4 ms·
It makes sense. Why pay someone $20 for a job they would have done for $10. There needs to be some logic to guess what this value is so AI would be useful. Tryi
by charcircuit 4y ago
It makes sense. Why pay someone $20 for a job they would have done for $10. There needs to be some logic to guess what this value is so AI would be useful. Trying to make this illegal would make the economy less efficient than it could be.
- Fauntleroy 4y agoThe economy will not function if everyone is optimized into poverty.
- charcircuit 4y agoThat doesn't contradict my point. The minimum rate someone is willing to work factors in that they do not want to live in poverty.
- chomp 4y agoMaybe in the fantasy land of an economics text book. In reality, minimum rate is a maximizing function of availability, capability, conditions and the wage. People will usually choose the highest wage job with the best conditions that they can obtain and perform, Dunning-Kruger aside. If the only jobs around pay poverty wages, people will take those. GP is saying that the economy no longer functions when businesses minimize wage. There has to be fat in the wage, or our economy becomes an economy of only basic life sustaining staples.
- saghm 4y agoPoverty isn't a single state; it's a spectrum. If every company making maximally efficient decisions causes people to only have the option to take a wage that isn't enough to lift them from poverty or no wage at all, people will still take it. I'm not saying that I think you're wrong or right compared to the parent comment that responded to you; I just don't think it's obvious that something being more efficient inherently implies that it should be legal. Maybe I'm incorrectly inferring that you're stating that "trying to make this illegal would make the economy less efficient than it could be" is implying that this means that it would be bad to make it illegal, but it definitely sounds like that to me.
- KyeRussell 4y agoDon’t conflate “allows the owner of the means of production to extract the most surplus value” with “market efficiency”. This sort of shit has negative economic and societal consequences. I’m sick to death of naive tech bros thinking that every other field is so easy that their sheltered intuition is enough to understand it.
- Wolfenstein98k 4y agoPrice discrimination is efficient. You don't have to like it, but you can't claim it isn't. Your claim that wages being below someone else's is "societally harmful" requires some proof beyond your intuition. This is not a method of cutting all wages in the country, it is a method of directing wages to higher productivity workers. It only shifts relative amounts. Just as we expect a cleaner to be paid less than the software engineer whose cubicle is being cleaned, there is no "societal" objection to the 3x engineer being paid more than the 2x engineer.
- et-al 4y agoFollowing your example, we should make wages transparent. So that way the 3x engineers know they're being correctly compensated by management, right?
- fn-mote 4y agoI can't tell if this is a sarcastic suggestion or not. This might be controversial in the private sector, but wage transparency is the norm in the public sector in my area of the world... and many people are employed in those positions.
- Dylan16807 4y agoWhen it comes to splitting up surplus value in a transaction, being efficient for one party means being inefficient for the other party. So I absolutely can claim it's not efficient, by not implicitly favoring the employer over the employee. And we're not changing the number of transactions here with these wage calculations.
- lukev 4y agoIt shouldn't be made illegal. The problem is that while the workforce is the most important part of the whole enterprise, each individual worker has very little bargaining power. Workers should be able to form some sort of group, so they can negotiate on something resembling an even footing with huge corporations.
- HPMOR 4y agoWOW it's almost like you're describing a union!
- happytoexplain 4y agoThere is the largest number the employer would be willing to pay, and there is the smallest number the employee would be willing to accept, and in a just world the two parties would have equal footing in the battle to arrive at a number in the middle. However, the employer has powerful systems dedicated to pushing the value toward the lower number, while the employee has only their intuition and fear.
- abigail95 4y agoThere's extreme competition in gig work. It's completely flexible and completely transferable. Companies have very little pricing power. The workers and the customers have all the power.
- panic 4y agoThis type of thinking might be acceptable if access to necessities like housing, health care, food, utilities, child care, and education didn't require you to make money. As it is, the end result of your efficiency is real human suffering.
- chii 4y agoThe fact that those things you mentioned as necessary for life exists today is _because_ of efficiency. Without this efficiency, you'd get even more human suffering. Imagine how your life was back in the dark ages.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]