5 ms·
> How in the world does a submarine going at < 40 mph not detect that it's running into a mountain? Seamounts don’t give off active emissions (except maybe if
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> How in the world does a submarine going at < 40 mph not detect that it's running into a mountain?
Seamounts don’t give off active emissions (except maybe if they are erupting), and subs usually use passive hydrophones (which rely on the active emissions of targets), not active sensors when operating underwater to avoid detection.
Navigation is done by charts using inertial navigation alongside dead reckoning. Hitting a mountain is generally because the mountain wasn't on the chart being used, though in principle in could also be due to an error in positioning (with inertial navigation, that should be much rarer than with dead recknoning alone, but its not impossible.) (In the case of the San Francisco, for instance, other charts had a notation of "discolored water" which suggested a probable seamount, which the investigation noted should have been transferred to the chart in use, but was not.)
> Are light, radar, and sonar still not enough to detect obstacles that big?
Radar is useless underwater, light would also be useless for spotting anything in time to react at speed, and sonar isn’t routinely used because it compromises stealth.
- throwaway8503 4y ago>> Are light, radar, and sonar still not enough to detect obstacles that big? > Radar is useless underwater, light would also be useless for spotting anything in time to react at speed, and sonar isn’t routinely used because it compromises stealth. Any people with knowledge in the field care to comment on whether it's feasible for a light (em?)-type, active, near-range detection system to work? It seems to me the basic problem is: - enough energy to get a signal at a range sufficient to move around any detected obstacles - high enough dissipation in water to minimize range at which detection by external sensors is possible
- iancmceachern 4y agoThe light transmission through the water, it's cloudiness, is just way to variable for something like this to work constantly, reliably.
- throwaway8503 4y agoWouldn't the cloudiness itself be a signal? Presumably it's essentially clear of suspended particles, most of the time.
- iancmceachern 4y agoA signal of what?
- throwaway8503 4y agoSomething solid ahead To clarify: I mean that, generally speaking, the presence of 'cloudy' water would presumably signify that the seafloor was close. In the open ocean, maybe a sea mount is surrounded by essentially a cloud of particles. Edit: I think your reply made the thread reach maximum depth, so I'll end it here.. I should do more reading on the topic.
- iancmceachern 4y agoThe problem I'm highlighting is it also gets cloudy randomly in open ocean, for lots of other reasons.
- iancmceachern 4y agoThe issue is that the cloudiness of water, even open water, varies greatly. So there would be either lots and lots of false positives, or the system would be too insensitive. Think driving in fog
- robbiep 4y agoHave you ever dived? Max visibility is like 30-50m unless you’re in a filtered environment
- gamblor956 4y agoYour two requirements contradict each other. You can choose one or the other, but not both. The world's militaries have invested a great deal of time and money into researching underwater sensors. The solution is not going to be discovered by random people on the Internet.
- skinkestek 4y ago> The solution is not going to be discovered by random people on the Internet. I'm fairly certain someone knows a number of things that have been discovered by random people on the internet.
- dexwiz 4y agoWater absorbs photons at most frequencies outside the visible spectrum. What we deems as visible light is actually where water is most transparent. Since eyes evolved underwater, it makes sense they would use this section of the spectrum. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Absorption_spectrum_of_liquid_water.png https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Absorption_spectrum_...
- jvanderbot 4y agoThat makes so much sense and actually unravels a few other mysteries for me. Thanks!
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Any people with knowledge in the field care to comment on whether it's feasible for a light (em?)-type, active, near-range detection system to work? I’m not in the field, but I follow it enough to say: in theory, yes, (blue-green lidar), and there is a lot of work on moving this from theory to practice. But approximately everyone is working on it (for bathymetry and for detecting subs, and similar blue-green laser tech for underwater comms), so its likely once its deployed so that a sub could in principle use it as a “headlight”, it’ll raise similar concerns to sonar, because if it is used actively, passive sensors looking for active use will also be common.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agothe issue is to detect these while maintaining stealth.
- kyriakos 4y agoNaive suggestion from someone who has zero knowledge about these things: can't an unmanned submarine drone be constantly moving ahead of the main submarine to detect these obstacles before they become dangerous to the submarine and crew?
- Loic 4y agoYes, but noise would be a problem.
- kyriakos 4y agoNoise from the drone propeller?
- hyperthesis 4y agoWouldn't a small drone make less noise than a submarine?
- jvanderbot 4y agoThat seems intuitive but one thing I've learned in my career is that obvious easy ideas that nobody does are usually missing key details.
- dragonwriter 4y agoA small drone and a submarine would make more noise than either alone.
- bheadmaster 4y agoWhat about using a pressure sensor fixed to a long pole in front of the submarine? That way, if they hit anything, the pole would hit first, and could activate the stopping mechanism.
- adastra22 4y agoThese things can't stop on a dime.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> Hitting a mountain is generally because the mountain wasn't on the chart being used How could it not be in the chart though? Is the ocean not fully mapped?
- Wronnay 4y agoNo, the ocean is not fully mapped. It's written in the article: "With only one-quarter of the sea floor mapped with sonar, it is impossible to know how many seamounts exist."
- dragonwriter 4y ago> How could it not be in the chart though? In the specific case of the San Francisco, because notations indicating a probable seamount were not transferred from other charts when the chart being used was compiled; there is some lack of clarity on how much the failures involved are the responsibility of the command crew of the sub and how much of higher command, but its definitely a failure to appropriately use existing information, not a “the information did not exist” problem. While the area was apparently not well charted, the responsible crew not using the information at hand (including information as to the the quality of charting data for the area) was also apparently at play in the Connecticut grounding.
- hilbert42 4y ago"Radar is useless underwater." But sonar and detecting changes in gravity (caused by the higher density of the seamount) aren't. The seamount should have been detectable.
- adastra22 4y agoThere's no way you could have gotten a gravity sensor to work reliably enough in that environment. Active sonar would defeat the point of a stealth submarine.
- hilbert42 4y agoIs that an assumption or do you know from fact? Gravity detectors work from moving aircraft (it's a common method of deployment), so motion's no problem and can be made incredibly sensitive—sensitive enough to suit the job in hand (place one on a table and then on a book on the table and you'll easily read the difference in gravity). Moreover, seamounts are incredibly large objects and would have huge signatures and thus easy to detect. I'd suggest the real issue around this matter is that it'll be classified.
- abecedarius 4y agoWhat's the technical term for this type of gravity detector? Do you mean a gravity gradiometer? It seems hard to steer a modern pigheaded search engine away from LIGO when you search for "gravity detector".
- hilbert42 4y agoGradiometer as here: https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/earth-and-planetary-sciences/gravity-gradiometers https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/earth-and-planetary-sci... We'd have difficulty in fitting LIGO in a sub methinks and seamounts are static and thus no G waves. You're right though, I should have been more specific, perhaps a more understandable description would be a mass detector or sensor. I reckon the reason we don't hear much about this subject and the reason it's likely classified is that's its primary purpose would be the detection of other subs, detecting seamounts a secondary benefit.
- amelius 4y ago> and sonar isn’t routinely used because it compromises stealth. Can't they use the same frequency/waveform as whales? Or a different question: why don't whales routinely hit underwater volcanoes?
- hguant 4y agoCouple of different answers to these questions: a) whales don't tend to go where volcanos are. Whales dive to find food, and their food sources aren't near the seabed. I think the deepest diving whale species are sperm whales, and they go after squid, which are not typically found near volcanos. b) it's not a question of matching frequency with the whales, it's a question of noise emissions and the amount of energy you're putting into the water. Modern active sonar systems are incredibly energy intensive, and the technology to modify the waveform and limit the power of the waveform to match something biologic doesn't really exist, and would have to justify all the added complexity c) USN and US geological survey charts are really really good, and regularly updated, to the point where "It wasn't on the charts!" is a claim met with extreme skepticism. 9 times out of 10 some sort of navigation or systemic error was involved.
- catminou 4y agoI recall looking at the various charts and from what I recall the "discolored water" notation was sourced from a chart several decades before and was offset by a few miles (incorrectly charted in the first place).