12 ms·
“Inside-out Wankel” rotary engine delivers 5X the power of a diesel
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- debacle 4y agoMy understanding is that everyone acknowledges that rotary engines are great, bt in comparison to piston based engines they have far shorter longevity.
- tudorw 4y agoI understand this too, however, the technology might be worth revisiting with modern techniques, I understand the power output is 'smoother', which can reduce vibration, some applications might need that?
- brodouevencode 4y agoNearly all engines need some level of vibration reduction if anything just to prevent it from damaging itself.
- djaychela 4y agoThey also have issues meeting emissions targets - both because of the basic design (there isn't the ability to actively control valve timing events), and also because they typically need some sort of lubrication for the combustion chamber. They are similar to two-stroke engines in these respects.
- skullone 4y agoRunning them at a pre-determined RPM constantly can resolve lack of VVT, but that limits their applications. New materials for apex seals being researched could alleviate their longevity issues too. But, I have a big soft spot for rotaries and would love to see them applied more :(
- manarth 4y agoWhilst also being worse-performing? Take a two-stroke Moster 185 engine: 25 HP at 7.800 RPM, for a 15kg package. I'd be keen to understand how (if) this outperforms a typical two-stroke.
- djaychela 4y agoI think it's difficult to make a direct comparison because of the way the capacity of the engines is calculated. I know it's "fair" from one point of view, but it's not from another (depending on which team you support). The only straight-ish comparison I can think of is the Suzuki RE5 vs the GT500, which are same-era motorbikes from the same manufacturer, with roughly the same capacity. The RE5 wins on horsepower (62 vs 44), but weighs about 50kg more.
- Supermancho 4y agoMy near-mint condition 2009 Mazda RX-8 never had a Wankel engine problem (over 100k miles). It would have easily lasted another 5 years without a doubt or hiccup. Wankels are usually excluded from all engine comparisons, because it's a considered a different class...for piston engine marketing reasons. I sold off my RX8 in 2018 because my fiancee and I moved to Seattle (passing emissions testing wasn't anything special). We needed the money and we had her car, which was more functional. I do miss it.
- mywittyname 4y agoMore antic-data: i worked with a guy whose brand new RX-8 needed two engines in the time we worked together. Granted, his was a 04 automatic, which is the worst combo. But still, Mazda didn't go out of their way to extend the engine warranties on the early RX-8s for no reason. Did you happen to have an 08+ model with the updated engine and/or remove teh catalytic converter?
- Supermancho 4y agoYes, the model was 2009 automatic (updated my initial post for clarity). No, I did not remove the converter.
- nogridbag 4y agoMy RX-8 needed a new engine at 50k miles. As you likely know, if you start and stop an RX-8 engine without allowing it to warmup you risk flooding the engine. In my case, I was taking a trip with my family and my RX-8 was blocking the driveway. We were running late for the flight, so I pulled it out, parked it back in the driveway, and let it idle there for 30 seconds knowing I'm not supposed to shut it down so quickly. But I had people waiting for me and what am I supposed to do, say "Sorry I own a strange car and I need to drive around the block for a bit to let it warm up!". Of course that flooded the engine, but I didn't know until I got back from the trip. I followed all the instructions to de-flood the engine but it wasn't working for me so I had it towed to Mazda where they probably screwed it up further. It was there 2 weeks before they told me the engine needed to be replaced. They eventually had to fly an engineer from Japan to replace the engine since the dealer apparently had no one capable of dealing with rotaries. I think my car was at the dealer for a good 2 months. Thankfully all covered by warranty.
- msandford 4y agoThe folks in the article seem to have figured some of the longevity problems out.
- jandrese 4y agoThat's what they claim, but since this engine isn't in general use yet it's impossible to verify. In the past "supercharged" and "Wankel" have been a combo prone to maintenance issues.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoThey're not great, at all. They have very few moving parts and they are very smooth because there are no reciprocating parts. Other than that, they have emissions like 2-stroke engines because of the incomplete combustion and we have never been able to devise any kind of material to make the apex and side seals last anything like as long as piston rings. Piston engines are a terrible way to power vehicles, but everything else we've tried is worse.
- himinlomax 4y agoWankel engines are great in one respect, power density. But they have terrible reliability and fuel efficiency. Turbine engines also have great power density and terrible fuel efficiency, but they are very reliable. Diesel engines are reliable and fuel efficient but heavy. This one appears to have improved reliability and fuel efficiency over the Wankel without sacrificing power density.
- jabl 4y agoLarge turbines running at close to rated power actually have pretty good efficiency. Turbines are bad at scaling down to smaller sizes due to e.g. boundary layer friction, and also part load efficiency is poor. Recuperators help somewhat, though still not nearly as good as a piston engine.
- projct 4y agoLiquidPiston addressed both of those issues.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoMazda addressed both of those issues, Rotax addressed both of those issues, Norton addressed both of those issues, NSU addressed both of those issues, Comotor addressed both of those issues... The issues remain fundamental, and largely unaddressed.
- busterarm 4y agoMy '88 RX-7's engine went 120k miles before I decided to rebuild it and it still probably had a good 30k miles before it would have 'gone'. This is completely normal through the 70s and 80s when these engines were popular. We didn't start getting million-miler cars until the Lexus LS400 came out. The problem with the rotary is heat and the damage it does to other components. The RX-8's engine design was actually bad and doesn't adequately lubricate, but that gets 'fixed' in the last three model years. The biggest reason that RX-7 owners have seal failures are often due to adding on too much power without adequately upgrading the fuel system. Keep in mind that Wankel engines are absurdly popular in the world of amateur aviation without any of the stigma.
- rascul 4y agoSome years past, a friend who worked for Mazda explained to me that the engines need to be driven for a bit because until they're warmed up fully there can be a lot of carbon buildup and it needs to be run some amount of time to get the carbon through. Once they're warmed up and running for a bit they're fine. Supposedly it's the short trips of only a few miles that can kill them over time. Not sure if that's correct.
- Enginerrrd 4y agoYeah I talked to some race mechanics that said the mazda rotary engines had much better longevity if you really drove the piss out of them. They liked to rev high and hard, which would be basically consistent with that notion.
- devnullbrain 4y agoIf we lived in a world of rotaries and BMW came out with the S85 we'd say that piston engines were emotive and fun but too unreliable for mainstream use. When we refer to rotary engines we mostly talk about two generations of one engine from one manufacturer used in sports cars that were designed before emissions targets changed.
- ww520 4y agoThe problem with rotary engine is that its max power efficiency is at a very narrow rpm range and loses power at most other rpm ranges. This is due to the constant air intake inherent in the design. Piston engine has variable valve air intake to ensure optimal air oil mixture compression to deliver max power efficiency at a long range of rpm’s. That’s why rotary design is not popular for cars. Mazda is reviving small single cylinder rotary engine design for HEV by running it at a constant speed with max power efficiency to charge the battery.
- mywittyname 4y agoA non-turbo diesel is an interesting choice of competitor. The big selling point of the Kohler motor is that it's almost silent - even the valve train is belt-driven to reduce noise. Not sure a rotary engine screaming at 6500RPM is comparable here to a diesel with a peak torque at 2000 and peak power at 3600. > LiquidPiston has been working on these X-engines for nearly 20 years now, I'm guessing they will never actually release a commercially viable product. 20 years to design an ICE is...too much.
- Zak 4y agoThe specific version described in the article appears to be a Diesel rotary that runs on jet fuel with military UAVs as a primary application.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoI think a lot of commenters in articles like this will only think about automotive as a use case for alternative engine designs. I'm reminded of a linear piston engine (iirc two pistons that just go back and forth without their motion being translated into rotation; one where they were side-by-side moving alternately, the other one where they'd actually move towards each other and share a combustion chamber). The use case for that was to have the pistons move through coils, thus generating electricity. We used to have a flashlight that works with the same principle, shake it to generate electricity.
- themaninthedark 4y agoMy first thought went to cargo ships. They require huge motors, so I imagine that if you can keep or gain performance while reducing size they would be very interested.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agothis is backwards. the reason cargo ship engines are big is because they don't care about size. they would rather have a 2x bigger engine that was 1% more efficient
- BWStearns 4y agoSounds like it could be awesome for some GA applications given the lack of weight budget and it seems like they did solve the issues with rotaries. Hopefully someone starts cramming them in some experimentals!
- stametseater 4y agoGeneral aviation are perhaps the most cautious and wary ICE users around. Most of the engines used in GA, Lycomings and Continentals, are essentially 1960s designs with very well known cost, performance and reliability characteristics. That is not to say change is impossible, GA's overdue changeover to unleaded gasoline seems like an inevitability. Unleaded gas is already being approved for many of these engines, like new production O-360 engines (which date back to the 1950s.)
- BWStearns 4y ago> General aviation are perhaps the most cautious and wary ICE users around. That depends on if you're describing the pilots or the ~manufacturers~ Textron. The experimental fleet has been pretty adventurous and it's a fast growing fleet. I think most of the conservatism in GA ICE tech has been driven by the broader issue of consolidation into a near monopoly on the cheaper end of the market. If you have no competition then why bother innovating?
- stametseater 4y agoIt starts with GA pilots being very conservative with what kinds of planes they invest in, since planes are huge money sinks already. The old engines have very well characterized reliability and cost, so pilots know what they're getting into and can accurately plan for all their expenses. New planes/engines are proposed fairly regularly, but generally fail because there are too many unknown factors that buyers are wary of.
- causi 4y agoOk, so they're "shooting for" a performance of 1hp per 1.57 lbs of engine weight. A Toyota Camry engine produces 1hp for every 1.41 lbs of engine weight. It produces 1ft-lb of torque for every 1.94 pounds of engine weight, compared to 1.58 for the Camry. How is this revolutionary motor being outdone by a mid-range sedan engine?
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoAdd 10,000 or 20,000 lbs to the vehicle weight, does it all scale the same?
- causi 4y agoI'm not sure what your point is. The XTS-210 hasn't been put in a vehicle as far as I know.
- shadycuz 4y agoThe engine is the size of a push mower. > XTS-210 is about the size of a basketball, weighs in at 19 kg (42 lb), and displaces 210 cc. So you are talking about a 26HP lawn mower. While the Camry might make more power at its normal size. It would not if you scaled it down to the size of a basketball. I'm guessing it would make 1-3HP at that size.
- 93po 4y agoA Traxxas 5407 TRX 3.3 engine used in RC cars makes 1.42 horsepower, weighs 305 grams, and fits in the palm of your hand. This is 1hp per 0.46 pounds of engine weight, nearly three times better than the camry engine. Granted an RC engine runs on a mixture of fuel and nitromethane, and doesn't have any reasonable durability compare to a Camry engine. But it also only costs $200.
- seabird 4y agoYou can't just make the Traxxas 18x bigger and get linear performance improvement. Trying to compare power/weight between engines with radically different weight constraints is silly.
- jldugger 4y agoI guess the "inside out" is that the rotary block is also the fuel injector? Would have to read more to figure out how they get fuel into a thing moving at thousands of rpm.
- Etheryte 4y agoWe do this all the time with cylinders, no? I don't see how this is any different.
- bagels 4y agoThey were, I think, imagining placing the fuel injector on the moving part itself (eg the piston) which doesn't makes much sense to do, taking the inside out bit to the extreme.
- bagels 4y agoThat is unlikely, it's probably in the housing, just like a wankel.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- HWR_14 4y agoA traditional Wankel engine has a rotary block in the shape of a reuleaux triangle moving in a more cylindrical stationary chamber. The "inside out" refers to how this engine is a more cylindrical rotary block moving inside a stationary reuleaux triangle chamber.
- andy_ppp 4y agoI'm surprised the air intake isn't more aerodynamic, more like a fan blade to compress the air into the engine? Could this engine be fitted inside the rear wheel to save space and weight as well?
- bmelton 4y agoThat's a really good idea. Mazda is doing something that I think is fairly novel, which is almost exactly what you've described. They've scaled down the rotary engine from their RX cars to a single-rotor and put it into their new EV (almost tucked into the front wheel well,) and letting it act as a 70ish horsepower generator for the otherwise battery-powered car to extend range.
- tromp 4y agoPresumably this new model: https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1138444_mazda-mx-30-r-ev-is-a-plug-in-puzzle-americans-might-not-get https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1138444_mazda-mx-30-r-e...
- digdugdirk 4y agoMazda really seems like the only company innovating in the ICE space (this, wankel rotary engines, skyactive engines) and their cars look damn good these days too. On top of that, they make fun cars. With buttons and knobs on the dash! I'm glad they're still around doing their thing.
- CocaKoala 4y agoMazda's also one of the few carmakers that's independent, as opposed to being part of a much larger conglomeration!
- KRAKRISMOTT 4y agoNo. Japanese conglomerates are not structured the same way as those in the west. Right now Mazda is semi dependent on Toyota, similar to Subaru.
- Cockbrand 4y agoSurely the engineers who came up with this are a lot smarter than myself, but to me it looks like the lower half of the rotor rotates into the combustion and thus has to work _against_ its force. If this is true, I'd assume that this takes away a lot of effectiveness.
- jutrewag 4y ago[dead]
- KAMSPioneer 4y agoI'm not sure what you mean -- are you referring to at the end of the combustion cycle during the exhaust phase? If so, then because the exhaust channel is open, the gases in the combustion chamber won't be exerting appreciable force on the shaft/rotor, the gasses will simply escape through the exhaust channel. At least, that's how I see it. But maybe I've understood you wrong.
- Cockbrand 4y agoYes, it’s a bit hard to explain, and I’m not a native speaker. But you got me right, and now I see that too. Thanks for the heads up!
- qbrass 4y agoIt actually happens less on this engine than piston engines because the lobe on the rotor kind of rotates over the combustion chamber for a while instead of moving towards or away from it. On the other hand, it exposes a lot of surface area to heat, which gets absorbed by the rotor but isn't used to turn the engine. It's a problem it shares with wankel engines. The advantage over wankels is the extra time air and fuel spends burning in the combustion chamber before the chamber volume expands. It means it gets more time to combust evenly which should help reduce both hydrocarbon and nitrogen oxide emissions.
- eYrKEC2 4y agoI know this goes towards steam-engine design, but why can't that heat be re-captured as steam? When the engine heat gets above a threshold, inject [distilled?] water instead of fuel.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- spydum 4y agoI suspect a lot of folks confusion on how this works is better explained by this from warped perception (first place I heard of this inverted rotary): https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=jLtyNtf9_ew&t=10s https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=jLtyNtf9_ew&t=10s
- dingaling 4y agoConfusion is also possibly due to misuse of the term 'rotary'. A true rotary engine turns on its crankshaft. The Wankel is a rotating-sleeve-valve engine.
- LesZedCB 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wankel_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wankel_engine https://www.britannica.com/technology/Wankel-engine https://www.britannica.com/technology/Wankel-engine both seem to disagree with your technical definition. at the very least, the colloquial usage is broad enough that adhering to some archaic technical definition isn't sufficient to explain some confusion. even this wiki article says it's obsolete https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotary_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotary_engine
- tbruckner 4y agoSurprised they didn't consider the Middle-out wankel.
- stillworks 4y agoHaven’t been exposed to the rigorous competition of TechCrunch Disrupt as yet I guess ?
- davidbanham 4y agoA commodity chainsaw (Stihl ms660) returns 1.4kg per kw from 2 stroke fuel. Before any performance tuning takes place. That’s at about a quarter of the size of this. I bet there’s efficiencies to be had if it were scaled up. I’m just not sure this is the game changing breakthrough the article’s tone suggests.
- kortex 4y agoTwo-strokes are extremely dirty, due to blow-through of the fuel-oil mixture, incomplete/less efficient combustion due to crude fuel metering, and inability to use conventional catalytic converters (due to fouling from the above two points). But they do afford roughly double the power-per-RPM of four-stroke engines, and a further power-to-weight multiplier due to their simpler design. AFAIK there's nothing mechanically stopping you from scaling a 2-stroke, but it would very quickly render the immediate area noxious. But they are simple, lightweight, and easy to shrink. This is actually a really important point as we are trying to clamp down on VOC/NOx emissions. Ignoring CO2, two-strokes emit way more emissions than cars per unit work. But a 4-stroke engine, in addition to expense, does not lend itself to tools like chainsaws. In theory this engine could fill that niche.
- davidbanham 4y agoThe rotary in the article is a 2 stroke design, by my understanding. Fuel injected 2 strokes have been around for years now. In saws, the Stihl 500i. Scaled 2 stroke engines, both with and without fuel injection, have also been around some time. The KTM 300 XC is a very modern example with 300cc displacement, so the same general category as the one in the article. Modern outboards on boats go even bigger. Yes there’s a push on at the moment to retire the fleet of small 2 stroke engines in older garden power tools. Emissions controls have been tightening up on new tools over the years. Electric tools are rapidly displacing them with lower maintenance requirements and less noise. There’s a lot more to 2 stroke engine development than just saws and lawnmowers from the 80s, though.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Synaesthesia 4y agoThis mechanism is really ingenious. I really liked the video explanation, it does seem like a very efficient and promising design.
- soliton4 4y agoabout 5 decades to late, but non the less impressive
- elihu 4y agoKind of weird article that doesn't talk about either the main benefits or design hurdles. The advantage of the LiquidPiston design is that at the time of ignition, the combustion chamber is a roughly round shape, as opposed to a traditional rotary where it's a long crescent. This should theoretically improve the emissions and fuel economy to be more like piston engines. I don't think Liquid Piston was talking about a 2-stroke version before. That's news to me, and it seems like it would throw out the efficiency/emissions benefits in exchange for more power. Maybe the author of the article was confused and this isn't actually a 2-stroke design? The main design hurdle has been longevity. Their prototypes in the past only work for a short time and wear out. That's probably just a matter of doing the necessary R&D to figure out the best alloys to make the engine out, and the best ways to lubricate everything. It's not clear from the article if this new version has this solved so it can last a normal amount of time or not.
- m3047 4y ago2 stroke has poor unburned emissions because of mix flow-through when ports are open. If air charge / purge is completed before fuel is injected then that doesn't occur; whether that's diesel or something else is irrelevant. As a bonus, built in EGR if properly managed.
- abfan1127 4y agoI thought 2-strokes had poor emissions was the injection of lubrication oil into the air fuel mixture. traditional 2-strokes I'm familiar with pull in air into the crank case (which requires lubrication), then uses a portion of the exhaust stroke to compress the fuel/air creating forced induction. By keeping air out of the crank case and providing lubrication delivery outside of the air/fuel mixture, emissions can be significantly improved. The article claims the design allows external lubrication, but it doesn't say how. I'd like to see how the seals are better than apex seals.
- mannykannot 4y agoThe basic crankcase-scavenged two-stroke suffers from both problems. Typical diesel two-strokes use a separate blower for scavenging, so the combustion air inflow never passes through the crankcase and does not come in contact with the lubricating oil, while the fuel is not injected until after the exhaust is closed. The engine described here can have its shaft and eccentric bearings externally lubricated, but its apex seals, like those of Wankel engines, seem to be in a situation analogous to that of a piston ring. Unlike either of those, however, they are mounted in the stator, not the moving part, and so may be easier to lubricate precisely. https://www.cycleworld.com/2015/04/06/two-stroke-motorcycle-engines-explained-tech-talk-by-kevin-cameron/ https://www.cycleworld.com/2015/04/06/two-stroke-motorcycle-... https://auto.howstuffworks.com/diesel-two-stroke1.htm https://auto.howstuffworks.com/diesel-two-stroke1.htm
- jiveturkey 4y agocame across this company a few weeks ago. the engine design is neat (who doesn’t have a soft spot for the wankel). while the design is neat, the scammy investors page turned me right off.
- AceyMan 4y agoTFA didn't seem to hint how they addressed the hot-side/cold-side issue that troubles Wankel designs. Anyone who knows more, please share.
- Zigurd 4y agoThey were advertising on Twitter for crowdfunded investment, which is a very small-time vibe.
- DesiLurker 4y agoI know this is targeted towards military/aviation applications (now, initially it was different), but, I honestly cannot understand why there is so little research on just making a hyper-efficient low-maintenance engine that runs at maybe 2 optimal rpms and powers a small battery bank plus electric motor (i.e.. typically series hybrid). None of these gas engines will come anywhere near the power-per-pound & torque output of a electric motor. If traditional carmakers had done that research about 10 years ago they wouldn't be facing such crisis with EVs today. a high-efficiency multi-fuel range extender engine is all we need today but still I cant find many automakers jumping on it. PS: it would have been nice to see a micro-turbine based generator with high thermodynamic efficiency but my understanding is that need a lot of maintenance so not suitable for consumer applications.
- driverdan 4y agoOne of the reasons is government regulation. I'll talk about US regulation but similar situations exist in other countries. 1. US incentives and regulation result in car manufacturers having to shift production from hybrids to EVs. 2. In order to qualify as an EV a vehicle can't have a range extending ICE that provides more than a 50% range increase. There's also a very low limit to the size of the fuel tank. These regulations have resulted in very few vehicles with ICE range extenders. Existing engines are easily capable of maxing out that regulation so there's no incentive to research other engines.
- DesiLurker 4y agoUS incentives aside, Nothing was stopping them from doing this for more expensive vehicles even if they didn't care about environment. I mean wouldn't you want to have a pickup truck with acceleration & torque of an EV with 2+1 motors powered by series hybrid and also have fuel economy of a 40mpg in city? I think its just institutional laziness & innovators dilemma. Even in last 5 years when it was clear Tesla is starting to rise they decided to sit on their hands and do nothing. Even till last year toyota has been singing BS about hydrogen cars and not enough lithium. they deserve whats coming to them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- davidthewatson 4y agoSurely, I can't be alone in reading this having driven an RX-7, numerous turbos, but no diesels, thinking this is EXACTLY what I need to replace the 310cc single cylinder in my BMW motorcycle that gets 70 MPG consistently, sits comfortably at 70 MPH on the highway, but is slow on the uptake in a crowded on-ramp. I remember the BMW single being a revelation because it's a single, DOHC, eats corn gas for breakfast without indigestion and has plenty of breathing room at the top end of the tach, which is unusual in single cylinders at redline, 10.5K RPM IIRC. One can only hope since one has less-than-zero mechanical engineering skills.
- davidbanham 4y agoPeople have shoehorned diesels and wankel rotaries into BMW airhead frames. It’s possible but not for the faint hearted. With a small frame like yours you’d probably be better served by an EV conversion if you want to go down that path.
- davidthewatson 4y agoThanks for the comment. I don't know anyone who has done the rotary or diesel conversion, though I have driven the zero and know another designer who built an electric motorcycle from scratch. When I say from scratch, I mean sketches, solid works, chassis - the whole 9. Of course, this gets easier at the edges where wheels, handlebars, exhaust, lights, and batteries are abundant. My daily awareness of his progress was working close to his desk at work, so I'm not sure where it's at today though I recall he was about to transition from chassis to engine at the time - 2016. He was definitely ahead of the curve. Sadly, my skills are in things that we have the luxury of pretending are not bound by the laws of physics. ;->
- clort 4y agolooks neat and I am in no way any kind of expert; I wonder why there is an external counterweight? It seems to me that the rotating 'piston' has hollow chambers in one side only to allow passage of gases and therefore needs a counterweight to balance it; is there a reason they cannot have some hollows in the other side but not have them connected to the burn chamber so that the piston is balanced by design, and the external weight not required?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- _ea1k 4y agoKind of looks like a peanut in a Dorito. So yeah, basically the opposite of the usual Dorito-powered version.
- garaetjjte 4y agoPhoto clearly shows spark plugs on it, and they claim it runs on diesel, so which is it? I don't think spark ignited diesel would work very well.
- CharlesW 4y agoHow do you know they're spark plugs and not glow plugs?
- garaetjjte 4y agoGlow plugs don't have HV insulator.
- LesZedCB 4y agothey also claim it runs on gas and propane and hydrogen. probably the photo is set up for only on of the 4 options?
- swamp40 4y ago> As electrification takes off, it's a difficult time to be working on new combustion engine concepts Turn it into a portable battery charger...
- joshuaheard 4y agoToo bad internal combustion engines are being banned throughout the United States.
- pengaru 4y agoThis motor is doomed... dirty exhaust gases exiting through part of the rotor? Only a matter of time before carbon+sludge builds up and the thing is out of balance. This is one of those designs that works fine initially when everything is fresh. Diesel piston engines work fine when everything is worn out and full of goo.
- davidbanham 4y agoThe exhaust gas recirculation valve on a modern diesel engine does exactly this. It diverts a portion of the exhaust product back into the intake manifold of the engine to achieve more complete combustion and lower emissions. Yes, it does result in a buildup of goo in the intake. No, the engine does not run well in that state. That’s what maintenance is for. Clean out the goo every 50,000km or so and it’s fine. Modern diesels are very reliable machines, just like modern petrol engines. They’re certainly not the robust rocks they used to be, though. High pressure common rail fuel systems, precision injectors and multi stage turbos are standard issue these days and they all require regular maintenance, clean air and clean fuel to operate properly.
- pengaru 4y ago> The exhaust gas recirculation valve on a modern diesel engine does exactly this Anyone who thinks the EGR valve should be made part of the rotating assembly requiring a complete overhaul to clean out, unbalancing the assembly until that occurs, needs their head examined.
- eurasiantiger 4y agoI find it hilarious that an energy war makes inventions like this suddenly come out of the woodwork.
- bartvk 4y agoIt comes out of the woodwork with a $9 million grant from the US Army, that is true. On the other hand, the article states "LiquidPiston has been working on these X-engines for nearly 20 years now, with numerous prototypes already tested in small planes (see above) and go-karts."