6 ms·
> It's not clear how you could effectively regulate this stuff It's not hard. It just upsets vested interests. Make it illegal to show ads to kids. You don't
by Animats 4y ago
> It's not clear how you could effectively regulate this stuff
It's not hard. It just upsets vested interests.
Make it illegal to show ads to kids. You don't have to make "kid" identification airtight, because few people of any age want to opt into ads. The ad industry was very upset when the American Psychological Association proposed this back in 2004.[1]
This doesn't raise constitutional issues because ads are considered commerce rather than speech.
[1] https://www.apa.org/pubs/reports/advertising-children https://www.apa.org/pubs/reports/advertising-children
- galaxyLogic 4y agoGreat point about speech
- iudqnolq 4y agoNo it's far far more complicated than that. See for example: https://www.oyez.org/cases/2021/20-1029 https://www.oyez.org/cases/2021/20-1029
- Animats 4y agoThe court upheld the City of Austin on prohibiting off-premises digital signs, even if some of what they displayed was non-commercial. So that's not a problem.
- iudqnolq 4y agoThe court engaged in a complex analysis to determine the appropriate framework for analyzing this specific first amendment advertising case. This shows there isn't a blanket exemption from first amendment scrutiny for advertising.
- camgunz 4y agoI didn't delve into the opinions but it seems like the decision relied on basic content-neutral doctrine. That's par for the course 1A stuff.
- jrochkind1 4y ago"par for the course 1A stuff" suggests that advertisements actually ARE first ammendment protected in the USA. Because... they are. Original commenter suggested they were not even considered "speech" and were not, which is not accurate description of the law. (In fact, though, advertisements are not treated exactly the same way as other kinds of speech, say, political speech. The bar is different, and more regulation of advertisements is allowed than, say, political speech. Who knows if the current supreme court and other courts will change that though, they are changing a lot, often in favor of protections for commerce).
- galaxyLogic 4y agoThere's a fine line between free speech and fraud
- imadierich 4y ago[dead]
- hutzlibu 4y ago"It's not hard. It just upsets vested interests." Yeah, this is what makes regulating anything hard or pointless, if the "vested interests" are powerful enough.
- eastbound 4y agoIf you forbid ads, then only political propaganda with bring funding to content creators. It’s not just because you hide money that it’s not there.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoThat solution fails to sidestep the not minor issue of how do we determine it's a child online brought up by the article.
- bsenftner 4y agoHow's about we start testing for maturity, and despite a person being 45 years of age, their maturity tests to be 12 years of age, so no social media for them. That would actually be significantly better for everyone involved. But who can trust anyone with a "maturity test" and then who can be trusted to administer said test honestly? Perhaps our entire society is immature and nobody deserves social media?
- DoreenMichele 4y agoPerhaps our entire society is immature...and it's time we grew tf up.
- bsenftner 4y agoThis is, in my opinion, a serious issue facing the human race today: we have a material number of flat out immature adults, and some of those immature idiots (looking at you Elon, and you Murdock, and many more) are far too powerful for their childish insatiable minds.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoI don't disagree with that. I just don't think banning people from the internet is the answer.
- eimrine 4y agoWho will test a maturity of maturity test developers? They will be kind of a shaping factor for a society.
- bsenftner 4y ago
- vincnetas 4y agoAnother problem is the definition of "ad". Is kid playing with fancy toys is an ad? Is product placement in movie an ad? How and who will determine if this is and ad or not?
- giraffe_lady 4y ago"did the company selling the thing pay for any part of it" seems like a good enough place to start.
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoEven that isn't as clear-cut as it seems. It isn't just the company that you need to include. Does your company produce ads for the company that produces Proprietary Toy and get money if they sell more products? Does your company supply batteries for Battery Operated Proprietary Toy? Does your store sell either Proprietary Toy? And so on.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoIt really is though. > Does your company produce ads There it is, don't do that. All these other questions are also just "yes." You're looking for nuance where there isn't any. Sponsorship is ads, product placement is ads, giving free product to influencer to review is ads. There are certainly edge cases some of them likely to be thorny but none of the things either of us has mentioned so far are them.
- joenot443 4y agoI think there’s absolutely nuance here and pretending “make it illegal for kids to see ads” is a simple or even attainable solution is a bit naive I think. What about product placement? Nearly every movie in Hollywood from the past 40 years has some level of product placement, so under this new law we’ll either go back and edit it out or slap an R rating on it? How about arena ads or billboards? Special AR headsets for teens which will block ads from sight? It’s a silly hypothetical, of course, but you did just say that it’s a hypothetical without nuance. I think it’s easier to imagine a world where advertising is outlaws entirely than one where we specifically shield it only for those underage.
- jutrewag 4y agoWhat problem does that fix? It’s not particularly the corporations that are a bad influence on the kids, it’s their own peer group.
- bsenftner 4y agoAh, the subtle aspect you're missing: it is the corporations that created and promote the environment in which the kids abuse one another. It's similar to creating a large park, and then not policing the situation when bullies take over the park, and probably also accepting payments of some kind from the bullies for their extraordinary access to the corporation's "park for people and kids".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cornholio 4y agoBut then the bullies park will let you kid in for free and then charge an adult fee for you to retrieve them or supervise them. They still make money either way, so the problem will still exist - an attractive park built for kids which disregards safety.
- Joeri 4y agoAds have very little to do with the harmful effects on minors of social media use. And besides, banning ads will not prevent social media from trying to lock minors in, either to already have them when they turn 18, or to benefit from peer network effects to rope in more of the 18+ audience.
- djhn 4y agoBut the ability to show ads is the only reason to allow the youth on the apps. Remove the commercial reason for brainwashing kids, and the rest will probably sort itself out (I guess is the logic)
- germinalphrase 4y agoAddicting kids to the platform such that you can show ads to them when they turn 18 seems to have obvious value.
- scythe 4y agoTo some degree. But addiction describes a range of behavioral symptoms with a variety of durations and dynamics. The expected return of designing platforms to entertain 17-year-olds will decrease a little, but the expected return of designing a platform to entertain 13-year-olds will decrease a lot. By the time the latter group is monetizeable, they might move to a competitor's platform — just as prescription painkiller addicts have an easy time substituting heroin when they find it's cheaper. One thing that's particularly convenient for regulators in this case is the tendency of adolescents to deliberately change their behavior as they approach adulthood in order to reinforce a sense of personal growth. 18-year-old me didn't want much to do with games and movies for 13-year-olds.
- cowl 4y agoThe problem is what is an Ad? Is the Cryptobro shilling for the coin of the week an Ad? is the Influencer that "casually" is using her brand of Mascara while talking an Ad? Do creators need to have two versions of the same video (one with promotion, one without)? Most ads now are difficult to tell apart from content. Is this review really a review or content length ad?
- _heimdall 4y agoThere's way too much gray area here for an effective law to ever be defined. How do you define what is considered an ad here? How is age verified online? What if I have Hulu on TV from my account while my kids is in the room? Are other forms of ads banned as well, like cable TV commercials or billboards? Cereal boxes only use cartoon mascots to advertise to children...so also illegal?
- andsoitis 4y ago>> It's not clear how you could effectively regulate this stuff > It's not hard. It just upsets vested interests. Vested interests are precisely why it is hard.
- Joker_vD 4y agoHe probably meant "it's not complicated" because it really is not complicated, it's just hard, the same way e.g. weight-lifting is simple but hard.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoTake a look at the Fortune 500 list, and you can see exactly why the US has the problems it does. The largest companies correlate to the shortcomings, e.g. oil & gas & cars vs. public transit, or all of the healthcare companies that are in the F50 vs. affordable healthcare. Vested interests rule the US at this point.
- jrochkind1 4y agoSo... I'm not sure that ads are the center of negative consequences... AND it's not actually true that advertisements aren't considered speech with first ammendment protections in the USA, it is (although it has LESS protections than some other speech, and can be regulated, probably including in this way)... But on top of all of that... what is an "ad"? Is it an "influencer" who is getting paid to promote a product but doesn't actually disclose that? Which already violates FTC regulations, and we aren't even managing to enforce the regulations we've already got, cause this is pervasive.
- guelo 4y agoThere's too thin of a line between ads and algorithmic feeds.