5 ms·
It's amazing how big the settlements are for discrimination lawsuits vs. other labor law violations. Wage and hour violations get a slap on the wrist. Safety vi
by Animats 4y ago
It's amazing how big the settlements are for discrimination lawsuits vs. other labor law violations. Wage and hour violations get a slap on the wrist. Safety violations seldom cost a company more than a few thousand dollars unless someone is killed, and even then payments rarely exceed 5 figures.
- publicmenace 4y ago[flagged]
- smt88 4y ago> Wage and hour violations get a slap on the wrist It's very easy to calculate financial harm, and for an individual worker, even multiplying that harm by 10x isn't going to be a "significant" amount for a large-ish company. In this random case, the company was ordered to pay the wages and then the same amount on top of that for the damage caused[1], so it was 2x total. > Safety violations seldom cost a company more than a few thousand dollars unless someone is killed, and even then payments rarely exceed 5 figures. This isn't true. Just looking at some random, low-profile cases, you can easily find awards in the six figures[2]. Anyway, what's your point? 1. https://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/whd/whd20220810 https://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/whd/whd20220810 2. https://www.osha.gov/news/newsreleases/national/06222022 https://www.osha.gov/news/newsreleases/national/06222022
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> Anyway, what's your point? I'm not Animats, but there might be a suggestion that being discriminated against is not actually worse than being killed.
- notch898a 4y agoLooks like being discriminated against in this case is roughly worth the same as having a limb cutoff according to one law firm. I don't want to be presumptuous and say that feeling discrimination on the job is better than having your arm cut off though, maybe it does feel worse. https://www.losangelespersonalinjurylawyers.co/average-case-value-amputation/ https://www.losangelespersonalinjurylawyers.co/average-case-...
- Animats 4y agoValues for work-related injuries are far lower: [1] [1] https://www.yourlawyer.com/library/workers-compensation-body-parts-worth/ https://www.yourlawyer.com/library/workers-compensation-body...
- notch898a 4y agoMaybe someone with experience here can chime in, but my gut tells me those must be the worker's compensation insurance payout for the limb and the lawyer was including the surrounding lawsuit which would litigate the neglect resulting in the loss of limb.
- smt88 4y agoThese are workers' comp, not lawsuits. They have nothing to do with this thread.
- smt88 4y agoYour own link gives lots of examples where compensation was much greater than $3M depending on the severity of the injury. $8,000,000 Verdict: The plaintiff lost three fingers and underwent numerous surgeries to save her hand. A conveyor belt was detected to have a defect and caught her hand in it, leading to extremely debilitating damages. $150,000 Verdict: While he was operating machinery in a school, the plaintiff severed the tip of his finger. Thanks to the efforts of medical professionals, the finger was reattached; when he pursued legal action, he was found partially at fault and had a 35% reduction of his verdict. $1,200,000 Settlement: A young boy, age 11, suffered partial leg amputations after being struck by a train. He was playing on the railroad tracks and was caught. A Minneapolis jury was set to hear the case, but a settlement was reached beforehand. $400,000 Settlement: A 45-year-old man in Minnesota was working on a tri-roller machine at a bakery when the rollers snatched his glove. His arm was pulled into the machine, causing irreparable damages that resulted in amputation below his elbow. $325,000 Verdict: A man, nearly 40 years old, suffered an amputation after the cast he wore on his broken arm was applied too tightly, causing ischemia. $5,000,000 Settlement: A man was struck by a semi-truck while on his motor bike. The crash caused severe damages to his leg. Despite numerous surgeries, the leg could not be adequately fixed, and was amputated below the knee.
- smt88 4y ago> there might be a suggestion that being discriminated against is not actually worse than being killed He very specifically said unless someone is killed. The awards for deaths are absolutely astronomical. They have often reached into tens of millions all the way up to billions[1]. There's also a lot of historical precedent for racism leading to workplace deaths. 1. https://www.enjuris.com/blog/resources/biggest-wrongful-death-awards/ https://www.enjuris.com/blog/resources/biggest-wrongful-deat...
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> He very specifically said unless someone is killed. And if you read... the rest of that very sentence... he notes that the penalty in such cases is effectively capped at $100,000. You quote him saying it. And then you rebut it by saying you can find penalties below $1,000,000, which isn't much of a rebuttal.
- culi 4y agohow much did Musk pay to get to force the founders of Tesla to allow Musk to say he was a cofounder? Reputation is hard to maintain but something you can buy
- kjksf 4y agoNothing (except lawyers fees). It was Eberhard who sued Musk trying to get the courts to declare that only he and Tarpenning can be called co-founders of Tesla. And that backfired because the judge declared that, actually, Musk and JB. Straubel are also co-founders of Tesla. https://www.tesla.com/blog/judge-strikes-claim-who-can-be-declared-founder-tesla-motors https://www.tesla.com/blog/judge-strikes-claim-who-can-be-de...
- sschueller 4y agoYou can't cite Tesla's blog as a credible source when that specific site still contains blatent lies and falsehoods such as FSD.
- jeffparsons 4y agoIt doesn't really need a citation at all. It's pretty standard for people to be considered as "founders" even if they weren't the first person to be involved in the first incarnation of a business. The only reason this particular instance got any attention is because of the lawsuit. If you're curious, pick a few companies at random and dig into their history. You might be surprised by how late some of their "founders" became involved in the business.
- glenngillen 4y agoI’m way out of my area of expertise here, so posting this comment mostly in the hope to solicit someone who is more knowledgeable to expand on it… A commenter on a previous post a few months ago pointed out that different countries/legal systems have different approaches that I think they may have referred to as punitive vs restorative? And even in systems with both, certain classes of crimes may only be able to approach sentencing from on of those approaches. Which can mean the outcome is more about making the aggrieved party whole again (with potentially a little extra for the inconvenience). It leaves no room for the kind of very very large outcome that acts as a signal to the defendant and any others to not break this law again.
- WalterBright 4y agoIt also sends a signal to unscrupulous people who file baseless lawsuits looking for a jackpot settlement.
- savolai 4y agoI was wondering about this. I'm equally not an expert in law. Are there three classes of punishment: punitive, tort, and restorative? Are punitive and restorative mutually exclusive?
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoA tort is a type of lawsuit. "Restorative" damages aren't a thing except maybe in some odd legal jurisdiction (inb4 Louisiana, because the french) or niche subset of law. You have compensatory and punitive damages. They are not mutually exclusive. Compensatory damages are to make the injured party financially whole. Punitive damages are awarded by the court and basically serve as a "don't do this" fine.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoDiscrimination lawsuits in the US are supposed to be torts I believe, which is what allows you to have these big settlements (think McDonalds coffee too hot, that was a tort) I would think that Safety violations may also be torts - but probably not all the time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tort https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tort
- jeffparsons 4y agoThe McDonald's coffee incident is often cited as an example of litigation and punitive damages gone mad. Some woman got scalded by her coffee? And she was awarded how much? It's less often noted just how badly the woman was injured (third degree burns, significant amounts of skin seared off, etc.) and the details of why McDonald's was held liable (dangerous policy, not an isolated mistake). The details are worth a read: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald%27s_Restaurants https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald%27s_Rest...
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoI certainly agree that McDonald's got what it deserved, hope you don't think I was implying otherwise. on edit: actually I think the ability to sue for torts is one of the pluses of the American system, and is definitely better than a lot of other supposedly fairer countries.
- afiori 4y agoMcDonald got the verdict it deserved, but later appeals reduced the sum to a much lower value IIRC not even covering the total medical expenses + lawyers.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoIt was reduced but in the wikipedia article linked above https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald%27s_Restaurants https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald%27s_Rest... it says >The judge reduced punitive damages to $480,000, three times the compensatory amount, for a total of $640,000. The decision was appealed by both McDonald's and Liebeck in December 1994, but the parties settled out of court for an undisclosed amount. I would think that the settlement out of court was less than 640000, because it was McDonalds that was appealing, thus for them to drop it they would have to pay less than what they were going to anyway (I suppose) It also says >Liebeck died on August 5, 2004, at age 91. According to her daughter, "the burns and court proceedings (had taken) their toll" and in the years following the settlement Liebeck had "no quality of life". She said the settlement had paid for a live-in nurse. So I think it was still significantly more than the 160,000 the suit was originally for in order to afford a nurse.
- amelius 4y agoIt's modern slavery, but without the racism component.
- zozbot234 4y agoExcept that if I was a racialized person and saw scrawled swastikas in my place of employment, I might very reasonably start to be concerned about my actual safety. The law clearly says that the employer is liable for a hostile work environment. So a damage award in that range really doesn't seem that excessive.
- robertlagrant 4y agoI don't know any of the detail, but I don't see how this symbol interpreted as a threat of violence should receive a larger award than an actual death, which is what the person you're replying to was saying. Have I misunderstood?
- shadowgovt 4y agoPay for death is complicated. Im many ways, it's an apples-to-oranges punishment: no amount of money can bring someone back from the dead, so one could argue that no amount of payment is appropriate (or inappropriate) for a death. Assuming we accept the premise "Sorry your loved one is irrevocably gone; here's a sack of cash" is fair: It is, perhaps, the case that since the laws against workplace-caused deaths are older, their damage values have been pinned to lower pre-inflation numbers and the right response to "How can a hostile-work-environment suit cost the company more than a workplace death?" is to increase punitive payments for deaths.
- newsclues 4y agoEconomic class isn’t a protected group