7 ms·
Editors quit top neuroscience journal to protest against open-access charges
- UhUhUhUh 4y agoWill take one seminal paper to be published on Arxiv for the house of cards to collapse.
- Qem 4y agoThe publishers are working hard to give the term "open-access" a bad reputation in the scientific community, by charging researchers extortionate fees.
- alexb_ 4y agoWhy do we even need publishers? What is stopping the scientific community from saying "Fuck this" and simply posting their PDFs on their own websites, or on an archival site? Is it simply bureaucratic inertia?
- robg 4y agoPeer review is still a good way to ensure some semblance of quality. But there are clearly better ways.
- mjburgess 4y agometareviews & literature reviews can serve the same functions it's quite reasonable to have a policy not to cite an original source without a literature review attached
- ska 4y ago> metareviews & literature reviews can serve the same functions these are not the same functions.
- alexb_ 4y agoPeer review is a recent development in science that has slowed scientific progress immensly, as well as making all papers read for reviewers and not actually be understandable for other people to read them. If you've ever seen a scientific paper before peer review, you can see that they were actually made to be understandable (unlike papers today). There's a reason Einstein hated peer review. Peer review is an experiment on the scientific method, one that has failed spectacularly.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoAnyone who wants their paper to be understood by a non-expert audience can write a blog post explaining the work. Here’s a great example [1]. Papers have become more intricate and technical because science has become more intricate and technical, in some cases because we found subtle errors and exceptions in the more casual early papers! [1] https://thegradient.pub/othello/ https://thegradient.pub/othello/
- AraceliHarker 4y agoThis is because academics are assessed on their achievements based on how many articles they have published in prestigious journals.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> is because academics are assessed on their achievements based on how many articles they have published in prestigious journals Why have these companies been so successful at curating prestigious journals? I hate our academic publishing model. But I'm careful dismissing the journals as pure rent seekers. Their is a source to their staying power beyond merely habit.
- ska 4y agoPart of it is momentum, they date back from when a) everything was on paper, and b) producing and distributing the paper was hard. However, I suspect much of the staying power is that organizing and executing on a top tier journal, or equivalently replacing it, is real work - and it is real work with no model for getting paid for or otherwise compensated for in an academic career. There is also some value to being arms-length. A few top universities could gang together to pay for a flight of journals, but there would understandably be concerns about acceptance policies, etc.
- joquarky 4y agoIt feels like they are subjecting themselves to the consequences of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- steppi 4y agoResearchers do post PDFs on their websites, and on preprint servers like the arXiv, bioaRxiv, etc. Unfortunately, publishers act like gatekeepers towards career progress in academia. Climbing the ladder depends on getting publications in high impact journals and getting your papers cited by other publications. Competition for academic jobs and funding is already very high, and anyone who refuses to play the game will most likely fall behind.
- drbwaa 4y agoThe culture doesn't allow it. If you don't publish enough, in prestigious enough journals, instead of tenure you get replaced. That's one reason this is a pretty interesting move - by providing an alternative publishing location based on principles that the universities supposedly value, this sort of departure _could_ help push the academic culture toward a less-abusive publishing model. Institutional change is hard.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI keep trying to organize my academic friends to join unions and engage in organizational sabotage of administrators, who have completely taken over the academy and left most faculty in a state of abject misery. Huge endowments seem like part of the problem, universities are essentially run as financial concerns with a vestigial teaching staff attached that many regents would rather do away with completely.
- AlbertCory 4y agoWhen big donors say to Big U: "I'll donate again when you reduce your ratio of admins to faculty to what it was in the 60's" Then we might see some change.
- anigbrowl 4y agoTrue, but in the meantime faculty need to find ways around the power of the administrators rather than waiting for fairy godparents to intervene, especially given that administrators control all the budgets and have entire departments devoted to flattering donors.
- galoisscobi 4y agoAcademia is addicted to pedigree and prestige. People in academia could very well create their own publishing and peer review platforms that they all use, cutting out the middle men but there's an obsession with top journals/conferences and how that is tied to career progression that stands in the way.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- SubiculumCode 4y agoNo. Its just that we are all very very busy doing science.
- galoisscobi 4y agoThen what’s stopping very very busy scientists from submitting to open access and “less prestigious” journals? Those journals exist today. I’m not saying the onus is on scientists to fix the entire issue but the progress has to start by committees that hire and promote people in academia and to stop looking at publications in prestigious journals as a marker of career progression and differentiation.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoWhat stops us is that many Universities and departments only count certain journals/conferences as “prestigious” and make both hiring and promotion decisions based on the number of publications in these venues. Even if you’re senior enough not to care about promotions, you will always have students and junior collaborators who need to run this gauntlet. And more to the point, these prestigious conferences and journals often get the best researchers in the field to peer-review for them, because doing that work (for a prestigious venue) also holds some value in the promotion/hiring process. People like to dump on peer review, scientists more than most, but in retrospect many (some) of my papers have improved through the process of getting those people to sign off on the work.
- db48x 4y agoArchiving, especially of scientific data sets, can already be done for free too. Researchers could simply upload them to archive.org. With suitable metadata linking the data back to the published article, and links to archive.org included in the article, there’s little risk that the data would get lost. Authors putting things on their own websites won’t have the same success rate.
- bena 4y agoYou mean self-publishing or finding another publisher. Probably cost and reach.
- crote 4y agoIt's not about the publishing itself, it is all about the review. Anyone with an internet connection can write a "paper" and publish it, but that doesn't mean it is useful to the scientific community. Peer review allows the community to filter out quack papers, research which is inherently flawed, or research which has been done before. This leaves the journals filled with novel research meeting a minimum quality standard, allowing other scientists to build upon them. If you can't get your research published it ostensibly isn't worth anything, so a lot of institutions use the number of papers published and the citations they get as a measurement of a researcher's output. There is nothing wrong with this process. However, the issue is that journals have been captured by rent-seeking publishers who charge exorbitant fees. This is made even worse because some journals have historically been more strict than others, so getting a paper published in a strict one leads to a higher valuation - and of course the publishers charge higher fees for the more prestigious journals. Changing this entire model is difficult. Publishing in one of those journals is literally how your worth is valued. Breaking this circle can be done, but it won't be easy.
- dimal 4y agoThere are a lot of good arguments [0] that peer review doesn't work, and leads to worse outcomes than just publishing openly and letting the marketplace of ideas decide which papers are actually worthwhile. Think about it. A small group of gatekeepers decides what research is worthwhile and what is not. How well does that kind of gatekeeping work in other areas? For example, Einstein only had one paper peer reviewed (which was rejected) and things turned out well for him. What if his papers had gone through a committee? [0] https://www.experimental-history.com/p/the-rise-and-fall-of-peer-review https://www.experimental-history.com/p/the-rise-and-fall-of-...
- jltsiren 4y agoThe group of gatekeepers is not small. When Science Twitter was still a thing, two common topics were editors complaining about how difficult it is to find peer reviewers and academics complaining how many review requests they get. Pretty much every established researcher is involved in the gatekeeping, and they can devote as much time to it as they want. In many fields, preprints have been an established practice for a long time. That allows us to see the alternative to peer review. The main variables that predict how much attention your preprint gets are your name and the topic. With all its imperfections, peer review at least gives a second chance for less known researchers working on less fashionable topics.
- jfoutz 4y agoMy academic career is checkered at best. I think about this [1] from time to time. For a long time, it seems like, university was a place to hide the weirdos and occasionally neat stuff would pop out that changed the world. That institution mostly survived industrialization. but I'm pretty skeptical it'll survive monetization. 1. https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/vl/notes/dijkstra.html https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/vl/notes/dijkstra.html
- musicale 4y ago> simply posting their PDFs on their own websites Every author should do this - either the final version if it's open access, or a preprint if it's an awful closed journal. Though I prefer boycotting awful publishers like Elsevier in the first place.
- xhkkffbf 4y agoWe already have both systems running in parallel. Many researchers post PDFs immediately. Then they go through the process of trying to get them into a journal. Both have advantages. While the peer review and typesetting process of publishing in a journal has many issues, the changes generally make the papers better. It's usually easier to read the final published version than an early preprint. It's not just inertia that keeps scientists using the old journals. Anyone can issue a preprint. The material that ends up in the journal is usually the better material. The filtering helps and so does the editing. The filtering may be flawed, but it's better than nothing.
- robg 4y ago20 years ago Neuroimage was the journal researchers went to when their results were borderline unpublishable. Amazing how these publications manage to stay in business, no surprise they are raising publication fees paid by authors. While it’s good to see editors vote with their feet, there are plenty of academics who will line up to take their place to burnish their CVs.
- SubiculumCode 4y agoNeuroimage has been , ever since I've been in the field (let's say 2010), a very reputable, and definitely not the journal of last resort.
- photochemsyn 4y ago> "Elsevier, based in Amsterdam, says that the APCs cover the costs associated with publishing an article in an open-access journal, including editorial and peer-review services, copyediting, typesetting, archiving, indexing, marketing and administrative costs." Taking Elsevier claims at face value is a bad idea, but an obvious solution would be make the authors responsible for all of the above. Which is basically the arxiv publishing model: https://info.arxiv.org/help/submit/index.html https://info.arxiv.org/help/submit/index.html
- alecco 4y agoI think a foundation with open accounting and paid reviewers would be a better trade-off.
- crote 4y agoThe arxiv publishing model does not do peer review, though. The papers on there aren't validated beyond a very cursory look into whether it is basically spam or not.
- cpncrunch 4y agoYou can look at their financial results. Net profit margin is 19%: https://www.google.com/finance/quote/REN:AMS https://www.google.com/finance/quote/REN:AMS
- ska 4y agoarxiv is a pre-print model, which is super useful but not the same thing.
- YeGoblynQueenne 4y ago"copyediting and typesetting"? Ah, that would be where they take your article, already formatted using the LaTeX template they made available, and completely change the formatting so that all the formulae and all the tables become unreadable. In CS you get this service for free. Neuroscientists have to pay for the privilege? Wow.
- algoatecorn 4y agoIf you are a US taxpayer, you should be highly critical of exorbitant publishing fees of major journals. Grant money is automatically reduced by the rent seeking behavior of firms like Elsevier i.e. you are not getting your money's worth out of taxes which make their way through NSF et al.
- bee_rider 4y agoIs Elsevier generally considered the Walmart of academic publishers, or is this just some random misperception I’ve had? I’m really bad at the who’s-who bit of academics.
- SubiculumCode 4y agoI've never heard of that. They have many very reputable journals in neuroscience. I don't like the company, but many of the journals are solid.
- _yb2s 4y agoIf wal-mart means "massive scale, low quality," then no. Elsevier runs many of the most highly regarded journals.
- cpncrunch 4y agoThey say their charge is going to be about half of the Elsevier fee, but Elsevier's net profit margin is 19%. So basically they are saying they can be more efficient than Elsevier, but they're still going to have a fee to publish as open access.
- drb493 4y agoKudos to the editors for taking a stand. Absurd cost for publications was a major reason I left academia as a postdoc. Senior scientists with large grants and salaries write it off as a business expense but paying 2-3k for a paper is insane for junior staff that are already being underpaid. Arxiv and opensource publishing options exist. But for neuroscience, the funding and direction of research is implicitly governed by the reviewers and chief editors whom are embedded in these journals. Thus for your work to get exposure and citations it is critical to publish in the given journal for your domain. Journals have a reciprocal relationship with chief editors in that journals will publish "special" editions essentially allowing the editors to publish their work with their collaborators carte blanche. Switching to an open source model is objectively a better option, but there are entrenched incentives that prohibit this change.
- kelipso 4y agoSalaries and underpaid? Not relevant since no one pays open-access charges with their own money. It always comes from the funding.
- not2b 4y agoIt comes out of the grant that also pays salaries, so excessive paper costs might mean that a research group can't afford to pay as many postdocs and grad students.
- bluefirebrand 4y agoOr can't afford to pay the postdocs and grad students they do have what they are worth.
- kevviiinn 4y agoThey already don't
- foven 4y agoAbsolutely relevant. Had a huge issue with the University recently about being able to publish in a journal because they wouldn't pay the fees - every point at which there can be a problem, there will be.
- YuriNiyazov 4y agoI work for an academic publisher, so I’m deeply biased, but I’ll say this: criticism usually consists of something like “it doesn’t cost $6300 to publish one article”, and that’s true, but, it does cost that much to receive 15 articles for submission, peer review all of them, reject 14 and then publish 1. Remember: publishers don’t charge for a rejected submission, but incurs costs with all of them.
- algoatecorn 4y agoRemind me again how much the reviewers get paid.
- YuriNiyazov 4y agoNothing. Nice gotcha, bro. I never said reviewers get paid. I mean the internal machinery that needs to get 15 articles reviewed costs money - employees that search lists of potential reviewers for people with expertise in the relevant subfield, email the potential reviewers, wait for them to accept or reject a review request, coordinate the entire thing, etc. etc.
- lozenge 4y agoYou said it costs to peer review them. But they aren't reviewing them. If that's worth $6,000, the reviewers deserve $60,000/
- anigbrowl 4y agoI don't agree with OP here but they are reviewing and rejecting some submissions.
- strangeloops85 4y agoAs an academic editor for a society journal this is ridiculous. Most of this process is automated and takes a grand total of 15 mins of time. Also, Nature charging $10k for open access while PLOS charges more like $2k should tell you what’s going on here
- seydor 4y agoNot only that, i ve noticed they now charge more for reprinting an old picture in a new article. Years ago, in Rightslink the reuse rights for almost all the images was $0 , now it's $70-90 and everybody has to pay, including students, nonprofits etc. The whole thing is just insane and the needle doesnt seem to move
- macinjosh 4y agoWe need a GitHub for peer review and publishing papers.
- IYasha 4y ago> fee at Nature Neuroscience, published by Springer Nature, is $11,690 WHAT!? That's our f** average annual income! No wonder independent science is in such weak and obscure state :(