https://www.jacksonlewis.com/sites/default/files/docs/IllinoisBIPAFAQs.pdf https://www.jacksonlewis.com/sites/default/files/docs/Illino... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/End-user_license_agreement#Enforceability_of_EULAs_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/End-user_license_agreement#Enf...
- andygeorge 4y ago> GDPR doesn't work as described could you expand upon or clarify that? i work in systems infrastructure and have been a part of implementing GDPR-driven changes in both apps and infrastructure, so it certainly seems to be working in my line of work
- taosx 4y agoI'm not saying that systems are not in place, I'm just saying that it's too hard for the average consumer. - After you've requested deletion the company has 30 days to "respond" but they can extend that with two additional months. - They can go to extreme lengths to verify the identity of the user which they have the right to do so and if you don't respond to the confirmation they are not obligated to delete anything. I've encountered both practices in the past (and I've only made 3 requests, ever). The dream would have been an automated way to do it, something like a government service where each company would have to publish metadata about captured user data and once you request deletion through the service the company would receive an event, a webhook call...
- andygeorge 4y ago> it's too hard for the average consumer oh yeah, hard agree with this
- givemeethekeys 4y agoIf by GDPR you mean the cookie banner that appears on most websites? It's as if we ask for something and are punished for it. I'd like to see some proof that GDPR has achieved major changes in data privacy before a copy-paste.
- minsc_and_boo 4y agoNitpick: EPD is responsible for the cookie consents everywhere, not GDPR - https://gdpr.eu/cookies/ https://gdpr.eu/cookies/ GDPR primarily concerns the user with information and takedown requests, the latter which could be considered deletion.
- koito17 4y agoFrom the senate press release, > The CPPA would create a simple way for Californians to direct all data brokers to delete their personal information, free of charge. I wonder how something like this would actually be enforced. At the moment I can request my personal information to be deleted, but there is no way for me to determine whether such request was actually fulfilled. Even with this option to direct "all data brokers", the problem remains, and it seems to be briefly acknowledged in this sentence > Tsukayama said that what most experts in the field agree on is that California law leads the nation in this space, but that it’s still barely enforced. I don't know of any good way to enforce this kind of legislation, even if I totally support it.
- bobthepanda 4y agoIt sounds like a recipe for enforcement by lawsuit, which is similar to the ADA for example.
- mlyle 4y agoIn order to enforce by lawsuit, the people who have standing to sue (or a regulator acting on their behalf) need to somehow know that an organization is out of compliance. For the ADA, you can see whether there's enough parking spaces or whether the ramp is legal or whether you were denied a reasonable accommodation. Here, there's a mandatory audit mechanism, but it's unclear whether the proper recordkeeping will be required to really allow issues to be spotted at audit.
- d4mi3n 4y agoIs there any way to know if any audit mechanism works before it's actually been put into practice? I share your concerns, but it seems a bit early to worry that auditing + lawsuit enforcement isn't worth giving a spin. Do we have examples of similar legislation that has or hasn't been successful with similar contexts/enforcement? The closest examples I can think of are in finance, like fair lending laws or SOX compliance; both of which are heavily dependent on auditing data.
- dan-robertson 4y agoI hope that other jurisdictions (than the EU) will find different policies around data protection to try to achieve something that is actually good for people in practice now that they can look at how gdpr worked out. I think the law requiring subscriptions to be easily cancelled is a good example of something that is good for people because it makes something they already want to do easier/better. On the other hand, the thought of having to cope with umpteen different privacy laws makes me glad I don’t work on a website for the general public. My main complaint with data protection laws is that they often require actions from users, either some kind of ‘informed consent’ like gdpr/cookie laws, or some kind of deletion request. I would much prefer some simpler laws like ‘no keeping behavioural data more than 45 days’ that don’t require people to opt in to privacy. Though there are flaws with what I wrote – what does it mean for training neural networks; there are cases where you want that memory, eg maybe if you liked a tv show/YouTube channel and there was more than 45 days between series/videos, you would want the new series to be recommended to you; there are complex chains of causality like if eg I watch a cat video, get recommended a bunch more cat videos over time, watch some of those, then in some sense the signal from the first cat video has caused me to still be getting recommended them more than 45 days later. It seems like this requires taking action to delete a lot of data from a lot of places and puts the onus on the consumer, which I think isn’t great. But the ‘data broker registry’ might make it easier to do? I wonder what the EFF were thinking about when they supported this. Perhaps they just considered it to be strictly privacy-increasing and therefore good, and didn’t worry about second-order effects like consumer fatigue. Maybe the second-order effects don’t matter so much – they are second order after all.
- cccbbbaaa 4y agoData retention limitations are absolutely a thing in GDPR and previous European laws (ie. Informatique et Libertés).
- dan-robertson 4y agoI don’t think the problem with GDPR is that it is lacking rules.
- superkuh 4y agoI can't help but notice in the bill itself there's no definition of what a data broker is. Does anyone know the legal definition in California? Do you have to be an incorporated person to be a data broker or can human persons have this force applied to them as well? edit: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displayText.xhtml?lawCode=CIV&division=3.&title=1.81.48.&part=4.&chapter=&article= https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displayText.x... "California's definition of a "data broker" is set out at Section 1798.99.80. (d) of California's Data Broker Law" It sounds like data broker has to be a "business" that collects information about someone they don't have a direct relationship to and sell that to a third party. This might still include sole proprietorship businesses but it sounds like normal non-incorporated human persons and personal websites wouldn't be forced to delete things. It's interesting to note that "Financial institutions" are given an exception from the "data broker" tag and regulations and can still do whatever they want.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> it sounds like normal non-incorporated human persons and personal websites wouldn't be forced to delete things Natural versus artificial person is probably irrelevant. (Sole proprietorship is a "normal non-incorproated human" doing business.) If your personal website is somehow collecting information from non-visitors and then selling it, that's a data broker. In practice, I can't see why or how that would accidentally occur.
- superkuh 4y agoI think your implicit assumption here is that all websites are businesses in some sense? But people often run websites that have no monetary transactions involved (except hosting, domain, etc costs). Since I'm one of these I worry about being forced to delete data just because some random persons who came to my metaphorical backyard BBQ didn't realize there was a metaphorical photographer there taking pictures. I get the spirit of the law and I'm glad incorporated entities will be regulated. I just anticipate substantial use of the 'Delete Act' for frivolous cases and malicious uses. Much like GDPR. With the good comes the bad.
- rootusrootus 4y agoRight along with this, about we set up enforcement and require all data brokers to register with the gov't and give them API access for enforcement queries. Then the gov't can have a page that lets citizens find out which data brokers have information about them. Hell, let's put a button on that page that says "Forget me."
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> require all data brokers to register with the gov't and give them API access for enforcement queries This codifies a unified surveillance apparatus.
- rootusrootus 4y agoCan the government not already purchase access to these databases?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Can the government not already purchase access to these databases? Sure. But providing mandatory registration and a legally-required API sure makes it easier. (There is also zero chance those data don't wind up accessible by every small-town cap.)
- yieldcrv 4y agoOther assets classes already have that
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Other assets classes already have that Financial assets. You can even become an M&A advisor and, as long as you never touch securities, avoid registering with anyone.
- yieldcrv 4y ago
- tayo42 4y agoThis site you're posting and reading comments on won't let you delete your comments and accounts. I think at best if you email and ask they might randomize your username.
- anaganisk 4y agoI don't know if it counts but this site also doesn't collect personal information, I don't even remember if I had to verify an email.
- tayo42 4y agoYou still need to have the foresight to do things like not reuse usernames, even use your real name, or accidently post something that could identify you. It's still an account owned by a person
- r00fus 4y agoI've always thought - if it's possible for someone trawling HN to build a pretty comprehensive profile of users based on usage pattern, comment structure, and occasional personal details shared (like gender, familial status, location). I think it'd be pretty easy for most accounts that have > 1000 comments.
- flangola7 4y agoHow does that work with GDPR right to be forgotten? Many users here are EU residents. YC undoubtedly has accounts with banks that have a presence in the EU, making judgements enforceable. Stylometry will be an identifying characteristic soon if it isn't already.
- emodendroket 4y agoHey, sure. Keep inventing stuff for me to do at work. I don't mind.
- Robotbeat 4y agoI wonder if this will effectively ban LLMs like the similar legislation in Europe?
- gaogao 4y agoLikely not, but it depends on the language around anonymizing that the bill uses
- SoftTalker 4y agoWhy make this so difficult? Just ban personally targeted advertising. That's what everyone is really trying to achieve. Nobody really cares about any individual's personal data beyond using it to try to sell him something. Ban using it for advertising and it becomes worth less than the cost of collecting and storing it. Sites can just go back to content-based targeting for ads.
- amelius 4y agoYes, and as a result people might consume a little less than they did before and that will help the climate as a nice side-effect. I guess we'll get a ban on personally targeted advertising when Chinese companies start buying data brokerage firms in the U.S.
- unpopular42 4y agoNo, people won't consume less, as long as they have the same disposable income. Unless you mean that this will hurt the economy and people will become poorer. In that case yes, they will consume less, but not sure how it can be seen as a nice side effect.
- amelius 4y agoI mean, you don't have to always buy something. You could save some money?
- wnevets 4y ago> Why make this so difficult? Just ban personally targeted advertising. Probably because they think that would cost the economy billions of dollars overnight. Very few politicians would want that on their resume.
- sjfidsfkds 4y agoMeasurement of conversions (ie. did somebody make a purchase after clicking the ad) is even more economically significant than targeting, and this is where ad publishers are most afraid of losing revenue due to privacy rules. The popular commentary on this subject is pretty detached from the business. The grandparent commenter’s “ban ad targeting” proposal manages to be both too extreme while also having little effect on data collection.
- stainablesteel 4y agoi saw some youtube advertisements for a service that requests data deletion on your behalf, but i was super skeptical of that because it just seems like the service you're paying to do this would then become the next centralized hub of what information of yours once existed. I don't mind the idea of a government-based interface to all of this with strict adherence to privacy
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- unpopular42 4y agoI wonder how do they plan for those requests to be authenticated. Easily proving that you are you over the internet is not a solved problem.
- jeppester 4y agoOne would think that tracking companies are experts in that specific field.
- cm2012 4y agoThese laws make no sense at all because basically no one is actually hurt by ad tracking (it actually improves ad quality and relevance), except if you just think advertising in general is wrong. All of these data privacy laws are just a minority of people wanting to push back against capitalism and big tech. I get it but it's such a waste of energy.
- jkubicek 4y agoI value my privacy. I don't have a relationship with data brokers and I see no need for them to know anything about me. For the record, I have no issue with targeted advertising within a single org. If Google shows me ads based on my search history or youtube history or gmail contents, that's great. If I don't want Google to know anything about me, the process is easy; I stop using Google/Youtube/Gmail. If Google shows me ads based on an online purchase at an unrelated web store, that's completely unacceptable. If I don't want Google to know anything about me, it's not clear at all how I would do that.
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoOne can never delete data from the Internet; one can only Streisand it.
- jrnichols 4y agoI'd love to see "people search" websites like Spokeo/etc be forced to delete everything about me. once I find a website, make an account so I can get my information deleted, another 3 sites have popped up. I think even one of them wanted a copy of my drivers license before it would delete my information "obtained from public sources." it's been frustrating. I shouldn't have to hire an identity protection service just to remove myself from annoying websites.
- YeBanKo 4y agoWhy not just make it opt-out by default with a requirement of a a specific consent, that needs to be renewed every periodically?