9 ms·
I have commented this many times on such articles, and will say it again: Google still thinks of AI as a research project, or at best a way to produce better s
by paxys 4y ago
I have commented this many times on such articles, and will say it again:
Google still thinks of AI as a research project, or at best a way to produce better search results. They essentially created the entire current generation of the AI space and then... gave it away, because no one on the product side understood what they had actually built. Handing the reins to the DeepMind team – who have never launched a single product in their history – seems to be a doubling down on that same failed strategy.
Google doesn't need more smart AI researchers, academics or ethicists. They need product managers who understand the underlying technology and can commercialize it. They need pragmatic engineers who can execute, launch and maintain services. That has always been their problem as a company.
- lallysingh 4y agoThey're the new Xerox, looking at PARC's output and asking, "How will this make our copiers better?" Internally, everyone's asking "How will this help my promo packet?"
- wmeredith 4y agoAbsolutely. You could also sub in Microsoft, looking at the internet in 2002 and asking, "how could this make Windows desktop better"?
- crop_rotation 4y agoIE was already dominant by 2002. Microsoft didn't ignore the Internet. They went hell bent on it during Gates era and won decisevely. It's only when they had no competition IE got stuck and then surpassed.
- paxys 4y agoIf talking about bundling a web browser inside their OS, sure. It was more that Microsoft missed the entire potential of the internet as a whole and how fundamentally transformational it could be. They had no presence in online services, e-commerce, search and more until they saw competitors eating their lunch, and have been lagging behind ever since.
- crop_rotation 4y agoThey had a presence in online services, MSN is older than even IE.
- paxys 4y agoAOL was already dominant by the time MSN launched. Yahoo was close behind. Even back then Microsoft was playing catch up in the space.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> AOL was already dominant by the time MSN launched. And never got off the pre-web walled garden end-to-end business model, despite connecting to the web, and died because of it. Not exactly the best example to use to argue Microsoft missed the boat on Web-era online services.
- paxys 4y agoAOL dominated, then Yahoo dominated, then Google dominated, then Google and Facebook dominated. Microsoft was just never in the picture.
- nailer 4y agoNumber one browser aside, they had the number one web mail app, the number one chat app, the number one voice chat app, the most web native news service. Yes Ballmer threw everything away and IE, Hotmail, MSN Messenger, Skype and MSNBC are jokes now, but that doesn’t mean they weren’t dominant force in Bill Gates era.
- salad-tycoon 4y ago> Yes Ballmer threw everything away and IE, Hotmail, MSN Messenger, Skype and MSNBC are jokes now, but that doesn’t mean they weren’t dominant force in Bill Gates era. At least we got Xbox and Xbox live… which seems to have barely lived by a life line. Confusing mess with Xbox vs windows vs media center PC. I still think they could have been much more successful with the kinetic. Wii was loved for its ability to bowl and play tennis and etc. Nobody I know really wants to strap a sensory deprivation device onto their face. I don’t see VR working out but a highly evolved sensor bar that allows you to interact with humans physically present and online seems an easier pill to swallow. Never owned one but seems like Kinect is still fondly remembered in some applications. All that said I wouldn't buy one today because I don’t need x amount of cameras and lidars and y microphones recording inside my house 24/7 and going to MSFT and whoever else.
- jabradoodle 4y agoHow is bundling a terrible browser with your OS going "hell bent on it"?
- crop_rotation 4y agoIE was not a terrible browser, and Microsoft did really go hell bent on it in terms of dedicating resources to the IE development. I am not sure why you call IE a terrible browser here. (IE has to be compared to Netscape for any such assessment to make sense). IE development stopped once Microsoft had won, not before.
- nightski 4y agoActiveX and XMLHttpRequest were pretty revolutionary, it's just especially the former was plagued by security problems and implementation issues.
- chillfox 4y agoOr Kodak inventing the digital camera and deciding to shelve it because they couldn't figure out how to sell film for it.
- Aeolun 4y agoThis turned out to be sort of precient though. It turns out Kodak sucks at selling digital cameras.
- foxandmouse 4y agoThis is a great analogy, and it touches upon why I try to avoid google services. The company that once championed "don't be evil" now cannot think outside of the system of perverse incentives it has created (by that I mean add based revenue).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- safog 4y agoThe cat's out of the bag now, it doesn't take a genius PM to work it out. Maybe a genius PM could've worked out how revolutionary generative AI is going to be pre- chat GPT release but I really doubt that a random MBA who knows nothing about AI can do that. Every single day there's a cool new AI application. The problem space is fairly fleshed out. It's a matter of executing. How do you make enterprise tools better? (Photoshop + AI, Code + AI etc.) How do you make consumer tools better? (YT tools + AI) How do you make search better? etc. etc.
- medler 4y agoIs there anyone who has successfully productized AI? ChatGPT isn’t a profitable product, at least not yet. Google Photos and Spotify recommendations are the best AI products I can think of with clear revenue, and in these examples AI is just a cherry on top of a product people would use anyway.
- dougmwne 4y agoGithub Copilot seems like a pretty clear example. They charge a subscription that's in excess of the marginal cost of inference.
- medler 4y agoThat’s a good point. I forgot about Copilot.
- visarga 4y agoMidjourney, NaturalReaders (text to speech reader)
- andygeorge 4y agocurious if/when MS will get desirable returns on the significant investment needed to run/train copilot
- dougmwne 4y agoIt's a good question, but also helpful to point out that one of the beauties of these models is that you can train them once and deploy to many use cases. The same model can be used by Github, Bing, Office 365, Azure and so on. And as for the big multi-billion investment in OpenAI, they may have more than made that back up on their valuation already. Plus the deal was structured that OpenAI would pay it's revenues into Microsoft till the investment was paid back and MS would sill end up with a 49% stake. All in all, sounds like a smart investment from MS and, cerry on top, managed to majorly embarrass a main rival.
- bartwr 4y agoAs someone who's been at Google Research ~5y, this nails is it 100%. I was at the non-Brain part of Research and it was seen as Google Brain is the "cool", pure research one, dealing with some future abstract AI and not caring for the products, feasibility, or even if the research "could" be made practical any day. Deepmind was an "extreme" version of it, with some animosities and politics between the two, which I didn't follow too closely. There were attempts at making Deepmind useful, called "Deepmind for Google", but the people there were... clueless. Though one really cool thing came out of it (XManager). (I was at a closer to the product part, "Perception", which I loved. And still got to publish, explore, pursue my own research goals, etc.)
- dmix 4y agoThat's what great about competition. It kicks you in the pants and reminds you you need to try. iPhone scared the shit out of the phone market and today we have great phones from Samsung and Google which dominate the market. If everyone was trying to predict the smartphone market in 2007 they'd be talking about how Nokia missed the boat but excited to see their response (or Motorola/Sony/Blackberry etc). The market today won't necessarily be the market in 10yrs from now. It might be Google, they have a solid head start to be #2 and future #1, but who knows what will happen and whether that talent/advantage stays in Google. It could just as easily be other companies we don't even consider serious players today.
- nr2x 4y ago* dominate the low-end of the market. Apple has the platform where users have money to spend on apps and services.
- 76SlashDolphin 4y ago* dominate the global market. Apple is a very minor player outside of the US and Japan.
- throwaway2037 4y ago
- attractivechaos 4y ago> they need product managers who understand the underlying technology and can commercialize it. I would say they more need engineers who care about and can make good products. In my limited experience, it takes time to turn a research-focused group into a product-oriented team. Research vs production requires different skill sets.
- walnutclosefarm 4y agoI completely agree. I was involved as a tech executive at a large medical center trying to get collaborative work with both Google per se, and DeepMind, to a usable or product stage, and it was essentially impossible. DeepMind in particular was more interested in pushing the research envelope, and getting more papers in Nature, than in building products. I wouldn't underestimate the degree to which this is by design, from the very top of Google. Different Google and other Alphabet companies' executives more than once told me they just weren't interested in products that didn't have an obvious path to more than 1 billion users. The companies don't have a clue how to make money retail. If they can't print money with an idea, they don't have the tools and skills to bring it to market.
- momojo 4y agoI don't doubt your analysis of Google, but what was OpenAI able to do differently to get them here? Aren't they just another research hub?
- nr2x 4y agoThe deeper problem is the money people who lead Google have no imagination whatsoever and literally can’t figure out how to make money in anything that isn’t mining user data for ads. Cloud is a money pit, and will NEVER be #1 in the space. They literally put more effort and resources into rigging ads auctions than trying to solve real user problems.
- candiodari 4y agoThey're just making a correct calculation. Do we increase our $70 billion / quarter with 2% or do we put resources towards doubling the income of a $1 million / year product. Yes, the answer isn't what you'd like, but let's not pretend it's not rational.
- nr2x 4y agoInnovators dilemma is the issue: that’s rational, until suddenly it isn’t, but by then it’s too late to change course.
- krick 4y agoWell, I'm ok with Google having this "problem". Hopefully, they will produce a couple more of useful things, until it somehow kills Google or whatever.
- jrm4 4y agoTo me, you've described a situation that's infinitely more a feature than a bug. They don't pay me, so I don't care about their profits, but the stuff they've more-or-less given away and people don't think much about is their best stuff. Colab, Docs, Scholar, etc...
- paxys 4y agoSure, but all of this disappears the second their money fountain (search) gets disrupted.
- cjmcqueen 4y agoFor a business to survive it needs competition. You could argue it was necessary to create competition in the AI space before business needs arise that Google could provide. Without competition, there's no way for the market to rise to demand. Google didn't give away stuff, they created demand.
- cafed00d 4y agoI would go farther still and say Google doesn’t need PMs — it needs a singularly bold visionary — a Satya Nadella or John Legere or maybe someone else — not a good ceo or a bad ceo; nor a polite ceo or a trash-talking tough ceo — they just need someone to yank the empire builders out and go all in on product building. Not product managing.
- thomasahle 4y agoHow did Nadella yank the empire builders out of Microsoft?
- cafed00d 4y agoThe Nadella example was meant to illustrate visionary & bold. You’re right; my statement is not scientifically accurate
- thomasahle 4y agoI was just curious, since it seems impossible to remove empire builders. I fear the only thing you can do is to start a new company. But maybe there's a way to better align the incentives...
- est 4y ago> because no one on the product side understood what they had actually built and more because Google's mission was to "organize world information" instead of understanding, intepreting & utilizing world information. https://www.google.com/search/howsearchworks/our-approach/ https://www.google.com/search/howsearchworks/our-approach/
- sanderjd 4y agoIsn't the exact opposite reading of this just as likely to be true from what we know so far? That rather than handing over the reins to DeepMind, they're actually reining them in and forcing them to work on productization?
- p-e-w 4y ago> Google doesn't need more smart AI researchers, academics or ethicists. They need product managers who understand the underlying technology and can commercialize it. Google's revenue is equal to the GDP of New Zealand. Google's cash reserves are sufficient to sustain the company through half a century of bad quarters. Not that they have had any bad quarters, ever. They don't need anything. Their ad business is a donkey that shits gold, with Chrome and Android keeping the competition locked out, and everything else doesn't matter for Google as a company. They've done little more than play around for the last decade, with an endless procession of hyped-then-canceled "products", and it hasn't affected their market dominance in the slightest. They can keep fucking up for the foreseeable future, and it won't really matter. If a startup emerges that appears to have the right approach to AI, Google can simply buy it. Power is power, and everything else is nothing.
- jiggawatts 4y agoSearch has virtually no moat to luck customers in. People switched from AltaVista to Google fast! I already use phind.com almost as much as I use Google. A significant percentage of the non-development "queries" that I have, I now ask ChatGPT 4. I'm starting to suspect that within a year, I won't be using Google search much at all. That should terrify everyone at Alphabet Inc.
- p-e-w 4y agoGoogle controls 90% of the browser market, and 70% of the mobile OS market. They can force anything they want down the throats of billions of people, the vast majority of which aren't even aware that there are alternatives. And even those that are aware are in many cases unable to switch, as for example most phones will only run their manufacturer's version of Android, from which Google features usually cannot be completely removed. This isn't even remotely comparable to the AltaVista situation. Google has a planet-scale stranglehold on how half the world's population accesses information. This arguably makes Google more powerful than most nation states. I can guarantee they won't be dislodged by some search startup with a cool idea.
- 4y ago
- vishnugupta 4y agoIt’s hard to overstate how far ahead of everyone else DeepMind was as far back as 7-8 years ago. When AlphaGo burst on scene it blew everyone’s mind and even redefined what’s possible by an AI agent. I had thought back then surely Google will figure out a way to convert those research breakthroughs into consumer products. And yet here we are. If anything it’s a great example of how a “money printer” business, Google’s ad business, makes an org into a lazy, risk averse and accumulates an army of empire builders who collectively breed promo culture. Combine that with a decade of 0% interest rates which also boosted its stock price and it’s no wonder that Google is struggling on so many fronts.
- gofreddygo 4y ago> They need pragmatic engineers who can execute, launch and maintain services Not the job description Google has for engineers. Their hiring process effectively eliminates anyone who matches that description and bothers to put themselves through it.
- maegul 4y agoSo Google did a Xerox PARC or an IBM PC (to a lesser extent)? It’s curious how predictable it is that a major player is going to fall into this trap at any point in time. There’s probably some way you could measure its likelihood if you were tracking internal comms, org charts and maybe some finely designed survey data.
- stevev 4y agoI couldn’t agree more. Research is great, but when there’s no platform, nothing stands. Among some of the biggest flop in history by starting so late. We’ll have to see how their generative text to videos do.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dudeinjapan 4y agoNah bruh they just need to make an AI that is smart enough to do the marketing for them. Give it time.
- tomerbd 4y agojust take a couple of engineers and ask them to solve real world problems.