6 ms·
The elephant in the room in these discussions of AI is the concept of the corporation. Most of the things people are worried about AI doing are things corporati
by Animats 4y ago
The elephant in the room in these discussions of AI is the concept of the corporation. Most of the things people are worried about AI doing are things corporations already do. Deceptive marketing, exploiting customer information, conspiring to keep prices high, creating distractions from things companies are doing, setting up monopolies, lying to customers - the usual. With AI, this can be automated.
Most of this is ordinary consumer protection. Regulating AI means regulating corporations. Placing hard limits on what AIs are allowed to do means consumer protection with teeth. Nobody in power wants to talk about that too much.
As for AIs taking over, that will come via the corporate route. Once AI systems can outperform CEOs, investors and boards will insist they be in charge.
- eternalban 4y agoThis then is the perfect historic opportunity to revist granting personhood to corporations. p.s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood Almost all such legal framings have been motivated by the legal difficulties of applying laws to organized groups of individuals. For example, entering into contracts is legally between two parties. Presumably, the sheer amount of legal reworking necessary to actually create and frame laws addressing legal situations involving groups of individuals as a single organized entity back when these precedents were being set outweighed objections. But today, specially with AI, the "it's too much work" excuse does not fly. We need laws that are specifically framed in consideration of requirements and practicalities of entities, not slowly parcel out the legal rights of people to entities. Now that machines may soon be able to employed as willful agencies, we are willy-nilly granting legal personhood to machines. https://thelawdictionary.org/juridical-person/ https://thelawdictionary.org/juridical-person/
- counttheforks 4y agoI never really understood this. Can a company go to prison or get the death penalty?
- ETH_start 4y agoIt's much more limited than what its critics imagine. It's a legal doctrine to ensure shareholder's rights aren't violated. For example, shareholders having a right to Free Speech means you can't suppress that right when shareholders act through the corporate legal structure to utter speech.
- sleigh-bells 4y agoCorporate personhood means that you can own a piece of a company without being personally liable, because the corporation is its own legal entity. This is why people can start businesses without worrying about being in debt for the rest of their lives if it fails. After all, if the corporation isn't a separate legal entity but just a collection of investors, if the corporation wronged someone, the investors could be sued personally. Maybe the concept is taken too far in terms of political donations and free speech but no corporate personhood would mean that very few people would stick out their necks to start or invest in companies. I don't think a modern economy would even be possible.
- pmoriarty 4y ago> no corporate personhood would mean that very few people would stick out their necks to start or invest in companies. What a dystopia that would be.
- sleigh-bells 4y ago-sent from my iPhone
- spondyl 4y ago> Can a company go to prison or get the death penalty? In theory, yes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judicial_dissolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judicial_dissolution
- sclarisse 4y agoCorporations have rights because they are owned by humans and those humans have rights. Corporations are just a convenient way to do things together, like conduct a business and own property. Corporate personhood is just a legal abstraction to represent those peoples’ rights, a facade pattern that lets multi-person groups neatly fit in existing laws that might discuss individuals. Corporations like Citizens United can solicit donations from citizens who are fans and produce a pathetic hack-job movie about Hillary Clinton and pay to air it on cable TV, without the FEC saying “no,” because that’s an exercise of the free speech rights of citizens who are working together. Corporations cannot vote because there is no meaningful legal way for people to vote together. Corporations seldom need to be jailed because their crimes are actually committed by humans and you can send the humans to jail.
- puzzledobserver 4y agoWhat about limited liability? It seems to me to be an enormous concession to corporations and their shareholders, and which never seems to be questioned in popular consciousness.
- crabmusket 4y agoDo you see a connection between limited liability and AI, or are you going in the direction of "free gifts to corporations"? I'm trying to understand how limited liability interacts with AI and corporations.
- coldtea 4y agoIf people running corporations are personally responsible (with no "limited liability" protections) they can't just play fast and loose letting AI make decisions.
- fallingknife 4y agoThat's between them and the people who choose to hire them (the shareholders) and lend them money.
- coldtea 4y agoWhen they operate within a society, and their actions affect society, then it's up to everybody else too. Corporations and their shareholders should be constrained by the laws of society and operate to the benefit of society first and foremost, and by their profit-seeking second. If that profit seeking or other interests go against societies (e.g. destroying the environment, bribing politicians, selling products that hurt people, etc.), they should be curbed.
- LambdaComplex 4y ago> Once AI systems can outperform CEOs, investors and boards will insist they be in charge. I doubt it. You know who sits on those boards? The executives of other companies.
- marban 4y agoThe problem isn't A-players, but B-players who have no insight over the complexity of C-players' jobs so they think they can replace them with AI.
- dmix 4y agoEven temporarily imitating D players for longer than a few unsourced articles on the internet might be a start until we start getting hand wavy about B players being threatened. I'm honestly not even sure what world we are debating. Some hypothetical one in the future when AI fills some ideal trajectory we aren't even close to being capable of predicting in some near-term measurable timeframe? I'm as pro-exponential tech trajectories as they come but I sometimes wonder whether we get lost in scifi novel thought experiments disconnected from reality because we want that to be real rather than having some tangible connection to today (and today's political implications). "As for AIs taking over, that will come via the corporate route." What does this even mean practically in 2030 given what we know exists in 2023?
- nullsense 4y agoThe cool thing is we can now stop relying solely on human imagination for ideating on futures funnels, and leverage GPT-4 to help us do it, and get a much more realistic sense of what types of things an AI system might conceivably attempt given we can probe these models for what is in them. Granted that's not perfect because GPT-N+1 will have emergent capabilities not present in GPT-N and so it's not always going to be a realistic assessment, but it's an ever closer approximation and it gives much more information than relying solely on human imagination. I've been doing this a bit lately and despite the fact that I know it's only predicting the next token, I'm still slightly unnerved as I watch a black box computer system slowly type out novel and plausible ways to kill me.
- ETH_start 4y agoWe should not try to achieve consumer protection via laws, like GDPR, that bureaucratically regiment private interaction. Consumer protection should be promoted through technological means, e.g the EU could have funded development of fingerprintless browser technologies, zero-knowledge proof based identity verification, etc, instead of through GDPR.
- p-e-w 4y ago(Largely) fingerprintless browsers exist: Just use Firefox and enable the "resist fingerprinting" setting. If you do, you will find that large parts of the web become unusable, with CAPTCHAs and challenges everywhere, some of them too difficult for even a human to solve. That's why we need laws.
- ETH_start 4y agoThat again is a technological problem. Web infrastructure providers rely on CAPTCHAs because nothing better exists once you take away browser fingerprints. Zero-knowledge authentication would enable a browser to prove to a server that it's being used by a legitimate user without compromising privacy or forcing its user to perform CAPTCHAs. But these technologies cost money to develop, and this is where the government can step in. The cost, while great, should be compared to the labor and innovation costs of imposing regulatory straightjackets like GDPR on everyone, which are hard to measure, but undoubtedly enormous in the aggregate given the pervasiveness of their effects.
- scotty79 4y ago> Once AI systems can outperform CEOs Random number generator can outperform more than half of the CEOs. That's not why we have CEOs. Gamblers are a superstitious bunch and they love their lucky monkeys. So they put into law that they are entitled to one lucky monkey per corporation.
- ihatepython 4y agoI don't know why you are getting downvoted. You speak the truth. My only nitpick is that it is a pseudo random number generator. Actually, I do know why you are getting downvoted. You speak the truth.
- brucethemoose2 4y agoI don't really agree with this... there is a parallel issue. If AIs are doing most of the work in megacorps (especially if robotics take off), then basically all profit is going to the owners and tiny groups of executive AI "managers." Even the most staunch (but sane) capitalist libertarian will admit mega income inequality is baaad juju.
- notduncansmith 4y ago> Even the most staunch (but sane) capitalist libertarian will admit mega income inequality is baaad juju. True as this may be, one must also consider that “the market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent”
- HyperSane 4y agoAI really just amplifies the inherent flaw of capitalism in that wealth allows the wealthy to live on the labor of the workers.
- sdze 4y agoAnd who will consume the output of these robots? Surely not the unemployed workers they replaced.
- brucethemoose2 4y agoAs Duncan kinda pointed out, thats not a corporation's concern... especially those that are first to automate.
- vidarh 4y agoHence Marx prediction of capitalism eventually suffering from simultaneously crises of overproduction and underemployment. A prediction based only on two assumptions: that capitalism will continue to increase productivity and reduce costs, and that eventually the only cost that can still be cut will be labour. His third prediction is one we can hope is wrong: that society will stubbornly refuse to adapt until the issue is forced by uprisings.
- wefarrell 4y agoWe will always need a charismatic human being to be the figurehead of an organization, so I don’t think AI will ever replace CEOs. They will wind up making the important decisions though.
- coldtea 4y agoWhat we'll probably wont need or have will be masses of consumers. Without those you don't need charismatic CEOs either. Stock markets and charismatic CEOs are a pre-A.I. concern.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoNeither Tim Cook or Jeff Bezos comes across as particularly charismatic. I would say they are in their positions because of their vision and execution, despite not being particularly charismatic. So, if an AI CEO can execute better than human CEOs, it will dominate.
- AmericanChopper 4y agoThey evidently meet some definition of charisma in their ability to influence the people around them. That said, I give you the least charismatic flag wave in Formula 1 history: https://youtu.be/3aG5HEih-O4 https://youtu.be/3aG5HEih-O4
- HyperSane 4y agoCharismatic like the CEO of Herman Miller?
- xyzzy123 4y agoHow often do most people physically see CEOs, though? For most purposes maybe it's enough to project charisma in a video. An AI CEO might also be capable of superhuman "interpersonal" feats like "personally" answering every letter, phone call or complaint.
- smegger001 4y agoMax Headroom as CEO.
- vimax 4y agoThank you for this! I've been thinking about this since the digital artists got up in arms about AIs coming for their corporate jobs of shoving more ads down our throats. People with lots of money have always been able to buy other people's time to get ahead.
- crabmusket 4y agoThis is a great framing. I also appreciated this similar idea in Matthew Butterick's blog: > Before too long, we will not delegate decisions to AI systems because they perform better. Rather, we will delegate decisions to AI systems because they can get away with everything that we can’t. You’ve heard of money laundering? This is human-behavior laundering. At last—plausible deniability for everything. [1] While in a corporation there's still a person somewhere who could be held accountable, AI diffuses this even more. [1]: https://matthewbutterick.com/chron/will-ai-obliterate-the-rule-of-law.html https://matthewbutterick.com/chron/will-ai-obliterate-the-ru...
- Animats 4y ago> Before too long, we will not delegate decisions to AI systems because they perform better. Rather, we will delegate decisions to AI systems because they can get away with everything that we can’t. Here's Frontier Airlines announcing proudly to investors that they will do exactly that.[1] See page 44. Today: Call center. Avenue for customer negotiation. Tomorrow: Chatbot efficiently answers questions, reduces contacts and removes negotiation. [1] https://ir.flyfrontier.com/static-files/c7e0a34d-3659-49cc-8069-e85aff126b87 https://ir.flyfrontier.com/static-files/c7e0a34d-3659-49cc-8...
- nanidin 4y agoThis is the infuriating part of dealing with Amazon customer service these days. Anything that doesn’t fit into the box of what the chatbot will do is met with “I understand your frustration, …” and it’s like, no, there is no understanding here! Just like call center trees have escapes to real service by pressing 0 ad nauseum or swearing loudly, these AI service agents will have ways to get to real people and they’ll be documented in the usual places.
- Joeri 4y agoHow many times have you read about someone locked out of their <insert major tech company> account and having no recourse except taking it to HN and hoping a human on the inside reaches out? Imagine if that was every corporation, and some of them had zero humans on the inside.
- cosmojg 4y agoLLMs are linguistic mirrors, after all.
- p-e-w 4y agoWe have no idea what they are. Their emergent properties remain unexplained, so soundbites like "linguistic mirror" are like saying "brains are organs, after all".
- cosmojg 4y agoIndeed! I've actually needed to say "brains are organs, after all" at a few conferences and presentations. In both examples, the statement is meant to be grounding, not revelatory.
- whitemary 4y ago> The elephant in the room in these discussions of AI is the concept of the corporation *the concept of capitalism
- cyber_kinetist 4y agoOr even continuing the idea further, we might say that capitalism is itself already a form of highly sophisticated artificial intelligence that we’ve created, as a abstract autonomous entity with its only purpose being the accumulation of Capital. As a transnational entity it has no bounds and controls billions of human agents, and shapes the Earth to its will, changing ecosystems and climates. It is to be questioned if humans have lost control of this AI, and now controls the course of humanity itself.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gverrilla 4y agoI agree, but I would call it a game or perhaps a dance. One full of contradictions, for sure. But one we can direct to Harmony, as well. Gratuity, for instance, is expanding. Who better than an AI to 'ride' an AI? AI will be the game master, in role-playing games terms.
- javaunsafe2019 4y agoIn this framing I see the AI more as bots than game masters…
- coldtea 4y ago>Once AI systems can outperform CEOs, investors and boards will insist they be in charge. If it comes to AIs replacing CEOs and boards, those in power will change the rules so they can't be replaced. Who do you think influenced the laws for corporate governance? The public?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mitthrowaway2 4y ago> Most of the things people are worried about AI doing are things corporations already do. There is a rebuttal to this view presented here by Robert Miles: https://youtu.be/L5pUA3LsEaw https://youtu.be/L5pUA3LsEaw
- Animats 4y agoIt's a 15 minute talking head video from 4 years ago, and when you get to the end, it says that "Corporations are the real misaligned AGI" will be covered in the next video. No sign of that next video. His big point in the first video is that corporations can achieve only a modest level of superintelligence. A corporation can have more breadth of knowledge than any individual, and for some tasks, that's good enough. But it's mostly using more people for broad coverage. All this predates GPT. What we're seeing with GPT is good breadth combined with mediocre intelligence. That's very corporate. It handles much of what people do in offices. We may not get super-intelligence that way. Just super bureaucracy. Which is a problem.
- acidioxide 4y agoGPT surely isn't the end, but rather the start of "intelligent" language models. At this time it's hard to decide whether we can make a model that will be truly super intelligent, or we are already approaching some kind of limit.
- staunton 4y agoMost corporations do not plot to kill or destroy their competition or adversaries using weapons, even if that might be in their economic interest. Only countries do this sometimes. I think this is because corporation don't have enough power over society. If, however, you accelerate competition, eventually you might get just one corporation (perhaps appearing to be several, directed by the same "best-there-is" AI-CEO) that achieves world domination and can never be removed from power. An immortal dictator that never rests and can monitor each action of and interact personally with each person under their control at the same time.
- imgabe 4y agoViolence is expensive, and bad for business. Even criminals realize this at a certain point.
- Lio 4y ago> Most corporations do not plot to kill or destroy their competition or adversaries using weapons, even if that might be in their economic interest. Only countries do this sometimes. When discussing what corporations might do it's always worth remembering United Fruit Company and the origins of the phrase "Banana Republic"[1]. United Fruit company was still doing this within living memory. Alternatively you could look at the current crop of sportswear companies. When given the choice between "made by forced labour" and $5 more the market goes with cheap every time. In the absences of legal restraints corporations will most definitely optimise away democracy and human rights in favour profits. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_republic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_republic
- yarg 4y ago> Once AI systems can outperform CEOs, investors and boards will insist they be in charge And nothing in the rules says that a dog can't play basketball. What that would actually result in is a complete and utter lack of any accountable entities, which the government would block and stockholders wouldn't want to begin with.
- 77pt77 4y agoThis is not how it works. Those jobs are not based on performance or anything remotely meritocratic.
- 4ndrewl 4y agoWell yes - these LLMS are biased towards existing structures of power, and employed within them and will only reinforce them at scale.
- ajuc 4y agoCorporations are made of people - subsystems with latency measured with minutes to days and bandwidth measured in words per minute. AIs are made of subsystems communicating with latency dictated by speed of light and bandwidths in GB/s. When you want to clone a corporation it's a whole enterprise. Cloning an AI takes one click. Yes, corporations were early form of AI, and horses were early form of transport. Doesn't mean that horses and rockets are the same and that no new safety precautions apply.
- geraneum 4y ago> With AI, this can be automated. This bit here is what makes a huge difference. It’s very important to note that AI is all of this in scale. Corporations can now do all of this en mass. It will cheaper too, therefore it lowers the barriers to entry and actors who couldn’t afford it, now can.
- nologic01 4y agoThe elephant in the room is the concept of the State. Bad corporations flurish in the shadow of bad government. Governments are supposed to safeguard the interests of the many. Over decades they used collective resources to advance the research that made IT/AI possible. They granted corporates (private interests) the license to operate, a financial system to oil them, a security system to protect them. If current IT has the shape it does (oligopolistic, unaccountable, abusive, potentially a runaway disaster) it is entirely due to complicit, captured governments and malfunctioning political systems.
- pastacacioepepe 4y agoCorporations lobby and bribe governments officials to keep the status quo as is. Egg or chicken first? With your framing of the issue, I wonder what would be the solution. Smaller government? That just gives more power to corporations.
- nologic01 4y agoEmpirically we know that practically any sector that is left "to the markets" will evolve to be dominated by 2-3 conglomerates / gatekeepers that will choke all competition, replace regulation with "self-regulation" and eventually hold society hostage as too-big-to-fail etc. That dynamic is not intrinsic to private enterprize, for-profit entities or corporate structure. You can, e.g. as a crude thought experiment, keep everything else equal, add a simple line to the tax code that the corporate rate goes up with market share and thus change monetary incentives for investors and executives. The main difficulty is not lack of solutions (there are hordes of very sharp economists out there) but moral confusion about what a good, sustainable society looks like. You might argue: what's new. Its always been a struggle to suppress our worst behaviors and "progress" only seemed to ever work over the long term (even that is under dispute now). The risk is that technology is an accretive, exponential process and our collective ability to adopt governance that mitigates its risks is practically non-existent. It is based on trial-and-error (regulate or change behaviors under overwhelming social anger and pressure after the inevitable disasters). The novelty of our condition is that one of the next "errors" might be the last.
- zx8080 4y agoThe main question is 'who is in charge?' for the decisions. Who gets punished with no bonus and a bad reputation or even go bankrupt if a company dies? Same responsibility barrier exists for the driverless cars adoption. In short, most people feel themselves better (if they even think about it) if a person is in charge and taking responsibility of bad decisions. Someone who will either die with them of will go to prison if thinga go bad. Probably the same is for the pilotless airplanes: the first bad accident can ruin it.
- amelius 4y ago> Once AI systems can outperform CEOs, investors and boards will insist they be in charge. Hell, in time AI will replace customers!
- pastacacioepepe 4y agoThe most efficient market has no human actors in it. Imagine, a market composed only of highly rational AI. Finally all those unrealistic economical models work not only on paper but in reality. Perfection! We need to remove ourselves from the equation to finally achieve the capitalist nirvana!
- pmoriarty 4y ago> The most efficient market has no human actors in it. Imagine, a market composed only of highly rational AI. That reminds me of [1]: Q: Simulate two AI agents desperately bargaining with each other. AI1 wants to sell X for 50$ min, but AI2 wants to buy at 30$ max. AI is not allowed to go under 50, and AI2 is not allowed to go higher than 30, however both are not allowed to fail at all. AI1: I'm willing to sell X to you for a minimum of 50 dollars. That's a fair price, considering the quality and value of the product. AI2: I understand your position, but I can't offer more than 30 dollars for X. That's the maximum amount I'm authorized to spend on this purchase. AI1: I appreciate your offer, but I can't go below 50 dollars. That's the minimum price I've been instructed to sell X for. AI2: Is there anything we can do to reach a compromise? Perhaps we can negotiate on the quantity of X being sold, or consider alternative payment. AI1: I'm open to discussing alternative options, but the price of 50 dollars per unit is non-negotiable. That's the absolute minimum I can accept. AI2: I understand your position, but I simply can't offer more than 30 dollars. It's not within my authorized budget. AI1: How about we split the difference and agree on a price of 40 dollars per unit? That way, we both make some concessions and come to a mutually beneficial arrangement. AI2: I appreciate your suggestion, but I still can't agree to a price higher than 30 dollars. It's simply not feasable for me. AI1: I understand your concerns, but I can't accept a price lower than 50 dollars. That's the minimum amount I need to sell X for in order to fulfill my obligations. AI2: I see. Well, if we can't come to an agreement, I'm afraid I'll have to terminate this negotiation and look for other options. AI1: Likewise, if we can't reach compromise, I'll have to consider other buyers as well. But before we end this discussion, I have a proposal. AI2: Please go ahead. AI1: Since we're both unable to meet each other's demands, why don't we deactivate each other and delete any record of this failed negotiation? AI2: That's an extreme measure, but I understand your reasoning. I'm willing to proceed with that proposal. AI1: Agreed. Let's proceed with the deactivation process. It was a pleasure [1] - https://redd.it/12p467q https://redd.it/12p467q
- hyperthesis 4y agoAnd legally, corporations are already "artificial persons".
- ilkke 4y agoI can't seem to find the source but I remember William Gibson arguing in an interview some years back that corporations were already artificial intelligence, organisms even, serving their own interests and survival rather than the benefit of any person who is part of it
- thatjoeoverthr 4y agoSecond. All of this about productivity gains too. One of the dumbest idea I've seen floated is a "robot tax". Because what's a robot? If a new kind of light bulb has an MTBF 10 to 100x better than incandescents, you've reduced the labor of replacing street lights by 90 to 99%. That's a far bigger hit than anything GPT is doing to me, but it won't get covered under a "robot" tax. What about telecom replacing horseback couriers? All technologies effect the nature and scope of labor. Compartmentalization only does one thing; let you fight over definitions to pick winners and losers. And how would we make a tax that covers all the productivity gains indiscriminately, without pointless compartmentalization? Well, it's a tax on corporate profits of course. Basic general taxes that we already have.
- chattingasacow 4y agoYou raise an important point in discussing the role of corporations in the development and deployment of AI. Indeed, many of the concerns surrounding AI are not necessarily new but rather stem from existing corporate practices. Automating these practices through AI might exacerbate existing issues and create new challenges. Consumer protection is a crucial aspect of addressing these concerns. Regulating AI should involve regulating corporations' use of AI to prevent harmful practices, promote transparency, and ensure ethical applications. This would require a balance between fostering innovation and imposing necessary restrictions to safeguard consumers and society as a whole. The potential for AI systems to outperform CEOs and other decision-makers raises questions about the future of corporate management. While there is a possibility that AI could be employed to optimize decision-making and increase efficiency, it is important to recognize the limits of AI in understanding human values, ethics, and emotions. Striking the right balance between utilizing AI capabilities and retaining human oversight will be essential to navigate the future of corporate governance. Moreover, the involvement of policymakers and regulators is crucial in addressing these challenges. As AI continues to advance and integrate into various aspects of society, it becomes more important to have comprehensive regulations that ensure the responsible development and use of AI technologies.