7 ms·
Skyscraper Proposed for 2700 Sloat Boulevard in Outer Sunset, San Francisco
- mostlysimilar 4y agoGood, now do it again 2000 more times all across Sunset and Richmond.
- tivert 4y agoYes! https://www.shutterstock.com/image-photo/hainan-china-january-2021-aerial-view-2027814032 https://www.shutterstock.com/image-photo/hainan-china-januar...
- tedunangst 4y agoThe diagram showing the evolution of the plan, using different zoning rules, is interesting. You can't just start with the tower you want to build, you have to start with an ugly lump, then mold it into the desired result.
- philsnow 4y agoHow exactly are they planning to go from step 1 ("additional density") to step 2 ("reformation") ? It looks like they would have to demolish about 10 floors' worth of housing and rebuild it in the center of the lot. That can't be done overnight, and all those people whose housing you have to demolish would have to go somewhere.
- evtothedev 4y agoI had the some question, but then realized I was misunderstanding the diagram. Replace the word "step" with "iteration" and it makes more sense. This is showing how the design evolved with additional constraints.
- tedunangst 4y agoStep 1 isn't a building. It's a CAD file.
- rocket_surgeron 4y agoThis will never get built. If anything it is a "hi" proposal with the hopes that "med" will make it through the process. If the final project exceeds five stories ("lo") I will be very surprised. Locals will fight tooth an nail to limit any and all construction. They freaked THE FUCK out when someone proposed a 7-story apartment unit back in 2021, comparing councilman Gordon Mar to the "the leader of the Chinese communist party" for supporting affordable housing (then he lost his election to someone with no meaningful positions on affordable housing). Do you really think that residents who went ballistic on 7 stories won't go full-on nuclear winter on 50? Residents don't care that they're screwing their children, they don't care about homelessness (beyond punishing them for existing), and they certainly don't care about "the nature and character of our neighborhood"-- they only care about "number gets bigger" when they look at the Zillow page for their address.
- bifrost 4y agoThey're not screwing their children lol. Homelessness in SF is about drugs, not housing, its very clear.
- ghaff 4y agoGenuine question. Even if it could be built, is there a real market for a skyscraper that's mostly housing in that area of town? The Bay Area is a bit atypical but the "housing shortage" in a lot of places is mostly a shortage in the specific places where people prefer to live.
- bifrost 4y agoNo, there is no market for this. And even if there was it'd be hamstrung by the lack of infrastructure (roads/parking) so it'd be a nightmare to live there.
- gonehome 4y agoYeah, there’s a market. The units would likely be nicer than the old houses people currently rent there for a lot money. Increased supply may make them cheaper too. Sunset is pretty nice, especially now that most work remote and the downtown soma area is not a great place to be. I’m in dogpatch because it’s one of the few neighborhoods that has a lot of condos that isn’t downtown soma.
- evtothedev 4y agoThis proposal is like a miniature class in negotiation - and boy have they anchored high!
- aorloff 4y agoThe state is empowering developers to challenge local control to try to break the logjam of CA housing development
- timr 4y agoThere's such a thing as bidding so high that you're not perceived as serious.
- Redoubts 4y agoYeah that’s what local review has been doing for years, hence this counter offer; not to mention the state stripping zoning rights from municipalities. There originally was a serious offer on the table, yet it wasn’t entertained either.
- timr 4y agoSure, OK. So there's systemic ridiculousness, and a giant downtown tower in a suburb ridiculousness. One is obvious to anyone who looks at it. I'm pro-growth, but this is a farce. It will backfire.
- kristopolous 4y agoIt's a concrete candy bar It'd be great if it had a bit more character. Terraces, maybe a public skywalk. These modern buildings are hostile to communities. They look like fortresses. After we shape a building like that how will it shape us?
- joe_the_user 4y agoTerraces can be nice but I don't think the presence or absence or terraces can correlated with community. I've lived in both apartment complexes and single family neighborhoods and I've known more neighbors when I lived in a complex.
- kristopolous 4y agoI'm not an architect in the slightest. But I've traveled and the modern US building look dull, sterile and hostile compared to what I see in Asia and Europe. If you're going to put in that kind of time and money, try to make something that 50 years from now will be thought of as a culture heritage site
- aobdev 4y agoI'm guessing the renders are not representative of what it will actually look like as the article states that "their initial filing does not provide us with much detail about exterior design". It also seems unlikely that this exact proposal will be approved and constructed as-is.
- jonas21 4y agoYeah, this is just the massing. It's kind of like a wireframe for buildings. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massing
- jseliger 4y agoThe building looks great and landowners should be able to build what they want on the land they own. Don't own it? You shouldn't get a say. Imposing restrictions on other people's property led us to today's housing crisis.
- mrDmrTmrJ 4y agoWe need thousands more of these, and at twice the height! A great start.
- mc32 4y agoI think this is cool; but mostly a one-off? Real impact would be something more of a city-plan such as "High density mid-rises along a corridor such as: California, Geary, Sunset or even Sloat (but Sloat is hinterlandish) and build an underground Muni (or Bart arm) to support the population's transit needs.
- bifrost 4y agoThis is a terrible idea. The SF YIMBY movement is completely out of touch with the spirit of SF. I say this as a native San Franciscan.
- tqi 4y agoWho gets to decide what is or isn't the spirit of SF?
- bifrost 4y agoPeople who live here, and I mean actually live here, not ones that just pop in for a few years and decide it needs to change. YIMBYism is very misguided in SF.
- pcwalton 4y agoI've lived in SF for years as a residential property owner, in the Bay Area for over a decade, and I say bring on the development. Views on this issue are not as one-sided as you think. (Also, the idea that you need to have lived here for some arbitrary tenure to vote on issues is gross.)
- bifrost 4y agoIts only gross if you think being a multi-generational stakeholder is wrong.
- tqi 4y agoIt's not wrong, but making it a requirement for one's opinion to be taken seriously is pretty gross. For one, it actively favors people with money, since they are the only ones who can afford to establish new multi-generation bonafides. Also, lest we forget, this city's not too distant past includes long periods of redlining and the displacement of Japanese American residents from the homes. In other words, it's nice that your family was able to make it work here, and I genuinely think that it is an important perspective to consider, but maybe keep in mind that just because others weren't / aren't as fortunate doesn't mean they shouldn't have an equal claim to shaping the city's future.
- tqi 4y agoI'm very pro development in general, but I'm not sure if the market for a building of that type makes sense for that location? Over 40 minutes to FiDi on public transit and not especially close to 280, so not super convenient for commuters. That far out there also isn't a ton of bars/restaurants, so no especially attractive to younger people. And for families lack of dedicated outdoor space + downstairs neighbors to worry about makes it less than ideal. I hate that SF has painted itself into a corner, where development has to occur in whatever random locations that happen to open up. I think for higher density housing, locations off of muni closer to the core of the city would obviously make more sense / have a clear market, but we just can't get there.
- jaggederest 4y agoFrom what I've seen this kind of building grows it's own ecosystem of supporting shops, restaurants, and services. Ideally in the building itself but it usually spills over into the area as well. A lot of attitudes like this become a catch 22 where we can't build dense in an area because it's not ready, but it's not ready because the density is low. Even pro housing folks fall into this trap pretty regularly.
- bifrost 4y agoWon't happen. There is brand new unused retail space across the street. Its been vacant for years.
- jaggederest 4y agoWould it still be vacant if there were 1500 people right out the door?
- bifrost 4y agoAssuming the demo that moves in - probably. It could be a GoPuff/Amazon warehouse though.
- jabbany 4y ago
- runarberg 4y agoWhat is the climate footprint of a tower like this. I was under the impression that skyscrapers didn’t have that positive of an impact even when accounting for the positives of more dense living. Isn’t there an optimum around 5-8 stories, higher than that you’ll start seeing diminishing returns, and after like 20 stories, than the impact starts getting more and more negative?
- peter422 4y agoThis seems very unintuitive to me, what is the reasoning behind this?
- runarberg 4y agoI’m not an architect nor a civil engineer so perhaps I’ve got this completely wrong, but I think it has something to do with both the amount of concrete required, which has a huge climate footprint, as well as the logistics around pluming, cooling, heating, vertical escalation, emergency response, etc. become increasingly difficult as you add more stories. At some point these difficulties add up to make it worse than a 5-8 story mid-rise.
- carabiner 4y ago[flagged]
- latchkey 4y agoJust noting that the space is currently a plant nursery, used to go there a lot when I lived in the area. If this gets developed, they are going to need to figure out much better public transit since it is in the middle of nowhere SF. There is a train line that goes through there, but it is slow AF cause it has so many stops.
- w10-1 4y agoYes, let's build the tallest building on sand about 10' above sea level a couple blocks from the sea, in an era of climate change. Yes, 212 parking spots for 996 people/bedrooms in 722 units will cause no parking problems. Yes, let's do a the largest mega-project of a large and historic residential area next to the shared resources of the ocean and zoo, based on findings from a tiny recently incorporated design company from Nevada run by a few entrepreneurs. Actually, there's one benefit: they are right next to the sewage plant.
- a_t48 4y agoThe lack of parking wouldn't be horrible if it weren't...all the way out in the Sunset. Maybe the mentioned MUNI L renovation would be enough.
- bifrost 4y agoThis is also right on point. Although the sewage plant is not exactly right next to it lol.
- baq 4y agoI hear parking spots in the Manhattan cost a million dollars. SF isn’t New York but gotta start somewhere. No such thing as a car-friendly city.
- bifrost 4y agoSF used to be a very car friendly city, then fauxgressives attempted to ruin it.
- DevKoala 4y agoI want to see this happen just for its ability to shake the status quo.
- resters 4y agoSuch a shakeup is long overdue. Also imagine the westerly views of the west coast sunset and foggy mornings from the skyscraper, or the northerly view of the golden gate and bay, or the easterly view of the city spread out before you. Wow.
- amluto 4y agoSo 712 apartments, 212-car basement garage, and “additional parking will be included for 327 bicycles”. Even right out of college, I would not have purchased or rented a place in SF above ground level with no back yard, no car parking, no bike parking, and no good access to transit. Good luck to the developers, but I think this is a mistake. If they increased it to, say, 1000 bikes worth of parking, maybe.
- bifrost 4y agoIt'll be no bikes worth of parking when the thieves find out where this is.
- amluto 4y agoSecure bike parking underground isn’t that hard. You can have locked doors, gates, and cameras. And possibly even 24/7 attendant coverage. It’s the bikes parked outside that will disappear fast.
- bifrost 4y agoNope, addicts break into buildings routinely and steal bikes from "Secured" parking.
- amluto 4y agoA 712-unit building can afford real security. This is solvable, even if it takes some time, and the developer and the HoA have a strong incentive to solve it.
- bifrost 4y agoIts not solved now in larger buildings in SF. As long as addiction and bicycle theft remains unchecked, having "bike parking" is not viable. Also, Biking to downtown from that area is probably unfeasable for most people. I've been biking here my whole life and even though I live midway on that commute I would never want to do it. I only know ONE single person who ever did it, and he basically did it to make the spandex biker crowd look weak. San Francisco is not and will never be a city that bikers do well in.
- bblpeter 4y ago[flagged]
- conradfr 4y agoThey forgot to cast the shadow in that rendering.
- bifrost 4y agoI should also point out that the newly built building across the way from this spot has had vacant commercial space since it was completed (24+ months). This building simply doesn't belong here and the quicker the YIMBY folks understand what is and isn't a bad idea the better.
- carapace 4y agoNeat! Some thoughts, in no particular order... Make use of the ocean, and the wind. Don't build a building with no good views of the ocean (like that ugly thing[1] opposite the Zoo). Shape it to direct the wind to your wind turbines to generate energy. Figure out what it's going to do to inland wind patterns. All of that "land" is sand. It's faster to get downtown from the East Bay than the Outer Sunset, for both cars and mass transit. How long until the ocean reaches the building? It's already threatening to destroy the Great Highway. Can we build a wall of these running North-South from the Zoo to the Golden Gate Park? Then put a roof over the Sunset District? ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_Man_River%27s_City_project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_Man_River%27s_City_project ) Back-fill housing into a grid or matrix? Like the "stacks" in that movie, but nice? We could house all the homeless people in the entire country just by building out the Sunset and Richmond districts. Turn SF into a vast "recycling center" for people? (I know that sounds weird but I haven't come up with a better metaphor yet. "Redemption"? "Rehabilitation"? help me out here?) To grow enough food and handle the waste we can convert [part of] the Bay into Greenwave-style marine farms. ( https://www.greenwave.org/ https://www.greenwave.org/ ) [1] "The Westerly" @ 3535 Wawona St, San Francisco, CA 94116 https://goo.gl/maps/rREGHXWGy8zCAM7G7 https://goo.gl/maps/rREGHXWGy8zCAM7G7 I'm generally a fan of brutalist architecture but I hate this, it looks hideous to me. I don't like the way it ignores the ocean.
- rightbyte 4y agoSo in an area of quite cute two floor houses they wanna build that? It looks terrible and destroys the neighbourhood. I don't live in SF and have no stake in this what so ever. But there seems to be some smug self-righteousness in wrecking other peoples backyards to house tech yuppies and maybe some token homeless people for flavour. Also, developments like this will raise property values for the local home owners not lower them. There is moneywise no rational reason for local homeowners to oppose this. So I don't buy the greed argument.
- andy-x 4y agoBut will it blend?