9 ms·
This is wonderful sage advice: > Google Adsense was profitable on the site for many years, earning me some really nice pay checks here and there. That is, unti
by freedomben 4y ago
This is wonderful sage advice:
> Google Adsense was profitable on the site for many years, earning me some really nice pay checks here and there. That is, until I got my Adsense account banned by trying out some too good to be true website purchases that turned out to be using fraudulent clicks. Since there there has been next to no profit, and that was years ago.
Be very cautious about services in that field as there are lots of shady things going on, and the ban hammer falls hard, and there's often no remaining options if you lose adsense.
- nadermx 4y agoThere are other ways to monetize, some significantly more profitable than adsense, but yes media buys of shady traffic will most likely cause shady results
- freedomben 4y agoWhat are some of the other ways? (honestly asking). Premium features and such are a possibility, but I don't really see the value for people to pay for this beyond maybe a tiny community, and they would surely need some premium features in return (like maybe private torrents or something).
- nadermx 4y agoPerahps an API, for stats maybe, or something else not sure. Affiliate of VPN or Hosting, or if you know how to code, roll your own VPN service and use that as a traffic source. The hardest thing, at least in my opinion to get on the internet is traffic. That generally only comes with great products, or great branding.
- en3r0 4y agoAPI would be interesting. Tried the affiliate route for Amazon (Hard Drives ect) and VPN ofers. Never had any luck with those. My conclusion: if you are on a torrent site, you probably are not looking to buy something.
- pc86 4y agoI buy a decent amount of stuff online. I've even seen ads for something and bought it the first time I saw it. But I would never, ever, buy anything after clicking an ad on a torrent site, even one I knew to be 100% legal and above board. Hell you'd be hard to get me to even click one of the ads in the first place let alone just open a new tab and search for whatever the product was. The risks are everything from spam to scam to fraud to full-blown identity theft if you click the wrong ad on the wrong site, and all of that can be obviated by just searching for the thing in a new tab 99% of the time. The juice (getting the site owner a fractional percentage of the sale at best, or a fraction of a penny for a click) ain't worth the squeeze IMO.
- en3r0 4y agoYup, can't blame you there!
- PaywallBuster 4y agomany networks will not approve your website with shady content so then you're running ads for porn, sketchy software and VPNs or wtv
- en3r0 4y agoYa, basically no one would touch a torrent site, even if it was legal, with user submitted content.
- freedomben 4y agoTo downvoter, this is the OP and this is not some hypothetical speculation from a random internet cynic. This is their actual experience with this site. This comment should be highly upvoted, not downed.
- fsckboy 4y agoI'm not at all suggesting that GP should be downvoted, but just because a person ran a site doesn't mean they thought of and tried all the possibilities for making it work. Do we want to blindly accept all the advice friendster and digg have to give us? Should we accept everything Musk has to say about twitter, or should he simply listen without objection to Jack Dorsey?
- mst 4y agoNobody claimed it should be read uncritically. The considered opinion of the site admin, based on his own experience, is still worthy of note and of upvoting. I happen to think he's right, but the point would stand even if I didn't.
- zackmorris 4y agoThe fact that there is no recourse or viable competition, strikes me as an injustice. Maybe the biggest injustice on the web currently. Maybe it's time to not let it stand anymore? I know, we're just a bunch of ragtag hackers who just want to be able to have time to tinker and make/play video games. But we're the ones who could truly disrupt online advertising and get the web back to how it used to work 20 years ago, where the average person could earn residual income online with a few clicks. Get back to building a positive, thriving future together, instead of whatever all this is. Of course I have absolutely no idea how to do that. Or how to protect people from exploitation. There's a website that pays you tips for your traffic, it's a synonym for gratuity but for the life of me I can't remember it at the moment. Google and even DuckDuckGo are so SEO'd that I can't find it. Imagine a nonprofit Adwords that paid out near 100% of proceeds in an egalitarian way, instead of using a winner-take-all algorithm that dumps more money than God on people who are already rich. I guess that's just not possible?
- phpisthebest 4y agoThe biggest injustice or problem with the web is lack of viable micropayments, not the lack of competition in Ads. The falsity of an Ad Support Web is what needs to die.
- arcticbull 4y agoThe problem is nobody wants to make a hundred purchasing decisions per day. Which is why micropayments aren't a thing despite us having had the infrastructure for decades. There's no reason PayPal can't support sub-dollar transactions now, or ever before. Nick Szabo and I disagree on probably everything else in this world, but we agree on micropayments. Nick's paper is worth a read and does a great job of explaining the issues [1]. tl;dr: around micropayments is that in reality users/customers don't actually want them. They run afoul of our fundamental human behavioral costing model. The reason ad-supported is so prevalent isn't because it's being forced on us by a shady cabal or anything, it's just the least-worst option we've compromised on. [1] https://nakamotoinstitute.org/static/docs/micropayments-and-mental-transaction-costs.pdf https://nakamotoinstitute.org/static/docs/micropayments-and-...
- counttheforks 4y agoI wonder why people don't use this to take out their competition more often. Just buy them lots of fraudulent clicks.
- freedomben 4y agoI have no idea how often it happens, but I have read anecdotal comments on HN about people having it done to them. Not too long ago there was a person. I can't for the life of me find it now, but some time ago on HN there was a person whose account got banned for upvote gaming, but it wasn't actually him. Fortunately dang let him make his case.
- codexon 4y agoIt happened to me. Was permanently banned and I never made use of a service like what the OP mentioned. Now I am still using adsense but through a 3rd party that takes a large cut.
- progmetaldev 4y agoUnfortunately, this does actually happen
- counttheforks 4y agoIt should happen way more often, so it becomes ineffective.
- irrational 4y agoOnce they realized what had happened, couldn't they started over from scratch?
- pimlottc 4y agoCan someone clarify what “too good to be true website purchases” is talking about? What does it have to do with AdSense?
- RileyJames 4y agoI don’t know. But I suspect they bought some established websites via a marketplace like flippa, that had established earnings (traffic, ad revenue). They then swapped the Adsense account to their own, and discovered that the ad clicks were fraud / bots, which resulted in their entire Adsense account being banned.
- pimlottc 4y agoAh, that sounds plausible. I read "website purchases" as "online purchases"; it didn't occur to me they might be talking about buying actual websites.
- heavyset_go 4y agoTrying to figure this out, as well. Makes it sound like he bought some service that would optimize ads or increase ad CTR?
- codexon 4y agoEven if you don't use services like that, a competitor can easily use it for you to get you banned.