6 ms·
Chemist Rafael Luque suspended without pay for thirteen years
- belter 4y ago"...The chemist admitted that since December, he has been using the artificial intelligence program ChatGPT to “polish” his texts. “These months have been quite productive, because there are articles that used to require two or three days and now I do them in one day,” he said..." WTF!
- iamerroragent 4y agoYeah WTF. This is just going to become standard practice within years if not months. Perfect application for this AI tool imo.
- lisasays 4y agoPerfect application for this AI tool imo. Yup - credential whoring and research fraud. It's the new frontier.
- iamerroragent 4y agoThat was something Luque was being accused of before using AI though. Using a machine to work more efficiently is not bad.
- igetspam 4y agoWhy the "WTF!"? He wasn't sanctioned for using an LLM to speed up his work, so seeing this as the first reply could confuse some people. I've been doing this for months now too. I can get docs done in a day that used to take a couple weeks because of constant interruptions.
- belter 4y agoThat is not the point...It's the fact his supposed valuable research, ( he is getting published after all!) is of so flimsy quality, that a LLM model can be a productivity improvement! That is the reason of the WTF. Do you think Tesla or Einstein with a LLM model, would spit out 5 new discoveries per week instead of one every decade?
- coldtea 4y ago>is of so flimsy quality, that a LLM model can be a productivity improvement! Who said the research was of flimsy quality? Who said that the discoveries (as opposed to the BS padding journals require) was what LLM was used for? They might or might not be. But not because he used an LLM to "polish them".
- belter 4y agoHas been publishing sometimes every 5 days, it seems mostly, by being listed as co-author. I like my genius with some effort and sweat. Even Terence Tao talks about his challenges... https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4190-1916 https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4190-1916
- shadowgovt 4y agoWhat is the nature of the space he's working in? Something like physics, you can have a gap of months or years between a new theoretical breakthrough or the completion of a new machine giving you new raw data to churn through. ... but chemistry is something (no offense to chemists) you can do to the dirt outside your house, and every novel molecular arrangement can be paper-worthy.
- belter 4y agoLet's not go that way... - https://xkcd.com/435/ https://xkcd.com/435/
- rscho 4y ago
- mithr 4y agoJust to clarify to the casual observer, parent's quote is from a one-paragraph section about how Luque's been able to be particularly productive recently, rather than anything to do with his suspension: > The university has sanctioned Luque for working as a researcher at other centers, such as the King Saud University in Riyadh and the Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia in Moscow, despite holding a full-time publicly funded contract with the Spanish institution.
- coldtea 4y agoYeah, what? Millions will do the same, and thousands are already doing it...
- sgift 4y agoNice that you didn't quote the part directly after that: > Luque said he basically uses it to improve his written expression in English What's the problem here? That a non-native speaker now doesn't need as much time to write text in a foreign language?
- belter 4y agoWhat your comment and others are missing is: The problem here is that the fluency in English, seems to be the main obstacle, to the speed at what he can publish novel research. Maybe if he would be a English, Oxford educated scholar, would not need ChatGPT. Could then maybe do a paper every 4 to 8 hours?
- nequo 4y agoAs a non-chemist academic, it is fully beyond me how anyone churns out papers at a rate of one every three days. That is the rate he says he has even without relying on ChatGPT. Is there a lot of overlap in the contribution that each of his individual papers make? Or are a lot of these replication studies, carried out by different teams in parallel, with him being a co-author on each of them? I'd be curious to read an academic chemist about how this is possible.
- fock 4y agoHe seems to have kickstarted his citation count by reviews. This is sadly extremely common; a surprising amount of researchers nowadays don't have an actual discovery/novel experiment in their first 10 highest cited papers... He now still does those in reputable journals to relatively random, but en-vogue topics. Then he goes out and trades his name to less visible research (which is ok to do) to actual crap in 2nd to predatory tier journals in exchange for more citations (probably citing other works including him ;)). Generally possible everywhere, also done in the none-Google/Meta/... world of ML. Just look here: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpl/conhome/9764877/proceeding https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpl/conhome/9764877/proceeding - just a random collection of crap.
- boeingUH60 4y ago[flagged]
- coldtea 4y agoOr you know, to just go where he would be appreciated, probably for a pay increase...
- rscho 4y ago[flagged]
- lyaa 4y agoIn fairness, I don't think the lack of Nobel prizes is a valid criticism here. The average time from discovery to a Nobel is close to 30 years at the moment and the Saudis built their first major research university (KAUST) in 2009 and their first university ever in 1961. Their economy started to grow after they got some control over their oil in 1972 so let's say a decade after that is when they could be expected to start spending to any significant degree on research. That only gives them roughly 40 years to get a Nobel which is not enough without systematic support from foreign governments and universities which was not there due to wars, politics, and some internal Saudi policies that limited their ability to attract experts and get access to the latest advanced technologies.
- fuzzbazz 4y agoIn chemistry? the same number as in his current country
- Alifatisk 4y ago"The prolific chemist, who has published a study every 37 hours this year..." I found this part quite impressive until I read the following part: "Luque is constantly publishing papers. Last year he authored some 110 articles. So far this year he has published 58. The chemist admitted that since December, he has been using the artificial intelligence program ChatGPT to “polish” his texts. “These months have been quite productive, because there are articles that used to require two or three days and now I do them in one day,” he said." Even if this is unrelated to the actual story, I find it a tiny bit disturbing. Is this the new standard practice? Let some robot spew out paragraphs of text to convey the scientist research?
- malka 4y agomost papers are made of 90% of useless fluff, and 10% of meat.
- CodexArcana 4y agoIf the domain expert is there to audit the results, where is the issue?
- greenthrow 4y agoYou're assuming they are going to do as thorough of a job auditing as they'd do on their own writing. I doubt that's what will happen when the point of the AI is to spew content out faster.
- i_am_jl 4y agoI can't tell whether this is a question from someone who didn't read the article, or whether this is the most meta comment I've ever read.
- belter 4y agoIt could be both at the same time :-)
- trabant00 4y ago
- alsetmusic 4y ago> The university has sanctioned Luque for working as a researcher at other centers, such as the King Saud University in Riyadh and the Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia in Moscow, despite holding a full-time publicly funded contract with the Spanish institution. ChatGPT is getting cited in comments, but this is the real lede.
- LadyCailin 4y agoWhile concerning, this seems to be the least bad thing this guy does.
- grumple 4y ago> They have a grudge against me because I am a very prolific scientist and a lot of people adore me, because they know my worth. They are envious and mediocre people This guy is extremely egotistical. And he's publishing papers with people he doesn't know. The article implies most of these papers are of low quality... I doubt he contributed in any way to many other than by adding his name. That's fairly common in academia even in normal times. But in these cases it's unlikely that he collaborated in any way with the authors and can't verify the content of the papers.
- sgift 4y agoYeah, he even admits that he broke rules but obviously it's all due to this genius that they are mad at him. If he would be less of a 'genius' the university would have accepted it? What a megalomaniac. > Luque acknowledges that he skipped the established procedures to collaborate with other institutions, but attributes the sanction to envy and a lack of understanding.
- t344344 4y ago[flagged]
- suddenclarity 4y agoI get that he was fired for other reasons but his method is a plague and should be worrying for everyone. When I wrote my latest paper more than half of the published papers I found through research hubs were so subpar that I would've failed my students if they submitted it in one of the regular assignments. Anything can be published. Add some ChatGPT so it sounds convincing and the practice of citing your colleagues to up the stats and it will be near impossible to sort decent science from junk without spending all your time on reading papers instead of doing actual research.
- saulpw 4y agoI'm also worried about this, but "impossible to sort decent science from junk without spending all your time on reading papers instead of doing actual research"--isn't spending all your time reading papers what "actual research" is? re-search?
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoResearch is for discovering new things, not just reading old things.
- pvaldes 4y agoIs both. Reading old things, sometimes published in several different languages is required to master a theme. And finding it first takes an awful lot of time
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoMy comment implied as much. >not just reading old things
- greenthrow 4y agoDoesn't really matter how prolific he is if he violated his employment contract. He should have negotiated a new contract before working for Saudi Arabia and Russia. Seems like a non-story.
- xtracto 4y agoThanks, this is a trivial thing IMHO. Worker violates working agreement, news at 11. All the other fluff is just yellow journalism. He uses GPt? Yawn... he publishes mainly as co-author? That's completely normal in academia, particularly for high ranking professors. Wait until people discover that in several places in Germany, Proffesors delegate most of the PhD supervising tasks to lowly post-docs. It's just layman peeking at the Academia world and getting mad at a cloud.
- emaginniss 4y agoIt's normal for academics to publish a study every 37 hours?
- jjk166 4y ago"Suspended without pay for thirteen years" sounds an awful lot like "fired"
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoExcept without the actual firing. European employment laws (and university rules) may have something to do with it.
- strangeloops85 4y agoHe admitted to publishing a paper with authors he didn’t know.. and which external evidence suggests had authorship for sale. These people are a disaster for science..
- tripdout 4y agoIs the problem that it was Saudia Arabia / Russia, or would this have happened regardless of country due to his contract with the Spanish university? If it's the former, it really doesn't seem like a justified reaction.
- pvaldes 4y agoMost probably, but we could miss things that we don't know. He could had been caught cheating and let him go without disclosing it in a damaging control move if we assume that everybody in his department could appear in one of his papers at least, and this could destroy the entire careers of many people or damage the ability to receive funds for everybody
- throwaway14356 4y agoHumans wont have to read the papers, might as wel run them though the llm to see what it makes from it. We could even require a machine readable benchmark for future compatibility.
- jonnycomputer 4y ago>“They have a grudge against me because I am a very prolific scientist and a lot of people adore me, because they know my worth. They are envious and mediocre people,” he said. “I have never felt supported by the University of Córdoba, even though I put it on the Shanghai ranking. Being on the ranking is entirely due to me.” He appears to have a very high opinion of himself.
- dannykwells 4y ago“Without me, the University of Córdoba is going to drop 300 places [in the Shanghai ranking]. They have shot themselves in the foot,” said Luque, who attributed his suspension to “pure envy.” Seems like they really lost a real gem with this one /s
- n0tahacker 4y agoI am not a scientist in this field and can not evaluate the quality of his studies. But if you let ChatGPT do the "non-scientific" work, this seems to be okay to me. Also, I think that with the time there will be better mechanisms for evaluating studies/scientists as generating spam will be easier. But nonetheless, I think these rankings don't fulfill a scientific need. A scientific discovery can be important, but that doesn't mean anyone recognizes that.
- merek 4y agoI'm not in academia, is the industry vigilant of researchers who try to game metrics, or is metric-gaming commonplace and largely overlooked? Does it depend on country?
- curiousgibbon 4y agoWho is "the industry"? My managers want me to succeed at the metrics. Research is too diverse for them to have real understanding of all of their underlings and their work so metrics become important. My peers (well, the ones I respect) know that the metrics are awful. The metrics seem to have the property that people who I consider successful do score well, but it's possible to score well entirely on the back of work with no scientific value too.
- pvaldes 4y agoAnother for the list of recent scandals of scientists publishing faster than light Susana González, lost an EU grant of 1.8 million euro in 2017: https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms14006 https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms14006 The wistleblower that disclosed that there were problems with the data and found images manipulated was fired and unable to find other work in research. Maybe is unemployed still, dunno. Somebody saved a lot of money also.
- testemailfordg2 4y agoFeels like the terms academic plagiarism and brute force, got married to produce AI generated research papers...
- remcob 4y ago"Vegetative electron microscopy" is likely a poor rephrasing of "low-energy electron microscopy", which is a thing [0]. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-energy_electron_microscopy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-energy_electron_microscopy
- andrewshadura 4y agoIn fact, it's a copy-pasted OCR error.