10 ms·
A $300k Salary Feels Like $100k in the Priciest US Cities
- adam_arthur 4y agoThis is just residual due to pre-covid working trends inflating prices in city centers over decades. Pretty clear the trend going forward is for deflation in the previously dense/working urban areas relative to areas such as the Sunbelt. Either policy adapts in these areas to be accommodative for general living, and not simply a hub and spoke office commuting model, or the people leave and area fails to prosper. Hawaii, NYC and some others likely to stay supported due to already being great places to live for other reasons beyond work.
- pb7 4y agoWhat does $100k feel like?
- kbelder 4y agoIt would feel pretty damn good for most people.
- MuffinFlavored 4y agoAnd for others?
- s5300 4y agoA reminder that they’re likely to never find happiness or meaning.
- tennisflyi 4y agoYes. HN will try to tell you otherwise.
- davidw 4y ago100K is considered low income for a family of four in San Francisco. If you're on your own, it might not be so bad.
- beebmam 4y ago*until you have a serious medical expense
- neither_color 4y agoAt those salaries you definitely either have work-provided healthcare or can afford Kaiser platinum
- linguae 4y agoAs someone who works in tech in Silicon Valley but who doesn't make FAANG-level salaries and who doesn't earn RSUs, it's enough for a single person with no dependents to live a comfortable upper-middle class lifestyle provided that the person doesn't have significant amounts of debt. I'm able to afford a one-bedroom apartment in the Santa Cruz area without roommates, make student loan payments, drive a new car, go to Japan once or twice per year, buy a new computer once every other year, make a few domestic trips on the West Coast annually to see friends, eat out occasionally, and still have enough money leftover for savings, both for immediate needs (six-month emergency fund, down payment on a house) and for retirement. It's not bad, though the pandemic-era inflation is quite noticeable and it hurts to see my paycheck not grow as fast as the price of food, services, and housing. However, I'm 34 years old and I'd like to get married and have children one day. Having grown up in a low-income household, I want to be able to provide a middle-class standard of living for my future family. I want my children to have good educational opportunities and live in a safe neighborhood. However, these things are not cheap in America, and in Silicon Valley these things are very expensive, generally requiring the income level of two highly-paid professionals in order to afford purchasing a home in a safe neighborhood with good public schools. Private schools are also very expensive. I don't see a path toward home ownership in Silicon Valley unless I win the lottery (either something like the Powerball or I win "the startup lottery"), and so I see two potential alternatives: (1) continue to rent in/near Silicon Valley while exploring homeownership opportunities elsewhere (which is still expensive, but renting in Silicon Valley is much cheaper than paying mortgages on comparable properties), or (2) leave Silicon Valley and base my career somewhere else where home prices are cheaper, either taking advantage of remote work opportunities or starting my own business.
- calvinmorrison 4y agoFeel that. Get married and had kids and suddenly 100k is diddly squat
- paulpauper 4y agoFeels good if you live within your means
- mdrzn 4y agoFeels like what I make in 5 years
- jxidjhdhdhdhfhf 4y agoTo me, this is kind of like saying "this $5000 Armani suit feels the same as a $500 suit from Men's Warehouse". They're only the same if you ignore the details, like living in one of the areas of the country with the nicest weather and best access to nature (California) or having access to the best culture, best food and most opportunity to make it big (New York).
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 4y agoLike fashion, those "benefits" are highly subjective.
- lexhart 4y agoTrue, but nevertheless the objective prices are only rising. The fact is that enough people enjoy those benefits to maintain the trend.
- brianleb 4y ago>>the best culture, best food and most opportunity to make it big (New York). You should get out more. None of those things are true anymore, if they ever were.
- rufus_foreman 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- govolckurself 4y ago[flagged]
- rongenre 4y agohttps://archive.ph/hSVKU https://archive.ph/hSVKU
- TrackerFF 4y agoIf you're putting a huge chunk of that money into equity, like paying down a mortgage, at least you'll get that money back (with a decent likelihood), and probably with a decent return.
- cschneid 4y agoCost of living is weird, since it ignores the fact that shopping on Amazon costs the same everywhere. I imagine it'd result in feeling like physical goods are incredibly cheap vs anything that requires local labor (restaurants, private schools, construction, medical, etc). Buying a big TV or a new iphone would be a lower % of total salary since those wouldn't scale w/ the location. And then you'd turn around and pay $20 for a cocktail. But what do I know, I live middle of the country :)
- ArtemZ 4y agoI spend most of my salary (130k$) on rent, food and daycare for my kid, not Amazon purchases. And 130k doesn't feel like a lot anymore even though I live in Ohio in order to reduce my expenses.
- hanoz 4y agoAll around the western world, money printing to prop up the house price bubble is finally reaching breaking point, with housing costs completely decoupling from fundamentals, and inflation breaching the banks and flooding into consumer pricing.
- govolckurself 4y agoWhat? No, there simply isn't enough housing. Prices don't always go up simply because of an increase in the money supply (which is also something you can measure).
- exclusiv 4y agoExactly. Not enough supply. Build costs exorbitant. There will not be some magical supply out of nowhere nor a big drop in build costs. So thus prices, IMO, in most major metros are connected to fundamentals. If housing was not connected to fundamentals, home sale prices would have been exposed and taken a nose dive with the movement in interest rates. People aren't getting any easy money. They are still buying.
- tmaly 4y agoIn 2000 the starting engineer salaries at Intel were 55k a year. I am sure others could provide reference salaries. It seems like in 20 years salaries have more than doubled. Cost of living has gone up quite a bit. Most meats are double per pound compared to pre-covid.
- sponaugle 4y agoI started at Intel in 1994, Electrical Engineer from Purdue, 44K.
- paulpauper 4y agoIt makes sense though. Huge, competing tech companies means higher stakes due to winner-take-all markets, moats, and network effects, hence paying top dollar for talent to get products out fast and prevent competitors from hiring said talent or getting products out sooner. Given how profitable at least some of these companies are, paying top dollar is not a problem.
- linguae 4y agoYup, I remember my freshman year at Cal Poly San Luis Obispo in 2005. The computer science department boasted that its graduates had the second-highest starting salaries of Cal Poly alums: $50,000. The department with the highest average starting salary was aerospace engineering: $55,000. I remember being blown away around 2007 when I heard of a master's student making the equivalent of $70,000/yr during a summer internship. Those were the days.
- ylee 4y agoMy salary as a first-year analyst at Goldman Sachs in 1999 was $40K. In 2000, to compete with dotcom companies, salaries rose to $55/65/75K for first/second/third-year analysts.[1] The compensation scale remained despite the dotcom bubble bursting. [1] All figures exclude bonus, which is a huge part of compensation on Wall Street.
- user-one1 4y agoAdjusted by inflation, a $55k salary in January 2000 is $98,347.04 right now. https://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl?cost1=55000&year1=200001&year2=202303 https://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl?cost1=55000&year1=20...
- paulpauper 4y agoThis fails to take into account many mitigating factors and is too pessimistic: 1. For a person living alone modestly, $300k even in the Bay Area is more than enough to put away a decent chunk of money for retirement. Just run the numbers. 2. Pundits also vastly overestimate taxes, which are low in the US. The top tax rate is for anything above 400k, so the amount you pay is way lower if you make $300k/year. 3. High cost of living areas have more amenities overall which may not be factored into calculations. Things like walkability, so you don't have to pay for car, car insurance, gas, etc. 4. More public services, another amenity . more convinence. like better schools, better public transportation, nicer neighborhoods (this may be subjective). 5. Expensive mortgage is not like pissing the money away--you are building home equity.
- frankbreetz 4y ago300k puts in near the 1% for one of the richest countriesin the world, I would certainly hope it could afford a single person modest life including retirement anywhere
- rgmerk 4y agoThis. Live in the Bay Area on 300k, pay off your mortgage, save a little bit on top of that and you’ve got enough to retire early and live like royalty somewhere cheaper.
- citizen_friend 4y ago> you are building home equity. The interest portion is the price you pay to be able to purchase that equity. Compare how much does get thrown away, and the value of that tiny slice of equity relative to other investments. Maybe Big city real estate is really that good (it seems better to me than anywhere else). Furthermore a 30 year mortgage in the Bay Area locks you into a high earning life style These are somewhat stressful jobs with market ups and downs. It almost becomes impossible to pursue an alternative, like a career change. What about selling and moving out? You can, but if you're forced to that situation is also where you incur the most real estate risk (high transaction costs, forced to sell underwater, etc).
- juve1996 4y ago> Meanwhile, in Houston, an employee only needs to gross about $125,000 to achieve the same purchasing power as someone making $312,000 in New York. A six-figure paycheck is much easier to achieve in Texas, according to SmartAsset’s analysis, since the cost of living in many Lone Star State cities is lower than the national average and residents don’t pay a state income tax. In cities like El Paso, Corpus Christi and Lubbock, salaries can be as low as $122,000 and still feel like a true $100,000. The real reason people have been moving to these places. There's no way to solve the problem. Unless you love living in those places, you can do much better for your future by leaving ,especially in this era of more acceptance of remote work.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> real reason people have been moving to these places There are unique factors that can make this person in New York more valuable than in Houston. Chiefly: once their function is in Houston, why not Honduras?
- jmoak3 4y ago>once their function is in Houston, why not Honduras? I agree, and it's something that I'd like to get ahead of if it's the world we're approaching. In a world where high-skill-non-managerial jobs can be outsourced easier, wages will become depressed. Would you rather take what you have saved and try to get something in Houston now, or watch from New York as your income stagnates but your expenses grow with inflation? Nobody knows the future, and remote work could very easily be phased out. Or we lean in and US companies draw from a pool of tens of millions of talented international software engineers. It's a hell of a situation. EDIT: lots of tweaks here and there.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Would you rather take what you have saved and try to get something in Houston now, or watch from New York as your income falls but your expenses stay flat? Depends on if you’re learning and growing or coasting. Truth be told, I’m presently the latter, which is partly why I moved to Wyoming. That is not an option if you’re starting out. And it won’t be when I shift back into first gear.
- davidw 4y agoIt's primarily housing costs, which are driven by * Expensive, scarce land * High construction costs * Rampant NIMBYism To some degree, we dug ourselves into that mess, and can dig ourselves out if we work at it.
- hnburnsy 4y agoDon't forget property taxes partially driven by political choices.
- davidw 4y agoThose are just 'messed up' in California. For some people they're quite low. For the house next door, maybe they are 10 times as much. Property taxes are actually higher in many states because they're not capped. Which in many ways is as it should be so that homeowners share in a bit of the pain from rising prices.
- pydry 4y agoProperty taxes also help keep a lid on rising prices.
- iancmceachern 4y agoAnd it causes weird incentives, like keeping land empty and undeveloped, etc.
- ramesh31 4y agoDebt is the real killer. I will clear 200k TC this year but I live like a broke person. I'm talking ramen noodles and busted ass apartment broke. After housing, debt payments, bills, 401k, taxes, and daily living expenses, I really can't afford anything. Saving for a modest house is a huge goal for me, and I'm in the 90th percentile of incomes. I can't even imagine how the other half is living right now.
- ketzo 4y agoIs a lot of your comp in equity? How bad are your debt payments? Not trying to shame or anything. That just sounds insane that you could be barely making ends meet on 200k
- hnburnsy 4y agoWhy are you contributing to a 401K but have significant debt payments? See Dave Ramesy for a start, then Bogleheads as you climb out of debt and start to save and invest. Best of luck.
- ramesh31 4y ago>Why are you contributing to a 401K but have significant debt payments? See Dave Ramesy for a start, then Bogleheads as you climb out of debt and start to save and invest. I have a different philosophy on this. A 401k is basically your life raft of last resort. And it's so tax advantaged that you're throwing away money not to use it. I'd rather pay to hold debt while maintaining and growing my assets, and rely on inflation + asset growth + wage growth chipping away at the debt. If the economy crashes and credit freezes up, a good credit score from paying down my debt won't mean anything. But a bank balance still will.
- hnburnsy 4y agoHSAs and Roth IRAs would like a word with you. Both can be preferred to 401ks in some situations, but the point is take care of debt first.
- eliseumds 4y ago
- Chinjut 4y agoI advise anyone making $300k to give half of it to me. Then you will end up at $150k, which is $50k ahead of where you started.
- tzs 4y agoA year ago after seeing a claim that $250k in San Francisco is like $100k in most of the rest of the country, due to rent, taxes, and food, I tried to check if that was true and it didn't seem to be. What have I missed? For rent, a median one bedroom apartment in SF would be $14-18k/year more than a median one bedroom apartment in Seattle, Chicago, Nashville, Orlando, Sacramento, Austin, or Fresno. Average monthly spending on food in SF is about $150 above the national average, so that's another $1800/year you need. But that probably includes a lot of people who do their own cooking. Maybe tech workers need to buy all their meals. I found a tourist planning site that said the average tourist in SF spends $32/day on meals, so let's use that instead of $150/month above national food average. That would mean we need $12k/year extra for SF for food. So someone coming to SF from one of those other places needs an after tax income that is equal to their after tax from their $100k in their old city, plus $30k after tax for rent and food. That requires a salary of $148k. That's a long way from $300k, so what other costs are missing?
- ndesaulniers 4y agoAvocado toast.
- lostmsu 4y agoWait, you eat them without salmon? =O
- jjdeveloper 4y agoAre you Australian? Apparently this is what is stopping us from affording a house
- ac29 4y agoThe article isnt comparing SF to places like Seattle or Chicago (Seattle is actually in their 10 most expensive). They are comparing to places like El Paso or Oklahoma City, which are much less expensive.
- gautamcgoel 4y agoNot sure who is paying $18k/year for rent in SF. I live in Oakland and pay almost $28k/year, not including utilities.
- southernplaces7 4y agoYet, millions of people in every one of these cities manage to live there, often even in the central urban districts, without making anywhere near $100K, let alone $300K. Yes, some of those complaining about the cost of living at these salaries are self absorbed to the point of absurdity and could really just stop spending so much on so many luxurious things, or if they can't forego those, there's the option of, you know, just moving to a cheaper place.
- anony23 4y ago"Manage" to live there, but not well. Maybe they pile 4 people intona four bedroom apartment and work 2 jobs to do it.
- iancmceachern 4y agoNo, a lot of people have rent controlled apartments. This article says more than 60% of SF rental units are rent controlled...https://bungalow.com/articles/rent-control-in-san-francisco-everything-you-need-to-know https://bungalow.com/articles/rent-control-in-san-francisco-...
- dualityoftapirs 4y agoA key thing to note is that rent control in SF isn't quite what most people think of. The apartment itself is not locked to a specific price (which is how NYC rent control works, for example) but rather the lease between the landlord and master tenants can only increase so much per year. For example you can have a rent controlled apartment renting for $500 a month, that tenant leaves, and the new tenants would sign for $3000 a month. There's no requirement the new master tenants would get the $500 a month. Whereas I believe in NYC's rent control the apartment itself is set at $500 a month, and anyone who moves in, that's what they pay.
- iancmceachern 4y agoNot quite. Your conflating several things. Rent control is different from rent stabilization is yet different from rent increase laws. Often cities have all 3. In SF the rent controlled properties, both for rent and for sale (yes you can buy super affordable apartments in SF if you don't exceed certain income) folks just have to make less than a certain amount a year. The income tiers are listed here, and are higher than I expect some would expect. https://sf.gov/reports/may-2022/income-and-rent-limits-inclusionary-rental-units https://sf.gov/reports/may-2022/income-and-rent-limits-inclu... There is also a citywide rent increase cap of 3.6% currently (its calculated based off inflation and other factors) on any and all rental units, regardless of income or rent control status : https://sf.gov/information/learn-about-rent-increases#:~:text=2.-,Current%20allowed%20rent%20increase,Consumers%20in%20the%20Bay%20Area https://sf.gov/information/learn-about-rent-increases#:~:tex....
- gregors 4y agook, now do saving/investing 5% of your salary over 10 years with those 2 numbers....
- gregors 4y agoThis also ignores you don't pay FICA after 160k. So the more you make, the more you take.
- ttymck 4y agoYou are aware of marginal tax brackets, yes?