10 ms·
I seriously don't understand how Apple's processes are allowing this to happen. How is it that simultaneously, so many apps fail review for tiny details, showi
by crazygringo 4y ago
I seriously don't understand how Apple's processes are allowing this to happen.
How is it that simultaneously, so many apps fail review for tiny details, showing that apps really are having manual review done on them...
...and yet all this spam is getting through?
Forget opinions about Apple or the App Store generally. I'm far more interested in what the actual process failure is here. Because this is really bad and it's precisely what the whole concept of the App Store is meant to guard against.
So what the heck is wrong with their processes? This is such an "own goal" I'm baffled. This is supposed to be a core competency of the App Store. There's no benefit to Apple allowing all these spam apps. So how the heck is a company as generally competent as Apple messing this up so bad?
- LeoPanthera 4y ago> ...and yet all this spam is getting through? It's difficult to believe anything other than bribery.
- mulmen 4y agoNever attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoBut this would not be explained by stupidity.
- colejohnson66 4y agoLaw of large numbers seems to be one people ignore. If I’m making a scam app, I’ll just use multiple accounts and hope one gets through eventually. I won’t be discouraged by rejects because I’ll have an automated system that handles everything including retries. If I’m banned, I’ll just buy a new account and try again.
- heavyset_go 4y agoHanlon's razor is great when you apply it to your personal relationships, but it falls apart when you apply it to trillion dollar companies and their golden geese.
- mulmen 4y agoI don't see why we should assume malice based on market capitalization. It's easy to imagine a situation where an organization the size of Apple just doesn't have the competence to deal with all the spam. They're a huge organization, I doubt any one person has a complete view of App Store moderation especially (by definition) their unknown unknowns. It depends on how they measure moderation in the App store. Everything may appear to be going well from what they can see and measure. I see no reason to believe apps are getting through because of bribery when we can explain this situation as "large organizations are inefficient".
- benatkin 4y agoNo surprise at all. Every app store has been like this. It's why the whole idea is about restricting freedom, nothing more. Stallman is right.
- gloryjulio 4y agoSpot on. Very interested in this sausage factory. How did those get made exactly?
- whstl 4y agoThe infamous processes just aren't happening. When an app is updated you have to put it for review, but they don't seem to check anymore. I've worked with a couple of customers and we had to send Apple custom credentials for login, and they never use the credentials. Sure: perhaps they just wanted to see the boring login screen, or just do some automatic checking of the code. But apart from the first version, they don't seem to really open the app anymore.
- everyone 4y agoThe last app I submitted (a few weeks ago), they rejected it like 1 minute later.. Saying they wanted me to send them a link to a video of if being used (That is not a requirement that is written anywhere on the app store or its docs).. After replying with a video link they immediately accepted it.. I can only assume they just wanted to watch a video and give it a pass rather than bother actually opening it themselves.
- crazygringo 4y agoThat's really funny. My guess is actually not laziness but their device just had some problem installing apps or whatever and they had a quota to fulfill.
- ShadowBanThis01 4y agoYep. I've had them do this multiple times, although my app was made to control specific hardware that they didn't have. I did put a "demo" backdoor into the app for them to use without the hardware, but they demanded a video. I thought that was pretty reasonable and sort of enjoyed doing it. But... there is so much wrong with the App Store, and Apple purposefully keeps it that way. For example, the so-called search is an absolute sham. Apple claims that publisher name is one of the top three criteria for app search, but searching for our app by exact publisher name didn't bring it up AT ALL. At least not in the first 300 listings, which is where I stopped. What WAS in those first 300 listings? 300 that didn't contain the search string ANYWHERE. The first few contained a similarly-spelled name that Apple replaced the search term with, without asking... essentially undermining our trademark. After that there was nothing but completely irrelevant results, including numerous FART APPS, which Apple decries as undesirable in its own documentation. When challenged on this repeatedly, Apple (after initially blowing off my complaint with boilerplate) claimed to have reviewed the situation and found everything working fine. I would have had to escalate it to a legal issue asserting some kind of hijacking of our trademark (no idea if there's any legal ground to stand on there) to take it further. Apple knows the search is bullshit and lies about it. You can test it yourself as a developer.
- moonchrome 4y agoVery likely these apps are just spammed and you don't get to see the rejected apps. As for why the process isn't catching such obvious flaws - I'd say there's no strong incentive, the only feedback I've seen consistently is related to protecting their revenue cut - the rest is much more random, especially after initial review.
- spansoa 4y ago> I seriously don't understand how Apple's processes are allowing this to happen My guess is the decisions are deliberately stochastic to stop human bias entering the chat. So we get sketchy apps slipping through the cracks, whilst developers who spent a lot of love and care polishing a fine app getting rejected.
- tempodox 4y ago> There's no benefit to Apple allowing all these spam apps. You're being naive. Even if the crapware didn't sell, getting it into the AppStore costs the developer an annual subscription fee, and thus creates revenue for Apple. And if you've seen the AppStore, you know that 99% of apps are crapware with maybe 5 users.
- sinatra 4y agoThere are 20M developer accounts. And Apple charges $100 per account per year. That's $2B in revenue. Apps on the App Store make $100B in revenue. So, Apple makes equivalent of 2% of Apps revenue from developer accounts. I doubt they'll intentionally risk the $100B revenue by making their App Store full of crapware for a 2% equivalent.
- Someone 4y agoI think “developer accounts” doesn’t imply “pays $100 a year”. I have an account on developer.apple.com, but never pay anything for it. That gives me the right to generate a certificate to sign development applications and install them on a few devices (where the certificate will rapidly expire), but not to put anything on the App Store. Are you sure there are 20M paying accounts?
- sinatra 4y agoSorry, I meant that the maximum they’re making is $2B. But in reality it’s surely a much smaller number. Which makes it even more unlikely that Apple is optimizing for developer fees.
- ricardobeat 4y agoThey are not risking anything since they also take a 30% cut off any successful scam. This can only be stopped by goodwill somewhere up the management chain.
- heavyset_go 4y agoIt's the same principle as Amazon choosing to ignore the scams on their store. Amazon still benefits from scam reviews, for example, because those reviews entice people to make purchases from Amazon. Amazon profits from the scam, and has little incentive to do anything about it, given that the vast, vast majority of their customers don't know or don't care about fake reviews in the first place.
- everyone 4y agoWhen u create a walled garden like this. The people who are more likely to get into the garden are the unscrupulous dodgy assholes who will learn how to, and do whatever it takes to exploit and profit from the system. The good actors doing things in good faith are the ones who will have difficulty getting in. Another example: Youtube: Content farm garbage gets promoted by the algorithm while well made videos get hellbanned by spurious copyright claims. ..... Any system u make, people will find the best way to exploit it. Like with a democratic system of government there needs to be transparency, accountability, ombudsmen, investigative journalists + a complex web of agencies and regulations and mechanics constantly working to stop it falling into total corruption and de-facto despotism. These systems run by big corps are like the wild west, there is none of that stuff, so of course they immediately become completely corrupt.
- lapcat 4y ago> How is it that simultaneously, so many apps fail review for tiny details, showing that apps really are having manual review done on them... > ...and yet all this spam is getting through? It's important to understand that App Review is not consistently nitpicky but rather randomly nitpicky. Every indie dev has stories of urgent bug fix updates getting rejected for stupid, unrelated, nitpicky reasons, things that had already been in the app for months or years. Yet every indie dev also has stories of major updates flying through review in minutes, so fast you know it's impossible that anyone looked carefully. I do get the impression that they're doing random inspections. "Every week, over 500 dedicated experts around the world review over 100K apps." https://www.apple.com/app-store/ https://www.apple.com/app-store/ Apple seems to be bragging about that, but if you estimate how much time is spent on each app, the numbers look pretty bad. If 500 reviewers spend full-time 40 hours every week doing nothing but reviewing apps — no breaks, no meetings, no training, no vacations, etc. — that leaves only 12 minutes per app, maximum. And they're reviewing not just the app but the App Store metadata: release notes, description, screenshots. They definitely do metadata rejections.
- kitsunesoba 4y ago> I do get the impression that they're doing random inspections. As someone who's been responsible for various iOS App Store submissions for closing in on a decade, the impression I get is that the variation is primarily due to inconsistencies in process between reviewers. The corners probed by one reviewer might go entirely ignored by another and what one reviewer finds perfectly fine constitutes a violation in the eyes of another. The Play Store review process on the other hand comes off as feeling almost entirely automated barring a handful of exceptions, which works fine until some innocuous change in code or the automated review system trips something somewhere and your app listing is removed. Good luck getting in touch with a real person to fix it.
- saagarjha 4y agoI mean there’s that too. Inconsistency and lack of resources are both present.
- MathMonkeyMan 4y ago
- duxup 4y agoI wonder if it possible to really quantify how difficult it is to get an bad acting app for any store approved? We've all heard stories about random bans and apps black listed and so on. Happened to some folks I know. Having said that ... I worked on an app recently that used location data heavily. I was told all about how picky Apple (and they mentioned Google too) would be, from folks online, and at work. Some folks even suggested hiring someone who had managed to get an app approved to help us get it approved. I asked that everyone calm down ... and just let me TRY submitting the damn app first before we decided we're climbing a tall mountain or whatever they thought. I got right in to the App Store and Google Play ... no problem. Now granted my app is REALLY up front about using location data and such. But I wonder what the story really is?
- iudqnolq 4y agoI've heard (from random people) it's about whether the permission aligns with the category the app falls into. A map app is assumed to have a legitimate purpose for location. But if you want to make a journalling app that automatically captures where you visit (like Apple just did) you'll have a hard time being allowed to make the argument.
- duxup 4y agoThat would make sense as far as my usage goes. The app revolves around logistics, it's a business focused app... all those things go hand in hand with location data. I can imagine if a human saw it it would be a "yeah of course" kind of moment. Some rando "free crossword puzzles", might get a closer look.
- transcriptase 4y agoI still remember the early days when you needed a third party app to use your camera flash as a flashlight, and then having most of them request your contacts, location, and every other type of data that the OS would allow.
- 4y ago
- DuckFeathers 4y agoWhy would they have manual reviews? How would it scale with hundreds of thousands of developer accounts? It's mostly automated with rare manual escalation for "suspicious activity". The "process" is to ban the malicious accounts when reported, like everywhere else.
- kevingadd 4y agoThey quite literally justify the lack of sideloading and the 30% cut by saying that they provide you actual human services like review. "The guiding principle of the App Store is simple—we want to provide a safe experience for users to get apps and a great opportunity for all developers to be successful. We do this by offering a highly curated App Store where every app is reviewed by experts and an editorial team helps users discover new apps every day. For everything else there is always the open Internet." https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/ https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoThe problem is fundamentally that doing a thorough review of every app is unreasonably expensive and as a consequence, that will not happen. You are then left with a trade off between false positives and false negatives. It is entirely possible to have both at once. The real problem is that centralizing this process is in error. Because not all users are the same. It makes sense to have a manual review process for e.g. games, where anybody can make a game but games are relatively expensive apps that can eat the cost of a manual review in exchange for the largely uninformed user being assured that the code is trustworthy. The review process could then e.g. exclude apps that screw with the operating system in order to implement some kind of shady DRM. Some users are using their device in a professional context where lives are at stake if the device gets messed up and can justify an even more thorough review of anything that goes on the device. Some apps don't require any meaningful permissions and if run in an appropriate sandbox should not require any review at all. Some users are technically inclined and would like to run whatever code they want on their device, including code that modifies the operating system and code they wrote themselves. There is no one size fits all. A system that pretends otherwise satisfies no one.
- rapind 4y ago> The problem is fundamentally that doing a thorough review of every app is unreasonably expensive and as a consequence, that will not happen. Well they do take a 30% cut. There's no way 500 reviewers cost more than a drop in that bucket.
- AnthonyMouse 4y ago500 reviewers is what they have now and it's not working. That it's 30% is also the problem. 30% is plenty to review a paid app in the top 1% of downloads, but >94% of iOS apps are free. Not least because Apple takes 30%, which puts a lot of paid developers out of business. But 30% of nothing pays for nothing.
- illiarian 4y agoThere was also a race to the bottom early on, and everyone expects all apps to be free or five bucks at most. This put a lot of developers off
- tonyedgecombe 4y agoYou have to remember that Apple struggled because developers weren't targeting their platform for a long time. The Mac was for creative software and little else. That problem has burnt itself into their psyche to such an extent that as far as they are concerned more software targeting their platform is always a good thing. The upshot of this is Apple boasting about having 2 million apps in the App Store. This is the complete opposite of their normal product strategy where everything is pared back to the minimum. Sadly you can't have 2 million apps and maintain a high standard. The costs to review each of those apps thoroughly would be astronomical.
- ricardobeat 4y ago> Sadly you can't have 2 million apps and maintain a high standard. The costs to review each of those apps thoroughly would be astronomical. Well, that's part of the problem. Should we really have 2 million apps in the store, when 70% of them are knockoffs, scams or absolute garbage? That's currently one app for every 850 iOS users, it's a ridiculous number. The estimate for Apple's cut for app sales & subscriptions last year was 85 billion dollars. Surely that can fund a decent reviewing process... but they also benefit from all this 'activity'.
- nirav72 4y agoAre two millions apps really needed?
- hparadiz 4y agoThis is why I get so annoyed by people claiming that side loading will make iOS less secure. You trust open source apps on desktop all the time. I'd rather use crowdsourced trust indicators than some shmuck working at Apple.
- coldtea 4y ago>You trust open source apps on desktop all the time The desktop has the luxury to afford not being as secure as your phone, which serves as a 2FA device, a digital wallet, something that can record your voice and location, and your main means of everyday communication. Side-loading would just mean every person getting nagged or strong-armed to side-load alls kind of apps (from official stuff from major companies wanting to avoid Apple's pay-cut, to all kinds of shady BS), with average Joes and Janes getting their phone smashed with malware, spyware and such. The app store review doesn't have to be perfect or catch all. It just needs to be better than no review, and it does fare majorly better than Android (e.g. studies showing the latter gets 90% of the mobile malware). The app store process and notarization also means apps can be revoked.
- SCLeo 4y agoI really don't get the argument that desktops don't need to be secure. I have my password manager (yes it is encrypted, but can be bypassed by a keylogger) and my ssh private keys on my desktop.
- coldtea 4y agoThey should, but that train has left the station. At least phones have more accepted security than the "anything goes" that are desktops.
- lapcat 4y ago> The desktop has the luxury to afford not being as secure as your phone I don't understand this argument at all. I have everything on my desktop (laptop). Tax forms, credit card statements, bank statements, financial info, photos of all kinds, emails, ssh keys, etc., going back many many years. > It just needs to be better than no review It's not clear that this is true. I think that the existence of app review makes unwary consumers overconfident about the crapp store, and then they get scammed. That's how these scam apps exist and make money. The App Store is honeypot, a scammer's paradise. It's a lot easier to get yourself highly ranked in App Store search than it is to find people to scam on the open internet. But Apple tells consumers that the App Store is safe, which is a lie. > it does fare majorly better than Android The lesser of two evils is still evil. > The app store process and notarization also means apps can be revoked. Notarization is sideloading.
- anonymouse008 4y agoI feel I understand how this happened. I’ve gone through the process multiple times - smooth sailing for many apps to getting rejected for 4 months de facto (we’re rejecting you know we will be back in touch) only to be told, “you download YouTube videos” … for a text based app with no download features! What I think is this: apple is optimizing for a 24 hour turn around time. That means many systems do high level checks: entitlements, api calls, then simulator based testing. This means that if one targets specifically for simulator, there are certain ways around what is presented to AppStore, vs what is published. Further, there appears to be a check for similar references only in the target categories, or the terms placed in the App Review request. So gaming all of these features at once can lead to extremely smooth sailing by an organized effort.
- jeroenhd 4y ago>“you download YouTube videos” … for a text based app with no download features! I've heard several stories of app reviewers opening and reviewing the wrong app, including entering the credentials for a demo account into some unrelated app or service. I imagine something like that could've happened to your review.
- grog454 4y agoSo Apple's app review process never made it out of internal beta. That explains a lot.
- api 4y agoThere is no competition, so there’s no incentive for Apple to put any work into making the App Store quality better. Review is awful, search is awful, rankings are gamed, and it’s full of spam and shovelware. All the app stores are like this to varying degrees.
- oblio 4y agoAwesome! Let's pay Apple tens of billions of dollars per year so that we're basically back to Softpedia.
- sholladay 4y agoI think the most logical explanation is that app review is largely automated, perhaps with a permissive algorithm, while some sampling of apps are reviewed by humans with strict standards, which may be applied inconsistently because that’s how humans do. It’s really not that surprising to me, given the scale of the App Store.
- nonethewiser 4y agoCouldn’t it be as simple as their their auto detection is weak and their manual detection is good but isnt done on everything? In fact, isn’t that exactly what we should expect?
- AussieWog93 4y ago>How is it that simultaneously, so many apps fail review for tiny details, showing that apps really are having manual review done on them... ...and yet all this spam is getting through? Because a trillion dollar company chose to outsource manual app review to Indian call centre workers. End of story.
- saagarjha 4y agoA significant portion of the review team works from the US.
- heavyset_go 4y agoA few years ago, I made comments on HN about how I found Chinese Bonzi Buddy clones on the Mac App Store, except using different animals like tigers and lions. Same functionality of Bonzi Buddy outside of that. It's absolutely astounding to me that this problem is still going on to this day, with even scammier apps. It is worth noting that even the iOS App Store hosts multimillion dollar scams on it[1]. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2021/2/8/22272849/apple-app-store-scams-ios-fraud-reviews-ratings-flicktype https://www.theverge.com/2021/2/8/22272849/apple-app-store-s...
- redareda9 4y agoI know for a fact that some people manage to bypass Facebook Ads review process by bribing some local employees in developing countries (India, Indonesia etc..). I wouldn't be surprised if this was used with Apple as well as they usually tend to outsource these jobs in Developing countries.
- saagarjha 4y agoIt’s probably not really necessary given the poor quality of review.
- jeffparsons 4y agoIn addition to what everyone else is saying, in my experience a lot of it can be explained by one simple thing: the reviewers are just plain bad at their jobs. I'm not trying to be mean; it's just my experience. They generally don't familiarize themselves with even the most recent previous interaction, so they repeat the same mistakes that have already been resolved. They don't know their own rules. They imagine things that aren't there because some word sounded similar to another one, and they don't have enough technical context to actually understand what the words on their checklist mean. Is that surprising? I don't think so! Think about what these people are being asked to do? They're repeatedly stepping through a tedious checklist full of stuff they barely understand, and then they have a choice of either waving an app/update through, or pissing off some developer. How many people with otherwise-marketable skills are going to stay in a job like that?