17 ms·
Master Plan Part 3
- gleenn 4y agoThis is a pretty massive setup, coming in at a capitol cost of 10 Trillion USD.
- schiffern 4y agoOver 20 years. Per Tesla investor day,[0] this compares favorably to ~$14 trillion in investment that would be needed for fossil fuels over that time. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=2013s&v=Hl1zEzVUV7w https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=2013s&v=Hl1zEzVUV7w
- cduzz 4y agoAs a fraction of human endeavor on this planet, rather than using some monetary unit... What was the cost of light and heat in 1850 relative to human output? Whaling and chopping wood and digging up coal, etc. 20%? 30% I'm sure it's been estimated. None of those 1850's assets survived electrification. How many 50 year old infrastructure assets of the coal and natural gas ages are still working fine? Lots of them, I'd wager. $10 Trillion seems like a lot (and oh boy, it is a lot), but that's how the soil gets turned over for the next season's crop. We don't harvest whale oil for lights anymore, though it was the primary source of high quality light in the 1840s. We shouldn't burn oil from the ground to boil water to spin a thing to make electricity 800 miles away from the light today.
- chrisweekly 4y ago> "We don't harvest whale oil for lights anymore, though it was the primary source of high quality light in the 1840s. We shouldn't burn oil from the ground to boil water to spin a thing to make electricity 800 miles away from the light today." Amen! :)
- blake1 4y agoPrimary energy infrastructure planning takes place at a 20-30 year timeframe. GDP for 25 years is nearly $600 trillion USD, so the Master Plan is approximately 1-2% of available resources.
- oezi 4y agoUS GDP * 25 = 600 trillion World GDP * 25 = 2,400 trillion Spending 10 trillion is less than 1% of world GDP over that time.
- LegitShady 4y agothe issue isn't cost rather its risk.
- fundad 4y agoMoney printer goes what?
- amoss 4y agoHow many liquidity injections and financial bailouts we will need over the twenty year timescale in the plan? One advantage of this plan is that it provides a direct liquidity injection and provides demand in several key industries. It goes without saying that an EV company would be a huge beneficiary from some of those funds, but I wonder what the net cost would be if it offsets the need for even some of the trillions being used to glue together the world economy since the events of '08.
- dougmwne 4y agoI think it would be easier to run for president than do something at this scale through private enterprise. Thank goodness he is ineligible.
- doctor_eval 4y agoThis is a terrific set of ideals and I think like many great visions, even if it’s not accomplished directly, it will put wheels into motion that will advance the world in the right direction, and might just help save the environment. I just wish the guy in charge could apply the same systematic thinking to his approach to politics. I fear that the major short term risk to humanity is not the environment, but toxic politics. If renewables are the solution to our energy problems, I like to think kindness and tolerance might be the solution to our political problems. Perhaps he could publish a master plan for that, too.
- logicchains 4y ago[flagged]
- soperj 4y ago34% of people identify as independents, more than the 29% that identify as Republican or the 29% that identify as Democrats.
- natch 4y agook so roughly two thirds of the population, not half, reinforcing the point with your correction. I hope that was what you intended.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> the coordinated censorship of the political views of half the population Tell me again which news network is the largest?
- systemvoltage 4y agoSee Twitter files. OP is right.
- systemvoltage 4y agoHere is a better view of the hegemony of the left across the board: https://twitter.com/loganclarkhall/status/1644157299244642304 https://twitter.com/loganclarkhall/status/164415729924464230... It's completely lopsided.
- nothrowaways 4y agoGlad that master plan does not include mars :)
- NovaDudely 4y agoI get were you are coming from but that would be SpaceX not Tesla. ;)
- Diederich 4y agoWhy would Tesla be talking about Mars?
- la64710 4y agoWhat worries me is lack of concrete plans built into the master plan for recycling. The only mention I found was “ In the 2040’s, recycling will begin to meaningfully reduce primary material demand as batteries, solar panels and wind turbines reach end-of-life and valuable materials are recycled. Although mining demand will decrease, refining capacity will not.”. There needs to be an integrated plan to not only prevent industrial by product pollution but reduce it over the years.
- mjamesaustin 4y agoTesla is already recycling 92% of its battery cell materials, but the low volume is mainly because people are not turning in their batteries for recycling yet. As the EV fleet ages, this number will steadily increase. https://electrek.co/2022/05/09/tesla-increase-battery-recycling-capacity-battery-packs/ https://electrek.co/2022/05/09/tesla-increase-battery-recycl... This master plan has a section dedicated to the estimated curve of material demand based upon recycling. It shows a large initial increase followed by a leveling off and then eventual dramatic decrease, as a result of battery retirement and recycling.
- elif 4y agoI dunno my old chemistry 2012 leaf battery is still going strong at about 80% capacity. It hasn't seemed to budge a km in the last 5 years.
- mlindner 4y agoThere's already several cash flow positive companies doing lithium ion battery recycling. You need to keep in mind though, that recycling, at this point, recycles mainly batteries from smaller products, hybrids or very very early EVs (or EVs that were totaled). There are almost zero EVs that are at end of life at this point. Tesla doesn't need to be getting into battery recycling if there's already companies doing it and are competing for that revenue source. I believe Tesla already works with such battery recycling companies who buy up Tesla's old batteries. It's not Tesla doing it, which is why they don't make big mention of it.
- alfor 4y ago
- skybrian 4y agoTo set expectations, this report seems to be about worldwide energy trends, not about anything specific that Tesla is planning to do.
- brandonagr2 4y agoTesla's mission is literally to accelerate the transition to a sustainable energy economy. Tesla will execute on this plan but they obviously can't do it alone.
- schiffern 4y agoOr to put it in Musk's own words[0]: "This is really the main message of today. And I really wanted today to be not just about Tesla investors who own stock, but really anyone who is an investor in Earth. "What we're trying to convey is a message of hope and optimism. And optimism that is based on actual physics and real calculations, not wishful thinking. Earth can and will move to a sustainable energy economy, and will do so in your lifetime." [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=2362s&v=Hl1zEzVUV7w https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=2362s&v=Hl1zEzVUV7w
- xracy 4y agoThe tv show Ted Lasso introduced me the phrase: "It's the hope that kills you." And in the show they rag on it, because people take it to mean "be hopeless". While I would never want people to be hopeless, I think that it is irresponsible to be hopeful without much more concrete plans to actually get things moving. Climate Change is a tragedy of the commons, and nothing that Elon is working on fixes that. It still needs action as a tragedy of the commons, and Elon (and Tesla) can't fix that. We need other actions, and it's not enough for people to sit by and do nothing. It's not even enough to buy an electric car. We need people to change the ways in which they consume, and more than that we need them to vote to force companies to change the ways in which companies consume.
- schiffern 4y ago>it is irresponsible to be hopeful without much more concrete plans to actually get things moving. Is there a specific criticism of the numbers given in the paper?
- wpietri 4y agoAm I missing something here? This seems to be a white paper with a vision of a global energy future. But it is not what I'd call a plan in any usual sense of that term, especially not a plan for one of the many companies that would be working to fulfill the vision.
- fwlr 4y agoIt is certainly a departure from the previous master plans, which were informal blog posts by Elon describing Tesla’s future plans. Maybe this is the formal groundwork for another such informal blog post, and it just happens to share the same title. Or maybe “informal blog post” was the effective medium for Tesla’s previous target audience (consumers) and “formal whitepaper” is the effective medium for a different target audience (government policy-makers?) and this indicates a change or expansion in Tesla’s target audience. I know that the US is putting out a “total electrification via renewable power” vision, perhaps this is Tesla positioning itself to be a critical supplier of that vision.
- SECProto 4y ago> Maybe this is the formal groundwork for another such informal blog post, and it just happens to share the same title. Close - this is the detailed background behind the plan as presented a month ago. From the executive summary (page 2): > On March 1, 2023, Tesla presented Master Plan Part 3 – a proposed path to reach a sustainable global energy economy through end-use electrification and sustainable electricity generation and storage. This paper outlines the assumptions, sources and calculations behind that proposal. Input and conversation are welcome.
- IAmGraydon 4y agoIt's a quick attempt to make their stock stop falling.
- xiphias2 4y agoI wish electric car manufacturers would focus on serving taxis / Ubers first, as maintainence is the cheap part of electric vehicles in theory, and those cars would have a huge immediate impact. I remember in Europe a taxi company wanted to switch to 100% Tesla, but service times were too bad, because Tesla is focusing more on selling cars than servicing them in guaranteed timelines, even though both can make profit for Tesla.
- paxys 4y agoCosts have to come down a lot more before that can happen.
- gigel82 4y agoEVs are a bad choice for a high-use vehicle like taxis / ubers. You'd need to recharge every 30 - 40 trips; in an ICE, that's 2 minutes at the pump - in an EV that's an hour of time you're not making an income.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoFor taxis that operate from taxi stands, that shouldn't be a problem. Even if the individual breaks are short, you only need to recharge one trip. According to a Uber driver I asked about this, it's not a major problem for them either: The battery comfortably lasts half a day, and after that, it's lunch time anyways. Or, using your numbers, you'd need to recharge after 5 hours of 6-8 trips per hour. Looking at EV ranges, ranges inside cities are higher (unlike with ICE cars). Combine with lower speeds (i.e. more hours per mile) and more frequent stops, and it means a lot of "range" in terms of hours between recharges.
- yazaddaruvala 4y agoHaving ridden in multiple Tesla Ubers: The drivers are consistently upset they hadn't switched sooner. What they tell me: - They love the charging breaks at malls, etc where they can also take a deserved 20 min break. - They love the entertainment between rides. - They love the heat/cold remains on even when not driving - without "running the engine". - They love not needing to use their brakes. Saving them money. - They love that there are no fanbelts that can break, no oil needing to be changed, etc. Saving them money. - One of them told me it is paying itself off 3 times faster than he had calculated because of the additional savings from maintenance.
- mmcconnell1618 4y agoWhat is under the sheets on page 23 of the PDF? The first vehicle under the 300M looks like it has a flat roofline like an SUV or RoboTaxi. The second vehicle under the 700M looks more like a sedan. https://www.tesla.com/ns_videos/Tesla-Master-Plan-Part-3.pdf https://www.tesla.com/ns_videos/Tesla-Master-Plan-Part-3.pdf
- LegitShady 4y agocargo van/minibus and/or minvan for families.
- geerlingguy 4y agoRight now the only minivan that's even remotely electric is the PHEV Chrysler Pacifica, and it only gets a few dozen miles on battery only. As a father of 4, I'd welcome any newcomer in the minivan space. Most people don't realize that a minivan is better than a truck, SUV, or crossover for the blend of efficiency, people-moving, luxuries, and cargo capacity for anyone with more than a kid or two!
- aeontech 4y agoDoes the Volkswagen ID.Buzz count? Or not yet, since it's still upcoming?
- xnzakg 4y agoStill upcoming? Have seen several of them on the roads here in Norway
- fwlr 4y agoFirst principle analysis strongly suggests Tesla is definitely working on minivan/peoplemovers and cargo vans. In terms of broad clusters of vehicle types, you have: Personal vehicles: sports cars, small sedans, large sedans, and SUVs. Tesla has 5 offerings in this category (S, 3, X, Y, Roadster). Utility vehicles: pickups, utes, trucks. Tesla has one forthcoming offering in this category (Cybertruck). Heavy transport: Semitrailers, 18 wheelers, freight haulers, road trains. Tesla has one forthcoming offering in this category (Semi). Light transport: Minivans, peoplemovers, cargo vans, “Maxi Taxis”, mailtrucks/delivery vans. Tesla has no forthcoming offering in this category as of yet. All of their previous offerings synergize well with development of this category, and the advantages of Tesla-style electric vehicles have a lot of comparative advantage in this category.
- sfblah 4y agoWould the plan be more or less effective if instead of focusing on electric-only vehicles governments had only subsidized plug-in electric vehicles with, say, an electric-only range of the 90th percentile commute in America? I ask because I have the general impression that we are installing 150Kwh batteries in cars when we probably could instead use 25Kwh batteries while still massively reducing carbon emissions. Also I have the impression that Tesla chronically understates the carbon intensiveness of building lithium ion batteries. I'm not actually arguing for or against the plan detailed here. I'm interested in any further reading materials to help my understanding of the choice between plug-in hybrids and full electrics and why the current (largely political) choices have been made.
- coderintherye 4y agoPeople want extended driving range, irrespective of whether or not they need that range. Just as some people want bigger trucks/SUVs even if there is not a true need for such. Success is built on selling people what they want.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoIndeed. People wanted sexy electric cars, not a plug in Prius. Go where the volume and margin is.
- foogazi 4y agoIt’s about convenience You can fill up on gas at any street corner in minutes
- toomuchtodo 4y agoI fill up at my house overnight (In the United States, the majority of housing units are single-family houses – about 82 million out of the total 129 million occupied units in 2021 [1]), or at my grocery store in 20 min while shopping (250kw Supercharger). This is very convenient! I have a CCS adapter if I need to use an Electrify America station but have yet to use it. In ~100k miles of US cross country traveling over the last five years, the only place I could not charge fast was middle of nowhere southeast Missouri, and there is a Supercharger there now [2] [3]. The city did let me plug into a dryer outlet to charge for free at the time, thank you Cape Girardeau! My gym has a free destination charger, as does my local brewery and airport parking. I no longer carry a 100ft 120V extension cord in my frunk, which I had to do in 2018. Yes, we still have much to do to expand EV charging infra, but it’s not an unknown, it’s just more work. Street parking? Street charging [4]. Renters? Mandated EV charging spot quotas with funding for the infra. Workplace charging is important as well. You can even install EV chargers directly on electric poles and tap into the above power lines [5]. Where there is power, there is EV fuel, and what chargers you install where will be the intersection of dwell time and current needed. [1] https://www.statista.com/topics/5144/single-family-homes-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/topics/5144/single-family-homes-in-... [2] https://supercharge.info/map https://supercharge.info/map [3] https://www.plugshare.com/ https://www.plugshare.com/ [4] https://electrek.co/2019/11/13/la-adds-hundreds-of-ev-chargers-to-streetlights-giving-renters-a-place-to-plug-in/ https://electrek.co/2019/11/13/la-adds-hundreds-of-ev-charge... [5] https://www.nationalgridus.com/News/National-Grid-Deploys-Innovative-EV-Chargers-in-Melrose,-MA/ https://www.nationalgridus.com/News/National-Grid-Deploys-In...
- tmaly 4y agofor 10T, this is a deal for what it gives to us and the world. I am curious how we would deal with heavy machinery and airplanes in an electric world.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoThe current idea is to use ammonia to fuel container ships. Perhaps that could work with the largest heavy land equipment.
- gdsdfe 4y agoIt's funny reading this during what is now over a 5 hours power outage
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoFor anyone thinking 10% of GDP is crazy, like I initially thought: 1. It's 10% of one year's GDP, i.e. e.g. 1% of GDP for 10 years. 2. NATO standards for defense spending are 2% of GDP. Assuming it really is that cheap, cost is not a blocker.
- somsak2 4y agomajority of nato doesn't even meet their own standard though.
- ben_w 4y agoGiven that, I think the better comparison is how much the world spends on fossil fuels. I'm not sure what the latter number is, as I've heard claims that fossil fuels are subsided by anywhere from $1 to $5.9 trillion per year.
- tim333 4y agoThe report argues for spending that over 20 years and that it would be cheaper than the alternative of investing in fossil fuels. (https://www.tesla.com/ns_videos/Tesla-Master-Plan-Part-3.pdf https://www.tesla.com/ns_videos/Tesla-Master-Plan-Part-3.pdf p26)
- pdonis 4y agoThis is about what I'd expect from someone who makes money selling electric vehicles. I wonder what it would look like if Musk had chosen to start a company for making small, safe nuclear reactors.
- bjelkeman-again 4y agohttps://www.energymonitor.ai/sectors/power/small-modular-reactors-smrs-what-is-taking-so-long/ https://www.energymonitor.ai/sectors/power/small-modular-rea... Seems to me that SMR is far of commercially.
- Geee 4y agoI wonder why they don't see small modular nuclear reactors as a part of the solution. Also, they mention iron-air chemistry for batteries, but don't consider them in the calculations. Their approach seems to be pragmatic; utilizing and mega-scaling tech that is available right now.
- MrBuddyCasino 4y agoYes nuclear was notably missing. Also the „Li-ion (4h-8h)“ range for storage is doing a lot of work. You can’t operate a grid with intermittent energy production on a 4h buffer, 8h I‘m not sure. Unless they include nuclear I‘m assuming this compares unfavorably.
- nl 4y ago> You can’t operate a grid with intermittent energy production on a 4h buffer, With good electricity transmission you can. Infact, in this plan they specifically model this, and it comes out that by overbuilding solar/wind 32% you are fine. > here is an economic tradeoff between building excess renewable generation capacity, building grid storage, or expanding transmission capability. That tradeoff may evolve as grid storage technologies mature, but with the assumptions modeled, the optimal generation and storage portfolio resulted in 32% curtailment and the footnote: > Currently, the transmission capacity is <1% of the combined regional peak loads (with transmission to/from Texas the lowest). Higher transmission capacities generally reduce the total generation and storage buildout, but there is an economic tradeoff between building more transmission and building more generation plus storage.
- MrBuddyCasino 4y agoAm I misunderstanding this or does this make the whole grid a lot more vulnerable? The internet was once designed to be resilient, economic forces have made it centralized in large network exchanges and thus vulnerable. We did the same with our supply chains, and it backfired so badly during covid that we're still not fully recovered. Should we do the same with our electricity supply?
- oh_sigh 4y agoIf you're going to show a map of area used by X, then choose an equal area projection!
- elif 4y agoI would have ordinarily considered this a pipe dream but I kind of stumbled into a personal break from fossil fuels last month. Due to the tax incentives, I have been expanding my solar array by investing about 10k every year, and I added a powerwall to distribute the energy better. The result is that last month my electricity bill was $38, despite being an all-EV household that grows 36 food plants hydroponically. I also coincidentally cancelled my gas bill the same month as I replaced the final gas appliance in my house with a really efficient Japanese electric oven. I'm not fully net zero, but considering I wasn't even considering net zero, let alone trying for it, I have to say it's startling how easy it was compared to the impression I get from talking heads and Twitter warriors. Considering people spend 10-20k per year on hobbies and I've only been at it for 3 years, i would highly recommend the hobby of self sufficiency.
- ragebol 4y agoIt's an addictive hobby. We ordered a hybrid heat pump in March '22 and it was finally installed last week. It's 6 degrees C out here out and this thing is chugging along steadily. It's quiet too. Also adding more insulation as we speak (guys stomping over my WFH office roof now), so as these things happened to get installed in the same months, it's been an expensive month, with about €20k invested, before subsidies. But already thinking about what to do next. Expand the current set of 12 solar panels (has to happen eventually. Our home is about 200 square meter with mostly flat roof, so ideal for adding lots of solar myself), get a heat pump boiler for hot water for showers etc, better windows in some places, etc. Also got a dynamic energy tariff, busy setting up Home Assistant. I have a huge spreadsheet with potential measures, their potentials savings and estimated cost, iPython notebooks with temperature and energy usage graphs, comparison of a dozen heat pumps. Yep, addictive.
- leehuffman 4y agoWho spends $10k - $20k annually on hobbies?! I think the HN demographic of heavy six figure annual earnings has, uhm, lost sight of being an outlier and what’s ‘normal’ for the _vast_ majority of the population.
- 4y ago
- robomartin 4y agoIt is remarkable to me that on HN (a tech discussion forum?) the top comment on this thread is about politics. Sign of the times, I guess. I look at papers like this and predictions with great interest. Several years ago I wrote a simulation model to try to understand energy requirements for a full transition to electric ground transportation in the US. I learned a few things through this exercise. The first was that speaking of energy was wrong. Charging vehicles is a power problem. Second, predicted a need for an additional 900 GW to 1400 GW. Again, just cars, nothing else electrified. Over the years I've had confirmation of this range being within what I would call a reasonable prediction. It is interesting to see Master Plan Part 3 (MPP3) continue to confirm I wasn't too far off. I have also modified my stance over time about what this meant. In simple terms, this prediction would be equivalent to having to build over a thousand new 1 GW nuclear power plants. This is never going to happen. I doubt we can (or want to) even build a hundred of them. MPP3 assumes we build zero additional nuclear. Not sure I agree with this idea. However, it isn't a deal-breaker. After reading this paper a while back I developed the thought that wind might just be a far more intelligent source of clean power than nuclear (definitely) and likely solar. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26355-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26355-z Table 6 (page 20) is interesting to me. We have to build a 5,338 GW (again, power) generation capacity in order to reliably produce the energy we will need. Our current capacity is 1,200 GW. This highlights the enormity of the project. We have to replace the current generation systems with clean systems and build an additional 4,138 GW on top of that. That is over three times current capacity on top of what we have. Again, just highlighting the enormity of the task so it doesn't get lost in the numbers. When looking at table 6 I immediately focused on what I will call the "specific energy generation factor" for each technology. I'll define this as Annual Generation / Installed Capacity. In other words: How much energy do we get per year for each GW of installed capacity for each technology. Here are the numbers (based on table 6): Onshore Wind: 3.07 TWh/GW Offshore Wind: 3.31 TWh/GW Solar PV: 1.33 TWh/GW Nuclear: 7.06 TWh/GW Hydro: 4.07 TWh/GW Once we look at installation cost solar and onshore wind are very similar. Yes, table 5 shows a difference in operating and maintenance costs. I'll take their word for it. My sense is these costs would decrease, perhaps significantly, through the natural optimization that happens as a technology is deployed and matures. My point is that, to me, wind seems like a far better idea that solar on many fronts. It is far more reliable on its own. Without going too far, solar is off approximately 50% of the time and requires 100% reliable backup even if a nice fluffy white cloud flies over a panel. Wind requires far less overbuild and somewhere in the order of a factor of four less storage to be over 95% reliable. Jumping to table 14, we discover how much land is required for each technology: Solar: 3.9 acres/MW or 3900 acres/GW Wind: 0.75 acres/MW or 750 acres/GW Wind requires 5.2 times less land. Going back to table 6, solar and onshore wind combined contribute 10,106 TWh. How many GW of installed capacity would be required to supply that much energy if all of it came from a single technology? Solar: 7,598 GW Wind: 3,292 GW How much land? Solar: 29,632,200 acres = 12 times the area of Hawaii (all islands) Wind: 2,469,000 acres = 1 time the area of Hawaii Anther comparison of land requirements: Solar: 30% of California Wind: 2.5% of California I am not categorically stating that wind is a better option. I am simply raising the question. To me it seems that solar might not be the best idea. It requires far more land, storage and overbuilding. The cost is about the same. And, apropos to the crazy times we navigate today, a massive proportion of the supply chain for solar is in China. NOTE: Sad that I have to make this request. Another sign of the times. It's OK to disagree with with me. If you do, please use numbers, not insults. There's just too much of that crap going around these days. I actively want to know where I might be wrong. That only happens in the context of a conversation, not by throwing fecal matter at each other. Oh, yes, and it is also OK to ask questions. For example "How did you calculate...?" or "Why do you think ... is more important than ...?", etc. Again, sad that I feel it is important to explain how to disagree and have a conversation these days. PS.: Hope I didn't make any dumb errors in the math. Please let me know.
- whatever1 4y agoReminds me of the energy outlooks of the different oil companies that were predicting up until mid 2010's that gasoline demand will always go up and more investment in deep water exploration was warranted. Then they came across electric cars and fracking. Nobody has a clue about the energy landscape in 20 years. They are just painting the canvas the way they want to sell it to their investors.
- xracy 4y agoI get that this seems to be tesla fan-boy central... And that for some reason trains are a dirty word for Elon... > Class 8 Truck 5.3 MPG (diesel) 22 MPGe (1.7 kWh.mi) f 4.2X But if I look at these numbers, they're missing the point. For one thing, how much can the theoretical tesla semi actually haul? Cause the gold standard in this space isn't a truck that gets 10 ton-miles per gallon. It's a train that gets 492 ton-miles per gallon (Note, everywhere I look for freight is using this other metric, which makes me think that this number is real bad for Tesla...) Trains have the additional possibility of actually being pretty readily electrifiable in a way that doesn't require a battery (potentially a large weight-add for trucks). Lastly Trains can cover a lot of middle/long distance trips that are currently being offloaded to planes. This solution would save on the total energy requirement for not-overseas-flights.
- mlindner 4y agoFYI, using "fan-boy" is kind of frowned upon on hacker news. However as someone who commonly agrees with Elon on many things, I do think trains are a good idea, but you can't look at them in a vacuum. The train network of the late 19th century is long gone in the US and many of those right-of-ways are long gone. There's no way to re-integrate a train network into the wider US without a lot of forcing people out of their houses. Using electric semis is the next best option. Trains definitely have a future in the US, but not as a massive fix-all.
- xracy 4y ago> FYI, using "fan-boy" is kind of frowned upon on hacker news. Why? It's not derogatory. What word would you have me use in place of it? There are a bunch of people speaking very highly of Elon for what is not a very interesting/ground-breaking paper, if I'm being honest. An impromptu Google search turned up a .gov website with a lot of the stuff in here[1]... I suspect the rest of it is also googleable (Grid setup, and per-grid usage, cost per watt, MPG, Dollar per kW). They made some cool infographics... But mostly this is a very thinly veiled sales pitch for Tesla products, wrapped in the beginnings of a case for more gov't funding. re: rail network You could readily cannibalize a lot of our highway system, as well as invest in fixing up the rail that we already have. Companies that have been making money off of rail should start paying for that infrastructure, in particular... [1] https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/us-energy-facts/data-and-statistics.php https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/us-energy-facts/data-and...
- d_burfoot 4y agoMost of the conversation about electric conversion relates to climate. But a huge additional benefit will be improved human respiratory health. Our current strategy of burning fuels at point of use - cooking, heating, ICE cars - means that the exhaust goes directly into the populated spaces where most people live!
- yencabulator 4y agoExtracting oil & natural gas also leaks a stupid amount of methane etc, that floats around for people living there to breathe.
- lazide 4y agoIf heating exhaust (or ICE exhaust) goes into spaces the users breathe, the users will be dead pretty quick. As in minutes, hours at most. Combustion heaters for occupied spaces use heat exchangers to make sure that doesn’t happen. Occasionally one cracks or fails and people die from the carbon monoxide poisoning. ICE cars pipe exhaust away from the passenger compartments. Occasionally someone kills themselves by running their car in their garage. Cooking, folks need to use fume hoods anyway, as smoke, oil fumes, etc. make massive amounts of air pollution and are unavoidable even with electric with most styles of cooking. Natural gas or propane stovetops if functioning properly only add a moderate amount of pollution, and little/no carbon monoxide. That said, most of the exhaust fans/fume hoods hoods in most houses or apartments do nearly nothing except make noise. So yeah. Open windows.
- dmonitor 4y agoThe universe does not end at a car’s tailpipe. That exhaust stays in the city. Eventually it dissipates into the atmosphere, but a constant stream of car exhaust is going to change the air quality.
- lazide 4y agoIt’s disingenuous however to say they are even close to the same magnitude of impact, or that those impacts are in any meaningful way reduced by the conversion of one’s own usage.
- twoquestions 4y agoI just hope bits of this plan can actually do useful work, I admit I don't know enough about energy to comment intelligently. What I'm really afraid of is Elon torpedoing this because one of his new friends told him it'd 'own the libs' or some other fit of pique. I hope it moves the needle in a positive direction.
- aaa_aaa 4y agoWhy no mention of the elephant in the room AKA Nuclear energy?
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIt mentions it, no new nuclear plants would be built under this plan, just existing ones run till they age out. 700 TWh of production per year from 100GW of capacity.
- Kon5ole 4y agoMy guess is that they thought deeply about it and discovered that it’s a very bad idea.
- diamondfist25 4y agoWhy all the hate for musk? He was beloved just a few years ago
- kayge 4y agoCan't say I "hate" him myself, but I've been losing respect for him at a pretty constant rate over the last few years. Quite a few references to his recent bizarre online behavior discussed (and occasionally defended) here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35055839 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35055839
- alfor 4y ago1- Media machine 2- He took position against the left mass censorship and narrative
- alfor 4y agoMuch better a imperfect plan than no plan. I hope it will help the industry/government to push things faster. It seem to me there is a huge problem of incentives at the moment: the price of electricity is mostly constant (in most place) but the production is not. In particular EV could help a lot to stabilize the grid and use excess renewable energy.
- roeles 4y agoAs a European, I miss any mention of rail transport.