9 ms·
Yeah, about that active comeback...
- 082349872349872 4y agohow apropos: it's the 50th anniversary of A Random Walk Down Wall Street (1973)
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://longnow.org/ideas/warren-buffett-wins-million-dollar-long-bet/ https://longnow.org/ideas/warren-buffett-wins-million-dollar... https://longbets.org/362/ https://longbets.org/362/
- dehrmann 4y agoWhat's neglected about this is arguably the most successful active asset manager bet against active asset management.
- roncesvalles 4y agoWell he hasn't exactly bet against active management since all his wealth is actively managed. A more accurate interpretation would be "what I'm doing is incredibly difficult and I bet most who try will fail."
- dehrmann 4y agoNot just that, but that most of the really smart people who do it professionally will fail.
- snowwrestler 4y agoIf you read the original bet and discussion carefully, what Buffett really bet against was the fees. It’s a very important detail in the original bet that the returns would be compared net of fees. His argument was not that active management was doomed to fail, but rather that active management is usually not worth what you pay hedge fund managers to do it.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoExactly. He was basically saying that over time for practically all managers: (80% * managers return) - 2% < market return. Not: managers return < market It's quite different.
- somethoughts 4y agoI think its helpful to realize that the S&P 500 is not some static index of companies whose selection has been on auto-pilot but actually a fairly actively managed index whose selection algorithm is continuously being updated and refined. There is a not insignificant human judgement component of how to define the selection/weighting criteria. In some senses, behind the scenes its likely similar to the Twitter/FB/Netflix algorithm - at some point there is some editorial opinion being inserted via criteria and weighing of those criteria. "Some years ago Bill Miller, then a well-known Legg Mason portfolio manager with a stellar record of beating the market, noted that the S&P 500’s track record of being very hard to beat suggested that active management can succeed and that the Index Committee were actually good active managers." https://www.indexologyblog.com/2014/08/07/inside-the-sp-500-an-active-committee/ https://www.indexologyblog.com/2014/08/07/inside-the-sp-500-...
- anonu 4y agoYes there's an index committee comprised of humans. But the index methodology is public and when there are tie break decisions needed, they're fairly predictable. Another thing to think about is that most of the outperformance of the index is driven by the largest companies. But not because they were added when they were their current size. But because of the buy and hold approach of getting them in when they're still on the small end of the large caps. There was a good recent paper on this concept, showcasing that most of the big index returns are attributable to only a few stocks. Similar to how most of global market returns are mostly just US.
- herostratus101 4y agoI think you mean that the committee comprises humans.
- somethoughts 4y agoDefinitely agree the algorithm is likely pretty well documented but as noted in the blog it is adapted in realtime. Here's the current breakdown: Apple 7.08%, Microsoft 6.20%, Amazon.com 2.62%, NVIDIA 1.87%, Alphabet 1.84% Berkshire 1.65% Alphabet 1.61% Tesla 1.44% which if it was an active manager would be highly opinionated.
- anonu 4y agoThe issue is that some active funds do beat the market... And they do consistently. But the buyin is high and the fees are above industry averages. So people look for lower cost active returns and fail.
- belter 4y agoBut normally they do it with closed money pools. In the meanwhile they normally have other money pools that offer to their customers...but the algorithms never seem to work as well for those money pools...
- huhtenberg 4y agoE.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renaissance_Technologies#Medallion_Fund https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renaissance_Technologies#Medal... > From 1994 through mid-2014, it averaged a 71.8% annual return, before fees.
- belter 4y agoBut not for everybody... "Renaissance suffers $11b exodus with meager quant returns - https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/markets/stocks/news/setback-for-jim-simons-as-renaissance-suffers-11b-exodus-with-meager-quant-returns/articleshow/83664577.cms?from=mdr https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/markets/stocks/news/set...
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoThat is a different set of funds, with a different mandate. Same people running it, but not the core fund.
- belter 4y agoYou comment confirms the point I was trying to make.
- miohtama 4y agoRegardless if it fits to FT’s thesis or not, note that the S&P recent gains can be attributed to 7 tech companies https://www.forbes.com/sites/dereksaul/2023/04/10/these-7-tech-stocks-command-almost-90-of-the-sp-500s-gains-signaling-market-rally-may-not-be-so-healthy/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/dereksaul/2023/04/10/these-7-te... Everything else is still down and recession likely glooming. And when the recession hits the massive gainers are likely getting same-size correction.
- miohtama 4y agoAlso it’s always sad to see Meta (Facebook) to success - They are making $40/year avg. off a user by selling users data - They announced massive stock buybacks Not sure if this is the best capital allocation for society - would love to see less parasitic platforms to success.
- nordsieck 4y ago> They announced massive stock buybacks Not really sure why people complain so much about stock buybacks. They're tax advantaged dividends.
- biohax2015 4y agoBecause they indicate that a company cannot do anything more creative with their capital than use it to inflate their stock price.
- nordsieck 4y ago> Because they indicate that a company cannot do anything more creative with their capital than use it to inflate their stock price. OK. So they are returning that money to their shareholders. Which is kind of the point of a company. Does that mean the company is no longer a growth stock? Probably. But not being a growth stock isn't exactly a crime against humanity.
- 4y ago
- fredgrott 4y agoI have an economic question. Several people in the hedge and equity industries have asked that hedge funds in general pay a 5% tax. If that were to happen how would that change the outcome as in such a situation one has to factor in making enough on investments to cover the 5% tax? Or in general what can be done to economically align hedge funds with making some basic 5% or more return?
- sitkack 4y agoWay too much meddling by the SEC has caused structural inefficiency in the liquidity and the distribution of capital.
- dehrmann 4y agoCould you elaborate? On first read, I read the Fed, but the SEC causing this is interesting.
- GalenErso 4y agoThe SEC is regulating public companies too much. This leads to higher compliance costs, which decrease shareholder returns, and to more and more companies opting to remain privately held rather than going public, which is siphoning sophisticated investors away from the stock market and toward private equity investing.
- jrochkind1 4y agoIf you had invested in a fund that just tracked S&P 500, what would have been your, over, say, the last ten years, what would have been your returns? I can't figure out if this info is in the article. Are there low-fee funds that just track the S&P 500? That would seem to be the way to go for long-term investing? What such funds can I find? (taking into account as other comments in this thread point out that, yes, the S&P is actually actively managed itself, sort of).
- belter 4y agohttps://www.fool.com/investing/how-to-invest/index-funds/average-return/ https://www.fool.com/investing/how-to-invest/index-funds/ave... "...If you had invested $10,000 in the S&P 500 index in 1992 and held on with dividends reinvested, you'd now have more than $170,000. The market volatility in 2022 could cause this return to decline somewhat. However, the index has proven to be a winner over the long term..."
- jrochkind1 4y agoOK thanks! now to figure out how to calculate that as an annual rate of return (APY?) Sounds like this was through 2021, already a bit old? If I plug this into a random calculator on the web without knowing what I'm doing, $10K to $170K over 20 years looks like... around 15.25%? That does seem quite high, can that be right?
- belter 4y agoLike Warren Buffet said...nothing like just buying the index and enjoying it... https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/042415/what-average-annual-return-sp-500.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/042415/what-average... "The average annualized return since adopting 500 stocks into the index in 1957 through Dec. 31, 2022, is 10.15%." "Over the past 20 years (2002 to 2022), the average annualized return on the S&P 500 is 8.19%."
- jrochkind1 4y ago
- aynyc 4y agoIt's hard to beat index fund because everyone is buying and holding. 401K is now total like $7-8 trillion dollars. Soon, baby boomers will start the withdrawal wave, I don't know if index funds will be as hard to beat then. I hope so because my retirement is riding on 401K.
- missedthecue 4y agoMost baby boomers are already withdrawing. The very youngest are almost 60. But there are more gen x, millennials, and now gen z that are buying into the market every 2 weeks. The boomer sellers are outnumbered.
- aynyc 4y agoThe older group of gen x will be withdrawing soon. Also, more participation doesn't mean more money, at least from what I heard last time. Meaning boomers, gen x contributed more due to their career track vs millenials & gen z. Part of me feels like the market is a pyramid at this point, newcomers are paying for older generation in hopes the next generation will do the same.
- robocat 4y agoIn the olden days when most companies paid dividends, retired people would try to keep owning the shares and live off the dividends. The actual amounts sold by retirees are probably low (say a few percent a year), although I would like to see some numbers per age group. Presumably it is common for sudden death and their shares to be passed on to children?
- dehrmann 4y agoSort of a side note, but living off the dividends is mostly a psychological thing. The stock price goes down by roughly the dividend amount around the ex div date since a company with less cash on-hand is worth less. If you own shares of company that looks like it should pay a dividend but doesn't, you can simulate it by selling shares. That said, dividends are a decent proxy for company stability and health, but execs also know this, so they play games with dividends to keep income investors interested.
- ThorsBane 4y agoThis is going to change because too much money in indexes means not enough capital is chasing winners, and is instead enjoying the rising tide. That is okay and it is sustainable. But it still means that the upside for the ones who do chase winners and who succeed in placing correct bets on great companies will be more and more massive. Because the delta in capital from the index to the cream of the crop will be way larger in absolute terms as the indexes grow in size, and the winners will continue to prop up a huge rising tide of continued innovation. I’d be worried if nobody could beat the market. 7% to 15% beating the market seems reasonable to me. The market is an incredible abstraction and it works, and it’s also still great and reassuring to know that there’s still an echelon of actively managed funds that beat the market.
- cft 4y agoThat's a very good insight. The success of the index funds is nothing but an indicator of the inflation from the top, that has not trickled down to Main Street until recently. In a stable solid monetary regime, capital is forced to pick individual stocks, as opposed to riding the inflation wave.
- Gatsky 4y agoAgree, ~7% seems ok? The funny thing about the profession of active fund management is that there is a ‘scoreboard’. Almost no other profession can or would score itself like this. If they did, I doubt more than 7% would beat a suitable benchmark for hairdressers, plumbers, doctors etc. This ‘score’ has other useful properties. A successful fund manager has to operate under difficult and changeable conditions for long periods of time. They can’t get there just by default or by being lucky. Knowing which people can do this very challenging task means the advice they give about investing, managing your own psychology and life in general is imbued with a legitimacy that is difficult to find elsewhere.
- cool_dude85 4y ago>They can’t get there just by default or by being lucky. Why do you say that? If I ran a League of Coinflip Guessers with 10,000 entrants, someone would still win the league, and probably with an astonishing score too. Why not the same with stock returns? You have 10k managers it stands to reason some of them will by pure chance beat whatever metric you set.
- neonate 4y agohttps://archive.ph/gVXkw https://archive.ph/gVXkw
- majikaja 4y agoIn a basic theoretical model excluding things like individual holders, short term speculators and stocks outside of the index, if you add up all the active funds, then the holdings should indeed match the passive funds (since the passive funds are just holding a percentage of the total, the remainder must hold the remaining percentage). So in this toy scenario obviously active funds would underperform after fees. But there's more reason for investors to pick stocks than just beat the market (risk preferences - for a lot of people the benchmark is not the S&P but bond yields). The majority of active management is not hedge funds and are not in the business of providing outsized returns (especially not to small retail clients). To beat the market, one must take risks that the other active managers or index committees deem to be unacceptable.