9 ms·
This is basically Samsung asking Google to pay up. Google needs to pay Apple / iOS for Default Search Engine, and paying Samsung for staying on Android with Goo
by ksec 4y ago
This is basically Samsung asking Google to pay up. Google needs to pay Apple / iOS for Default Search Engine, and paying Samsung for staying on Android with Google Search.
Basically Google is being squeezed left and right. So the only way to increase revenue or profits to satisfy the money they spend on Apple and Samsung? More Ads on Youtube and Google Search. The more Ads they serve, the worse UX they have. All while completely fail to compete against AWS or Azure.
- seydor 4y agogoogle still owns android
- pulse7 4y agoTrue, but Android is open-source and suppliers can replace default search engine - and other services - on it...
- Zigurd 4y agoMore precisely, Google makes AOSP, which is the basis for a licensed version of Android that includes a number of proprietary apps. Two things are not likely to happen: 1. Samsung will not give up on licensing Google proprietary package of apps. 2. Google will not yank Samsung's license. Google will absolutely tighten the screws on their future contracts to discourage these deals, as well as sweeping out crappy "customizations."
- 0zemp1c 4y ago> as well as sweeping out crappy "customizations." huh? Samsung OneUI features have been making their way into mainstream AOSP...particularly the tablet-focused stuff there is no way Google will ever try to "strong arm" Samsung...Samsung is the Android market, the Pixel line is a rounding error and in no way a competitive threat
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoHmm... >40% of Samsung's net revenue is mobile devices. Only ~56% of Google's revenue is from Search ads - <50% of that comes from Android - and <35% of that comes from Samsung. <10% of Google's total revenue comes from Samsung devices >40% of Samsung's NET REVENUE comes from selling Android devices. It's almost as if Samsung is a lot more dependent on Google than the other way around. At the end of the day - the majority of people you default to Bing search are going to switch back to Google. Samsung will be lucky to get a meaningful amount of money. MSFT can't outbid Google because they can't make as much money from the searches as Google.
- 0zemp1c 4y ago> It's almost as if Samsung is a lot more dependent on Google than the other way around. in a pinch, Samsung could just fork the AOSP project and continue forward without Google, it would be trivial for app makers to re-publish their apps in a Samsung app store (and many already do)
- Zigurd 4y agoSomeone in Microsoft is going to deserve a huge bonus if they can talk Samsung into making a successor to Surface Duo.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoExcept they tried this several times, and it hasn't worked.
- Andrex 4y ago> there is no way Google will ever try to "strong arm" Samsung...Samsung is the Android market, the Pixel line is a rounding error and in no way a competitive threat They've been strong-arming every Android OEM since the start (Google Mobile Services agreement). ("Strong arming" being closer to Apple exerting control vs. the wild west of pre-2007 cellphones.) It's finally starting to bear fruit with things like Project Mainline and Project Treble, but the political winds have changed and I expect various Gov'ts to claw back the control Google has on OEMs over the next decade. Whether Google can continue their efforts to ensure a stable Android platform is an open question after that. I can't point to anything specific since I'm rushing this comment, but it should be fairly obvious that Google lets OEMs do things their own way until the dust settles and Google synthesizes the different approaches into the "official" AOSP way. I'm not sure any actual code from OneUI has made it into Android, that would surprise me. Google really likes doing things "their way" in Android. The Android team takes UI inspiration from everyone, but most of their eyeball time is on Apple.
- dougmwne 4y agoAn extremely second rate phone platform compared to iOS where the customers don’t spend nearly as much money and they have minimal control over their hardware partners.
- seydor 4y ago.. which owns 80% of the market. Maybe iOS users spend more on hardware & apps but everyone spends money online shopping
- adithyassekhar 4y agoThen linux should be a second rate platform since no one spend enough money and there is zero control over what it runs on. Android is also technically more advanced than anything Apple in pure versatility and user control. Apple execs might get nightmares if someone suggested giving more control to their user. I can stay in the walled garden or play outside with naughty apps and emulators. Android's safety model is not based on restricting what the user can do. Security by obscurity is the least one can do. I understand everyone has a phone choice and some people prefer their phone less sophisticated or less feature rich or more basic. But just because you prefer something so reduced in functionality that it's a waste of the incredible silicon powering it does not mean you can belittle something far more capable. Especially in a developer oriented website.
- balls187 4y agoIt does, and funny enough that Antitrust lawsuit against MSFT bundling IE in Windows may end up helping them here.
- gspencley 4y agoMost of Android is licensed under the Apache 2.0 license. So while the word "owns" is true in a technical legal sense, there is nothing to prevent anyone from forking it and doing their own thing. Unlike with GPL code, they don't even need to license their changes under the same license as long as they abide the terms with respects to the original. Personally I use GrapheneOS in order to "de-Google" without switching to the Apple ecosystem. No Google Play (you can install it but I choose not to), FOSS apps only. I don't recommend it for everyone but it made me not hate owning a smart phone for the first time since the "mobile revolution" passed my old grumpy self by.
- muyuu 4y agoI've been looking at it. Ironically, you needed a Google Pixel to run it last I checked, right?
- sebstefan 4y agoWhat could they possibly do with that that doesn't violate an anti-trust law?
- balls187 4y agoI’d bet Microsoft will gladly match all of Google’s offers here.
- alphabetting 4y agoJust the payment to Apple would be significantly more than their 2022 search revenue. I wouldn't be shocked but it would be a pretty big gamble.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoThe gamble didn't work out well the last time someone tried it, which was Yahoo buying the default search on Firefox.
- mattnewton 4y agoThat’s more because it was a bet on the wrong horse. If you know how to install Firefox you probably know what search engine you are using and how to switch the default search engine.
- h4ch1 4y agoIsn't installing Firefox the same as installing any other browser?
- dhruvarora013 4y agoIt's not the default browser on most devices. I think the parent comment is stating that if you're technical enough to install a 3rd party browser, you're technical enough to pick your own search engine. So people chose Firefox and chose away from Yahoo
- piyush_soni 4y agoI think Firefox users have now reduced to geeks and some 'real FOSS' enthusiasts etc. I still use Firefox as my primary browser, but I haven't seen any non-tech person installing it for a long time now. They all just search for Chrome and download, install that. So in today's times if someone's installing Firefox I'd say they'd mostly know their way around.
- jrockway 4y agoIs GCP really a failure? I think the product is OK and they seem to have some big customers. They're maybe #3 in the space, but you can make a lot of money without being #1. Yes, we all hate their support structure (it goes through SADA), but the price is right. At my last company with 4 engineers we were paying AWS ~$1000/month for support. At my current company back when we had a cloud service on GCP, we got weekly calls with support for $0/month. Folks at Google also seemed to approve my weird resource requests (tons of GPUs in the midst of a GPU shortage, etc.) without me going through any back channels. I didn't find it terrible to work with at all, and it was much cheaper than AWS.
- somsak2 4y agoI'd call being half of Azure's market share today a failure. Hell, they were better-positioned than Amazon to offer an AWS-like product when AWS itself came out.
- JustLurking2022 4y agoHonestly, with any vendor not named AWS, it's incredibly difficult to parse their actual "cloud" revenue. I believe Microsoft bundles in their Office 365 revenue just as Google does Docs. IBM stuffs in all sorts of seemingly unrelated stuff to make their numbers sound bigger. It's actually difficult to compare apples-to-apples because of all the gamesmanship.
- DangitBobby 4y agoCompanies think they are simplifying things by using Azure since they already rely so heavily on MS software. That's pretty much the only reason Azure is more popular. GCP is a far better platform.
- nunez 4y agoNot so sure about that. Their infrastructure is highly customized down to the PCB. They were designed in-house for Google's workloads, AFAIK. Did Amazon have the same constraints?
- paulpan 4y agoThe frenemy status of Google-Samsung is once again on display. Samsung probably hasn't been happy with the Google's continued Pixel phone push :p But why is Google paying Apple to be the default search engine on iOS devices? It seems a waste of money as Apple would be stupid to default to any other search engine given the lower search quality results. End users would notice if there was a result degradation and likely switch their default. Google seems to be playing the "Intel Inside" part without reaping the marketing benefits and only paying the traffic acquisition costs.
- Sai_ 4y agoApple may not consider any other default search engine only in the absence of a search engine other than google offering a pot of money to be the default search engine.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoso without a default search engine what happens when you type some words in the address bar like every user has been trained to do?
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 4y agoThe first time, you're presented with a prompt to choose your default search engine.
- bushbaba 4y agoOr they’d ask users which search engine they’d prefer. Likely a non small amount would prefer chat-Bing just to try it out
- tadfisher 4y agoIf Samsung really wasn't happy, they wouldn't be manufacturing Google's phones and providing custom silicon. I think the Pixel phones are a blip on Samsung's radar in terms of competition.
- Twirrim 4y agoWhen I saw the title it reminded me of the 20+ years we'd see almost bi-annual news articles about how Dell was considering adding AMD chips to their line-up. They'd do that, Intel would offer them a discount, and that'd be the last we'd hear of it for a year or so, until that discount would be expiring.
- slimginz 4y agoIIRC someone at Intel once said that Dell is the “best friend money can buy” in an internal email that came out when Intel was being investigated for anti-competitive practices.
- gofreddygo 4y agoGoogle is losing its competitive advantage in the search space. DDG and Bing are very strong competitors for the typical web search usecase. External forces of economic and technical nature are not in their favor. Internal forces from politics, leadership and management issues are surfacing. This does not sound good for Google. Almost like it will implode.
- dehrmann 4y ago> This is basically Samsung asking Google to pay up True, but Samsung isn't known for user-friendly phones, and they often come with a lot of bloat. At some point, it drives more and more users to Pixel.
- thelittleone 4y agoI moved to Samsung from Apple and that wasn't my experience at all.
- rootw0rm 4y agoThere's a separate Samsung version of every core Google Android app, a separate Samsung account system to sync everything, and a Samsung launcher. Mind you, I personally use none of it (except launcher), but that's basically the definition of Android bloat.
- sm_1024 4y agoI'd expect bloatware to be unnecessary software. To a user who is not familiar with google's offering, the bloat doesn't exist, they don't see two different softwares. Samsung phones don't have two messaging apps, gallery, or phone app Not including google's version doesn't equate to bloat. In fact, the opposite is true.
- rootw0rm 4y agoIf I have to resort to dev mode to remove things I don't need, then to me it's bloat. Those things aren't there in vanilla Android. I'm still using Samsung hardware and I like it, but it's got a little bloat goin on
- marcosdumay 4y agoSamsung is known for adding a more user friendly version of everything that comes from stock Android. (Personally, I disagree, but this seems to be almost unanimous. Even for people that don't buy their phones.)
- 2h 4y ago> AWS or Azure I was recently in the market for a basic VPS, and Azure is absolutely awful for this use. The most bloated complicated signup and setup process I have experienced in a long time. Google was tolerable. Of the three amazon lightsail was the best, but even that loses to something like digital ocean
- jiggawatts 4y agoI often see products optimise for the "get-started-quick" part, which is often 0.1% of the total experience. For example, reviews of operating systems often focus more than 50% of the content on the upgrade or installation process, even though that's actually a rare operation. Azure focuses on Microsoft's large enterprise customers. They want guard rails, separation of responsibilities, policy, compliance controls, etc... Nothing to do with the process required to get 1 VM up and running from scratch, including signing up. Their bread & butter customers have enterprise agreements in place already for Office and Windows licensing!
- LoganWhitwer 4y ago[dead]