11 ms·
If parrots can talk, why can’t monkeys?
- tiku 4y agoWell we are the apes/monkeys that could?
- gnramires 4y agoI've heard as well that some animals, like Gorillas, have a hard time understanding human speech. However, they can communicate in other ways (using simple signs) that make it clear they have some understanding of language (in the sense of concepts like position, individuals, etc.) and context. To me this suggests either their sound processing is also insufficient to understand human speech, or not their vocal anatomy, I wonder, but their auditory anatomy could be not ideal for understanding human speech.
- owenpalmer 4y agoParrots can't talk
- earleybird 4y agoParrots parrot parrots?
- withinboredom 4y agoParrots parroting parrots parodying parrots.
- bhawks 4y agoObviously we are the smart ones with our wonderfully clear, expressive, and concise language. /s --kind of. We really need to be aware of our own biases and biological limitations if we actually want to study and understand the ability of other animals to have complex communications. Birds experience reality differently than we do - they see more of visible spectrum, they can make multiple sounds at once, etc. I wouldn't be surprised that what they can hear and how they perceive things like time is very different then us. Anyone observing parrots, crows, and other highly social avians can see they have complex relationships.
- capableweb 4y agoGuess it depends on what you mean exactly with "talk". They can articulate phrases, isn't that enough?
- cactusplant7374 4y agoIt's not language. It's basically mimicking humans. Noam Chomsky on Nim Chimpsky and the Emergence of Language: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a39vcatTCVU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a39vcatTCVU Chomsky has a few other interviews where he addresses this.
- pks016 4y agoYou are correct. It is speech not language.
- cactusplant7374 4y agoBut it's almost not communicating as humans do -- something most commenters are implying.
- withinboredom 4y agoYou don’t need a language to communicate (ask my cat — or any cat/dog). You also don’t need words, but colloquially, “talking” means using words, not using language. Someone talking to you with random noises you can reproduce would still be called “talking” whether or not it was a language. In other words a baby saying “milk” because it wants milk doesn’t mean you should ignore it because it isn’t using a “language.”
- elpocko 4y ago> (ask my cat Ok. Hi cat. Do you need language to communicate? Plz respond.
- TexanFeller 4y ago> It's not language. It's basically mimicking humans. I owned a parrot for a few years. The speech she had was like a tape recorder, she could mostly only play back what she heard in an identical manner. But she was able to play back pieces of appropriate snippets in the right context to express herself to a level that I'd call it talking. It's not normal "speech", but if you gave an otherwise normal human with damaged speech centers in their brain a tape recorder it's very much like that.
- withinboredom 4y ago[deleted due to unintended double-entendre]
- bhaney 4y agoWell now I gotta know
- ggm 4y agoParrots talk to each other.
- krackers 4y agoOnly stochastically.
- jedberg 4y agoThey can certainly communicate their wants and needs with words. Some have shown the ability to communicate abstract thoughts and feelings. Why do you say they can't talk?
- WakoMan12 4y agoyes i can
- junon 4y agoI have a parrot. He can talk, both contextually and randomly (the former much less often, but does still happen). Not sure what your criteria for "talking" are but, by all of my own measures, my parrot sounds pretty much exactly like me in most cases, and like a child in most others. The words are clearly distinguishable, understandable, and in multiple languages (he lives in a multi-language household). So, yes. Parrots can talk. Can they converse? Sometimes loosely, usually not at all. But they can very much talk. If you mean that parrots do not understand the words and construction they are speaking, sure. But at that point you're splitting hairs. My parrot says "do you want it?" when he wants a treat. He says "good night" when he wants to go to bed. He says "c'mon!" when he wants me to come to him. He absolutely talks. Weird hill to die on.
- Izmaki 4y agoMy parrot will on every occasion that it stumbles, let out a surprised "Oh!" followed by a "Good boy!" when he gets back up again. I didn't sit around all day teaching him to say "Oh!" whenever I pushed him off the branch and praise him when he got back up again. I also don't tell myself I'm a "Good boy!" whenever I get back up from a stumble (which thankfully doesn't happen often at home to begin with). I'm sure my parrot doesn't know what "Oh!" or "Good boy" means, that is what the words mean in a human context. I'm also sure that he doesn't know what snapping finger noise followed by a stern "Ah-ah!" means, but he has used that on one occasion when he was mad at me and wanted to tell me to back off if I treasured the skin on my hands. (A learned behaviour from his first and previous owner). ...but at the end of the day, speech is in many ways "just" a series of correct sounds at correct times in correct situations, right? Does my parrot have a conversation with me? Well yes, sometimes, but not with words. Does my parrot mimic human words and phrases? Also yes, and sometimes in the most perfect situations possible.
- yazzku 4y agoFrom your description, it does sound like your Parrot has some understanding of meaning, much like dogs do. Not that they understand the grammar or can make out the individual words, but it seems like it can correlate <real world event> with <sounds>. <get back up> -> "Good boy"; <caught you right where I wanted you> -> "<snap> + Ah-ha!". Similarly, a dog may not understand that "sit" is an English word, but it can clearly understand "sit" -> <get that ass on the floor> (or whatever language you used to train them, they couldn't care less). That association is meaning, even if they are not fully acquainted with the works of Shakespeare.
- ggm 4y agoInfrasound aside, it seems that it's neural after all. Apes scream and grunt, so vocalisation follows gross mood. (I don't know if anyone has tested apes for ultra low frequency communications)
- IIAOPSW 4y agoI don't follow why screams and grunts can only encode gross mood. Presuming I can differentiate them enough to have some amount of vocabulary, why can't I make a well reasoned and abstract grunt?
- sdenton4 4y agoAccording to birds, we just emit a bunch of low pitched grunts and noise all day.
- IIAOPSW 4y agoHonestly, when you speedup or slow down the playback to be in proportion to their size, all animals sort of sound the same. This goes for whales all the way up to birds. Whale sounds sped up are hilarious btw.
- ggm 4y agoYou can, and arguably Apes do. I do not reject the possibility the range of grunts encode information beyond "stop behaving like the 9 month old ape you are before I rage quit and beat my chest"
- osamagirl69 4y agoA very interesting read, which describes how for ~50 years the community was lead astray by a seemingly simple oversight: studying dead animals instead of living ones! >Charles Darwin theorized that monkeys had the vocal anatomy needed for speech, but lacked the necessary neural mechanisms. >This was the most popular hypothesis until 1969 [when] Lieberman studied the vocal anatomy of a monkey corpse and concluded that other primates could not produce as many vowels as humans because of the position of their larynxes [which] cemented the idea that a descended larynx is a prerequisite for speech. >Towards the end of the 20th century, evolutionary biologist W. Tecumseh Fitch realized a crucial fact – all the existing evidence was based on the anatomy of dead primates. Surprised that this had not been done before, Fitch used x-ray imaging to study the vocal tracts of live animals while they were voicing sounds. He was amazed to observe that their larynxes at rest remained high and then descended during vocalization to a position very similar to the human larynx. >All these studies indicate that apes have all the anatomical characteristics necessary for speech. The reason they don’t is purely neural. Humans have much better control of the larynx, not because of its position, but because of the neural connections that connect it to the brain. Parrots don’t even have a larynx, but they have wonderful control of their speech organ, which enables them to articulate intelligible words and phrases. Fascinating
- nico 4y ago[flagged]
- HopenHeyHi 4y ago[flagged]
- nico 4y agoWho is this talking to me?
- HopenHeyHi 4y agoOh, my God, I was wrong, It was Earth all along. You finally made a monkey...
- causality0 4y ago"If parrots can speak, why can't monkeys?" would be a more accurate headline.
- triggerwarn 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pcrh 4y agoIt's interesting to compare this "sound-talk" that parrots can easily accomplish with the obviously greater intelligence of apes, who can't reproduce human sounds, with the debate over whether chatGPT is intelligent or not. Note that Koko was obviously a greater communicator than any parrot ever was. Is mimicking human behaviour a necessary, or even sufficient, criteria for demonstrating cognition and intelligence?
- Chinjut 4y agoI believe there is significant scientific skepticism as to whether Koko was communicating to the degree popularly portrayed.
- pks016 4y agoSpeech and language are two different things. > Is mimicking human behaviour a necessary, or even sufficient, criteria for demonstrating cognition and intelligence? Depends on how you define them. We love to anthropomorphize everything. If an animal shows language comprehension, that's bigger than speech.
- baja_blast 4y ago> obviously greater intelligence of apes Apes are not more intelligent than parrots, despite not having hands like apes parrots use tools with the same sophistication as chimps, and Crows surpass all great apes except humans in tool use and complexity. Parrots have been able to solve complex puzzles of equal or greater complexity to what a Chimp could solve. And when it comes to social behavior parrots/corvids are far more sophisticated and complex. Honestly if I had to bet which animal would outsmart which in a real world game of wits I would bet on the parrot or crow over a chimp every time. I apes have hands which are perfect for tool use and making, but crows make more complex tools using their beak.
- tokyolights2 4y agoThe short story "The Great Silence" by Ted Chaing feels very relevant here. > The humans use Arecibo to look for extraterrestrial intelligence. Their desire to make a connection is so strong that they’ve created an ear capable of hearing across the universe. But I and my fellow parrots are right here. Why aren’t they interested in listening to our voices? We’re a nonhuman species capable of communicating with them. Aren’t we exactly what humans are looking for?
- rmellow 4y ago> There was also a communications problem. Though they had an equivalent IQ of sixty, and could understand several hundred words of English, they were unable to talk. It had proved impossible to give useful vocal chords either to apes or monkeys, and they therefore had to express themselves in sign language - Rendezvous with Rama (1973) Guess it's more fiction than science fiction now.
- catchnear4321 4y agoIt would be impossible to give them useful vocal cords. Just not because of the vocal cords. There should be a category specifically for invalidated science fiction. Things found to be unpossible in any timeline, assuming consistent laws of nature.
- chatmasta 4y agoI believe this category is referred to as "uplifting" [0]. And while it certainly hasn't been proved to be viable so far, are you really sure it's time to rule it out as a possibility? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uplift_(science_fiction) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uplift_(science_fiction)
- catchnear4321 4y agoNo, invalidated science fiction. The science being invalid. Meaning the vocal cords were the weak link. When it was not.
- burnished 4y agoEeh, just 'poorly aged'? I dont think how likely the principle of the thing was is all that important for science fiction which tends to concern itself with the consequences of a given technology. Mind you, I tried to think up a fun word for this and failed which is why you're getting this answer instead of a word.
- bell-cot 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ConanRus 4y ago[dead]
- jscipione 4y agotldr; larynx position
- zuminator 4y agoHuh, according to the article it's not larynx position. It's that chimps seemingly lack the neural wiring to exercise fine motor control over their larynges. It's like humans comparative lack of control in wagging our ears compared to what dogs can do.
- pentagrama 4y agoSorry but I was going to sleep, the article title was intriguing to me but was 12+ paragraphs long, so I ask ChatGPT the same question and I got 3 short paragraphs. Hope I'm not missing too much. > If parrots can talk, why can’t monkeys? > Parrots are able to mimic human speech because they have a specialized vocal organ, called a syrinx, that allows them to control the sounds they produce. This ability is not shared by all birds, but it is particularly well developed in parrots. Monkeys, on the other hand, do not have the same type of vocal organ as birds, and so they are not able to produce the same range of sounds. While monkeys do communicate with each other using a variety of vocalizations, these sounds are not as complex or as adaptable as human speech. Additionally, language is not just about making sounds, it is also about understanding and using complex grammatical rules and abstract concepts. While some primates have demonstrated a degree of language comprehension and production in scientific studies, their abilities are still far from the complexity and flexibility of human language.
- argsnd 4y agoIt’s silly enough that you did this but rather annoying that you posted it here
- LatticeAnimal 4y agoThat is not a very good answer. What ChatGPT basically said was: “Monkeys can’t speak because they don’t have a bird-only organ and because syntax is hard” I think you would have had a much better result if you had asked it to summarize this (fun and interesting) article.
- quickthrower2 4y agoA couple more "whys" in you get: > Parrots are social animals that live in complex environments such as rainforests, where communication with other members of the group is essential. The ability to produce a wide range of vocalizations, including mimicry of other animals and human speech, could provide an advantage in communicating with other parrots and navigating the complex social dynamics of their environment. > In contrast, monkeys and other primates evolved in a different ecological context, where visual communication and social cues may have played a more important role than vocalization. Additionally, the physical constraints of the primate vocal tract may have limited the evolution of more complex vocalizations, including mimicry of human speech. Although it doesn't make sense to me now - monkeys also evolved in rainforests right? Maybe they stayed closer. After all birds can fly.
- hbbio 4y agoThis is an almost copy/paste in 2023 from another article from 2016: https://www.mirror.co.uk/science/monkeys-brain-power-talk-lack-9425521 https://www.mirror.co.uk/science/monkeys-brain-power-talk-la...
- sys_64738 4y agoI've seen this movie and it doesn't ever end well for us.
- ChatGTP 4y agoI’ve seen this comment and it doesn’t end well for the poster.
- Havoc 4y agoTalk or imitate?
- geenew 4y agoThis was a good show, about the relationship between birdsong and human language: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b05tz9jr https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b05tz9jr
- examplary_cable 4y agoParrots can't use sign language, but some great apes can(koko)[0]! Even thought monkeys don't have the vocal complexity to generate all the vowels(a,e,i,o,u) I think "great ape language" communication is more complex and nuanced than a fricking parrot repeating some phonemes after some form of stimulation. Fascinating. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koko_(gorilla) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koko_(gorilla)
- baja_blast 4y agoIt's difficult to use sign language without hands/arms.
- faitswulff 4y agoI think you are underestimating avian intelligence. Despite the term "parroting," if I recall correctly, they're estimated to grow to about the intelligence of a 3 year old human child: > ...parrots demonstrate sophisticated problem solving abilities, they can communicate their desires, they can count, add and subtract, and remarkably, they even understand the concept of zero - https://www.forbes.com/sites/grrlscientist/2018/07/12/what-makes-parrots-so-intelligent/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/grrlscientist/2018/07/12/what-m...
- falsaberN1 4y agoIt's not uncommon for people to underestimate avian intelligence, for some reason I never quite understood. At times I wonder if it's some sort of tiny vendetta from humans themselves. You know, like how (Eurasian) magpies are considered pests, even bad omens, despite being intelligent and crafty...only because they are able to get past human-made traps. I guess a lot of humans are sore losers, heh. But corvidae are legitimately intelligent, specially crows and magpies. The behaviors of crows in Japan are well-known, and magpies were proven to not only being able to recognize themselves in a mirror, they also used the view from the mirror as a tool (in the controlled experiment, to try to remove a sticker put on them by researchers). They can also remember humans visually (and therefore being able to hold grudges, or consider individuals "safe"), use and/or make rudimentary tools to achieve goals. Not to mention that a bunch of birds can go literally (and visibly) insane in captivity. You can't have insanity without sanity.
- forgingahead 4y agoWhat's with all this stories from El Pais being submitted by the OP all of a sudden? https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=elpais.com https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=elpais.com
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bobbylarrybobby 4y agoStrange that this article doesn't mention any of the current research into what the cause is. [Erich Jarvis](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erich_Jarvis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erich_Jarvis) has done research into the neurological mechanisms and seems to have discovered that animals capable of complex speech patterns have some mutations that permit a neural connection to grow from the motor cortex to the larynx (or syrinx in birds) by way of the brain stem. In other words, we can make complex vocalizations in part because we have fine motor control over our voice box, whereas most other animals do not. This is only part of the story — there's still the question of how auditory information makes it in as an input so that we can replicate sounds we've heard — but it's a pretty big part for TFA to omit.
- WalterBright 4y agoYet people can make perfectly intelligible speech without using the larynx at all - whispering. People can also speak using a vibrator pressed against the throat.
- unixgoddess 4y agomore importantly, people can make perfectly intelligible speech using a completely different set of symbols, for example writing, whistling^1, hand gestures (sign language), pictures, etc. Of course language is purely neural! ^1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whistled_language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whistled_language
- WalterBright 4y agoParrots are smarter. QED
- WalterBright 4y agoI recall that the origin of the word "barbarian" comes from the ancient Greeks, who interpreted foreign languages as simply "bar bar bar". So, other animals may be communicating vocally, it's just that all we hear is "woof woof woof".
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoOr it might be that because we aren’t teaching them the way we teach babies. With a baby you are constantly reinforcing the language and encouraging them to match you. They obviously don’t have a human voice in there but they may be capable of a richer dog language than they currently use if they were taught it from early life.
- dghughes 4y agoI think whales are just being sarcastic. Oooo look at the floating man in the boat he's so brave ooooo
- dasickis 4y agoWe've been building tech to translate dog barks to something meaningful for us to understand. A few things we observed: 1. Dogs are more communicative once they believe you are correctly responsive to their vocalizations 2. Their barks are more differentiated over time and they start to introduce new types of vocalizations or sequences of vocalizations 3. Dogs don't have a structured vocal language as it starts of slightly differentiated and mostly to get people's attention This isn't true for other animals (based on our reading of academic papers) and a commonality we've seen in the papers: as animals have more individuals they interact with across their life especially not directly related, their vocalizations are more structured. Within family units they tend to rely more on touch, body language, and some intermittent vocalizations. Though marine mammals are very vocal given they operate within acoustic environments in the ocean and it gets dark around 100m - 200m. Basically, as number of sustained individuals in a group goes up and the number of non-related individuals increases, vocalizations get more diverse. We see cows, pigs, goats, and other herd animals are also very vocal which is how scientists have been decoding their speech recently similar to prairie dogs. Much of what I've written here is a super simplification but happy to get deeper into the weeds.
- tlavoie 4y agoI do chuckle at one of mine, who definitely has a range of meanings to her barks. One solitary "WOOF", repeated at an interval means, "I'm stuck in the paddock, please let me out." She has another for "I've got a raccoon up a tree," and a gruff huffing noise for, "get off your ass and take us for a walk!" I'm pretty sure I'm at least as much the trainee as the trainer here though.
- r0rshrk 4y agoPlease please write an article on this. There's not information online about canine communication
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoWe had an old dog move in with us and it’s been interesting because it has developed a new dog culture based on my existing dog. It now barks when someone comes home, barks to go outside etc. It didn’t do any of that before but it has started doing it by watching the existing dog communicate and having people who are more attentive to its needs. Everything I see in dogs suggests that they are sentient, they just don’t seem to need language. They speak when it is useful, like for getting attention from people in different rooms, but they don’t really need it beyond that. So they don’t go any further.
- barryxxl 4y ago[flagged]
- dsign 4y ago>> And once again, Darwin was right. We should write that on the sky. A terrifying amount of things can be explained with evolution and natural selection. It can even be applied to social groups and systems of thought, i.e. religion, politics and economics. The article is also an illustration of how dangerous is to attempt mechanistic explanations in biology. It's almost never one factor that bolsters or prevent an outcome, but a lot of factors working together in ways the human mind can only very poorly model without mathematical and computational tools.
- amai 4y agoOn the other side: Parrots cannot recognize themselves in a mirror https://talkieparrot.com/behavior/can-parrots-recognize-themselves-in-a-mirror/ https://talkieparrot.com/behavior/can-parrots-recognize-them..., while monkeys can https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirror_test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirror_test . I consider the mirror test a better test for a higher form of intelligence than simply being able to simulate talking. So the real question nowadays would be: Can GPT-4 pass the mirror test? Can it detect it‘s own output, if you echo it back to it?
- kozinc 4y agoThe problem is also that intelligence isn't on some kind of a line where a specific test tells you that you're closer to a base amount of intelligence needed for sentience. It's a whole bunch of things combined in some yet to be defined way that ends up allowing for the development of intelligence. As for GPT-4 - it can't even recognize for itself whether data is good or bad, and it can't even recognize that it doesn't know something; IMO right now it's still basically just a black box that takes an input and produces a statistically matching output. A very good one, but still.