4 ms·
I don't buy the deception theory at all, that it was used to make it hard to determine the year it was made. Everybody has always known which movies are new thi
by crazygringo 4y ago
I don't buy the deception theory at all, that it was used to make it hard to determine the year it was made. Everybody has always known which movies are new this year! Or which movie is from 10 years ago. To me, this falls into the common fallacy of "oh people from back then were so dumb/unobservant..." Like the busted myth that Europeans used spices to mask rotten meat.
It seems nobody knows why it started, but it seems pretty intuitive why it's continued -- it looks fancy and formal and important. You went to the Cinema and you had an Experience and at the end it was capped off with a fancy set of Roman Numerals. It's silly like a hundred other aspects of the movies, but it's kind of lovable.
And I can't help but assume that fanciness derives from years being carved in stone as roman numerals for Important Things. On buildings (date of construction), memorials (for wars and important people), and of course gravestones.
I mean, it also wasn't Star Trek 3, it was Star Trek III. Because fancy.
- hydrok9 4y agoIt's more "gravitas" than "fancy."
- sjsanc 4y agoThe GP's turn of phrase read quite convincingly like Iain M Banks, then I see this!
- pif 4y agoquidquid Latine dictum sit altum videtur whatever has been said in Latin seems deep https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Latin_phrases_(Q) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Latin_phrases_(Q)
- rintakumpu 4y agoYes, this would be my hypothesis too. I see Hollywood epics all the way from D.W. Griffith (and the studios that made them) wanting to broadcast an aura of gravitas. And nothing does that like using pretentious Roman numerals. Of course it's all convention nowadays.
- maxerickson 4y agoI would guess it started because you can reuse your work (in an age where you are taking a photo of something physical). It's a lot easier to change V to VI than it is to change 5 to 6.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoI can tell you for certain that I use Roman numerals on the copyright dates of the videos I make, because I grew up with Roman numeral copyright dates on the TV programmes I grew up watching - even children's programming had it. For some reason the one that sticks in my mind is the Blue Peter one with a copyright symbol, the old "three boxes" BBC logo, date in Roman numerals and the little stylised sailing ship logo :-) Anyway, long story short, I use Roman numerals for copyright dates because fancy like.
- kuschku 4y agoInterestingly, that's less of a thing over here. e.g., productions of the public broadcasters in Germany usually end with the date in Arabic numerals. Including Sesame Street.
- Reason077 4y agoYeah, even today the BBC seems to invariably use Roman numerals on their productions. Must be a tradition for them?
- zamnos 4y agoThey've been around just over C years, or since MCMXXII. Yeah I'd say so.
- schrectacular 4y agoLittle known fact but in the very early years they went by "BB100".
- fredoralive 4y agoThe BBC didn't have copyright statements at the end of the credits until the early 1970s, and initially they used Arabic numerals, but after a couple of years later (the mid/late 70s) switched to Roman numerals, which they've stuck with since. I think the changeover is around the time end credits and channel logos stopped indicating "Colour". IIRC in 1999 one of the trailers for the BBC's millennium coverage involved years counting up to MM in Roman numerals, which seemed perhaps to be a nod to their use of them in credits.
- TylerE 4y agoHistorically not really true. Distribution used to be much… weirder. Gone With the Wind, for instance, toured as a premium roadshow release for almost 2 years before getting a general release.
- Geezus-42 4y agoAnd I still don't understand how people enjoy it...
- ubermonkey 4y agoNo surprise there. It's a film from 1939. The grammar of filmmaking has changed dramatically since then -- direction, acting styles, lighting, staging, everything. Watching something from even the 1960s is super weird and kind of alienating. Films from very long ago are best understood as historical documents. They tell us a story, sure, same as John Wick 4, but they also tell us about the time period they're from. This isn't something that's unique to film. Novels, too, get harder to connect with as you move decades past their release. Storytelling changed, and the shared context with the author becomes harder and harder to share.
- ogre_magi 4y agoI find _modern_ cinema spastic and alienating. The pacing and cinematography of pre-1990 cinema is what feels correct to me.
- marcosdumay 4y agoI strongly suspect you were born at the 80's or 90's... Not to say that modern cinema is perfect, but somebody born at the 60' or 70's would think the 80-90's style is shallow too. Cinema has been getting quicker since it was created. (I do think it has moved so far into quick takes that it can't help but go back a little now, but I was born at the 80's, so I'm not sure how reliable is my opinion.)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y ago> Like the busted myth that Europeans used spices to mask rotten meat. This is a "busted myth?" I have a friend who was in a Soviet forced labor camp and this is exactly what they did.
- crazygringo 4y agoThe myth is about the reason for the popularity of spices in midieval Europe. And yes it's busted, because spices were very expensive -- they were luxury. The people who could afford spices were not people who ever found themselves needing to eat rotten meat. And mixing with rotten meat was the last thing you'd do with something as expensive as a spice.
- porkbeer 4y agoWould it suprise you to learn that people used to gather their own spices? Not everything was imported. Not busted it the slightest.
- fsckboy 4y agonot disputing, but in ye olde times people had a taste for a lot more rotten things, like garum and various fermented meat and fish products.
- dotancohen 4y agoAdditionally, the spices on fresh meat helped preserve the meat for an additional hour or two.