7 ms·
AI Can't Take over Everyone's Jobs Soon (If Ever)
- qwertyuiop_ 4y ago> AI Can't Take Over Everyone's Jobs Soon (If Ever) Luddites - circa 2023
- jamesfeve 4y agoThis is unbelievably ironic considering Luddites literally opposed the advancement and use of new technologies because they believed that it would put them out of business. Those screaming that AI must be stopped or it'll get rid of all of our jobs have far more in common with Luddites, and in fact the quote you're trying to compare to Luddite beliefs is in direct contradiction with them. Just like any technological improvement in all of human history, AI will replace some jobs and open up economic incentive for brand new ones to exist.
- pixl97 4y ago> considering Luddites literally opposed the advancement and use of new technologies because they believed that it would put them out of business. I don't think you really understand the story of the luddites that well. So, lets say I replace your job with AI today, also I replace the job you were going to get after this job with AI. Ok, you need to eat today, and need to pay your bills tomorrow. How exactly are you going to do that. I mean you can start retraining, but that's going to take months to years and you have days before you're kicked to the street. This is what the Luddites experienced. In the US we really have no, to nearly no social safety net. If there are mass layoffs because of AI it will cause deep issues in the employment world as everyone adjusts.
- jamesfeve 4y ago>I don't think you really understand the story of the luddites that well Nothing you said was evidence that I don't understand the story well. You should leave your baseless opinion on my background with the topic out of it or provide evidence that what I said was incorrect. Additionally, nothing else that you said was relevant to my message. I'm not arguing with anyone about "the US social safety net". Calling someone that argues AI won't take your job anytime soon a "Luddite" is the exact opposite of what Luddites were. If I'm wrong, I'm happy to hear more about that.
- convolvatron 4y agoif ai takes over a fraction of the customer service, creative, and white collar jobs - what exactly are we going to be retraining to do?
- nsxwolf 4y agoAnd how do these companies that replaced all their workers make money when no one has any money to buy products or services anymore?
- pixl97 4y agoWell you see, the government will print money and give it to the companies, the companies will buy up assets creating further asset inflation. The government will print more money for austerity and give it to the companies that will then use it to buy up other companies. In the end one large company will own just about everything, and the government won't do anything about it because they 'are too big to fail'. I mean, you could say that's not possible, but watching the markets over the last 15 years should give one pause to realize it's not completely improbable either.
- nsxwolf 4y agoI'm not a smart man. But I just don't see how any kind of economics work at this point. This sounds analogous to the universe eventually reaching the same temperature and pressure everywhere, and no events can occur ever again after that.
- simonh 4y agoYou’re completely missing the point. It was the Luddites that complained automation destroyed their jobs. They were right. People now are complaining AI will take away their jobs. Others disagree with them. Which of these two groups takes the modern role of the Luddites?
- jamesfeve 4y ago>They were right [Citation needed] EDIT: Oh, we're being pedantic (I guess I kicked it off). "They were right", as in a group of individuals lost the employment they had at a particular time, reasonably believed to be a result of automation. Not that these people were unable to find new employment or that the total number of jobs available was reduced.
- simonh 4y agoJust look up any history of the luddites. There are plenty of resources online. I don’t see why I should have to cite sources when I’m pointing out something utterly uncontroversial for anyone knowledgeable on the subject. Many of them were weaving workshop owners who lost their livelihood to automated factories. The transition to automation in the early 19th century was painful. That doesn’t mean I support what they did or think automation was wrong. In the grand scheme of things it was a necessary transition. That doesn’t mean nobody was hurt by it though. EDIT I’m not being pedantic. I just made a statement that was factually correct that I’m surprised I have to defend. You seem to be inferring a whole lot of baggage that just wasn’t there. BTW for context like the articles author I see LLMs as just being another productivity tool. They will become part of our work flows and will have effects similar to those of other productivity tools.
- namaria 4y agoLuddites were conducting industrial action. Their activity correlated strongly with union busting activity by the English elite. It has nothing to do with 'stopping progress' or trying to reverse automation.
- nsxwolf 4y agoSo what do we do then? Should I just stuff a sock in the furnace exhaust tonight?
- DethNinja 4y agoYou can’t do much, unless willing to take extreme actions. Elites will decide whether to kill off rest of the human population or allow them to scrape by via UBI. Though buying couple of commercial GPUs and building your own company via LLM based agents might be an option for some.
- danielmarkbruce 4y ago"Models are still expensive to run, hard to use, and frequently wrong". The quote is true for human workers.
- brink 4y agoOnly to a degree.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoDebatable
- prettyStandard 4y agoBy AI?
- Symmetry 4y agoYes >Prompt: Someone said "Models are still expensive to run, hard to use, and frequently wrong" Does this also apply to human worker? >GPT4: This statement, while referring to AI models, can also apply to human workers in certain contexts. Here's a breakdown of each aspect mentioned: > Expensive to run: Human workers may have higher costs associated with hiring, salaries, benefits, and overhead expenses. However, the costs of human workers can be justified in many cases due to their adaptability, creativity, and ability to learn. > Hard to use: Human workers can be more difficult to manage compared to AI models, due to factors like communication, collaboration, and personal differences. However, humans are capable of adapting to new situations and understanding complex, nuanced scenarios. > Frequently wrong: Humans, like AI models, are not infallible and can make mistakes or errors in judgment. However, humans possess the ability to learn from their mistakes, improve over time, and apply critical thinking to avoid making the same errors in the future. > So, while there are similarities between the statement's implications for AI models and human workers, it is important to remember that both have their unique strengths and weaknesses. The best approach often involves combining the capabilities of AI and human workers to achieve optimal results.
- akssoni 4y ago"AI is expensive" may become invalid in the future when we achieve limitless fusion energy, semiconductors at the atomic level and quantum computers Edit: added quantum computers
- Workaccount2 4y agoThere already are dramatically more efficient models in development, I don't expect GPT4 level models to be relegated purely to server racks for long.
- pixl97 4y agoAlso humans are very expensive too, and in many places starting to become a more limited resource. If we look at a huge number of countries currently, many are at risk of population collapses. Japan being the poster child here. If you want more human brainpower you have to convince humans to breed, then dump a huge amount of resources in to that child for nearly two decades. After that you hope and pray they actually want to work at solving the problems in the world instead of playing online all day with their Waifu Replica. From a historical point of view, computing was expensive and rare, the idea we'd have massive warehouses full of servers connected to a global network was but a dream when I was a child. A single computer (large) computer would have cost as a much as a house and had less power then what you're surfing instagram on in your pocket.
- akssoni 4y agoTrue
- bob1029 4y ago> semiconductors at the atomic level This is definitely being achieved in some respects today. We certainly have the metrology needed to work with this scale now. I would also add quantum computers to your list. I realize the tortured path this idea has gone down, but even non-exponential speedups like Grover's algorithm could have a major impact on the economics of large-scale optimization & search. IBM is releasing a computer this year that allegedly has 16k+ qubit support.
- non- 4y ago> Even researchers can’t keep up with AI innovation So things are improving so fast that researchers can't keep up... and therefore nothing will change? This whole article smells like wishful thinking. You don't need workers to understand how their jobs are being automated, you just need a few experts who can drop in, turn half your payroll (or more) into a redundancy, and then move on to the next project. It becomes way cheaper to start a new business, so the number of jobs for people who know how to use AI increases, but all other job-markets with AI-exposure tighten.
- simonh 4y agoThe article does not argue that nothing will change.
- dllthomas 4y ago> the number of jobs for people who know how to use AI increases Also anything AI adjacent that hasn't been automated (yet?), but I don't see any guarantee of a favorable ratio.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y ago<< You don't need workers to understand how their jobs are being automated, you just need a few experts who can drop in, turn half your payroll (or more) into a redundancy, and then move on to the next project. Someone has to maintain it when experts drive away. I personally foresee something of a clusterfuck based on interactions with vendors and consultants, because that is kinda where it is heading. At some point, someone has to know what they are doing. It can't all be magic blackboxes. Or more accurately, it can..until it breaks.
- lobstrosity420 4y ago> So things are improving so fast that researchers can't keep up... and therefore nothing will change? Maybe you can ask ChatGPT to summarize the article for you, if you don’t have the time to read it.
- ozim 4y agoI think people overestimate rate of change. We have good enough robots to get warehouse workers out of the jobs - it did not happen overnight and is still in progress. I was working on warehouse automation 8 or so years ago robots were already insanely efficient at that time. I switched area to more compliance stuff. Guess what - loads of companies still doing pen and paper. I don’t even know if we had in history such an event where bunch of people would be cut out. It happens gradually anyway.
- Jupe 4y agoInteresting points in the article, but it seems to assume current state of the art will continue as-is, and frankly, shows little to no imagination of what "might be". It reads like the personal computer "ok, so what?" responses from the 80's. The creativity of a large group of people will find new and interesting ways to leverage this technology. We will see more AI-assisted IDEs, debuggers, assistants, document "interpreters" (e.g. converting contracts into litigation, specifications into running code, rough ideas into whole new literary or film worlds), and so much more. And, as far as I can tell, we are terrible at gauging the speed of AI advancement. See [1], [2]. These may be cherry-picked examples, but some of these are orders-of-magnitude off. "Training to use AI will be a job in itself"... until it isn't. Adversarial AIs are probably already in the works to teach these LLMs right from wrong. Such training will take time, for sure, but the next leap is pretty clear in my mind: human obsolescence given our current (at least here in US) sensibilities. I'm not saying new sensibilities won't come, but historically, it has taken a long time for such base-line cultural shifts to take effect. Even after armed conflicts. In my opinion, the question isn't, “[can] we automate away all the jobs, including the fulfilling ones?” The question is, "What will you do when your job becomes redundant?" The best AI researchers may be way off on their predictions here... it could happen in the next 12 months. Thankfully, to some extent, this is just the output of LLMs and predictive analysis. But I'd bet someone is already tweaking a prompt/chat along the lines of "Build me an AGI which can make decisions on its own." [1] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2017/07/how-long-before-a-robot-takes-your-job-here-s-when-ai-experts-think-it-will-happen/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2017/07/how-long-before-a-rob... [2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbestechcouncil/2021/05/06/artificial-intelligence-and-the-future-of-humans/?sh=3d3928b46e3b https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbestechcouncil/2021/05/06/ar...
- boredemployee 4y ago>> The best AI researchers may be way off on their predictions here... it could happen in the next 12 months. I honestly think we are getting there. the world will be a completely different place in 3 years or less (in terms of human activities/work/jobs)
- flavius29663 4y ago> "Training to use AI will be a job in itself"... until it isn't. Adversarial AIs are probably already in the works to teach these LLMs right from wrong. If you have a project that uses 2 AIs to train themselves and nothing else, and a project with 2AIs training themselves, aided by a human team, who will win? I'll place my bet on the human+AI team.
- bugglebeetle 4y agoIn our current high internet rate environment, we’ve already seen perverse incentives around firing workers to juice stock prices. Even if everything is the post is true, I don’t see what’s preventing c-suite’s from doing more of the same with AI. Sure, maybe it will all blow-up in their faces when an unchecked AI engages in wildly irresponsible or illegal behavior, but they’ll just golden parachute away to their next gig replacing people with LLMs.
- doitLP 4y agoWhat you’re describing is the commandment to “follow incentives”. We will adopt it to the hilt no matter who we are because the incentives dictate we must. What governments or people will do when many are out on the street because their job has been made obselete, that’s the real question.
- bugglebeetle 4y agoIn the US, we already have the answer to that in the decline in life expectancy as a result of overdoses, suicide, and interpersonal violence in areas where industry moved overseas. Those “out on the street” will be left to rot.
- falcolas 4y ago"Everyone's Jobs" "Everyone" is doing a lot of implied work here. AI doesn't have to take over everyone's job. Even 10% would have a disastrous impact on our workforce, especially if there are insufficient safety nets. That being said, I feel fairly certain that our economy will come up with (if not outright demand) more Bullshit Jobs† for the workforce to fill to keep all the appropriate graph lines going up. † https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs
- kaba0 4y agoWhat do you think might be such a bullshit job? 100 years ago a whole village had to help with crops, now a single air conditioned combine harvester can do the job (hell, doesn’t even need a driver, it works solely through GPS). We somewhat earned a bit of time with many of the bullshit jobs, but I think that bubble is bursting — we will have to undergo a huge societal change (UBI or something like that), otherwise we will get to Gotham city levels.
- mitchdoogle 4y agoJapan has bullshit parking lot jobs. Imagine if your local CVS had a parking lot attendant to direct you to one of the 30 open spots
- jstarfish 4y ago> What do you think might be such a bullshit job? Babysitter. We'll go from robots supporting humans to humans supporting robots. My Roomba still can't vacuum the house without needing some form of "help" at least three times. Robots can do a lot, but it will probably be cheaper to pay human custodians to manually intervene as needed than to program AI and bots to account for every conceivable failure case in every possible scenario.
- yamtaddle 4y agoI'm with you, I don't see where everyone will go. We've got a few sinks or de facto jobs programs (military; healthcare system, in the US) for "excess" workers, but I don't know how any of those can expand enough to absorb a shock of the sort that LLMs and related tech may soon usher in—especially when those programs or semi-deliberate inefficiencies aren't actually sold as being for that purpose, how much waste will we collectively tolerate? UBI definitely seems like a more-honest approach, and probably healthier all around. [EDIT] Just after posting this I had a mini-nightmare about how LLMs might enable a much, much higher volume of lawsuit activity with the same number of highly-skilled workers, driving an expansion of low-skilled ancillary jobs in that sector, at the cost of an absolutely huge drag on the overall economy and probably increased overall stress, to basically no actual benefit to society. God, chills up and down my spine.
- andrewclunn 4y agoThese are all valid criticisms of AI in its current state, but nobody (and I mean NOBODY) thinks AI is done improving.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- commandlinefan 4y agoEven the low-touch, mind-numbing jobs seem safe. I was at a 7-11 yesterday and I thought about how bored the clerk looked... but there's no way AI could take over the job of "being the human who sits in the store and makes sure nothing gets stolen". The task of physically carrying out the checkout and taking the money is pretty much already automated, but there still has to be a human there, for human-related reasons.
- mitchdoogle 4y agoAmazon has its convenience stores in which you scan your phone at the entry and walk out with whatever you want, it charges you for whatever you take. No human necessary
- meindnoch 4y ago>being the human who sits in the store and makes sure nothing gets stolen Automatic gun turrets?
- notahacker 4y agoNot gonna lie, I'm shopping at the shop without AI powered gun turrets, even if the food costs more...
- dllthomas 4y agoBut it means you don't have to talk to a human...
- simonh 4y agoPut down the can of tomatoes. You have ten seconds to comply.
- commandlinefan 4y ago"I think you'd better do what he says..."
- 4y ago
- yamtaddle 4y agoThey don't have to take jobs completely. Every job these tools make 5x, 10x, 100x more efficient, that'll be fewer workers needed for the same output. Those tasks will be rolled into other jobs (I expect a lot of that—consider how we're all secretaries now), department headcount reduced, whatever. Unless demand also rises tremendously because costs plummet, which it may for some things, but surely won't for all. Everyone's job? Yeah, sure, that's probably some time off or never gonna happen, depending on how things shake out.
- pixl97 4y agoYep, one of the worst possible outcomes of AI currently (skipping the entire AGI kills us thing) is by drastically increasing informational efficiency, hence replacing most of our high paid jobs, while not significantly increasing resource efficiency. You would have a massive decrease in wages while not having deflation in any other metrics.
- freeplay 4y agoThat's when it decides to do some population control.
- andrewclunn 4y agoThis is when things like 4 day work weeks and expanded vacation time via regulation actually make sense. We've become so much more efficient? Reduce the amount of work allowed to achieve full time employment to force the efficiency into more leisure time. Of course, the conundrum there becomes outsourcing and nations being incentivized not to do so to build their economies. We may be trapped in a tragedy of the commons leading us to slavery.
- sitkack 4y agoNone of the required changes will be made in our current corporate kleptocracy. We are going to see massive unemployment that will cripple the economy as a whole. Not the utopia we should have. The pause for me is to figure out the redistribution from the spoils of efficiency.
- user00012-ab 4y ago> This is one of several questions posed by the Future of Life Institute’s recent call for a pause on “giant AI experiments,” which now has over 10,000 signatories including Elon Musk..... In other news, Elon Musk paints over the W in twitter in petty dispute with landlord and changes logo to dodge coin logo. yup all quality people that know what's going on signing that petition.
- user00012-ab 4y agowhere were all these people when corporate America said it was ok to outsource all jobs to other countries?
- notahacker 4y agoWriting think pieces about whether America would have any jobs left by the year 2000...
- simonh 4y agoGiven that the US has record employment levels and huge numbers of unfilled positions, probably they were busy working.
- lordnacho 4y agoLet's take a historical analogy. Here's a cool video about how to make money trading. If you're under 40 you might only have seen this form of trading in the Eddie Murphy/Dan Aykroyd movie Trading Places: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ffEPqLIBnkM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ffEPqLIBnkM There's two kinds of advice in this video. There's the timeless advice: be informed, understand why people are trading, know the rules. There's the incidental advice: be physically dominant, stand in the right place in the pit, look around you. Not long after this talk, trading started getting done by computers. This is still ongoing amazingly, but it started around when this video was recorded. People were already known to be bringing in machines to calculate prices, and a friend of mine was one of the first to type in old commodity prices into a computer in order to find long running trends. Some of the guys who were successful on the floor were also successful "upstairs" sitting in front of a screen. Others went on to driving a black cab. What happened? Two things, one is that fundamentals remain fundamentals. If you knew the rules and understood the customers, you could still make money on a computer. You also had to learn how computers worked. This often meant that new hires were of a different culture entirely to the Essex boys who'd previously ruled the market. My first boss traded options without the equivalent of a high school diploma. He (wisely!) hired an Oxford engineering graduate. What also happened was that a new incidental skill-set became very important, namely programming. Suddenly opportunity opened up if you understood how microwave links worked, how lock-free queues worked, how exchange APIs worked. This was perhaps the equivalent of that story about the Rothschilds and the Battle of Waterloo, where the economic fundamentals were the same but the winner was someone who could organize the mechanics best. I suppose AI will be the same. Various businesses will have their fundamentals, but AI may entirely change the face and the culture according to who can figure out how to use it. Some people will survive having retooled, others will have to leave, having discovered their position was actually only held up by incidental factors.
- falcrist 4y agoThe arguments being made in this article are remarkably poor, and the entire premise is poorly defined. What do you mean by "take over", "everyone", and especially "soon"? If AI changes the world as much as the internet, personal computer, and/or automobile, does it really matter if it takes 6 months or 5 years? That's an extraordinary amount of change over such a period. That's worth the hype. > how, exactly, would AI be used to automate all jobs? Setting aside whether that’s even desirable—is it even possible? Obviously we can't automate literally every job at this time. You're still going to need a human around to feed questions or instructions into the machine and review or test the results, but automation was never going to eliminate all human labor simultaneously. Machinery reduces the number of humans you need. So far, this has always been the case. The printing press doesn't eliminate the need for people working on duplicating books. It means one person can do the work of a whole monastery. Stores still need cashiers to watch the automated checkouts, but now the machines can take care of 4 or 8 people at a time instead of 1. > OpenAI has touted GPT-4’s ability to pass numerous standardized tests—but did the model genuinely understand the tests, or simply train to reproduce the correct answers? It doesn't matter if the machine can think or feel. What matters is the result. > Still, it’s clear that a future in which “we automate away all the jobs, including the fulfilling ones,” is more than six months away, as the Future of Life Institute’s letter frets. Is this supposed to be comforting? I don't think anyone reasonable is under the misapprehension that they're going to be fired and replaced by GPT literally tomorrow. > Open AI’s ChatGPT-3.5 Turbo, for example, prices API access at roughly US $0.002 per 750 English words If you make $80k/yr, you're being paid something on the order of $0.64/min. You'd have to type pretty fast to overcome the two orders of magnitude between those numbers. And this is with current hardware. I know Moore's law isn't holding anymore, but computer hardware is still rapidly accelerating. It's also with the current trajectory of AI development. Nobody can say that won't accelerate. Similarly, nobody can say it won't slow down. We also don't yet know how or if humans will be able to react fast enough to the change on the horizon. Is the herald of a much better world or is it the antecedent to catastrophe. I don't know, and neither does the author of this article.
- akssoni 4y agoIt's refreshing to see an article acknowledging the limitations of AI technology in the workforce, as opposed to sensationalizing the idea of a future where humans are completely replaced by machines. The article highlights valid concerns around the high cost of running AI models, their complexity, and frequent errors, reminding us of the indispensable value of human empathy and emotional intelligence in certain industries.
- afavour 4y agoDismissing the potential of AI is naive but so is the mindless optimism that surrounds it. In a lot of tech circles it’s being treated as an absolute certainty, like when the internet was invented and everyone said the office was dead. The reality was a whole lot more complicated than that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kiviuq 4y agoIt's like saying a war broke out in Ukraine that has taken everyone's lives. Nothing can be done since we can't even figure out what's happening. When jobs are going to be taken, it's not by AI, but by the willful decision of a handful of people. The issue is with those who pocket the benefits and leave the consequences to everyone else. Privatize the benefits, socialize the losses.
- drbig 4y agoI'll risk a top-level comment without reading the article at all, not even clicking, with my first opinion-response: humans are _very cheap_, _mindbogglingly cheap_ if you were born in Cambodia or Gods Forbid a place even worse off (no offense to Cambodians, we're all _born somewhere_). Before I even finished high-school I worked on a factory floor - via a temp agency no less - and was just like "why doesn't the machine also do that too, it's so dumb?". Went to a decent university and... understood. So. Much. Cheaper. Now I'm life-settings further by a bunch and it still bothers me "Machines will free us all to be the best we humans can be!". No. For many reasons though! So yeah, the Żabka / 7-11 employees will be there for a long time to come... ... Page me when Japan declares "no more convenience store human employees".