3 ms·
Graeber's claim about bullshit jobs can be trivially dismissed. If there were actually many bullshit jobs in some profitable company then eventually a competito
by nradov 4y ago
Graeber's claim about bullshit jobs can be trivially dismissed. If there were actually many bullshit jobs in some profitable company then eventually a competitor with fewer bullshit jobs and thus lower costs would come in and eat their lunch. While middle managers in some organizations do engage in empire building to inflate their own importance, senior executives generally don't hesitate to cut costs by laying off unproductive employees. Their own bonuses and equity values depend on this.
There are certainly some bullshit jobs, especially in the public sector and non-profit space. But they are a tiny minority.
- epilys 4y agoNaïve dismissal. People, businesses, economies are not rational agents. And competitors eat companies' lunches all the time.
- confounded 4y agoAh, famously easy to measure knowledge worker productivity!
- 1123581321 4y agoBullshit Jobs isn’t about people doing nothing all day.
- nradov 4y agoSo what? I never claimed that it was. If anyone wants us to believe that bullshit jobs are common then they need to explain why senior executives who are generally ruthless in conducting layoffs would choose to keep many employees who aren't contributing to profit margins. The number of bullshit jobs is more than zero, but as an economic concept it's just totally implausible on a large scale. This is one of those "just so" stories: it sounds truthy but when you dig in there's little hard data or reproducible experiments.
- 1123581321 4y agoAgain, it’s not about not contributing to the organization. You should read the book.
- lm28469 4y ago> There are certainly some bullshit jobs, especially in the public sector and non-profit space. I don't think you understand the definition of a "public service"