9 ms·
Microsoft execs on Apple's music store (2003)
- chasing 4y agoI really don’t think MS had the consumer product vision at the time to pull anything like a music store off. Apple had the vision to get from point A to point B and have huge swaths of consumers hop on board for the ride. Wild oversimplification, but I always felt that MS suffered from their monopoly during the 90s in that simply never had to make products people really cared about. Apple did. And when the consumer market exploded — especially after touchscreen phones hit — MS just didn’t have any good muscles to use in the fight. They’d been sort of cheating it for so long that the stuff they kept bringing to market was just a total mess.
- dagmx 4y agoI’d argue that Microsoft still doesn’t have a consumer product vision outside their gaming division. I think they’re quite content with that now though. They’re firmly developer, enterprise and gaming focused these days.
- chasing 4y agoI would say that they seem to recognize that they need to appeal to the users of their products and not just those users’ managers. And that means playing ball with the ecosystem and not just trying to crush it. Baby steps, I guess. But a lot of their product line remains a mess. (Although the Xbox shouldn’t be discounted — that was a consumer success.)
- macintux 4y ago> I would say that they seem to recognize that they need to appeal to the users of their products and not just those users’ managers. Someone forgot to tell the Teams team.
- scarface74 4y agoThe definition of SaaS is basically where the buyer is not the user. The managers write multi year six and seven figure checks not the user.
- esafak 4y agoIt's not that simple. Look up "product-led growth". It's why Figma made Adobe eat $20b.
- scarface74 4y agoAnd Figma’s revenue was only $400 million before it got acquired.
- chongli 4y agoI would say that they seem to recognize that they need to appeal to the users of their products and not just those users’ managers Some of them recognize it, but not everyone. The company also seems to be pretty heavily invested into monetizing users to the hilt with telemetry and advertising. This is the sort of approach that will slowly drive people away from the platform, as users gradually tire of the ever-increasing intrusiveness of the ads.
- devnullbrain 4y agoGames consoles are a strange consumer product. They live and die on the ability to make deals with third parties and only a small number of companies have ever had sustained success.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoThe 2019 Surface Pro X is an excellent little machine.
- rawgabbit 4y agoI loved my Surface Book too. Until during the pandemic, Microsoft updates ran constantly. So I let the Surface Book powered on for several weeks. Foolish me didn’t realize that the CPU was maxed out and the heat would eventually cause the battery to swell and cause the display panel to become unglued.
- Philip-J-Fry 4y agoI think they're being "Appled" by Sony and Nintendo in the gaming industry though. The Xbox division has been on a downward spiral. Brand loyalty and Game Pass is arguably the only thing keeping them around. But as Sony continues to put out killer first party titles only on PS5, they will suffer. I think a lot of Xbox Series X/S buyers wish they had a PS5 or buy a PS5 as well to play Sony first party titles. And come next generation, if Xbox doesn't have anything to compete with the quality of Sony's games, then I think they're dead. We're 2.5 years into the current generation and Microsoft has almost nothing to show for it except Forza and Halo, which was a delayed mess of a game. Add in to that the fact that most third party games perform better on PS5. They've been on a downward trajectory after Xbox One, where they refuse to state how successful it is, with analysts predicting the PS4 outsold them 2-1. Xbox One was a terrible announcement and launch. Xbox Series X/S are great pieces of hardware but they just can't compete with PlayStation in every other aspect. They've let down developers with the Series S since developers have to target 2 separate SKUs for Xbox, increasing developer effort. And in some cases developers are withholding their games from Xbox if they can't run on the weaker Series S, as you are not allowed to launch on Series X only (see Baldur's Gate 3). If Microsoft changes the rules around this it will benefit developers but it will let down consumers. PS5 is predicted to be outselling the Xbox even more so this generation. There's practically no reason for a consumer to buy an Xbox unless you're a fan of their exclusives, which they have done an excellent job of killing interest in. I think next generation will be when Microsoft taps out and leaves the gaming hardware market, except for maybe their controllers. They will pivot to software only and focus on selling Game Pass for PC players and game streaming for the remaining consumers. Personally, I don't think that will have a good outcome.
- etempleton 4y agoI respectively disagree. I think Microsoft has put Sony in an impossible spot and, with the Activision merger about to go through, Sony is going to have an even harder time. The pandemic, I believe, has masked that people are migrating more and more to PC. Migrating to PC is a win for Microsoft. Kids play Switch and then are jumping right to PC. I don’t hear about a lot of Gen Z kids talk about PlayStation and have even heard it referred to as a boomer console and anecdotally the PlayStation crowd seems to be predominately 30+.
- rawgabbit 4y agoSteve Jobs and Apple can put together a music store and iPod prototype that was sexy, easy to use, and wowed the music executives who knew Napster and iPods were the future. Meanwhile Microsoft still manages to infuriate their own users with things like Windows 11 start menu. Not to mention the Microsoft Zune was definitely a dud. https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/itunes-10th-anniversary-how-steve-jobs-turned-the-industry-upside-down-68985/ https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/itunes-10t...
- junon 4y agoThis. It's always been wild to me how tone deaf Microsoft has always been. I always read these internal emails thinking how wildly out of touch with their own users they are.
- SCHiM 4y agoSometimes I start edge when something does not work in firefox. Everyone knows you want your browser to be quick, snappy and use few resources. What does Edge do? It shows you a unskippable, un-closable "how-to" (as if I've never used a browser), and a make-an-account-and-sync nag. It takes a minute to click though, what a turn off! It hasn't popped up for me in a while, but it definitively happens sometimes.
- siriusfeynman 4y agoInterestingly I've had the same experience with firefox, I keep it installed as a fallback if something isn't working in chrome but every time I (infrequently) use it I have to dismiss several popups about new features and how to switch to it as my primary browser/import history etc.
- FullyFunctional 4y agoThis resonates so hard. I really wish that SW stop assuming that if they are just installed, then the user is a complete ignoramus who needs to be educated and onboarded. I (for reasons) frequently install OSes from scratch and all the boilerplate is so tedious.
- dustedcodes 4y agoThat’s still the case until today. Microsoft has zero innovation capabilities. Nothing they built themselves since the 90s became even remotely a product which consumers enjoy. Everything they have today is Office which is kind of okay and the rest are acquisitions.
- imwillofficial 4y agoXbox is very popular.
- mahmoudhossam 4y agoI'd argue that PlayStation is dominating that segment. And even if we're talking about PC gaming, Xbox wouldn't be the word you'd be thinking of.
- sebzim4500 4y agoNot sure I'd say 'dominating', they have a 60-40 split IIRC.
- Macha 4y agoHonestly I think the only reason it's anywhere as close this generation is because of the PS5 supply issues until very recently meant many people gave up and bought a Series X. I don't think it actually has that much to put it ahead of the PS5 other than availability, and the Xbox One generation was such a flop that it seriously dented their network effects
- scarface74 4y agoFor perspective, Microsoft has sold around 20 million of the latest generation consoles that have been on sale since early 2021. Back in the iPod’s heyday, Apple was selling 20 million iPods during the Christmas quarter. Apple now sells from 40-65 million iPhones per quarter according to third party estimates.
- 4y ago
- duxup 4y agoI'd argue it has slowly gotten worse at Microsoft, and that's pretty bad. I login to windows and everything feels like they're coding / designing AT ME. It's like nobody making decisions is thinking about me accomplishing anything, more how they can make me do whatever it is they want. Don't get me started with the dozen (ok maybe not exactly a dozen) or so design languages inside Windows and how unfriendly some are.
- criddell 4y ago> Apple had the vision Yep. They know what they want to build and make fewer compromises than Microsoft. If Microsoft had developed the iPhone, it would have launched on every carrier possible and to do that, they would have had to allow the carriers to junk up the phone and restrict all kinds of user features. Remember the days of $3 ringtones and carrier run app stores? For all the problems we have with Apple and their products today, they did move us forward.
- thecupisblue 4y ago>Both teams on both sides wanted this to come together >It takes apple to make a move for us to break through communication issues and get anything done Imagine paying millions of dollars for "the best" developers, designers, managers, yet they can't even communicate with each other properly to align with common interests. FAANG culture is becoming so slow and ineffective that I'm not surprised they are cutting tens of thousands of employees. Where I'm from we have an expression - "many grandmas, lazy/spoiled child" - and it's especially rings true in creative work. For something truly brilliant to be created, you need someone with a vision and freedom to implement it. It's extremely rare for something brilliant to come from committee or top-down designed by managers delegating work to a bunch of teams. It's one of the reasons even open-source struggles with design - you need one or a tiny team of aligned brilliant people to work together, and you need to give them freedom to do it. Not constrain them with meetings, micromanaging the product and letting everyone express their opinion. That's how you get a terrible, bland, uninspiring design. Recently I had a chance to work at a theatre production that ended up suffering from the same issue - the director had no vision but only an idea, so he delegated different work to everyone, then micromanaged people and intersected into every attempt at collaboration with his own opinions and ideas. As new people were coming in, their ideas were added into the mix, creating a show that ended up being even worse than mediocre.
- operatingthetan 4y ago>FAANG culture is becoming so slow and ineffective that I'm not surprised they are cutting tens of thousands of employees. In my experience it wasn't the excess employees (everyone seemed to be busy) but that processes in the org didn't match the size and leadership from the top down couldn't see the problem. So no efforts were made to make teams work better together and align their incentives. A great example was API teams would ship incomplete and untested work as "done" because they were overworked and on an insane timeline. My front-end team tested the APIs for implementation and discovered all the missing parts, and then we had to document all of it and ask the team to fix it. The API team would then push back claiming we were wrong. My devs would have to spend hours on calls with them going over each missing piece and the API devs played dumb every time. I would have to escalate to my manager and he felt pushing back on the other leads would burn political capital he didn't have. This wasn't just one API team, it was seven. Somehow the culture of the org caused them all to follow the same strategy to push their QA to other teams and delay completion. It was so crazy that they would get defensive saying "we have the best developers in the world, that is not possible." A true organizational illness.
- PokemonNoGo 4y agoHonest question. Does this even exist today? I dont know.
- kingcharles 4y agoI really like these "leaked" emails because a couple of times I've gotten to see behind the curtain of projects, like this one, that I was involved in. I remember one issue here was trying to demo Microsoft's DRM to music execs. At the time Microsoft's software was unusable on Mac, but the music industry was Mac all the way through. Microsoft was first through the door, through outside agencies, they would do the grunt work of turning the labels on to selling their music, then Apple would turn up, sometimes literally the next day, with a much slicker promotion and win the deal. Microsoft's biggest problem through all of this was its absolute certainty that it should only provide the pick axes and not build this thing itself. It was certain the end user wanted a choice of 50 weak music players and a dozen different badly-developed music stores. If you want a job done properly do it yourself. Apple won because they did that and owned the whole vertical.
- lozenge 4y agoOh, that reminds me of Windows Media Player which had like 8 separate music stores embedded in it, seemingly as an iframe. They had the most random companies running them as well, like phone companies, supermarkets, etc. Of course it was just a white label product, so why even include them all?
- kingcharles 4y agoLOL. I coded all of those. It was horrible. Not one of those companies gave a damn about the product, they just wanted a revenue share for putting a link in their stores or on their web sites. The startup that I was working for was OD2, half-owned by Peter Gabriel, who is a very nice guy. He got us meetings with every label guy we needed to speak to. He gave me his iBook, bless him. OD2 eventually got swallowed by Nokia which of course got swallowed by Microsoft. The snake ate its tail.
- neximo64 4y agoYou don’t remember Zune then?
- kingcharles 4y ago
- bobleeswagger 4y agoMore proof that Microsoft should not exist, a company that drops the ball this hard, this consistently should be dissolved immediately.
- esafak 4y agoWhy? Wouldn't they go out of business?
- bobleeswagger 4y agoYou say that like it's a bad thing!
- esafak 4y agoI mean that the problem should resolve itself naturally.
- bobleeswagger 4y agoThat's kind of my point, it's not natural that Microsoft is still around after how much negative they have done for the tech industry. Xbox is their golden goose. VIDEO GAMES? Come on, let's not act like Windows, in its 11th iteration, is not a steaming pile of shit. I don't know how so many of you defend such a garbage company.
- bagacrap 4y agoBig brain Bill Gates predicting that subscription music services wouldn't work
- Waterluvian 4y agoGates being incredibly candid about Jobs and the music store situation is quite admirable. I’d like to find myself always working with management and executive types who speak and act that way.
- Macha 4y agoI'm sure many execs are much more open to their directs than to company wide channels, which likely plays into it.
- abhaynayar 4y agoCoincidentally, I just started re-reading Steve Jobs' biography a few days ago (~11 years after I had first read it). When I had first read it as a kid, I was more into the design/tech stuff. This time, I see my focus mostly going towards Steve's personality traits. His weird diets, his abrasiveness, his rudeness, his stare, him walking barefoot everywhere, his charisma, his directness. Him just going up to people and bending their wills in his "reality distortion field". It's really powerful stuff.
- ilyt 4y agoMore like "asshole field"
- spacetime_cmplx 4y ago>Richard: Now you're being an asshole. >Erlich: You say that like it's a bad thing. Richard, if you're not an asshole, it creates this kind of asshole vacuum and that void is filled by other assholes, like Jared. (Note: I don't necessarily entirely agree with all of it.)
- pedalpete 4y agoI'm surprised nobody seems to have questioned how it was possible that Microsoft went from these emails to releasing the Zune Store. For those not familiar, the ZuneHD was an incredible device. I still miss mine and wish someone would build a phone that felt as good. To buy music, you had to buy Microsoft points(1). Points had to be purchased in a minimum of $5 increments, and I think you got more points depending on how much you spent. Then your songs would be 87 points, or some ridiculous number. It was basically hostile to the user experience. Nobody wanted Microsoft points, and they were discontinued in 2013. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Points https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Points
- rasz 4y agoGot one going back to 1994. Not quite executive, but Alex St John was a group managed at Microsoft (DirectX) in 1992-1997. https://web.archive.org/web/20091006022255/http://www.firingsquad.com/features/alexstjohn/ https://web.archive.org/web/20091006022255/http://www.firing... : FS: What was Microsoft's philosophy or attitude regarding games when you began? Alex St John: Oh, it was completely nonexistent! During that time, their entire focus was on multimedia video, the primary mission of DirectX wasn't to benefit and push gaming, but simply to drive Apple and Quicktime into the ground. https://www.theregister.com/1998/10/29/microsoft_paid_apple_150m/ https://www.theregister.com/1998/10/29/microsoft_paid_apple_... "David Boies, attorney for the DoJ, noted that John Warden, for Microsoft, had omitted to quote part of a handwritten note by Fred Anderson, Apple's CFO, in which Anderson wrote that "the [QuickTime] patent dispute was resolved with cross-licence and significant payment to Apple." The payment was $150 million." "Microsoft and Intel had been shocked to find that Apple's QuickTime product made digital video on Windows seem like continuous motion, and was far in advance of anything that either of them had, even in a planning stage. The speed was achieved by bypassing Windows' Graphics Display Interface and enabling the application to write directly to the video card. The result was a significant improvement over the choppy, 'slide-show' quality of Microsoft's own efforts. Apple's intention was to establish the driver as a standard for multimedia video imaging, so that Mac developers could sell their applications on the Windows and Mac platforms. Microsoft requested a free licence from Apple for QuickTime for Windows in June 1993, and was refused. In July 1993, the San Francisco Canyon Company entered into an agreement with Intel to deliver a program (codenamed Mario) that would enable Intel to accelerate Video for Windows' processing of video images. However, although Intel certainly knew that Canyon had developed key parts of the code for Apple, it did not specify that this must be undertaken in a clean room," "Intel gave this code to Microsoft as part of a joint development program called Display Control Interface." "Canyon admitted that it had copied to Intel code developed for and assigned to Apple. In September 1994, Apple's software was distributed by Microsoft in its developer kits, and in Microsoft's Video for Windows version 1.1d."
- cryptozeus 4y agovery mature email from gates...even after being so successful he is admiring jobes and how they were caught flat-footed once again
- ducknalddon 4y agoI've worked for a couple of companies that were struggling in one way or another. The funny thing was everybody in the organisation knew what the problems were but they still couldn't address them. In one case the business failed and most people went off into new roles which were exactly what they should have been doing before.
- jbverschoor 4y agoWhat me most every time I read these sort of posts, is that these things get discussed in an email thread, yet most managers want meetings upon meetings