24 ms·
> As Microsoft puts it: “We are continuing the exploration of badging on the Start menu with several new treatments for users logging in with local user account
by JohnFen 4y ago
> As Microsoft puts it: “We are continuing the exploration of badging on the Start menu with several new treatments for users logging in with local user accounts to highlight the benefits of signing in with a Microsoft account (MSA).”
What is Microsoft really thinking here? You have to go out of your way (and probably do a web search) in order to figure out how to install Win 11 without using a Microsoft Account. So those people deliberately chose that -- they didn't avoid the MSA because they were unaware of the benefits, they did it because they were aware of the drawbacks and want to avoid them.
Harassing them seems more likely to make them angry than to make them change their minds.
- dylan604 4y agoSo you're saying Windows has become nagware?
- copper-float 4y agoAbsolutely, well beyond nagware at this point (with default settings).
- hef19898 4y agoI vaguely remember a time when browsers would install all kind of crappy add-ons, or any other software installer for that matter. Now we reached a point were the OS does it...
- dylan604 4y agoDid the browser do that install, or did the user install something on their own that came with additional software? the infamous purple gorilla or whatever it was that you thought you were installing one thing, but a whole other thing was installed at the same time. sourceforge's dark UI of downloading software, but also downloading/installing a whole other program hidden behind a vaguely worded auto-selected checkbox. i just don't remember being able to blame the browser for this.
- j16sdiz 4y agoOpera browser did bundle some Mcafee stuffs.
- dspillett 4y agoYes. It has already been spyware for some time.
- adriancr 4y agoYou could set machines up for family that don't know better and they will see the popup and create the account themselves... same as with badgering for upgrades, had family that eventually upgraded by mistake then panick if/when things didnt work
- rootusrootus 4y agoIt made my day when my mother told me she was disposing of her desktop computer because she had transitioned all of her computing needs to her iPad. One less headache to deal with.
- izacus 4y agoIt's obvious what are they thinking: "This gives us conversions, this gives us money, what are you gonna do, pay 3000$ for a Mac?"
- JohnFen 4y agoI don't think they'll get many conversions out of it. They're fishing in a pool that already actively signaled that they don't like the bait.
- dzader 4y agoand it's a pool not paying them for services so they probably don't care about losing them.
- JohnFen 4y agoSo then why bother targeting them in the first place?
- MathMonkeyMan 4y agoIf the numbers go up, somebody looks good. Maybe even gets a promotion.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoThe thinking is that MS' needs come first, and yours are way, way down the list, unless you're a volume license holder. Whereby, you get an off switch. So the magnitude or logic of the gain doesn't factor much unless a policy hits the news with a stickiness of several months.
- midoridensha 4y agoThey don't need a lot of conversions. If 2% of users take them up on the ad, that's an increase in revenue and profit. If it pisses off 40% of users, that's not a problem, because only 0.001% of users are going to get so angry that they'll stop using Windows (and those users probably paid for a license anyway as part of the computer purchase, so it won't affect MS's revenues).
- giancarlostoro 4y agoI went ahead and installed Linux the moment I realized I had to go through a ton of hoops in order to install Windows 11 offline. I'm only ever going to use Windows for work machines that someone else is paying me to use, and even then, I might just start asking for a Mac instead. I'm over this awful OS nonsense they're doing to Windows. Whoever is in charge of the OS clearly does not care. If I were manning the ship at Microsoft for Windows, I'd make the OS slimmer and far more lightweight.
- JCWasmx86 4y agoI recently installed Windows 10 in a VM to port a program to Windows (Was a horror story). On the left side in the start menu I have ads and other crap: "Trending searches", "Trending videos from the web", "Games for you", "Trending news" and some other stuff like a reminder for the International day for Monuments and Sites. On the right side I have a weather/news widget from some really shady or local newspapers about "celebrities", a lot of clickbait, stock data etc. And obviously the first time I opened Edge I was greeted with some annoying banner, that I should login etc. A default installation of an OS should only come with the bare amount of software necessary. If they had asked: "Do you want to have news/recommendations? - Yes/No,never ask again" it would be really okay as there was no forced consent, but installing it by default is simply a bad decision. (From a users' perspective, it probably makes sense from a corporate perspective as otherwise they wouldn't do it)
- copper-float 4y agoAll of these gross advertising decisions baked into the operating system disgust me. Not to mention all the tracking they probably do to you on top of it. The best solution I've found is Windows 10 IoT Enterprise. It feels like an alternate timeline where Microsoft didn't dive headfirst into manipulative advertising practices. None of those pointless bloatware apps, no blatant advertising loitered across the OS. I don't want tabloid trash baked into my start menu. It would be one thing if we were actually allowed to curate and choose the news, but it's all selected for us. It feels like they're trying to manipulate the way people think with decisions like that.
- JCWasmx86 4y agoCompanies should really accept a "No" from their users. No I don't want to use a microsoft account just to use my computer. (Without jumping through hoops) Don't ask me again the moment I say "No". You can see the same with all those dialogs that only have "Yes, do $THING" and "Remind me later".
- xattt 4y ago> Companies should really accept a "No" from their users. At some point, it gets into “creepy pervert” territory.
- afandian 4y agoI got this from BBC Sounds app. https://imgur.com/a/CSMwv96 https://imgur.com/a/CSMwv96 A full screen dialogue box with no other way of dismissing it but “maybe later”. “Switch on notifications and we'll find new releases that you might like, so you don't have to. Sounds good Maybe later” No shred of concern for consent. I get if you’re a scrappy startup growth hacking taking ethical shortcuts. But a public service broadcaster should have better standards. (edit - to be clear, scummy behaviour is scummy behaviour whoever's doing it)
- JohnFen 4y ago> I get if you’re a scrappy startup growth hacking taking ethical shortcuts. Nope. Scrappy startup or established corporation, it doesn't matter. Taking ethical shortcuts makes you a Bad Guy.
- not_a_shill 4y ago[flagged]
- JohnFen 4y agoI don't think I agree that ethics are ultimately irrelevant. Regardless, though, I think you're confusing being "manipulative" with being "opinionated". I'm 100% being opinionated. I'm not being manipulative, though, because I am not trying to make anyone do anything -- let alone trying to do it through unwarranted emotional appeals.
- bigger_inside 4y agoI've never used linux. After a hundred frustrations with my new laptop that runs Win11, I'm now looking to install ubuntu. Windows pushed me there.
- donkeybeer 4y agoBeware of snaps. Ubuntu would have been my recommendation too until recently. Also avoid gnome, I'd advise xfce personally.
- donkeybeer 4y agoI'd really not like spamming this again but I should strongly emphasize, stay away from snap and gnome, you would be completely put off computing if you are escaping modern Windows and come to Ubuntu and then experience this nonsense the first thing. They are the same tarpit of user hostile software requiring you fighting your computer 24x7. Some people might disagree about gnome perhaps, but they have a long and well documented history of nastiness, removing features, rewriting everything, deliberately not solving certain bug/feature requests for several years. And since they are de facto in control of gtk now, its also bleeding there too. There are talks of killing theming in gtk 4/5 for example. And snaps are basically an all in one packaging solution, the main evil relevant to you are forced updates and officially speaking there is no way around it last I checked, at best you can set a grace period. Also they put files in weird locations so good luck trying to edit their settings, etc.
- eimrine 4y agoDebian-based distribs are very beginner-friendly and Ubuntu's forum is full of helpful users.
- hef19898 4y agoUbuntu was my pick, main reasom being that it is the distro Lenovo is offering and thus guaranteed to work with my Lenovo laptop. Agree on the usefull forums and information. No idea how it compares to other distros, I never tried any. It is a breath of fresh air compared to Windows 10 so!
- justinholt 4y agoI think there'd be significant overlap with the folks that setup Windows 11 without a Microsoft Account and those that use tools like Open-Shell to rid themselves of some of these start menu "enhancements".
- irrational 4y agoApple has a similar problem. On setup it wants me to set up siri, payment, etc. My options are to setup now or do it later. There needs to be a third option that I will never setup these things and never ask me again.
- dotty- 4y agoI don't think Apple recurringly hounds you to sign in when you hit "Do it later" though. I read "Do it later" here as a subtle reminder that "the option is not gone. You can do it later on your own in your system settings if you want", as opposed to "ok we'll ask you again later unprompted :)"
- tohnjitor 4y agomy nearly 10 year old imac asks me daily to either install updates now, enable auto updates, or "remind me later" for software updates. apple doesn't even update anything for this OS anymore.
- thewebcount 4y agoThis is stupid, but if I recall correctly, if you click the close box “x” in the upper left corner of the notification, it will stop asking, but if you say “remind me later” it continues to ask you. It is utterly infuriating that they use this dark pattern.
- FireBeyond 4y agoApple and unintuitive UI patterns, be they dark or otherwise. How many people have discovered macOS or iOS behaviors with accidental keypresses, swipes or gestures, or long holds on a button or ... bleh.
- jwestbury 4y ago> How many people have discovered macOS or iOS behaviors with accidental keypresses, swipes or gestures, or long holds on a button or ... bleh. A similar number to those who have discovered them on Windows, I'd wager.
- zeruch 4y agoIt's not "more likely" to make us angry. It's a goddamn certitude.
- MikusR 4y agoThey saw that Apple was doing it and nobody complained.
- hef19898 4y agoGetting local user accounts working under Win 10 was already bad enough, just figuring that out took loner than getting my first Linux installed and running. And yes, I went through all of that to avoid yet another MS Account. Not sure what MS wants to achieve with all of that.
- r00fus 4y agoThey view their users as a captive audience. Where else are you going to go?
- wolpoli 4y ago> “We are continuing the exploration of badging on the Start menu with several new treatments for users logging in with local user accounts to highlight the benefits of signing in with a Microsoft account (MSA).” Wow. Even the sentence itself is incredibly indirect and obfuscated. They aren't able to own it and say "We are exploring new ways to promote the benefits of signing in with a Microsoft account by adding badges to the Start menu for users logging in with local user accounts." or "We are adding badges to the Start menu to bug users with local user accounts to switch to a Microsoft account."
- widowlark 4y agoCase in point, I only use windows for one game and one other program, and my long term plan is to eliminate it from my life altogether. Sorry microsoft, you really messed up here.
- cptskippy 4y agoIt works for Apple. You get a nice little upsell/upset every time you go into certain Apps. They call them "suggestions".
- andrewstuart 4y agoCan you imagine being in the Windows product design meeting and someone says: “No means NO! The user did not activate their account and we should respect that not harass them!” Would never happen.
- ShadowBanThis01 4y agoIt would if anyone with self-respect works there. I've done similar things at Apple, and I would damn well do it at Microsoft. At some point in your career you decide you don't have to suck up anymore. Could be day one; could be year 10. But it should happen.
- mdavidn 4y agoI wonder the same thing about the regular prompts to change my default search back to Bing, all disguised in language about optimizing Edge with recommended settings.
- bluedino 4y agoI mean, maybe 0.01% of us will switch to Linux and WINE, and that will show them.
- ShadowBanThis01 4y ago"You have to go out of your way (and probably do a web search) in order to figure out how to install Win 11 without using a Microsoft Account." You are not kidding. I bought my parents two computers and set them up from scratch, taking pains to create local user accounts (because they don't have Microsoft accounts). On one of them, I have no idea how, the sole user ID still managed to be a POS "Microsoft account" created with an arbitrary number of characters from my dad's E-mail ID or something. The endless badgering to log in with a "Microsoft account" that nobody wants or needs is enough to make me not use Windows. It is beyond offensive at this point. Dear Microsoft: NOBODY NEEDS ANOTHER "ACCOUNT." This offensive hounding, in combination with the fact that Windows is a disgraceful mess from form to function now, makes it an afterthought in my household. I'm a software developer, and I don't have a single installation of Windows running in my home (and office).
- Dalewyn 4y agoI have a Microsoft account (an ancient one even, anyone remember Hotmail?) I use everyday, but I refuse to use it with Windows 10/11. Why? Because I don't want sync. I treat each of my computers as separate, individual, unique machines. Synchronizing the data on them is fucking insane to me because I can't rely on a given machine to be the computer I expect it to be. And yes, I have separate Google accounts for my phone, tablet, etc., because I do not fucking want sync.
- ShadowBanThis01 4y agoYeah man. I have a Hotmail account I use as a spam-bucket, and that's it. For the sync I want, I tolerate iCloud. For everything else, I roll my own.
- the_overseer 4y agoMe and most people want sync though. That is why it's the default. And I hope it stays that way.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chaostheory 4y agoThis is probably their answer to piracy and market saturation long term.
- iphone_elegance 4y agomost users enjoy interacting with helpful advertisements if you want to call them that
- userbinator 4y agoI like how "badging" could easily be read "badgering", as I was naturally primed to "autocorrect" it upon reading the title and the article leading up to that.
- LegitShady 4y agoI have a windows 10 laptop I haven't upgraded to 11. Every once in a while I turn it on and its not at my desktop but at a "lets upgrade to windows 11!" screen and it requires several "no, lets not" buttons before you can tell it not go away but "go away for now". Quite irritating.
- orloffm 4y agoIt's not harassment. It's just there is some set of managers of various levels tasked with increasing the % of people using the online account in Windows. They have a metric, and they work towards it. There is no one in the company who can decide to not do this nagging - either a person doesn't have the authority, or it requires negotiating with too many owners, or this metric is very high-level, or it's the CEO who doesn't care about such low-level things because he uses the online account and doesn't see it. It's always like that in all modern corporations.
- wellthisisgreat 4y agoExactly! It’s the personal responsibility / fault of a handful of specific people who cowardly hide behind the corporation. I wonder if they would dare explain how they decide to add these adds to people’s OS in some new social setting.
- illiac786 4y ago> Harassing them seems more likely to make them angry than to make them change their minds. I think the sad reality is that more often than not this is how large corporations win, users do cave on average. Only the most passionate, the most engaged ones, the ones posting here for example will refuse to give in...